HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

h91wka

371 karma · joined November 23, 2017

submissionscomments
h91wka··on Coronavirus Came from Bats, Can Infect Cats, Ferrets, WHO Says
This is a misleading statement. There is consensus that there are no traces of gene editing in the virus. But this statement is not equal to "it wasn't produced in the lab".
h91wka··on Coronavirus Came from Bats, Can Infect Cats, Ferrets, WHO Says
> which are obviously implanted by the US media narative

As a non-american, please don't speak for us all. Also, using word "obviously" doesn't substitute for factual evidence. There are plenty of people skeptical about WHO's handling of the situation outside US too.

h91wka··on Making Emacs Popular Again
"M = Alt", "C = Control" is such a trivial thing to remember, yet it is brought up as a critical emacs deficiency every time. Why isn't this argument brought up in every Mac/PC discussion, or Xbox versus playstation?
h91wka··on Making Emacs Popular Again
In what sad, warped alternative reality did this happen?
h91wka··on Emacs' Org-Mode and Syncthing = Perfect (2017)
I double that. Some years ago I almost lost the entire synced state after adding a new device that hadn't synced anything yet. For some reason syncthing decided that the new device has the most recent version of the data and happily started deleting everything on the other peers. Thankfully I had a backup, and not all peers were connected. After that I concluded that syncthing is fundamentally broken.

I sync my org files using a low-tech solution: I have a .dir-locals file that injects a post-save hook that automatically commits changes to git and pushes them to the remote. It's stupid, but it works, and I never have to think about it.

h91wka··on Ask HN: What is the real difference between Terraform and Ansible?
To be fair, one can manage infrastructure with Ansible too.
h91wka··on Debugging Distributed Systems
As a systems Erlang designer who worked for 2 of the biggest Erlang companies in the market, I can assure you that Erlang/OTP is not some magic pixie dust that suddenly makes all the distributed systems problems go away. Playing is one thing, making a reliable, fault-tolerant system is another.

OTP doesn't give you _state of art_ distributed consensus algorithms out of the box.

h91wka··on I’ve made a conscious effort to stop apologizing for bugs in my code
> Replication costs have nothing to do with anything here.

Replication is the cornerstone of fault-tolerance. When logic is written in high-level languages with some minimal good practices, most SW bugs result in crashes rather than data corruption, hence data replication plays important role in protection against bugs as well as HW problems.

> Consider a bug in software used for landing SpaceX boosters... Or a bug in a trading platform. Or a bug in an automated medicine dispense

I specifically mentioned: "Programmers _usually_ work with the data. <...>" In the examples you listed above software manipulates physical world rather than pure data. I thought it was too obvious to explain.

h91wka··on I’ve made a conscious effort to stop apologizing for bugs in my code
To commenters who compare work of programmer with the work of civil engineer:

There is an explanation to this discrepancy. Risk = probability of fault * cost of fault. Programmers usually work with the data. Data has a pretty very unique property that it is easily and cheaply copied and restored. It also means data can be replicated more easily, which allows to build systems with large amount of redundancy. Therefore, price of a software bug is usually orders of magnitude less than the price of breaking something in the physical world. This allows to drive up probability of fault parameter and allows for much faster evolution and less regulation.

h91wka··on The ProtonMail Android app is now open source
This was a showstopper for me back when I decided to go with posteo.net instead. Well, better late than never, hopefully their service will become useful for more people.
h91wka··on Ask HN: Resources to grok Emacs and use it well?
There is another positive side effect of limiting customization to reasonable levels. Default Emacs shortcuts are hidden everywhere. Most importantly, bash understands them, as well as many other REPLs (erlang, ghci, julia, ...). Developing muscle memory for the default Emacs allows one to use many tools much more efficiently.
h91wka··on The Wolfram Physics Project
Maplesoft Maple is more powerful. hides
h91wka··on Mongolia to restore traditional alphabet
> That's not me. ... So I don't downvote anybody ever

Ok, sorry for false accusations. I, too, never downvote anyone for the same reason.

h91wka··on Mongolia to restore traditional alphabet
As far as I know, in Swedish å does not have any ambiguity and is always read as "o" (as in "ocean").

My point is that different people pronounce things as they are used to, reflecting it in a writing system leads to complexity and inconsistency.

h91wka··on Mongolia to restore traditional alphabet
That's not what you said in the original post. Also I would appreciate if you stop downvoting my posts, as I believe input from a native speaker may be valuable to someone.
h91wka··on Mongolia to restore traditional alphabet
> The Russians writing system tries to be phonetic but doesn't seem to do well this way.

It does not? Creating a fully phonetic writing system that is also consistent is an impossible task. For example, different dialects can interchange "o" and "a" sounds, how this should be solved in a "proper" phonetic system?

h91wka··on Mongolia to restore traditional alphabet
> That's because е is usually used to represent the same sound if it's not in the beginning of the word.

This is far from being a general rule. Your example is an exception. Consider "мера", "монета", "обмен" and so on. You cannot change "e" to "э" in these cases.

h91wka··on Ladder of Algebraic Structures
This diagram doesn't show semigroup and monoid. Although these structures aren't used in physics much, I find them very useful for understanding groups.
h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
I specifically mentioned in my post that problems related to _proof search_ are undecidable. Coq's tactics for proof search are unreliable. They rely on timeouts and tend to fail ("omega can't solve this system").

So you're not arguing with my post.

h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
This argument has been risen and dismissed in this thread already, no need to repeat.
h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
No. In CIC I can prove that, say, some property is valid for _any_ natural number. Your "memory is bounded" argument is invalid, as formal proofs can go beyond that.
h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
...Also I think you don't realize that formal inductive proofs can easily reason about programs operating with unbounded memory.
h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
This technically correct comment would be actually useful, if it linked a fully automated prover, that is capable of proving any property of a program that fits in N bytes.

If you remove infinite tape, you go from undecidable to "just" exponentially complex.

h91wka··on The SeL4 Foundation: What and Why
> Is it possible to have a programming language where the compiler does the formal verification?

Such compiler would require solving halting problem. Most problems related to search of formal proofs are undecidable.

h91wka··on A History of Erlang (2007)
> Appeal to junior developers and hobbyists is critical for large scale adoption.

Hmm, I have personally trained Erlang to half a dozen juniors and interns. Any person who knows basics of programming can pick it up and write/fix mundane business code in less than a month. And I am a horrible teacher.

h91wka··on A History of Erlang (2007)
I have long since learned that dismissing languages based on their syntax is very punitive, as novel and powerful languages very often come with unfamiliar syntax. Syntax is the least difficult thing to learn. Things like type system, approach to concurrency and memory management are orders of magnitude more important.
h91wka··on Doing a math assignment with the Lean theorem prover
Quick search reveals that some people have encoded Euclid's axioms in Coq (Lean and Coq are based on roughly the same theory):

http://geocoq.github.io/GeoCoq/

h91wka··on Microsoft Edge is now the second most-used desktop browser
Edge is packaged with Windows.

Chrome used Trojan horse tactics to get into the computers. Back in the 2010s when it just appeared, almost any popular freeware installer got sneaky "Also install Google Chrome and make it the default browser" checkbox.

So, underhanded tactics are extremely efficient. Therefore, I expect that Firefox will keep losing shares. Making a better browser won't help them.

h91wka··on Google emphasizes popularity over accuracy
Very true. Two years ago I fully switched to qwant and DDG, and never looked back. It's not because these two engines are great, it's because Google's output is as good as random.
h91wka··on How South Korea Reined In The Outbreak Without Shutting Everything Down
Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity. By delaying the response they made their bottom line sink exponentially deeper.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →