HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hankman86

452 karma · joined July 6, 2021

submissionscomments
hankman86··on YouTube may face criminal complaints in EU for using ad-block detection scripts
You are regurgitating Google‘s marketing where their poor YouTube division struggles to stay afloat due to all the evil ad blockers out there.

This is nonsense.

They are the gatekeepers to what is effectively a captive market. And they don’t exactly play fair to content creators (professional journalists and amateur video producers), do they?

hankman86··on YouTube may face criminal complaints in EU for using ad-block detection scripts
I would love to see the EU’s Digital Markets Act be applied to YouTube. By all accounts, they are a gatekeeper of the user-generated video streaming market. The DML could enforce some increased level of interoperability. This would not only make youtube-dl legal, but also allow other platforms to sideload videos from YouTube.

I would love to see other streaming services offer access to videos on YouTube for cheaper. YouTube‘s premium tier is exorbitantly expensive.

hankman86··on AMD may get across the CUDA moat
I suspect that AMD will use their improved compatibility with the leading ML stack for data center deals. Presumably by offering steep discounts over NVIDIA’s GPUs. This might help them to break into the market.

Individual ML practitioners will probably not be tempted to switch to AMD cards anytime soon. Whatever the price difference is: it will hardly offset the time that is subsequently sunk into working around remaining issues resulting from a non-CUDA (and less mature) stack underneath PyTorch.

hankman86··on John Carmack and Rich Sutton partner to accelerate development of AGI
I wish he would write a Commander Keen sequel instead.
hankman86··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
And to what end? I fundamentally disagree with the premise that a downsized human population creates a better future, simply because fewer people will require less land, pollute less etc. This not to argue that land use, pollution, climate change etc. are not serious problems. Population collapse is way worse though from an individual perspective. We may not be able to maintain the level of human progress or even regress sharply in our living standards when there are drastically fewer people.

To get an impression of what this looks like, look at what happened after major catastrophes in human history: the collapse of the Roman Empire, the plague that eradicated large swaths of Europe’s population in the Middle Ages, etc. It regularly took centuries for humanity to recover from these events.

hankman86··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
This is not something you can “seek”. It happens due to circumstances beyond our control.

As girls and women got more educated and started to enter the workforce, birth rates declined. This is for one the result of women pushing back having their first child until after they finished their education and progressed into the first stages of their professional career. And secondly, female hypergamy stubbornly persists in modern society. It causes a self-inflicted dilemma for better educated, financially independent women. They find it difficult to find a partner with an equal or better social and economic standing.

Other factors played into this as well, notably the inability to afford property on a single income, requiring both partners to take up work.

I do not believe that there is a silver bullet to any of these problems. The best policy may be to adapt to these developments, rather than trying to change them.

hankman86··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
How do you tell young families (women in particular) to have more children to avoid population collapse? This is a very real problem in a number of wealthy countries. I am not aware of government policies that have managed to coerce educated women to be wanting to have more (or any) children.
hankman86··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
There are nevertheless vast differences between demographic developments in different parts of the world. Many wealthy countries will see their population decline - unless they manage to compensate the same with drastically increased levels of immigration. It would take a complete reversal of policy to allow for this to happen in traditionally immigration-sceptic cultures like Japan or South Korea.

Immigration from other cultures brings its own set of problems of course and may lead to major social and economic issues in these countries. Newly arriving immigrants frequently lack the education to be easily absorbed into a highly skilled workforce. It may take at least one generation or more to overcome this at great economic cost.

But then there are also completely speculative developments that might happen as a society’s population retracts. Property ownership is poised to be more easily attainable for average-income people. As a result, there may be an increase in single-earner families, where the spouse can devote her (or his) time to looking after the children. Which in turn may increase the average number of children that families can afford to have. Again, that’s entirely hypothetical, just one scenario that could result from all this.

hankman86··on PostScript’s sudden death in Sonoma
They probably want to eliminate an attack vector. Removing PostScript support from WebKit/Safari seems like the right decision in light of PostScript’s waning relevance as a publishing format.

Not sure about EPS - last I used it was for vector graphics within LaTeX documents. That was in the early 2000s.

I am sure that applications targeting designers will integrate alternatives like Ghostscript soon enough.

hankman86··on It'd Be Nice to Live in Less of a Gerontocracy
Since when does stuttering make you speak nonsense, be forgetful and tired?
hankman86··on It'd Be Nice to Live in Less of a Gerontocracy
Yes, in many ways a 70 yo is less capable than a 40 yo. Mental acuity, stamina/fitness, rigidity of thinking (the lack thereof) and general health (mental and otherwise). Never ending political terms may also come with a sense of entitlement and disdain for the democratic process. As can be observed when someone from their own political side dares challenging figures like Pelosi, McConnell and others. Knifes are out and playing dirty is the name of the game then.

Where a politician who has “served” for decades does have the edge is knowing from experience how to pull the strings, cut backroom deals etc. They also have a far-flung network of political relations, essentially people who owe them favours. I don’t think these qualities are to the advantage of their constituents or the nation. They certainly help to keep them in power though, which makes gerontocracy a self-fulfilling prophecy.

hankman86··on Evidence mounts on toxic pollution from tires
Tyres don’t last forever. With regulatory intervention in place, tyre manufacturers will bring products to market that lower or eliminate hazardous emissions. This problem could be solved in less than a decade.
hankman86··on Evidence mounts on toxic pollution from tires
Or walk, cycle, use car pooling or public transport. Move closer to where you work, if that’s an option.
hankman86··on Evidence mounts on toxic pollution from tires
Then again, EVs often use regenerative breaking (“one pedal driving”). I have made it a habit to engage this as often as possible, avoiding to use the brakes. I wonder if this results in fewer sharp stops and is easier on the tyres.

What car owners (EV or otherwise) can do to relieve their conscience is to use tyres with the smallest possible dimensions. This should reduce the amount of particle emissions from tyre abrasions. As a plus, smaller tyres are also cheaper, lighter and increase the range.

The principal problem of hazardous chemicals in tyres and non-degradable micro abrasions appears solvable to me. Probably comes down to regulatory intervention and cost and not so much to an insurmountable chemistry challenge.

hankman86··on Peredvizhnikov Engine: Lock-free game engine written in C++20
It’s licensed under GPL3, where the developer suggests individually negotiating a license for commercial projects. I am not sure this is a good approach given the early stage of this project. Video game development is already commercially and technically risky enough.

I cannot see game developers lining up to even try out this unproven technology when they have no sense of what the eventual fees will be.

hankman86··on Humanised kidneys grown inside pigs for the first time
Sacrificing any animal would be morally justifiable if it saved a human life, as is the case with kidney transplants. It does not matter that we already breed and kill millions of pigs for meat consumption. The fact that some person with end stage renal failure could be saved, return to full health and live normally justifies the means. The species (other than human) does not matter - pigs, chimps, whatever allows is to accomplish this scientific breakthrough the fastest.

Where ethics come into play is how the animal is kept during its life. And whether we prevent suffering when its time to remove the kidneys and kill the donor in the process. I would speculate that in the interest of good donor organ function, we would make sure the animal does not experience any stress.

hankman86··on Humanised kidneys grown inside pigs for the first time
This is not about excessive meat consumption. Neither is it about animal abuse in the meat industry. It is not even about animal testing for pharmaceutical products. These issues are completely unrelated to harvesting donor kidneys from pigs.

I fail to see any more obstacles in sacrificing a pig’s life to give a person in end stage kidney disease a chance to live.

Oh and besides: the numbers would not justify moral outrage either: it is true that there are many people waiting for an organ transplant. However, that number still pales when compared to how many pigs are slaughtered for meat production. It is all but guaranteed that genetically modified pigs bred for organ harvesting would be treated well - unlike their meat producing cousins.

Not to mention that there are perfectly viable alternatives to consuming meat. By contrast, people suffering from end-stage kidney failure have little choice, other than dialysis and waiting for their turn to receive a donor organ (i.e. many years in declining health on the waiting list).

So can we stop the blubber about meat consumption and animal abuse in this context please? We should rather celebrate the apparent progress in addressing a major challenge in caring for people whose organs fail.

hankman86··on Humanised kidneys grown inside pigs for the first time
Incorrectly weighed priorities IMHO. People on dialysis have a poor quality of life, a dramatically shortened lifespan and will frequently not survive until that time that a donor kidney becomes available. By contrast, donor organ recipients live a normal life for 10 years or even longer.

A pig’s lifespan is shorter than that to begin with. So even if you were to equate a pig’s life with that of a human: the added lifespan of the human is more than what the pig’s entire life expectancy is.

But frankly, it bothers me that we are even having a debate about this: a pig is vastly less valuable than a human life. Whoever disagrees with this fundamental premise has his priorities completely wrong.

hankman86··on Do’s and don’ts during an Oracle audit
That’s a common practice in enterprise software licensing agreements. The organisation that is being audited signed up for this. Oracle uses audits to enforce being correctly remunerated under the agreed metrics. Nothing scandalous about it. Not sure if audits only happen for on-premise deployments and SaaS usage is automatically metered.
hankman86··on CEO of the VW warns EV price war will ultimately harm the interests of consumers
In other words, their EV strategy doesn’t work and they are losing to Tesla and the Chinese automakers.
hankman86··on German farmer invested €1.5 MM to cover his fields with solar panels [video]
I wonder what crops can cope with the shade that is being cast by the panels. Or whether there is a clever arrangement of the panels that allows for enough light to reach the plants.
hankman86··on Solar power is bailing Texas out this summer
Residential solar is an imperative when heat waves become more common. I live in Queensland, Australia where we are headed into an El Niño summer. Which means sweltering heat for many months.

My current 10 kW solar setup plus Tesla Powerwall is already sufficient to cover 85% of my electricity needs. That includes charging an EV, running pool pumps, a heat pump warm water system and everything else. Shifting these loads into the day means no loss of comfort at all. Exception being the aircon, which we didn’t run as often during the past 3 (cooler) La Niña years. I will add another 10 kW solar panels to my roof this year to also be able to run the aircon on hot days. Without taking electricity from the grid. Which (sadly) is still mostly based on burning coal in this country.

hankman86··on Iron fuel shows its mettle
But isn’t that the point of transmission lines - match supply and demand? Given a large enough region, there is going to be a place where renewable electricity can be produced. Case in point being offshore wind turbines where there are almost always strong winds to spin these. Moving this electricity to where it is consumed is a huge issue though. Existing power grids were created with centralised power stations in mind, which are usually located close to where the electricity will be needed.
hankman86··on Iron fuel shows its mettle
Or you just use the iron to build more towers for wind turbines. Or transmission lines to send renewable electricity to where it is needed.
hankman86··on CRDT Benchmarks
[1] is a bummer. Turns this project into a technology showcase without any practical use.
hankman86··on CheerpJ 3.0: a JVM replacement in HTML5 and WASM to run Java on modern browsers
Who would want a lazily ported Java desktop UI in the browser?

Web apps are bad enough as it is. But downloading massive jar files and execute them at a major performance penalty? No thanks. I will actively avoid websites that use heavyweight tech like this.

hankman86··on Gorillaz turn the world into a stage with augmented reality
VR is dead in the water and so is AR. I thought Google had learned that lesson from their own foray into the space with Google Glass. Latest evidence: Sony’s PSVR2 doesn’t sell. Oh and the ongoing crapshow that is Meta’s VR-based Metaverse program that doesn’t even draw in their own staff.
hankman86··on 1Password to Add Telemetry
This is very, very bad news. Even if their client telemetry ends up being opt-in, the “feature” will be part of the client code base, opening up an attack surface and chance of data leakage. I can already see the apology letter from their CEO coming in (“we let our users down”).

1Password, don’t do it!

Rely on other means to collect usability feedback like surveys, internal usability testing and developer tooling for build-time usability testing. Your app is simple enough that you absolutely, categorically do not need to subject your users to mass surveillance.

I am currently paying for a 1P family subscription and I will be moving to another provider or self-host a free/OSS password manager should your telemetry plans eventuate.

hankman86··on I made my blog solar-powered, then things escalated
Did you ever work out how much energy was expended to manufacture and transport the parts? Chances are that with solar panels facing west in a place like The Netherlands, it will take a long time to come out on top with your carbon footprint.

I reckon that the most energy-efficient setup for your blog would be a hosted solution. Data centres are already optimised for low energy use. And some cloud providers have committed to become carbon neutral.

Lowering your overall household electricity use would be a more effective way to lower your carbon output.

hankman86··on ChatGPT Has a GDPR Problem
Last I looked, the GDPR gives “data subjects” (=regular citizens) autonomy over their data in the first place. Your argument is rather flawed: how does it help well-informed people to merely know that LLMs use personal information in their training data sets when they cannot legally block OpenAI and others from doing that? What exactly is the upside for individuals when some LLM “knows” personal details about them? I cannot think of anything. By contrast, the misuse potential is huge.

Yes, laws like the GDPR are inconvenient and costly to comply with. But they exist because personal data is harvested, monetised otherwise and used without the individuals’ consent. Which is never to their advantage.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →