HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hankman86

452 karma · joined July 6, 2021

submissionscomments
hankman86··on ChatGPT Has a GDPR Problem
This is good news! And it makes sense. OpenAI stores swaths of personal information that it scrapes off websites and who knows where else from. The “right to be forgotten” applies: individuals for whom the GDPR applies (i.e. citizens of the European Union) can ask OpenAI to remove their personal information from the models. As the video points out, OpenAI may already be in breach with the GDPR by not asking individuals for consent when ingesting their personal information into training data sets.

Big fat lawsuits will be incoming and hopefully lead to banning non-compliant LLMs and hand out fines for their current breaches.

hankman86··on Personal Concierge Using OpenAI's ChatGPT via Telegram and Voice Messages
It amazes me to no end that some people would feed private conversations and other sensitive data into an experimental chat bot. Don’t these people not know that ChatGPT it not a mature technology, that does not reliably isolate sessions and may even permanently ingest user data for training purposes?

GPT and other LLMs are currently integrated into countless products and hobbyist projects. Expect an avalanche of lawsuits on the grounds of LLMs being structurally incompatible with notorious privacy laws like the GDPR. For instance, how would they implement the GDPR’s “right to be forgotten”? Untrain the model?

hankman86··on Founder who sold startup to Google says G has lost its mission, is mismanaged
While this is only a singular opinion, Google’s problems to successfully innovate are in plain sight.

Google Research produces the seminal paper on Transformers - only to see others pick up their work and run with it.

Android is losing market share.

Stadia flopped.

ChromeOS is on life support.

Search is subjectively getting worse (albeit still insanely profitable).

Google Cloud market share is nowhere near AWS or Azure.

The whole company feels like it’s frozen in time.

hankman86··on Microsoft announces new Bing and Edge browser powered by upgraded ChatGPT AI
Everyone keeps talking about Google being caught off guard, declaring a “code red” scenario and reeling the founders back in to avert an existential threat etc.

I don’t personally care about Google so much. They haven’t innovated on their core product in a long time.

What most of the journalistic coverage of the Bing+ChatGPT integration seems to be missing is that this is also the end of organic search traffic. Information-centric websites are the first to miss out on a lot of clicks. And as ChatGPT evolves into an assistant that performs actual jobs for you, websites that perform actual services (e.g., online shopping) may be next in line to suffer a decline in traffic.

hankman86··on Dreamix: Video Diffusion Models Are General Video Editors
AI feels very different from previous waves of disruptive technologies (e.g., Web 2.0, mobile, cloud, social). More than ever, negative consequences are in plain sight. AI proponents do not even deny that this is going to eliminate a lot of jobs. And it is going to produce an endless barrage of generic, soulless, manipulative content. Wouldn’t surprise me to see people retreating from online platforms as a result of that.

Where is the positive vision in all of this?

hankman86··on Google to reduce workforce by 12k
I wonder what hidden benefits there are in these layoffs. Sure, companies lose skilled staff and nominally taken a hit in overall corporate output.

On the flipside, people work twice as hard, eager to show their worth. That may be the cynic intent behind these industry-wide layoff. Scare the crap out of everyone and make them do the extra mile.

hankman86··on NanoGPT
Take a leaf from Seti@Home‘s book and try to come up with a distributed, volunteer-based approach to training an open source LLM. There is already an enormous amount of suitable ML hardware on end user devices.
hankman86··on Microsoft is preparing to add ChatGPT to Bing
Exactly. More to this: the incentive for SEO copywriting goes away - good riddance!

On the flip side, these new generative AI search engines will have to innovate on their business model as well. Google basically pays content creators in organic traffic. We don’t know what Bings new interface will look like. But I think it’s fair to assume that there will be fewer click-throughs to websites.

To keep feeding the AI with quality content, there will have to be new ways to incentivise the creators. Especially those creators that do not have access to other sources of funding - think journalists. Unless of course, the AI disrupts one of journalism’s key purposes: to explain facts to us.

hankman86··on Microsoft is preparing to add ChatGPT to Bing
Agree with your first paragraph and disagree with the second:

Google really has it coming. They bred the SEO industry that has essentially turned websites into SPAM. There isn’t a single website that doesn’t have you scroll through lengthy SEO-optimized bullish.. content.

As for ChatGPT “stealing” content: I’d rather take the view of aggregating human knowledge as a positive. Imagine ChatGPT aggregating, summarising, weighing and dumbing down academic content. And if as a result all that knowledge became accessible by a broad audience. What could this do for the average person’s scientific literacy? Or fake news for that matter?

hankman86··on Microsoft is preparing to add ChatGPT to Bing
This is a good thing in so many ways.

Imagine a search engine that summarises the world’s knowledge in comprehensible terms. That doesn’t just return a ranked list of websites, but answers that are synthesised from a multitude of sources. Google has technically made human knowledge discoverable. But it has never helped mere mortals all that much to navigate the maze that is academic publishing, reputable journalism, SEO SPAM and outright manipulation. By contrast, imagine how ChatGPT in Bing can not only improve productivity, but for the first time give everyone access to the world’s knowledge. What I love about ChatGPT is that you can ask it to dumb down the answer it has previously given. And to summarise complex topics.

For the first time since Google killed the likes of Altavista, their moat has become leaky. About time! We need true competition in search and hopefully Microsoft and others will also innovate on the business model. Heaven knows I would pay for a search engine that doesn’t spy on me and gives me better results. Not to mention that this will also kill the perverse incentive for websites to do SEO. Hopefully, the web will become readable again, as a result.

hankman86··on Haiku R1/beta4
Exactly. In acquiring NeXT, Apple bought leadership and culture. And we can argue forever if Apple’s engineers could have shipped the first OSX release earlier or in a better state, had they instead acquired Be. But I doubt it. Because - again - they bought themselves a high-performance culture, which they might not have gotten from Be. Porting BeOS to Apple hardware / existing software would have likely required an equally Herculean effort.

Oh and they got Steve Jobs of course who made quick work of pushing out the old Apple leadership. And good that he did.

hankman86··on Haiku R1/beta4
This deserves to be expanded on: I very much see the need for innovation in OS research. But I just don’t see anything in BeOS/Haiku that would address any of the big challenges for operating systems. Which in my mind include the following:

Can we get away from the “leaky bucket” security paradigm where despite all of the best efforts and gradual improvements, prevalent operating systems “keep on giving” in terms of exploits that are discovered all the time. Is there something akin to what Rust is for programming languages?

Or what about an operating system for AIs? Is the current stack of Linux, GPU drivers, and some ML SDK on top an adequate answer for emerging AI applications?

Or if you still believe in Blockchain applications, what about a native OS for that?

And the list goes on.

All I see in Haiku/BeOS is a pretty, albeit dated user interface. Someone educate me what else they bring to the table.

hankman86··on Haiku R1/beta4
Beyond the nostalgia: are there any other reasons to keep contributing to Haiku? Like critical infrastructure that is reliant on BeOS/Haiku. Or anything you can plausibly do best on Haiku?
hankman86··on Tech giants ditch office space in London and Europe
Makes me wonder whether we’re already past the point where remote work has turned from a perk into an essential skill (ie. the ability to work/collaborate effectively in a remote/hybrid setup). In the current economic downturn, it’s not difficult to see how firms want to curb their monthly outgoings for office leases.
hankman86··on The Tragedy of CharacterAI
Can someone please summarize in plain English what is the story (or “drama”) here? I had a hard time making sense of this article full of weird lingo and screenshots of some social media exchanges - about what exactly? A chat AI that gets tricked into perverted exchanges? Some startup without a viable business model?
hankman86··on An algorithm can use WiFi signal changes to help identify breathing issues
I imagine it might be difficult to get FDA approval for a medical appliance like this one. WiFi is already challenging to get right for its core purpose (ie. to wirelessly transmit data with a predictable throughout).
hankman86··on Corviale, a one-kilometer residential complex in Rome
These buildings are basically an anti-individualism ideology, cast in concrete. Which is why far left and far right regimes alike like to erect such structures.

And it’s not even a thing of the past. In its most recent incarnation, the German Greens have declared war on single family homes. The fashionable justification being their carbon footprint. Instead, they are for policies to house people in apartment blocks that are densely spaced within cities instead of suburbs. Often while mixing different demographics that would not normally like to live within the same neighbourhood. Suffice it to say that people continue to pursue the dream of owning houses on their own plot of land.

hankman86··on Google combines Maps and Waze teams in restructuring move
TIL that Google owns two mapping services/apps. Where’s the sense in that? And why are they only consolidating their offerings now?
hankman86··on The sad story of Heisenberg's doctoral oral exam (1998)
Not so much sad, but rather ignorant. Heisenberg knew that an experimental physicist would sit on the panel. What kind of questions did he expect to get asked?

In those days, the expectation for a physics PhD was to be well-versed in different branches of the art. Think of this as you may, but it seems like Heisenberg simply didn’t prepare properly.

hankman86··on Association vigorous intermittent lifestyle physical activity with mortality
This new research tells us that you actually don’t need to properly exercise, using up a lot of your time to see a positive effect on mortality rates. A few short activity bursts will do. Chances are that more people will be willing to fit this into their daily routine. Wearable devices can gamify this for you.

And it may act as a motivator. How many people end up being literally petrified by the prospect of having to spend a few hours exercising every week? And rather not exercise at all.

On the bottom line, it may help improve the health of a cohort that does not currently exercise at all.

hankman86··on Software horror show: SAP Concur
You have to remember why companies buy from the likes of SAP: compliance.

That’s the one thing that SAP excels in.

Sadly this means that usability falls by the wayside. And while SAP‘s user interfaces are exceptionally bad, their competitors do not exactly prioritise ease of use either.

In this case a subpar user experience is combined with an immature technology stack. SAP infamously stopped supporting 3rd party databases and now require their customers to use the in house HANA database instead. Problem is that HANA is not a great database. Painfully slow and lacks features. In this case, pre-sorted result sets.

hankman86··on Source Code for SunOS 4.1.3 (1992)
I miss the days of commercial UNIX workstations. Perhaps that’s because this happens to be when I was young.
hankman86··on Clever algorithm may be what's driving rent prices so high
Isn’t this just what naturally happens then demand outstrips supply? AFAICS, the algorithm merely removes any inhibition from landlords to ask excessive rents. It’s somewhat calming for one’s moral conscience to point fingers at the computer when screwing over renters.
hankman86··on Unlaunching the 12GB 4080
It’s smart how they make a backflip on the 4080 12GB naming to distract from the price hike. That’s playing 3D marketing chess …not.
hankman86··on 87% of American teens own an iPhone; 88% expect an iPhone to be their next phone
Because owning an Android means you‘re poor.
hankman86··on 87% of American teens own an iPhone; 88% expect an iPhone to be their next phone
It’s about status more than anything else. A teen‘s greatest fear is that owning an Android makes you un-effable.
hankman86··on iPhone Ownership Among U.S. Teens Hits 87%
Nothing gives it away more clearly that you’re undateable than your Android phone.
hankman86··on Meta Quest Pro
It’s the other way around. Wealthy people can opt out of Meta’s VR surveillance apparatus, others cannot.
hankman86··on Factorio is coming to Nintendo Switch
Is there going to be a physical release or digital only? Looking for a Christmas present.
hankman86··on Slack’s free plan change is causing an exodus
The 90 day cap on the search history essentially turns the free plan into a time-limited trial. Slack is probably happy to part ways with whoever still cannot justify their subscription price after that time. They will have figured that these users are not likely to upgrade to a paid tier at a later date either. As a for-profit entity, Slack has no reason to offer a free service to a longtail of non-paying users.

From a business perspective, this makes perfectly good sense.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →