HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

happytiger

4,440 karma · joined November 4, 2019

submissionscomments
happytiger··on Apple's Phil Schiller Works 80 Hours a Week Overseeing App Store
I thought he stepped down to take the role of fellow and Joz took his old marketing job? Two very competent people I will say.

https://www.apple.com/leadership/greg-joswiak/

happytiger··on “Emergent” abilities in LLMs actually develop gradually and predictably – study
That’s an astute observation.
happytiger··on Fresno School Tracks Students' Bathroom Breaks with Countdown App
This is prison, not school. If you can’t teach kids to be responsible in school, you’re failing as a school, and becoming a prison is not the answer.
happytiger··on FBI sent several informants to Standing Rock protests, court documents show
Ones on Indian treaty land done by Indians.
happytiger··on I used ChatGPT as a reporting assistant. It didn't go well
Perhaps. But I generally would expect some level of research and professionalism beyond such simplistic concepts from someone who has a degree in journalism and works in the field.

Hype is precisely what journalists are supposed to cut through. That’s why it’s called ‘reporting.’ So the idea that because many people with no background in AI are confused conflating to reasons why that’s acceptable for journalists writing about it seems rather weak to me.

I do see a broad series of articles that follow the pattern, and do believe it to be clickbait ‘journalism’ of the lowest standard.

Incompetence could be an explanation, but it’s article after article from professional mainstream sources: sources that should know better or at least have a consult with someone who does as part of their due diligence. That implies it’s being done because it gets views, not because it’s good journalism and is therefore intentional. But that is my conjecture you are right.

happytiger··on I used ChatGPT as a reporting assistant. It didn't go well
Being accurate and being helpful are different things. Otherwise there wouldn’t be liars.
happytiger··on How to Start Google
That’s interesting. Aging hasn’t been limiting my thinking about time remaining. Maybe it should. It’s been pouring on the gas about enjoying the ride as much as possible instead. Worry less, lean in more, focus on defining a success that is yours in a way that’s deeply meaningful.
happytiger··on I Used ChatGPT as a Reporting Assistant. It Didn't Go Well
Exactly. It’s kind of frustrating because I’d love to read an article that attempts to make it work. There’s a need for more advanced exploration than poking it with a stick and then talking about how poking it with a stick doesn’t work, but almost all articles seem to follow the format.
happytiger··on Study puts fermented foods, not fire, as pivotal moment in human brain growth
Well I think it’s awesome to have the discussion and I certainly think the idea has merit… I just don’t think postulations should have the same weight as substantive research no matter how prestigious the journey it gets published in.

That’s really the core of my point.

You could very well be right on fire / ferment and whatnot. We have so very little substantive paleontological information to go off of.

happytiger··on Intel to Receive $8.5B in Grants to Build Chip Plants
Oh yes, the bill has all kinds of nice ideas in it.

But then there is reality. And reality is that there isn’t some giant labor pool of fab workers in the US — yet.

- President Joe Biden signed the CHIPS and Science Act into law one year ago, and semiconductor companies across the U.S. have promised to spend $231 billion on building chip manufacturing hubs on American soil.

- Now, as the shovels hit the ground to begin construction, companies are realizing how difficult it is to find talent.

- Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company said it had to delay production at its $40 billion Arizona plant due to a lack of workers in the U.S.

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/08/09/us-chip-sector-talent-gap-em...

happytiger··on I used ChatGPT as a reporting assistant. It didn't go well
Despite warnings everywhere that accuracy isn’t part of what this generation of gpt-4 us all about, and the fact that Sama has said that right now they are optimizing for language capabilities and conversational flow rather than accuracy, every single article on the Internet criticizes accuracy.

LLMs are designed to create “helpful” and “convincing responses” without any overriding guarantees regarding their accuracy or alignment with fact. Right in the chat interface for chat-gpt is says, “ChatGPT can make mistakes. Consider checking important information.”

I’m sure accuracy will improve but it’s not a strong point for the current generation nor was it ever intended to be.

Not coming at you, just trying to support your point.

In my mind the fact that publishing houses are being co-opted (and I’ve seen it too) with this generation of LLM is more social commentary about the sad state of modern news and publishing. Imagine what happens when the LLM technology hits initial degrees or human equivalence.

happytiger··on I used ChatGPT as a reporting assistant. It didn't go well
I don’t think that’s true. I think a lot of these articles actually create these results intentionally so that they have the conclusion they want to write about: that AI isn’t ready.

I have been watching Devin and really see the model they have implemented working well for these kinds of executive function step-by-step LLM tasks. It’s remarkably smart how they implemented it.

https://the-decoder.com/cognition-unveils-ai-powered-softwar...

If you give vague instructions to a junior level human you get poor work product just like AI. But every journalist wants to write that ringer-dinger traffic bringer about ai not being ready for prime time or whatever bad headline works…

happytiger··on Intel to Receive $8.5B in Grants to Build Chip Plants
This is a re-shoring of strategic capabilities not a labor move. The labor will most likely be imported as it doesn’t really exist in the US at the scale needed with an eventual eye towards more domestic labor. Expect large numbers of imported skilled labor in the short term.
happytiger··on Study puts fermented foods, not fire, as pivotal moment in human brain growth
It’s actually discussed in the paper.

> Explanatory power compared to other hypotheses

> The emergence of meat-eating, tuber-harvesting, and cooking have all been proposed to account for human brain expansion; why should our just-so story be given any additional credence? Below, we consider several explanatory advantages of the External Fermentation Hypothesis versus other current hypotheses.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-023-05517-3

happytiger··on Study puts fermented foods, not fire, as pivotal moment in human brain growth
No. As you obviously know by the phrasing of your question, the issue is that the vegan community has a particular history of agenda over science, and the concern is that any group that starts with a conclusion will build research to support their agenda rather than create objective evidence.
happytiger··on Study puts fermented foods, not fire, as pivotal moment in human brain growth
It not a study. It’s a bunch of postulation and no data or experiment and based entirely on conjecture.
happytiger··on I Used ChatGPT as a Reporting Assistant. It Didn't Go Well
It’s optimized for conversation skills not accuracy. It will get better at accuracy soon.
happytiger··on Study puts fermented foods, not fire, as pivotal moment in human brain growth
> We close with suggestions for empirical tests.

Oooook. Call me when you have some of those.

This is just complete conjecture, and while interesting, isn’t a study. It’s a postulation.

happytiger··on How to Start Google
Wow, the older I get the more ambitious I get about what to build. A lot of the companies I created in my 20s and 30s I wouldn’t waste my time on in my 40s. I’m so the exact opposite it’s kinda funny.

Go big or go home, it’s no fun to chew bones.

happytiger··on EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after partial ban
We’re both wrong. Apparently Australia is the actual leader.
happytiger··on EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after partial ban
It’s quite easy to get a summary of a book. Open minds create futures.
happytiger··on EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after partial ban
To be clear, hell yea it would.
happytiger··on EPA bans asbestos, a deadly carcinogen still in use decades after partial ban
Leading the world in protecting Americans by following the lead of more than 50 countries. That’s my EPA. Good job!
happytiger··on Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
Yea done it twice and both times my account magically was restored
happytiger··on Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
Yea count me the fool on this one.

But like is said earlier, legality is always the argument that tyrants hide behind.

happytiger··on Y Combinator's chief startup whisperer is demoting himself
If the focus is on doing what’s best for founders, and doing a job that’s closer to founders helps them more than a high prestige but less effective position, that’s what you do. Hats off to him. He’s living by principle and acting like the absolute gem of a human being he is.
happytiger··on U.S. is investigating Meta for role in drug sales
Like together as one pill? Weird.
happytiger··on Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
Putting up fliers, choosing to be public is vastly, vastly different from using information previously provided under a different pretext for an entirely unwanted and unintended purpose, especially when it is to train digital intelligences that have inherently massive problematic social costs without explicit consent.

Put another way, it’s fine with me if someone wants to use the content that I provided to drive value on a social website.

It’s not OK with me that someone uses the content that I provided to replicate the author of what was written (without permission).

One thing to really understand about artificial intelligence is that it is in someways, essentially a reverse engineering of the person providing the content. I did not authorize a digital twin to be created from the content that I provided. I did not authorize a digital copy of myself, but that is what all of these companies are doing.

A fundamental stripping of the authorship to the point where you can replicate a proxy of the author and not just use the derivatives of that author.

This is a fundamental difference, because no other technology has ever been able to go back up the food chain and replicate the author in a way that allows for not only replication of the content and its relative functions, but a complete photocopying of the ideas and thinking and other mechanisms and patterns of the person that’s creating it.

It’s a profound difference of people have a hard time seeing.n

I gave permission to use the content I provided. I did not give permission for someone to act as me or make a proxy of me based on what I have provided.

I consented for my media to be used, but not me and that’s a huge difference.

happytiger··on Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
This is exactly aligned with my point. Expectations matter. Social contracts matter.

Legality is always the argument that tyrants hide behind.

happytiger··on Reddit's Sale of User Data for AI Training Draws FTC Investigation
His writings do seem precient. His methods of expressing his distaste for societies direction still suck though.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →