4,440 karma · joined November 4, 2019
Hype is precisely what journalists are supposed to cut through. That’s why it’s called ‘reporting.’ So the idea that because many people with no background in AI are confused conflating to reasons why that’s acceptable for journalists writing about it seems rather weak to me.
I do see a broad series of articles that follow the pattern, and do believe it to be clickbait ‘journalism’ of the lowest standard.
Incompetence could be an explanation, but it’s article after article from professional mainstream sources: sources that should know better or at least have a consult with someone who does as part of their due diligence. That implies it’s being done because it gets views, not because it’s good journalism and is therefore intentional. But that is my conjecture you are right.
That’s really the core of my point.
You could very well be right on fire / ferment and whatnot. We have so very little substantive paleontological information to go off of.
But then there is reality. And reality is that there isn’t some giant labor pool of fab workers in the US — yet.
- President Joe Biden signed the CHIPS and Science Act into law one year ago, and semiconductor companies across the U.S. have promised to spend $231 billion on building chip manufacturing hubs on American soil.
- Now, as the shovels hit the ground to begin construction, companies are realizing how difficult it is to find talent.
- Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company said it had to delay production at its $40 billion Arizona plant due to a lack of workers in the U.S.
https://www.cnbc.com/2023/08/09/us-chip-sector-talent-gap-em...
LLMs are designed to create “helpful” and “convincing responses” without any overriding guarantees regarding their accuracy or alignment with fact. Right in the chat interface for chat-gpt is says, “ChatGPT can make mistakes. Consider checking important information.”
I’m sure accuracy will improve but it’s not a strong point for the current generation nor was it ever intended to be.
Not coming at you, just trying to support your point.
In my mind the fact that publishing houses are being co-opted (and I’ve seen it too) with this generation of LLM is more social commentary about the sad state of modern news and publishing. Imagine what happens when the LLM technology hits initial degrees or human equivalence.
I have been watching Devin and really see the model they have implemented working well for these kinds of executive function step-by-step LLM tasks. It’s remarkably smart how they implemented it.
https://the-decoder.com/cognition-unveils-ai-powered-softwar...
If you give vague instructions to a junior level human you get poor work product just like AI. But every journalist wants to write that ringer-dinger traffic bringer about ai not being ready for prime time or whatever bad headline works…
> Explanatory power compared to other hypotheses
> The emergence of meat-eating, tuber-harvesting, and cooking have all been proposed to account for human brain expansion; why should our just-so story be given any additional credence? Below, we consider several explanatory advantages of the External Fermentation Hypothesis versus other current hypotheses.
Oooook. Call me when you have some of those.
This is just complete conjecture, and while interesting, isn’t a study. It’s a postulation.
Go big or go home, it’s no fun to chew bones.
But like is said earlier, legality is always the argument that tyrants hide behind.
Put another way, it’s fine with me if someone wants to use the content that I provided to drive value on a social website.
It’s not OK with me that someone uses the content that I provided to replicate the author of what was written (without permission).
One thing to really understand about artificial intelligence is that it is in someways, essentially a reverse engineering of the person providing the content. I did not authorize a digital twin to be created from the content that I provided. I did not authorize a digital copy of myself, but that is what all of these companies are doing.
A fundamental stripping of the authorship to the point where you can replicate a proxy of the author and not just use the derivatives of that author.
This is a fundamental difference, because no other technology has ever been able to go back up the food chain and replicate the author in a way that allows for not only replication of the content and its relative functions, but a complete photocopying of the ideas and thinking and other mechanisms and patterns of the person that’s creating it.
It’s a profound difference of people have a hard time seeing.n
I gave permission to use the content I provided. I did not give permission for someone to act as me or make a proxy of me based on what I have provided.
I consented for my media to be used, but not me and that’s a huge difference.
Legality is always the argument that tyrants hide behind.