HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hdctambien

692 karma · joined July 12, 2010

Computer Science Teacher
submissionscomments
hdctambien··on Elon’s Out
Cash Rules Everything Around Me is a Wu-Tang song (C.R.E.A.M.)
hdctambien··on When “Foundation” Gets the Blockbuster Treatment, Asimov’s Vision Gets Lost
I think I would have rather seen a version of Foundation written by Aaron Sorkin.
hdctambien··on How to help a programming student get unstuck
Excellent points.

I made it a point that "if it is on an assessment, then they will have seen it in class"

No tricks, no novel algorithms. Just show me that you learned the things that I tried to teach you.

If a lab asks you to write a for loop that prints all the strings in an array, then I've taught the syntax for strings, printing,accessing elements from arrays, getting the length of an array, writing a for loop, etc... There have been hands on activities and/or funsheets for each of those ideas that include fill-in the blank questions where they get the framework of for loops with arrays.

And they get handouts with the syntax / code structures / algorithms.

And they get those worksheets/handouts/etc to reference while working on the lab.

In a classroom environment, it's important to teach and build the foundation to solve problems. But then it's important to make the student do the work to build the connections so they actually learn something. Even if the something they learn is where they can look to find the answer to a question like "does an array start at 0 or 1?"

hdctambien··on How to help a programming student get unstuck
I would see this a lot, too. I think in many cases it is a coping mechanism that they develop and may not even realize they are doing it.

You see articles about not praising kids for being "smart" because that praises something innate about them, but instead praise them for working hard or growing or learning. Sometimes kids that are "smart" in middle school don't have to work/learn/study because everything just makes sense. But then they get to high school and their grades start to dip because their "middle school smarts" don't apply to high school material and they didn't develop the skills to study/learn effectively. But they are known as "smart kids" and smart kids get good grades... So they need to find ways to get good grades... because they are "smart kids"

I hope I was able to help some of those students unlearn some of those habits and develop more educational ways to "get good grades"

hdctambien··on How to help a programming student get unstuck
That's an excellent point. I actually stopped grading lab assignments. I found students were more interesting in getting "the answer" than learning the material. This would lead to students making decisions that optimized for"having the answer" but were detrimental to "learning the material".

Once I stopped grading the labs, it freed students to experiment and learn rather than rush and stress about the due date. It didn't really matter if they finished the lab, as long as they learned something along the way.

There was, of course, much more to my classes than the labs. Lectures, group activities, "kahoots", discussions, prelabs, funsheets, etc... Lots of ways to assess a students understanding and help catch the ones that are falling behind.

hdctambien··on How to help a programming student get unstuck
This is pretty much how I taught my High School Computer Science classes.

The biggest step for me was to never touch the student keyboards. And then I basically only answered their questions with more questions.

Sometimes I would hear students grumble "He never answers my questions...", But in the long run, they would start asking themselves the same questions they knew I would ask (what did you expect it to do?, what did it do?, Why did it do that?)... Then they would usually solve their problem without me!

Or, when they called me over they would start with "I tried a, b, and c" and got results x, y, and z" which is a way better start to a learning experience for everyone than the old "it doesn't work, fix it, please"

hdctambien··on Why Mathematics is Boring (2007) [pdf]
Following on from my other reply...

When we start teaching math to students, we start with counting blocks: "You have 2 piles of blocks, one pile of 3 and another pile of 2. If you put them together, you get a pile of 5 blocks!"

That stops working as well when you deal with fractions. You can get away with 2.5 blocks, but 2.5 blocks is really 3 blocks, but one is a little smaller than the others. And at some point you can't use blocks to represent 2.3456 blocks. So you need different kinds of "natural" problems to represent those numbers.

But, as you point out. There are some things that aren't really representable as "natural problems". For a long time the idea of 0 wasn't natural. (People were actually killed for talking about the idea of 0) I mean, what does it mean to have 0 chickens? You either have some chickens, and you say "I have N chickens", or you don't have any chickens and you say nothing. Why would you need a number to represent nothing?

Maybe n^2.1 doesn't have a natural explanation. At least, not one you can hold in your hand. Can you imagine a shape with 2.1 dimensions to relate it to geometry? Probably not. But you can use geometry to prove that n^(a+b) = n^a * n^b and then you can apply those rules to "unnatural values" with an understanding of what is happening. The natural explanation of n^2 can be applied to the unnatural idea of n^2.1

Everything in math can't be understood with geometry or "natural examples", lots of math (most of math?) describes things that are not representable within the constraints of our physical world. That's what makes it so powerful!

Also, not everything in math can just be calculated (see: irrational numbers)

hdctambien··on Why Mathematics is Boring (2007) [pdf]
I think the magic/miracle of math is that you can go from "real world" into "math world" then back into "real world". If a rule is true for c and n and n+1, and you can physically represent the idea when n=2 and n=3, then you can apply that representation theoretically to n>3 to understand ideas that are not easily understandable.

The 10th root of x takes you from a measurement of an 10 dimensional object to the measurement of a 9 dimensional object. That's crazy, right? Without needing to "understand" what an 10 dimensional object is, you know something about it because you understand what roots mean with lower values...

Of course, that doesn't help you actually calculate the 10th root of x. Is there a better way than basically guess, check, and refine? The calculator is just really fast at doing that (and only needs to calculate a relatively small number of significant digits). Sometimes that's just how math is. The only magic there is that computers are very fast at computation compared to people.

hdctambien··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
I was explaining that there is no "government branch", but as someone else pointed out that may have just been a translation error.

What you say about spending is correct. And, yeah, the differences between the legislative and executive branches are important and more than technicalities.

I wouldn't say the executive branch is under "stricter rules" than the legislative branch. It just has different rules and different responsibilities.

The legislative branch creates laws. The executive branch enforces/executes laws. The judicial branch makes sure those laws are constitutional and identifies their limits/scope.

Of course there is some gray area as congress likes to give some of its powers to the executive branch so that they can say "that wasn't my idea" to unpopular ideas.

Rather than make a law that says "forget about all that rent from last year" they would more likely make a law that says "someone in the executive branch has the power to say: forget about all that rent"

The other route would be for the judicial branch to say the executive branch already has that power... But they just said it doesn't.

And that's how the wheel of government turns... In the US

hdctambien··on Millions Still Months Behind on Rent After Eviction Moratorium Ends
There isn't a "government branch". The is legislative, executive, and judicial. They are all "the government".
hdctambien··on Calculus for Seven Year Olds [pdf]
I'm fairly certain that's what Common Core was trying to do... And parents around the US freaked out because it was different than how they learned math and states like Texas made it illegal...
hdctambien··on Ask HN: What is the most bloated website you use
Adding a spinner is just putting lipstick on the bloat. Progressively loading a page can at least hide the bloat from the end user.

A page of text should just be a page of text. That's the beauty in sites like hackernews and craigslist. They are down-and-dirty, just-the-facts, we'll-get-out-of-your-way websites.

You see bloat when you start adding stuff that obscures that core functionality and/or slows down/degrades the experience.

Of course, the core functionality changes depending on who you are. The customer might just want to read the article, but the sales team wants to get you to see/click on ads and the marketing team wants you to signup for their newsletter. So, one person's bloat is another person's core functionality.

hdctambien··on Pandemic homeschoolers who are not going back
I think you'd be surprised at what they were trying to teach you. At least in Texas the 3rd grade standards are pretty much the same as the High School standards (for values of "complex" adjusted for grade level)

https://tea.texas.gov/sites/default/files/ch110a.pdf

- The student uses metacognitive skills to both develop and deepen comprehension of increasingly complex texts

- The student recognizes and analyzes literary elements within and across increasingly complex traditional, contemporary, classical, and diverse literary texts

- The student recognizes and analyzes genre-specific characteristics, structures, and purposes within and across increasingly complex traditional, contemporary, classical, and diverse texts

- The student uses critical inquiry to analyze the authors' choices and how they influence and communicate meaning within a variety of texts.

- The student analyzes and applies author's craft purposefully in order to develop his or her own products and performances

What 3rd grade you thought you were supposed to be learning and what the teacher was actually trying to teach you were not necessarily lined up.

Or, you went to a school with a particularly poor English department that just had you write book reports for books you didn't read for no reason other than that's what they always did. That's actually more likely than not.

I was a very, very bad math teacher at my first school (I was basically "playing school" and acting like I remembered my math teachers acted.. I had a CS/Math major, not an Education major. I knew the content, but not the pedagogy). The next school I taught at had structures in place that helped me understand what the actual goals of a teacher are and how to reach them. I improved drastically (and noticed the students and teachers at that school were better overall than my first school)

hdctambien··on Pandemic homeschoolers who are not going back
I don't disagree with you. When I was in school (and still now, really) if there wasn't a dragon or a spaceship on the cover, I wasn't interested in it. I remember more about Where the Red Fern Grows, but not much (a kid gets mail order dogs to hunt with and (spoilers) the dogs die ... because the dogs always die). The only thing I remember about Silas Marner is that he buried his money and it was stolen (not a spoiler, that's like chapter 1).

Something to know about English classes in particular (but also History and other liberal arts/non-science classes) is that isn't not about "the books", but critical thinking and discussion. In fact, it's likely that the mandated standards don't specify specific books to read. It turns out, though, that in a class of 30+ kids, it's easiest (or even possible) to have a critical discussion if everyone reads the same books at the same time.

Also, if the kids think they are being "taught the book" but the teacher is trying to teach "literary literacy" using "the book" as an example, that's when you get arguments like "I didn't learn anything!" and "This is a waste of my time!" and "This other book is better!". Those arguments are besides the point. You should have been talking about why the author made the literary decisions they made, what were the themes? Whose point of view was it told from? How was the book impactful (or not)?

These are the standards in Texas. Other states should have this information publicly available and I assume they will be very similar.

https://tea.texas.gov/sites/default/files/ch110c.pdf

For English II these are the skills a student should learn (notice no specific books are mentioned, but "traditional", "contemporary", "classical", and "diverse" are used to describe the books)

- The student develops oral language through listening, speaking, and discussion

- The student uses newly acquired vocabulary expressively

- The student reads grade-appropriate texts independently.

- The student is expected to self-select text and read independently for a sustained period of time.

- The student uses metacognitive skills to both develop and deepen comprehension of increasingly complex texts

- The student responds to an increasingly challenging variety of sources that are read, heard, or viewed

- The student recognizes and analyzes literary elements within and across increasingly complex traditional, contemporary, classical, and diverse literary texts

- The student recognizes and analyzes genre-specific characteristics, structures, and purposes within and across increasingly complex traditional, contemporary, classical, and diverse texts

- The student uses critical inquiry to analyze the authors' choices and how they influence and communicate meaning within a variety of texts.

- The student analyzes and applies author's craft purposefully in order to develop his or her own products and performances.

- The student uses the writing process recursively to compose multiple texts that are legible and use appropriate conventions

- The student uses genre characteristics and craft to compose multiple texts that are meaningful

- The student engages in both short-term and sustained recursive inquiry processes for a variety of purposes

Much like learning a foreign language is about more than learning vocabulary, but you can't learn how to talk in a restaurant if you don't know the restaurant related vocabulary. English class is about more than reading books, but you can't have those discussions if you haven't read the books. Or, it would be much more difficult to effectively "analyze literary elements" in a classroom setting with 30 kids that all ready 30 different books.

Sure, teachers can be better or worse (or very, very bad) at teaching the material, or conveying what is being taught. But if you view English class as equivalent to "sitting under a tree and reading a book" (that was another commenter's words, not yours) then you're missing the forest for the tree and it won't matter how good the teacher is, you will be fighting them the whole way (which is maybe your point about not being able to challenge someone that doesn't want to be challenged)

hdctambien··on Pandemic homeschoolers who are not going back
I read an article (or maybe a biography author interview on NPR) about how pretty much all of his double-meanings/literary references came from the honors English curriculum from his time in school (probably pre-80's Dylan).

However, now when I try to google for it I just find pages and pages of results about whether he deserved the Nobel prize or not.

hdctambien··on Pandemic homeschoolers who are not going back
> most teachers aren’t experts, they just seem like that, to kids

Oof. That's cold. Not necessarily wrong, but cold. I mean, most software developers are not actually good at developing software, they just seem like that because they've only been asked to write the same CRUD app over and over again.

Teachers may not be "experts" like a PhD in a topic is an expert, but they are educated (Bachelors minimum, many states require a Masters eventually) but they are often experts in education.

It turns out just knowing a lot about a topic does not qualify you to teach it (see: many college professors). Effective teaching is a skill that lots of people think they have, but few actually do.

It doesn't really matter what Hamlet said. Literature is a class where you learn to express yourself and are exposed to how other people/cultures/times express themselves in a structured way.

And how would you know that you don't care about Hamlet unless you were made to read it?

You could live a successful life without reading any books ever (you could even be President of the United States!) but it would be much richer if you were exposed to ideas/topics that challenge you. And who knows where you could use that information. Heck, Bob Dylan made an entire career as a musician off of the AP English curriculum.

hdctambien··on Pandemic homeschoolers who are not going back
Reading threads about public school on HN and threads about WFH/in-person makes me wonder if there is a relationship between the people that are anti-public school and pro-WFH or if there is a dissonant-relationship between anti-public school and pro-in-person.

I am pro-WFH and pro-public school. But my experience (public school student, public state university, 7 years public school teacher, 6 years in-office programmer, 4 years WFT programmer) is drastically different from many of the posts I read in these threads.

If school is a "prison" full of incapable/ineffectual/communist teachers indoctrinating the "inmates"... what is an office?

The routine of school is prison, but the routine of an office is good? Ineffectual teachers? What about ineffectual managers? Lefty teachers indoctrinating children? Corporations have convinced us that if the minimum wage increases or taxes go up then McDonalds and Apple will just close their doors and decide to go out of business rather than make a teeny bit less profit!

hdctambien··on Ask HN: What is the most bloated website you use
Loading a page of text is effectively instantaneous. If the user's goal is to read that text, then anything else on the page that slows it down is bloat (from the user's perspective).

All the stuff that is extraneous to the reason you visited the webpage would be bloat.

Think about a news article on [insert your favorite news website]. Often before you can see the article, you have to process a bunch of JS (SPA framework, tracker code, etc) before the text loads and you can get the info you were looking for.

hdctambien··on Abolish High School (2015)
> a place your kids can go and be safe while you work

The last 18 months have shown us that this is really what parents (and the economy) want out of school.

Education comes after babysitting on the list of priorities.

hdctambien··on Abolish High School (2015)
I can't speak for every (or most, or even some) case of bullying. But keep in mind when someone says "I was bullied and the teachers did nothing" they are saying that from the memory of a 10 - 17 year old with little to no insight of what was happening from the perspective of the adults.

There are a million things that could result in a student bullying other kids. Are their parents drug addicts? Alive? Are they living out of their car? Does the bully go to bed hungry because the only time he gets meals is from school? Is the bully depressed and cutting themselves? Is the bully a drug addict? Is the bully working a night job so he can help his family pay rent?

None of these are things you can (legally) tell the target of their bullying and should be dealt with in ways other than "significant punishment". So from the perspective of the bullied, it looks like nothing is being done. But in the background, there are probably several adults working to remediate the situation.

Also, there probably aren't enough counselors/admins and your bully just isn't high enough on the bully-list to be dealt with (ie, that kid that is hitting people in the face with chairs needs to be dealt with before the kid that calls other kids names... and there are still 10 unfilled positions at the school).

Or the staff doesn't have the right training.

Or maybe the bully is just an a-hole.

Or the bully is a [rich|important|litigious] person's kid.

hdctambien··on Abolish High School (2015)
From a teachers perspective, the problem with cheating is that it doesn't help me help you. Especially if you are cheating from the get-go, it can take a while before I notice it and by then it might be too late.

Tests are supposed to be assessments, not some sort of trial-by-question or student ranking system. (Whether a particular teacher/school treats them that way is another discussion). If your assessment shows that you know 20% of the material, then I can help you learn (at least some of) the other 80%. However, if you know 20% of the material but cheat your way to an 80% on the assessment, then I will try to help you with the last 20% assuming you know the 60% of the content that you cheated on. At best that will end up with you knowing 40% of the material, but more likely you won't be able to learn much more than the 20% you already knew because I won't have the information to approach the content correctly for you.

And in the next unit, that missing 80% will compound and you'll learn even less. (I teach Computer Science... so imagine trying to learn for-loops if you don't really know how to declare/initialize variables)

So, cheating really only hurts yourself. You will be one of those people that doesn't get the job, or gets fired. But you could have been someone that was successful at the job if you had been honest on the assessments and got the help you needed when you needed it. (Similarly, I think guessing on assessments is a bad idea, because it can hide misunderstandings from the teacher and the student)

hdctambien··on The problem with reinforced concrete (2016)
> might be good advice in Seattle, but if I told a local builder to worry about frost mitigation where I live now (Singapore) they'd probably question my sanity

Texas felt the same way until February!

hdctambien··on The problem with reinforced concrete (2016)
Wasn't one of the problems with Boston's Big Dig that the contractors put an extra inch between bolts which saved them a ton of money (but ultimately killed a person)?
hdctambien··on How Intuitive Are Macs Really?
And "real life" cutting and pasting that the metaphor was based on (scrapbooking, ransom notes, etc...)
hdctambien··on All Hail King Pokémon
The original dual lands are very powerful in the game and haven't been reprinted since Revised so there aren't a lot of them. And people pay that much for them.

Modern dual lands come with restrictions/penalties for taking advantage of their dualness (time delays, damage, choosing which version to use when played, etc) and they are often some of the most valuable cards in a set.

hdctambien··on How to Teach Math?
> solve 10 generic and meaningless problems using this formula

I used to think this too, even when I started teaching. But I think if you look at a (modern?) textbook you'll see that those problems are not actually generic.

They are often designed problems that are trying to help you gain insights as you solve them. Each problem is probably demonstrating a different interesting pattern, if you are looking for that. Admittedly, students are not taught what to look for in those problems and if the text book as "answers to odd problems" in the back of the book, then there are probably 2x the number of problems necessary.

I teach HS Computer Science and I have to teach about division with ints and doubles. It would be nice if I could just explain the rules and give 2 or 3 examples and be done with it... but it turns out I have to have them work through lots of "generic and meaningless problems"

10 / 5 5 / 10 10 / 10 10 / 3 3 / 10 10 / 5.0 10.0 / 5 10.0 / 5.0 10 / 3.0 10.0 / 3 10.0 / 3.0 10 / 10.0 10.0 / 10 10.0 / 10.0

Each of those problems demonstrates a different "edge case". Towards the end there are some repetitive ideas I could leave off (once they know that double/int, int/double, double/double all evaluate to a double it may be overkill to keep repeating those patterns, but...) If I don't have them work through each of those problems, it is likely that at least one student will pick up the wrong pattern and run into problems in their labs when they encounter those patterns.

That being said, I think the biggest problem with math education (in the US) is that many Elementary teachers would probably rank their Mathematics skill as one of their lowest skills. I personally know an elementary school teacher (with a master's degree) that took her last Math class her Junior year in high school. I met her in her college Math credit course which was a Computer Science survey course where we listened to talks by researchers and wrote 1 page papers about what they were researching.. I know she's a great teacher, but she just doesn't have the math background to teach more than "these are the steps to do math, follow them to get the answer."

hdctambien··on How to Teach Math?
My first year teaching math (12th grade, "standard" level (below "intensive" and "honors")), I had a student that could solve "equations with fractions for x" but she was struggling with a word problem. I knew she could do the math, but I was struggling to understand where she was losing it.

The word problem was basically the same as in the video. If you're moving 20 miles/hour how long will it take to go 40 miles. (honestly, this was 20 years ago ... the problem probably said "20 MPH" ... it wasn't a very good textbook)

I read the problem to her, similarly to how the guy in the video was trying to explain. "If you are going 20 miles... per hour..."

She was in drivers ed at the time, so I tried talking about her speedometer and "MPH and how that stands for Miles Per Hour"...

Eventually I wrote it down for her as a fraction "20 miles / 1 hour" and not only did she figure it out but she also said "Oh my god, that's what MPH means? I thought that was just a number I had to match with the speed limit signs!"

One of the toughest parts of teaching is figuring out where you need to start (for each student). The thing that gets a student stuck might not even be related to the material... they may have an incorrect preconceived notion that you're not aware of so they think they know what MPH is, but it's actually something completely different, so you are not effectively communicating with each other because all the words you are using have different meanings.

hdctambien··on How to Teach Math?
Yes, that is more a misunderstanding of the purpose/role of university homework vs highschool homework.
hdctambien··on Ahoyo – Build a single-page online presence
Is this the same thing as about.me?

I signed up for that 10? years ago when I saw it on hacker news [1]. And that was apparently just a clone of flavors.me

Are these just sites that ask you to enter a ton of personal data so they can sell it?

Or are people benefiting from this? More than a LinkedIn or Twitter or Instagram or wix or Google site or free hosted WordPress or medium?

I had an idea for a site sellmyinfo.com where you enter your info and I'd split the profits of selling it with you. Maybe that idea has wings?

[1] I must have seen an article 4 days before this, but "about.me" is hard to Google for https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2025764

hdctambien··on Amazon workers vote against unionizing in Alabama
It's used as a joke in a lot of circles. "My daughter's old enough to date, I better clean my gun"
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →