HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

heimatau

868 karma · joined April 25, 2015

I love research. I like all kinds though & I love tech news.

Pro-tip to HackerNews (emailed when commented on; not mine): http://www.hnreplies.com

Current past-time: Certifications (electrical and cad tools) and Masters program (at my leisure).

Previous hobbies: DIY car repair, Handyman work

BTC: 17z2QWMByv5NHnMMg4VFwspJeL63Hn3Dm2

submissionscomments
heimatau··on Google/Fitbit will monetise health data and harm consumers
Click fraud sounds like an ominous term. But let's be real here. We aren't truly opting into all this tracking. I'd rather call it anonymous clicks. As for Google trying to resist it, I strongly suspect there isn't a network actively trying to give privacy back to the people.

On a related tangent, CloudFlare creating a Google Analytics tracker could help lessen Google's tracking. But this battle should've been waged about 10 years ago. It's a shame that Hydra has many formidable heads.

heimatau··on Hal Finney’s proposal for optimizing Bitcoin to be enabled in Bitcoin Core
Given that the network is checking constantly from numerous sources. It's a pretty significant improvement in efficiency.
heimatau··on It could be possible to transfer data through gravitational waves (2018)
> Well, that civilization need a sport too.

This legit made me laugh. Thanks for this.

heimatau··on Google to Increase Push for Apps to Give Cut of In-App Purchases
I agree that this now is extremely costly but it's better late than never.
heimatau··on The US is using the Guardian to justify jailing Assange for life
This is actually a very fair point. Not sure why we don't have news outlets pointing this very critical point.
heimatau··on Calibre 5.0
My experience with Calibre has been improving as of late. I'm really grateful for the snappiness of the software. I hope we can have a separate epub reader, so that I don't need to keep Calibre always open to skim through a book. Calibre is more resource intensive than I was expecting when I first downloaded it many many years ago.
heimatau··on Google to Increase Push for Apps to Give Cut of In-App Purchases
Why can't the top developers pool their money together and invest into an ecosystem that is more fair? They make enough profit. They could easily lead with a carrot (if you invest, you get preferential treatment). I understand the scale of this problem is immense but it seems that the duopoly of having only two choices is damaging to the high value companies on this platform and they are aggressively going to extract profit from them (of course the small players too but...one would need the top players).

If Epic doesn't win, then this (invest in an alternative) needs to be the next step. Seriously. We need to fight for sovereignty or we'll lose ground in more ways than we can imagine.

heimatau··on Mark in the Middle
> why employees at tech companies believe they have the right to police people's opinions period

Two things about this: 1. When FB Answers was a thing. I was very quickly banned from it, through various obscure mechanisms. All I was doing was gently being a contrarian on newsworth/fad topics. Partly contrarian because I was read up on a lot of scientific literature and other times, I just had different opinions than the 'popular' one. There is a culture of control there, full stop. Especially when your valid and potentially correct opinion goes against FB employee. I knew immediately than FB Answers wasn't going to succeed because they wouldn't allow a plurality of perspectives. 2. Let's be fully clear about this. This is entirely Zuck's decision. He runs a tight ship with clear guidelines. Zuck is playing politics right now, full stop. Saying one thing publicly and saying another privately. This 'leaked' memo isn't something that Zuck had no idea that it would be leaked. It's calculated. It's a public statement. How enforced will this leaked memo be? Will that be leaked? Doubtful. Zuck is trying to skirt responsibility with this 1st amendment problem. If FB really allowed dissent then Alex Jones and others would be allowed on the platform.*

*I do think the worst ideas need to be allowed on a platform. It allows the possibility to discussions. There are cults around various topics but...that doesn't mean that those with scientific understanding have perfect rhetoric about everything they say. Everyone needs to refine and it's best done with allowing everyone to the table.

heimatau··on Is revenue model more important than culture?
Thanks for the feedback! I was going to edit it but looks like I can't.

Regardless, the main idea is that I support greed as a motivator because financially sovereign teams don't exist nor scale enough to support a given cause (especially if it's a very difficult problem).

heimatau··on CIA Labs
> Each team has their own budget and has to pay for the resources they consume, even if that resource is another thing in another US Government team.

What ensures this? No one.

Last I checked the Pentagon 'lost' billions. Various agencies aren't rigorous with the taxpayer's money, also their time horizons seem skewed (very little R&D to reduce various costs internally).

Nor are they a fair actor. How could a single inventor petition the govt to pay up? Don't say a lawsuit because 'national security' supersedes any petition.

Nonetheless, my main point is none of the above. My main point is why would a worker/inventor have any right over a technology? Their job is funded by taxpayers. In business, the same is true. 'Work for hire' is the concept/term. I get that they are trying to modify this to returning some money to the people but...if 150k is the limit, will this be a new minimum wage? Or does this limit account for inflation? Honestly, highly skilled workers (mostly) know their value to the market. I think it's a poor use of taxpayers money to give a % of an invention. Fire the bosses, be more nimble, there are plenty of alternatives to this degradation entering the equation.

heimatau··on CIA Labs
What if the buyer of the technology is the US govt? Will those Officers have to give it to them for free?
heimatau··on Is revenue model more important than culture?
Preface: Might be easier to read my comment withOUT the parenthesis. Then go back and read with them.

I fully agree with you guys on a macro-scale. I didn't have this position years ago but now it's a firm position.

But my observation is that no one (read: a significant majority) is financially sovereign (FS), therefore they mis-calculate the time/labor costs and it's economic value/costs.

To think of this another way, if your (financial/material/etc) lives depended the Amish's* jam or chairs (or anything else they make). You can depend on their work, up to a certain scale. But even most software projects don't have this dependability because software is generally repackaged to fit a narrow use-case.

Iff (if and only if) the Amish were to embrace the automation technology, then you could depend on the Amish scaling for whatever you need.

Financial sovereignty is very powerful but the drawbacks are that the team, to do all the needed work, might not be FS. (Hence why I mention the Amish) This FS doesn't scale (this could with the Amish; if they wanted to provide jam to everyone, etc) with the complexity of the problem nor the robustness of the problem being solved. Another important drawback is that those that are FS tend to be myopic to those that aren't (i.e. their market/customers). This problem is pretty big as well. To find a product/service that solves all these criteria is immense and dare I say, improbable, hence my agreement to the two comments above. The simple solution is to try and align with the better alternative that have a positive feedback loop (i.e. monetary gain to improve the work).

* Note: I do understand that Amish charge money for jam/chairs/etc but the cost is tends to be nominal/small.

heimatau··on Facebook Accused of Watching Instagram Users Through Cameras
> would people stop using Instagram because of it?

Honestly, what other people do with their data/privacy concerns doesn't affect my life. So, if they are cool with that, that's on them.

For me (my family), we are fairly anti-technology at the home. 'Anti' in the respect that we actually enjoy the simple life and retirement for us is on a farm, off the grid. So, this behavior, for me, is the last straw. I will be removing IG within the next 12 months. (I won't get a FB,Whatsapp, etc)

heimatau··on The Battle over Dyslexia
The font Verdana has been the best thing for me. None of the 'dyslexia fonts' have been desirable. You might need to increase the size a little (depending on how the UI renders it) but it's very enjoyable to me.

I tend to even switch words when I read my kids because the font isn't normal to me, as opposed to when I'm on a computer.

heimatau··on DMT drug study investigates the ‘entities’ people meet while tripping
This could be a good analogy to what our brain experience. We do compartmentalize things, for efficiency reasons. (I.e. a book is a book. we have concrete models of the world to reference; like a PCB board has concrete functions it performs)

Then...one can swipe the board with a wet finger that produces unintended non-negative consequences. Same could be said of DMT and the brain. Great comparison Stierlitz!

heimatau··on Chuck Feeney Is Now Officially Broke
> Seems like that was by design.

Yup. Even Adam Smith talked about this, it helps propel the capitalist system.

heimatau··on Chuck Feeney Is Now Officially Broke
I'm not sure why people are down voting. Adam Smith would agree with you BrainInAJar.

Maybe HackerNews needs to read some Adam Smith.

heimatau··on Chuck Feeney Is Now Officially Broke
Imagine...if other Feeney's (mega rich; north $100M) were able to give back to their communities. In some dependable and systematic way.

I'd call it Sexat. It's like Taxes but spelled backwards.

heimatau··on Britain’s CO2 Emissions Have Fallen to Levels Last Seen in 1890 (2018)
> it made things worse by adding aviation and shipping...Talk about creative accounting.

I'm glad someone else recognizes it.

I'm not a massive proponent of 'local manufacturing' because there are efficiencies to be had letting others build their skills in something that you might not want to focus on. Regardless, I do think that the public's debate about this should be framed with your post (perfunctory), so that we can wrestle with all the unintended consequences and we can make those important decisions as an informed public.

P.S. This goes for any country. Not just Britain, hence I didn't mention Britain in my post. Ultimately, I'm just glad others see the shady 'facts' that deceive the public.

heimatau··on Nikola: How to Parlay an Ocean of Lies into a Partnership with GM
> No. Because people don't drive cross country everyday.

Do you like spending a non-insignificant amount of time driving to/from a gas station (or electric charging station) and then spending even more time to wait until your local energy (car's tank/battery cells) has recharged enough for you to go again for....non-insignificant amount of time...etc..etc.

How many people have done this? How many years? etc. It's a pretty important first principle to have a system where energy density is a maximum (or at least significantly higher theoretical maximum than existing trends [i.e. Li-ion]).

> For grid storage density is also totally irrelevant.

I'm not discussing this. I'm talking about high power demands needed for semi's/trucks. The above (in this comment) is also considering the consumer market efficiency to be had.

> Go look what is possible

I'm aware but many of the efficiencies that are implemented for Li-ion [and it's variants] could theoretically compound the limit with hydrogen based. Abundance of essential compounds is a better by product than a scarce quantity of essential compounds.

P.S. This is about moving the goal posts. We're talking about innovation in a specific market. But ultimately the end goal is improving all aspects that affect society. (less destructive to the earth, doing more with less, etc)

heimatau··on Ex-Google boss Eric Schmidt: US 'dropped the ball' on innovation
Is no one going to talk about the hypocrisy? Eric Schmidt isn't a beacon of sensible innovation pushing America forward. Peter Thiel called him out eight years ago [1] and I strongly encourage you to watch the 4 min clip.

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Q26XIKtwXQ

heimatau··on To manage wildfire, California looks to what tribes have known all along
> Is there any indication that this is caused by shortage of funds?

States don't have the luxury to just print money. For example, California uses inmates to supplement their firefighting workforce and at least 9 States have come to our aid this season, due to covid19 reducing that slave/prison labor.

I wouldn't call it 'policy' that prevents OR and WA. Most likely true in CA. I'd call it lack of desire. Most politicians aim for the most popular ideas that help get them reelected, not something prudent.

I don't care if I get down voted. Even if the West Coast wasn't in drier conditions, this would still be a problem. Not only that, I'm skeptical that WA is that dry. Maybe in select places but I'm very skeptical, maybe the heat changed the situation as well (record highs all throughout the West Coast prior to these fires).

Look, if you aren't blaming your leaders while things are this bad. How can you praise them when things are good? This is your life. This is your health. This is you and your families future. The blame falls on them, full stop.

The fact that the Governor didn't threaten the Bay/Tech Sector with steep taxes if they don't help fix it, is another stupid move. This isn't rocket science. This isn't something too far for humanity to solve. If you care about your State, be patriot and save it from the fires.

We're in crisis after crisis, yet no one is actually leading. Good luck having a State with 2 more decades of this. If you didn't murder them through gross negligence then you destroyed their lungs/health with all this smoke.

Gov Newsom signed a thing to allow prisoners to accept a low paying job as a firefighter? Seriously? Why not argue with your legislature and work on behalf of the people? That's right, no one gives a damn and if you think to the contrary, what actions have they done that make you think that?

Did you know a lot of residential new construction, in CA, is in fire prone areas? This is because...? Good leaders? Or are the people going to demand more from their leaders?

heimatau··on To manage wildfire, California looks to what tribes have known all along
Make no mistake. These problems are solvable. There is an active political will (via the majority of people). Yet, the three States that are burning millions of acres are apathetic right now. This could be solved for many years going forward. Raise taxes (the richer, the higher the fee) then fix the problem and also force the Federal Government to do a better job with their land. This isn't just a State/local govt problem a large portion of the West Coast is owned by the Federal Government.

Trump is brazen, you now have political coverage to be just as brazen to fix these issues. We should be expecting more from our leaders because what we have now is a poor rationalization for shitty leadership. 16 of the past 20 years have been record breaking fires in California, this isn't a new problem. It's just long overdue to be solved.

P.S. I have zero faith that this will be fixed. It's fairly clear to me that the entire political servants aren't actually leading, they're apathetic while the country literally burns. It's not a difficult thing to ask that our elected leaders stop this in the short-term, let alone the long-term. It's difficult when we rationalize their bullshit, so expect more.

heimatau··on Nikola: How to Parlay an Ocean of Lies into a Partnership with GM
> Just looking at the density is not enough.

On the contrary, it should be the driving force about making long-term decisions to benefit society. Hell, I'd be all for mini-nuclear in vehicles but the ability to make it safe is such a high threshold that it's not even remotely feasible.

No one thought electric cars would be where they are today. Elon made this electric car market happen by making it sexy (and selling only premium cars) which helped him double down on the real vision. There is a ceiling for the battery and it's not as high as many think.

We'll see what Tesla battery day shows but my main point is this: That to improve society with long-term thinking, we need to be more innovative and it's my opinion that attacking Milton's weaknesses is a waste of the public's time/energy. Especially when short sellers get a lot more freedom in how they deal with the market. No one is being a fair arbiter of the facts. Hydrogen is better for hauling big loads, it just is. To bring that to market is Nikola's real challenge. The upside to hydrogen is greater than the upside of li-ion, full stop. Shouldn't we want the better solution for society?

heimatau··on Nikola: How to Parlay an Ocean of Lies into a Partnership with GM
> The guy certainly seems to have a problem with telling the truth.

I actually disagree with this take but it gets close to the problem with Trevor Milton. Trevor is very unpolished. I'm skeptical of how detailed he gets with all the in's and out's with the technologies he's trying to innovate and make more efficient. What's going for him is a few things, he's partnering with many companies which means he's mitigating the company's risk. Now that Musk created the market, others want to join in and try whatever route that sticks.

Musk on the other hand, speaks in more precise words when describing a topic. Musk does sell vaporware but...eventually (behind 'schedule') Musk delivers. This lazy focus on manifesting a specific vision what what Musk is doing. He'll let the entire engineering department go, if they aren't willing to work hard at making the future a reality.

Going full circle, the energy density of hydrogen fuel cell is the future. I don't see how it's not. All you need now is for Toyota to join forces with them and you'll have an unstoppable force that will help reduce emission drastically and at a large scale. The technology is very close (1, maybe 2 iterations away) and I doubt they are far away from a breakthrough. I don't believe Milton could've focused on Hydrogen semi's prior to the success of Tesla, he doesn't have that skill but...he's making due with what he's after. He's also being wise at selling electric trucks too because the market is primed for it (read: Musk primed it).

In conclusion, there are a lot of investors deep into Nikola. If Milton gets in the way of bringing this realistic engineering challenge to market, the investors will change it up. I'm not certain of how much voting say that Milton has but...it's a good sign that he stepped back from CEO role. He's way too sloppy with his words but...he brings the hype and investors are still wanting his hype. It's messy but nothing worth doing is ever blameless.

P.S. I don't own either stock. Nor any energy/battery/car/electric stocks. I'm just interested in advancing our technology.

heimatau··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Opens for Business
I'm wondering a few things:

1. Can we do a direct stock listing?

2. How much equity needs to be offered?

3. Is there a minimum valuation that needs to be met to be listed?

4. What are the fees to be listed?

heimatau··on Apple Disabling 'Sign in with Apple' for Epic Games on September 11
I disagree with your entire take. Namely because you assume they can do whatever they want.

A mall owner can't dictate how it's residents receive money.* Nor would it be wise of them to take a share of their commercial resident's sales.*

I'm not arguing on legality. I'm arguing based on social norms (not ethics either).

Apple is extreme social behavior of a corporation. There are multiple situations where Apple copied something another app developer made.

I doubt Epic will win but...it may open up the conversation and maybe finally encourage other developers to push back on Apple, so that a more socially acceptable structure is within the App Store (and it's ecosystem).

If this doesn't cause Apple to reform, the next escalation is clearly inciting a frenzy to push the Govt to execute judgement with the antitrust laws. Even if they're outdated, the case is clear. Apple hasn't just been a bad actor once or twice but numerous instances. If Epic does this with their current case, I'm uncertain that they'll achieve their desired outcome because their limited situation doesn't seem as clear cut.

* - If the contract says this...it's still not socially fair. Land is vast...the phone ecosystem is not. Which means a mall owner will meet a lot of competition to push them to either change or they'll go out of business due to undue hardship put on the commercial tenants.

heimatau··on What Satoshi Did Not Know (2015) [pdf]
When I said 'no proof exists', I didn't mean 'no proof of authority'. I mean no document exists. Assuming Satoshi 'covered ones tracks' is a straw-man because then you open up the possibility to anyone being Satoshi, not an exclusive person.

Please understand that many people talked with Satoshi through email as well. Those emails are mostly private. When someone points to an authority, the entire argument is a straw-man, even with someone very relevant to the discussion.

> Satoshi seemed to be very good C++ programmer who had interests in electronic cash and cryptography but not a cryptographer.

What physical circumstantial evidence exists that is shows Kleiman was good at anything you've described or was even interested in these during 2008 or earlier (heck, I can't find anything prior to 2013)? What about any interest into any digital cash/gold attempts?

The argument you're giving is fairly persistent in the crypto community. I'm not entirely sure why, except intellectual laziness. The irony here is 'proof of authority' argument...is an absolute contradiction to what bitcoin's primary function is (trustless 3rd party system). Why are people lifting up a 3rd party and not the code/evidence? An opinion (no matter how relevant) isn't what we're looking for, we are looking for evidence. Did scientific reasoning leave everyone?

(edited for grammar)

heimatau··on What Satoshi Did Not Know (2015) [pdf]
I apologize for not being clear enough. "has anyone heard of Kleiman? Legit question." By this I mean what substantive proof exists that Kleiman was interested with the underlying technologies that bitcoin incorporates?

> He was getting interviewed by US TV stations so he had some reputation in the security industry. The field is pretty vast. This is like saying because I've made websites, I can somehow fix your laptop. (I probably could but I couldn't come up with a solution fast and well thought out.) Satoshi was clearly meticulous about this, if you've read enough of their posts, it's clear as day.

> And btw who heard of Jeff Bezos before Amazon? Nobody. A lot of top talent is in hedge funds. So, I'm sure many people were looking. It is fair to say I choose a weak logical argument but the point is still valid (hopefully the added clarity to my intent pushes us deeper into our actual points).

> You can not judge somebody just by looking at their past. People change and evolve. Sure, this applies if we're trying to gauge someone's character but this doesn't apply in the expertise required to be Satoshi. Terry Tao (expert mathematician) isn't going to just randomly come up with the next bulletproof SHA function. It's out of his scope. Bitcoin is out of the scope of Kleiman's skillset. I have seen zero evidence to the contrary, other than a false narrative (perpetuated by 'news') that him and CSW created Bitcoin. Even the court has thrown out numerous dated evidence [1,2].

Being a computer forensics specialist doesn't easily port to creating a blend of PGP, Hashcash, eCash, bitgold, etc. Satoshi was an expert at this stuff. What evidence shows that Kleiman did anything? Even in the Kleiman/CSW court cases, there isn't evidence that's been produced by either party. That's the court of law. Please don't avoid this point, no evidence exists to tie Kleiman even to the ideas of digital cash. I haven't seen any and I looked into it heavily, maintaining an open mind. I got no dog in the fight, just a sizable curiosity to this mysterious character.

[1] - https://decrypt.co/21995/us-judge-throws-out-craig-wrights-l... [2] - http://blockchaingrade.org/experts-dissect-craig-wrights-sat...

heimatau··on What Satoshi Did Not Know (2015) [pdf]
>I think it's either Hal Finney or Dave Kleiman.

You must be a new bitcoin user. Before Craig Wright came into the scene, has anyone heard of Kleiman? Legit question. What evidence is there of Dave? Dave wasn't even around then, zero evidence exists outside of CSW's claims.

← PreviousPage 5 of 17Next →