HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hennsen

197 karma · joined June 30, 2017

submissionscomments
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
How would all these things be legal just because an IP in a logfile isn’t?
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Why are ip adresses even considered personal data? They aren’t for most people and situations, unless a lot if other activities are done. All of which would be already illegal without consent by the law. The ip adress i write this from changes every day, and nobody can know if i share it with someone or not.

I want to be protected from marketing firms that sell my email adress , and everyone who uses it to send me mails for whatever product to buy judt because i entered it for some totally different reason. Those shall be fined with 5 figure amounts.

I don’t see how my(and my housemates/office colleagues etc) ip in the logfiles of the webserver which a small business rented for 3€ to upload 3 html filed can be abused (without storing my email and name without consent which is actual personal data and therefore illegal) and i dont want my hairdresser, car mechanic etc be in need to consult a lawyer to understand all that stuff and have a day worth of bureaucracy and adfing a “we have your current ip in the logs” note just because they want me to be able to google their street adresses.

The law is simply not well crafted for no use if the latter is the case.

hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
And all that stuff is super complex... for a number which is not person bound and personally identifying in the furst place. Only with a lot more effort. So my critique is, the lawmakers should have made actions to use ip‘s to identify persons illegal, but not storing ips themselves.
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Which is exactly my point put a bit shorter :)
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
You put it to a total overexaggerated extreme here.

That doesn’t help.

IP adresses are not 1:1 assigned to a person for a whole lifetime, fingerprints are.

Only with a lot additional effort and connection to other databases, IP adresses can actually be connected with a person, but only for an uncertain period of time, finding out this timespan, and ensuring it’s really only exactly this one person requires even more effort.

So a properly crafted law would have made all these efforts illegal, and put high fines on them, but not the decades old practice of storing ip adresses in logfiles.

hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Ip adresses are needed for security anslysis in case of attacks, for example.

the thing is not about doing what you propose but that however you‘re doing it, you have a lot of bureaucracy and legal insecurity right now.

The examples of wrongdoing you give should be leading to hard measures. But those with good intentions shouldn’t have high bureaucracy costs.

To be clear: i don’t say these laws shouldn’t exist. They just should have been targeted at the actual wrongdoers and put smallest possible burden on all with no bad intentions.

hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Exactly. Plus they don’t simply concentrate on people intentionally/ignorantly abusing data (putting my email on mailing lists again and again and ignoring me telling multiple times i don’t want it, reselling, etc) but put a lof of insecurity and bureaucracy on people with nothing more than a static website with IP adresses in logfiles...
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Extreme over-exaggeration in my opinion.

Actually, just because one critcices the way the law is made doesn’t mean they think it’s basic intention is wrong.

As of your slavery example: Forbidding slavery is one(good) thing. Saying „everbody having somebody work for them out of anything but total free will and not being able to prove it is doing forbidden slavery“ is something else. If i must work because i need to eat and pay rent, is that total free will? How can anyone prove that?

So sure, the wording is extremely important.

hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
Which law is that exactly (german here, but i dont know what you’re referring to€
hennsen··on GDPR for lazy people: Block all European users with Cloudflare Workers
How does for example a small yoga studio’s email list fit in your examples? Or even just it’s website? Without cookies and login even - the IP adress in the log files alone is considered potential personal data that basically puts people in the need of consulting a lawyer about how to safely deal with that. And makes you a potential target to being sued and getting a lot of hassle. Even found nit guilty in the end, no one will pay days of time and energy needed for defense.

And then: What kind of online business can reasonably be done without using an email adress, if only for login/resetting password if lost? You either have no option to reset passwords, or must do it by phone, which is extremely expensive.

hennsen··on The sad state of sysadmin in the age of containers (2015)
Can you elaborate that?

Whats a “devops person” for you and what keeps them busy? And why cant they have systems that hum along self-healingly automated?

hennsen··on The sad state of sysadmin in the age of containers (2015)
DevOps is uniting dev and ops through code? I believe it’s at first and most important to unite them through good(early, often, honest, etc.) communication and collaboration instead of “you broke x” and “you have to fix y” as well as “this is the other (dev or ops depending who says it) departments fault/task is the most important thing in DevOps. The code is just a tool to make this collaboration easier / automate it where the other things already happened and all understood they work on the same goal and not as enemies.
hennsen··on Announcing Fuse Open
How/why is a tooltip (that can only contain a few words / one or two sentences with the same info already written above as i describe it) better than a link to the full webpage?
hennsen··on Announcing Fuse Open
Well. If I’m a regular reader of a blog I definitely don’t want to read such an explanation again and again and again...

On the top of the page i read „Create better native apps for iOS and Android with a new...“ (iphone se and accoring screen resolution, might look different elsewhere).

So i know the rough subject it’s about.

I agree that the first / every mention of the product name can be a hyperlink that shows me more details/full product Website. Thats unintrusive for regular readers and gives full info at a click for new readers.

As it is now i have to read multiple paragraphs until getting to such a link, that can be optimized.

hennsen··on Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of America’s clean electricity
I’ve been told not to discuss downvoting (see faq). That said i think too there should be a proposal to comment what you don’t like on downvoting as it is in stackoverflow... otherwise people neber know how to change their behavior.
hennsen··on Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of America’s clean electricity
I admit i don’t know much about the coal burning radiation output. And im even further away from knowing the perfect solution to the worlds energy needs. So i have many questions, driven by the wish to live in a intact environment and leaving it to those who come in a good state.

Where and how exactly is the radiation release of coal plants happening? I can imagine its maybe a difference if a smaller dose of radiation is put out slowly and spread more (in time and space terms)than if it’s concentrated on one point? Radiaton is anywhere thats clear... but we rarely get strong radiation caused illnesses from just catching cosmic radiation do we?

And how exactly are politics preventing proper storage?

I definitely don’t wanna promote coal, but where are these numbers proving coal killed and harmed more people than Fukushima and Tchernobyl and the many smaller incidents?

Also i often wonder - where could science of reusable energy and reduced consumption be if the billions invested in nuclear research were invested there instead?

hennsen··on Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of America’s clean electricity
How is nuclear power „clean“ with all the radioactive waste that needs to go somewhere when burnt down?
hennsen··on Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in Food
Yes it will be paid back. By generations to come. While the corporations who invented/introduced/pushed the stuff and got governments to support them by adjusting laws to allow doing it keep flourishing...
hennsen··on Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ software it gives away free
Wouldn’t the appropriate comparison be collecting the free cheese test pieces in a bag and selling them outside at a cheese booth?
hennsen··on Google's “Director of Engineering” Hiring Test (2016)
Yes. And that this kind of discovery - especially detecting if they lied at you in written text, which for me is an exclusion criterion - requires having read the text...
hennsen··on Google's “Director of Engineering” Hiring Test (2016)
And somebody putting only lies in a resume will turn super honest on the phone?
hennsen··on Ask HN: Do you do code review?
Yes i do whenever possible - that is, if the team i work with as a freelancer already does or is willing to follow my advice to do it. That is - disturbingly - not always the case.

I only worked with gitlab abd github pull/merge request code review tooling and found it ok. There’s Gerrit, but i had no chance to work with it yet. Obviously always depends on how they need to be done. When in doubt, just sit next to each other and look at the part of code and changes for the current task your working on that is about to be merged. Not always a special tool necessary and if you don’t know which one to use better just start than let the tool choice get in the way. That being said I’m not against tools!

Suggestions? As with any process or meeting, define what the scope is! Is it about coding style? Which are your guidelines for that one then? Is it about getting a second look if the story is implemented in a good, efficient way? Is it to verify definition of done rules are met? About having (good) tests? It’s probably not (counterexample i just had) to discuss the actual requirements defined by the story the code should fulfill... that should have happened at another time, probably with other persons, like the Product Owner. How often? I think it’s best to do it with each merge request for the code it contains, and maybe in defined tinespans for the whole project.

hennsen··on Why Does “=” Mean Assignment?
I value clarity and explicity a lot. And I’m someone who generally lines to think about proper naming of a variable twice to make it easier for future readers of code.

At the same time when reading

> How can a = a + 1? That’s like saying 1 = 2.

I think: Well, depends how you interpret it.

If the translation is „we state, that from now on, a is the previous value of a plus 1“ it’s totally ok.

Not a big difference from saying

a = b + c

So i‘m not sure if the usefulness if changing all languages to using := is that high that it’s worth to think about changing it in current languages - and even when inventing a new language I’m not sure if it’s helpful.

I also wonder if reassignment, beside counters that need to be changed with iteration/ appearance of the event to be counted, is a thing that should generally be avoided if possible. Ok maybe in general everything where data is transformed in iterations...

hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
It‘s easier to change bad behavior if someone clearly states what that is.

My use of „crappy“ in the very first comment? Did that hurt someones feelings because they love their non-Mac system? That i state i think most other hardware is bad?

I dont know, unless I’m told...

hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
Then there should be a recommendation too that people should write a comment what they don’t like instead of just voting to help people understand what they did wrong. Like this it feels like downvoting is simply abused to push down opinions some don’t like.
hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
I wonder why people downvote posts who wonder why people downvote posts in which others state personal experiences...
hennsen··on Why are diapers so expensive?
There definitely should a price system that also encompasses the health/environmental/social damage a product brings over its full production and lifecycle!

That would generally reward people so much for the good things you mentioned that they still could afgord the one bad thing...

hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
It’s a matter of taste i guess.

Unless you tell more about what you like in the one and what not in the other it’s hard to get a value from your experience report.

hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
Tried Dell once and didn’t like it. Dont remember exactly why. Plus the service to return the unsatisfying product was complicated. Last time i checked there was still something missing in the xps linux system so it wasn’t an option and i decided to leave Linux as main OS after 20 years. MacOS is not better in general, mainly it just has different annoyances e.g. less open and configurable - but therefore not changing things i got used to so fast as Ubuntu and the various graphical desktop suites (yes the superspecial tabbed window managers are more stable, but i dont like them) which seem to try new stuff i don’t need and like with every release.

I‘m based in Germany by the way, so my choice of products here might be different...

hennsen··on Making the Touch Bar useful by abandoning Apple guidelines
And have even crappier hardware (thinkpads with screen resolution and disk sizes of last decade, not much cheaper, anyone?) with Win 10 preinstalled...
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →