1,081 karma · joined January 5, 2017
Also, to be clear, is it correct that they haven't actually built such a device, this result is still just in simulation?
I could see this line of work having implications for autonomous weapons systems in a hypothetical future, but my understanding is that at this time they're on a pretty short leash with very narrow AI systems if they're using AI at all. Incentives could push those systems to get smarter as the autonomous arms race heats up, and if it does so in an unrestricted manner that could spell trouble along the lines discussed in this paper, but incentives are definitely aligned for any group to build weapons systems that can't be turned on their handlers, whether by human hackers or their own volition. Theories on optimal policies have no bearing if there's some encrypted remote kill command, or if as we start understanding ML models better, we can do things like hardware-block policies that lead to certain predicted outcome sequences (blocking an off switch, harming a human, etc.). Ultimately, the dynamics here seem to be an evolution of the problems of human force and violence, rather than a qualitative jump to a different sort of threat entirely.
Geometry proofs are a terrible way of introducing rigorous mathematical proofs to students. Seriously. I cannot overstate how misleading they are. I remember my first abstract algebra class in college, after the first HW I got called in by the TA because I tried to structure my proofs like I learned in geometry class - a sequence of symbols and references to hard-coded lists of axioms and prior deductions. I thought that's what proofs are, but they are not, at least not as humans do higher math. High school geometry tries to distill this process down to a symbol manipulation game that students can memorize and regurgitate, and in the process loses the essence of the thing it was meant to capture in the first place.
To be clear, there are serious ethical concerns and threats to human life associated with modern AI, but they have to do with technology shifting the balances of power between groups of humans (country vs. country, in-group vs. out-group), not superintelligent Terminators hiding nerve gas in your shoes.
That said, I bet there's some other criterion that would have the desired effect.
Drunk driving laws aren't a conspiracy by Big Taxi.
In a way, this dynamic is an effective, natural check on moderation. If moderation primarily removes stuff that most people think is junk, then alternatives competing on reduced moderation will be junk. If moderation removes valuable stuff that lots of people want, then other platforms that host it instead will receive more traffic and legitimacy.
It's kind of like the Reddit vs. Voat thing. Reddit isn't great, but Voat ended up a cesspool, because Reddit's biggest exoduses were driven by hate groups.
Instead, I think it's basically ok to say that your point applies to people who have reached a certain threshold of stability and security in your life, and isn't meant to imply that people who haven't reached that threshold ought to be able to simply will themselves into doing the same thing.
Second, by bringing up free computer access at a library, it connects the point you're trying to make with the really complicated nuances around poverty. Even assuming we ignore smartphones and tablets (because how can you get any work done on one?), the demographic that only has access to a device with a keyboard at a public library is going to be almost entirely facing (at least) moderate poverty, and life in poverty just looks very different from the kinds of backgrounds that the rest of your piece implicitly addresses. So, you could focus instead on the wealth of free software tools available to the people who are in some range of circumstances to take advantage of them, assuming that access to a device with a keyboard isn't the primary challenge.