HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

heyitsguay

1,081 karma · joined January 5, 2017

submissionscomments
heyitsguay··on Former Tesla employees say 2016 ‘Full Self-Driving’ video was staged
Sure, but the difference between savvy product testing and charlatanry is doing this as part of a quiet internal study vs. on stage at a massive public demonstration.
heyitsguay··on AWS us-east-1 outage
I'm having issues with us-east-2 now. Console is down, then when I try to sign into a particular service I just get "please try again later".
heyitsguay··on Numerics applied to Casimir geometry generates intersection with Alcubierre warp
Any physicists wanna throw some cold water on our hopes and dreams here? Compared to most papers with far-out results, there didn't seem to be any obvious caveats here. What's up with worldline numerics? Could there be any issues hiding in the numerical methods there? How established are those methods in the field?

Also, to be clear, is it correct that they haven't actually built such a device, this result is still just in simulation?

heyitsguay··on Optimal AI agents tend to seek power
This is a really cool paper (that I definitely haven't had the time to fully grok) but the jump from the theoretical environment to concerns about superintelligent AI taking over is a bit strained. It misses the same key issues that most similar arguments miss, even while presenting some really amazing results on statistical properties of optimal policies - there's a lot hidden in the "if physically possible" part of the quote from the paper: "Average-optimal agents would generally stop us from deactivating them, if physically possible". I can see how the arguments in the paper lead us up to the possibility of kinetic conflict with intelligent robots, but the dynamics of power at that stage then seem to be more about how we've embodied those robots rather than optimality results of their control policies. Did we give them off switches? Will they run out of energy after a while? How susceptible to physical damage are they? If someone outfits a million Predator drones with a control policy with a will to live, we may have trouble, but we probably were going to have trouble from the group that decided to build a million Predator drones, too. If the number is lower, more realistic, then you're talking about standard armed conflict.

I could see this line of work having implications for autonomous weapons systems in a hypothetical future, but my understanding is that at this time they're on a pretty short leash with very narrow AI systems if they're using AI at all. Incentives could push those systems to get smarter as the autonomous arms race heats up, and if it does so in an unrestricted manner that could spell trouble along the lines discussed in this paper, but incentives are definitely aligned for any group to build weapons systems that can't be turned on their handlers, whether by human hackers or their own volition. Theories on optimal policies have no bearing if there's some encrypted remote kill command, or if as we start understanding ML models better, we can do things like hardware-block policies that lead to certain predicted outcome sequences (blocking an off switch, harming a human, etc.). Ultimately, the dynamics here seem to be an evolution of the problems of human force and violence, rather than a qualitative jump to a different sort of threat entirely.

heyitsguay··on Web3? I have my DAOts
It also misses the point for a large class of data relevant to individual safety - if GP gets associated (truly or falsely) with [outrage of the week] and his buddy from HS recognizes the username, what happens when said buddy posts his address (or his kid's school address?) to an immutable data store. GP is a monster and the law isn't doing anything, we gotta take matters into our own hands!
heyitsguay··on DARPA Funded Researchers Accidentally Create the World’s First Warp Bubble
Really cool if it reproduces and there's follow-up. Is there a less awful, more credible site with this story? That page was real gross.
heyitsguay··on Ask HN: Why is everything changing too fast?
*When they add one more crap // Onto your favorite app // That's tumoreeee
heyitsguay··on Hackers are spamming businesses’ receipt printers with ‘antiwork’ manifestos
Yes it's like i always say, if poor people don't like being poor, why don't they simply buy more money?
heyitsguay··on Hackers are spamming businesses’ receipt printers with ‘antiwork’ manifestos
I've definitely seen some bad takes on /r/antiwork, and my general opinion is that the community on any large subreddit (political or otherwise) gets pretty toxic pretty quickly if not heavily moderated, but it's hard to deny that the rise in popularity of the anti-work movement is a reaction to really bad labor conditions in the USA that have only been further strained during COVID. Lots of people are suffering and they're expressing that, even if some of them are not diagnosing the root problem correctly.
heyitsguay··on An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post and an open letter
As someone who did a BA and PhD in math, went through high school geometry proofs, taught geometry proofs to math students and math education students:

Geometry proofs are a terrible way of introducing rigorous mathematical proofs to students. Seriously. I cannot overstate how misleading they are. I remember my first abstract algebra class in college, after the first HW I got called in by the TA because I tried to structure my proofs like I learned in geometry class - a sequence of symbols and references to hard-coded lists of axioms and prior deductions. I thought that's what proofs are, but they are not, at least not as humans do higher math. High school geometry tries to distill this process down to a symbol manipulation game that students can memorize and regurgitate, and in the process loses the essence of the thing it was meant to capture in the first place.

heyitsguay··on Proposed Bill to Outlaw Bots from Scalping Online Goods [pdf]
What you're describing as a "problem" is people beyond the wealthiest members of society having a chance at owning popular consumer goods, while the wealthy must contend with an X% chance at getting them on demand instead of 100%.
heyitsguay··on Proposed Bill to Outlaw Bots from Scalping Online Goods [pdf]
Seriously. If you ever meet any of these people in real life, take their car keys and remind them the market dictates the price of all goods and the police are a statist intervention.
heyitsguay··on Could AI turn on us, or is natural stupidity a greater threat to humanity?
That's probably a bit broad - there are good philosophers doing good work in the world, this just might not be one of those cases.
heyitsguay··on Could AI turn on us, or is natural stupidity a greater threat to humanity?
Researchers and engineers are by and large trying to solve concrete real-world problems and don't care what label the public puts on them. Media darlings and lay people are the ones concerned with whether something is "real" AI or not.
heyitsguay··on Could AI turn on us, or is natural stupidity a greater threat to humanity?
Lol, how do you head an institute at Oxford while being so clueless about the relevant subject matter? This stuff is good emotion-grabbing speculation, but it has no bearing on developments in the real-world field of artificial intelligence. Replace "AI" with "fancy regression" and see how serious these claims sound.

To be clear, there are serious ethical concerns and threats to human life associated with modern AI, but they have to do with technology shifting the balances of power between groups of humans (country vs. country, in-group vs. out-group), not superintelligent Terminators hiding nerve gas in your shoes.

heyitsguay··on The slowest SR-71 Blackbird fly-by
Not to denigrate OP, but this reduced version has become a bit of a copypasta meme of its own.
heyitsguay··on My friends Instagram was hacked and deep-fake videos posted in less than 6 hours
Really? Have you not ever seen a comment thread here on a topic involving women?
heyitsguay··on Decentralised finance is booming, but it has yet to find its purpose
Less glibly, can you explain or point to references explaining how to solve this problem without relying on external identity verification services to confirm that a registrant is in fact that property owner? It seems like, if you have to do that, your records are more efficiently stored as a database with whatever authority is doing that verification.
heyitsguay··on Decentralised finance is booming, but it has yet to find its purpose
Cool, i just registered your address. Feel free to leave any furniture you don't want to keep.
heyitsguay··on Facebook's metaverse spending will top $10B this year
So, more consumerism, fueled by artificial digital scarcity. Gross.
heyitsguay··on Did a Chinese hack kill Nortel? (2020)
Would you have to catch all the ants and then burn them? Seems like a lot of extra work.
heyitsguay··on All 16,777,216 RGB colours (2005)
I actually just did try it! I'm finding that random pixels don't really get swapped. Except along comparatively uncommon borders between squares, pixels are already very similar to their immediate neighbors. Creating a video with 10000 swaps per frame, I found no successful swaps in 50 frames.

That said, I bet there's some other criterion that would have the desired effect.

heyitsguay··on New York Hospitals Face Possible Mass Firings as Workers Spurn Vaccines
Vaccines are being mandated because if you're dealing with the public without them, you're more likely to hurt people (and yourself).

Drunk driving laws aren't a conspiracy by Big Taxi.

heyitsguay··on SEC Doesn’t See Cryptocurrencies Lasting Long
I understand the appeal and benefits of decentralized services, and how they could apply to currency, but I think there's something wrong with the idea that a successful currency should increase in value by orders of magnitude (or even at all). Like, E-mail is a very successful decentralized service, and people make money in relation to e-mail protocol specifications by providing value on top of it. Nobody got rich just for getting their gmail account early. I know there is a lot of experimentation being done in stablecoins, but it seems like speculative quests for the next 1000x return drive development instead of just trying to solve the problem of safely, quickly, and reliably digitally storing and exchanging value.
heyitsguay··on Gödel's Disjunction [video]
The problem is going from results on curated datasets - usually with at least a little implicit overfitting, since even if you reserve test data, it's typically chosen in the dataset creation process - to data in the wild. BabyTalk had that cool result in 2013, and there have been great papers following up in that area, but there's still not, e.g., a website where you can upload a photo and reliably get an accurate description. It's not because nobody's tried, it's because it's hard - neural network vision methods are still generally quite brittle to unexpected variations in data, and "accurate description" is actually a very loaded term that typically needs some sort of in-the-world contextualization to unpack.
heyitsguay··on The Crime of Curiosity
Nobody has to use YouTube. There are many other video hosting/watching platforms. None of them are especially popular because they get filled with a lot of junk, because they attract the people who can't host their content on YouTube.

In a way, this dynamic is an effective, natural check on moderation. If moderation primarily removes stuff that most people think is junk, then alternatives competing on reduced moderation will be junk. If moderation removes valuable stuff that lots of people want, then other platforms that host it instead will receive more traffic and legitimacy.

It's kind of like the Reddit vs. Voat thing. Reddit isn't great, but Voat ended up a cesspool, because Reddit's biggest exoduses were driven by hate groups.

heyitsguay··on In Search for Wealth Irrelevance
Interesting, I bet that's an experience that most people on HN haven't had (I certainly haven't!). Since lots of the comments (including mine) have focused on how hard it is to take advantage of software engineering tools online without a CS/software background, and how hard it is to develop that background in precarious circumstances, it could be really interesting to write more about how you came to learn these things yourself.
heyitsguay··on In Search for Wealth Irrelevance
By the way, I think it's really cool that you followed up your writing with a dialog on how to address criticisms that commenters brought up. Having something you wrote on the front page of a social media platform is a very vulnerable position to be in, and then going on to participate in a measured back-and-forth about your ideas is rare and refreshing. The discussion your ideas have created is much more interesting because you did so.
heyitsguay··on In Search for Wealth Irrelevance
One other nuance is the difference between wealth and income. Wealth is productive assets that generate further capital in one way or another. Income just gets used to pay for things.

Instead, I think it's basically ok to say that your point applies to people who have reached a certain threshold of stability and security in your life, and isn't meant to imply that people who haven't reached that threshold ought to be able to simply will themselves into doing the same thing.

heyitsguay··on In Search for Wealth Irrelevance
To my mind, there are two angles to address. On the one hand, your argument really makes the most sense in the scope of "for people with a background in software", and due to the unique nature of software use and development, I don't think it would easily transfer to other domains. So, you can content yourself with making a point about people with a background in software.

Second, by bringing up free computer access at a library, it connects the point you're trying to make with the really complicated nuances around poverty. Even assuming we ignore smartphones and tablets (because how can you get any work done on one?), the demographic that only has access to a device with a keyboard at a public library is going to be almost entirely facing (at least) moderate poverty, and life in poverty just looks very different from the kinds of backgrounds that the rest of your piece implicitly addresses. So, you could focus instead on the wealth of free software tools available to the people who are in some range of circumstances to take advantage of them, assuming that access to a device with a keyboard isn't the primary challenge.

← PreviousPage 9 of 15Next →