I favorite comments often. I like to scan back through. I generate a lot of ideas and make a lot of connections doing so.
Same caveats apply to my favorites as yours.
2,927 karma · joined August 1, 2016
I favorite comments often. I like to scan back through. I generate a lot of ideas and make a lot of connections doing so.
Same caveats apply to my favorites as yours.
I'm not alone. Andy Grove and his concept of Task Relevant Maturity (TRM) have a lot of overlap here. Primarily in understanding that someone's prior knowledge/experience will dictate their ability to accomplish the task at hand.
Where I differ from Grove is how to help someone when their TRM is low. He states this is a time to tell them what/when/how.
1) In a structured org like Intel in the 80's when Grove wrote High Output Management, maybe this worked. In a startup where the work to be done is often as yet unknown by manager and worker alike, trying to tell someone what/when/how doesn't work
2) The ability to handle ambiguity is itself a skill and one people need to develop maturity in handling. This is where I see the idea of productive struggle/desirable difficulties as a useful addition to Grove's TRM framework
+Good teaching is good management--both roles are about developing people and setting them up for success
Thanks for sharing this story.
I think a lot of about potential impacts like this on students/learners. My goals when teaching are to nurture agency, autonomy, and a positive disposition towards what is being learned in addition to a student learning the content or practices/skills.
People often misconstrue this as wanting to make learning "fun" for students. For me it begins with inversion, look at how to crush a student's spirit, agency, and disposition towards a topic. Don't do that.
Then find ways to put them in situations where they can struggle productively, be creative, show ingenuity, and see the fruits of doing so. Sometimes students aren't aware of their own ingenuity, creativity, or their own productive struggle so that gives me an opportunity to go meta with them and help them see it.
Should you want to find out more you can search "productive struggle nctm/math/teaching." The concept came to me via the math education community but I would actually recommend starting out with the work of Robert and Elizabeth Bjork [0,1].
The Bjorks have researched the same concept extensively. Their term for it is "desirable difficulties."
Their work made the leap from academia to popular culture via David Epstein's book, Range.
[0] https://researchschool.org.uk/durrington/news/bjorks-desirab...
[1] https://bjorklab.psych.ucla.edu/robert-a-bjork-publications/
On the spectrum from direct instruction (I tell you/show you what to do) to inquiry (I set up a situation for you to use some of your prior knowledge to learn something new) it sounds like you leaned towards inquiry here.
You experienced the power of this yourself when you were younger so it's no surprise it informed how you chose to help/not help.
You used a mix of collaborative and cognitive questioning to both engage the learner in the problem and help them think through it. ------------------------
Next I'd like to ask you some questions to help you think through two important teaching concepts: 1) Productive struggle 2) Feedback
Was the student at a complete loss with what to do? Given time to take a break, maybe even sleep, and revisit the problem, do you think they still would have been at a loss?
If no, then give them time and space to think through it on their own or use cognitive questioning as you did to help them think through it.
This gets us to the concept of productive struggle. It is just as the name sounds. This concept has well researched benefits for learners.
If the student had no idea what to do and you suspect would merely get frustrated then that's struggling and its not productive. It's the kind of situation that leads to poor first order outcomes and has second order outcomes like making someone hate the thing you are trying to help them learn.
In that event it would be best to either help them through the problem with advice or find a different problem for them to work on that they have enough prior knowledge to productively struggle with.
Next up is feedback...
Did the student get any feedback after they made their choice? If it was programming could they run their code and see if it worked? Was it a binary right/wrong?
If it didn't work did the student have enough prior knowledge to work around any roadblocks they might encounter?
These questions take us back to the concept of productive struggle.
1) productive struggle is good 2) feedback or advice should be timely and based on what a learner needs to keep them from struggling unproductively
There are related ideas...some lessons you may have a focus and so you tell the student certain things that aren't the focus of the lesson instead of putting them in an inquiry situation. This is another skill needed for effective teaching: creating, selecting, and sequencing a curriculum.
Implied in all of this is the importance of knowing the content, how you want to teach, your learner's prior knowledge, and how they are reacting to the problem.
Throughout Robert Cairo's 1344 page biography of Moses, the reader sees how Moses' racism and clasism impacted the massive influence he had on transportation and sprawl in America.
+1 for Stamped.
In addition, Redlining is a well researched and documented practice in America [0]
It is the kind of thing I can understand. Everyone, at every income level has problems that are very real to them. At the same time, I look at their complaints in light of what someone in poverty deals with everyday and their complaints are pitiful.
But comments with many replies seem to draw more attention so I will add to this:
I have taught in an area that is poor. The opioid epidemic piled on top of that poverty to ravage it further. Students came to school and would say they were going to their uncle's in the next town tonight. I would say oh that's nice, what will you do. They would say, take a shower. We don't have running water so we go there once a week.
Basic needs that anyone in the middle class like me take for granted become focal points every day for someone living in poverty.
Do I put $5 of gas in my car or buy food? My car broke down and I can't afford to fix it. My minimum wage job uses dynamic scheduling and they just said I have to come in. My friend who I texted to take me can't do it at this time. There's no public transportation. How do I get to work? And if I do, who is there when my kids get home from school?
It's an insidious cycle. You can't see 5 feet in front of you and the treadmill never stops running.
God, I hope people read your comment and the article.
From Point #8
"by a continuous shifting of rhetorical focus, the enemies are at the same time too strong and too weak"
[0] http://interglacial.com/pub/text/Umberto_Eco_-_Eternal_Fasci... [1] https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1995/06/22/ur-fascism/
My understanding of watching VC over the past decade is that it's great for hyper-scaling software companies, tenuous at best for hybrid tech/real world companies, and ruinous for companies that don't enjoy the zero marginal cost benefits of a software company at scale.
Google firing all of its managers early on in its existence is a great example of this.
This is incredibly well said and worth highlighting.
So ballots go to the wrong place, fine. The probability of random person there being interested and then finding any of this information is low.
It is in no way a knock on teachers. They are caught up in a bad system and are responding to systemic incentives.
If we apply an always/sometimes/never framework to my assertion, we can find examples where teachers advanced their practice via continuing education. So the teachers you know certainly could have advanced degrees, some even very helpful in improving their practice.
My experience in K-12 as well as studying the history of education reform in America since Sputnik was launched inform this assertion. It has been a recurring theme for 60 years.
This is just not accurate.
Accounting rules not only can be argued, they are all the time.
FASB and GAAP are rife with subjectivity.
I have an accounting degree.
May be what OP is referring to.
I have seen it in teaching. Teachers need xx hours of training per year. Training often satisfies that requirement but provides no significant benefits in terms of pedagogical improvement or content knowledge.
Teachers that want to improve do so by other means. The training keeps us in compliance.
I woke up with knots in my stomach for months thinking about the things I would have to do to get customers and the non-stop rejection the day would hold as I worked to get a foothold for my startup.
There was no VC to call me to account, or VC firm to help with areas you I didn't like or couldn't do.
If I hadn't been able to hold myself accountable to do the things that I dreaded my startup never would have gotten off the ground.
I have seen this environment at a small university town where I used to live. You overhear all sorts of interesting conversations ranging from the middle school kids who walk there after school to professors researching antibiotic resistance.
Probably should have read it sooner but at least I had plenty of experience to compare against it when I finally did suck it up and read it.
I will add Dictator's Handbook to my queue and raise my hand and 4th the 48 Laws of Power
Am I wrong?
If no, how have they accomplished this?
Eric Jackson's book, Musk's biography, and other sources paint Paypal as an organizational mess. Successful mergers are no small order. Whitman succeeded.
In his biography, Ashlee Vance describes how Musk built a knowledge base about rocket construction after his exit from Paypal. Both the "how to" and a first principles approach to the economics of it.
Musk knew the calculus that he could attempt to build rockets for far less than his competitors before he ever put a dime into SpaceX.
In contrast, vertical farming sounds more like the computer engineer equivalent of "I built a thing, isn't it shiny and cool" without understanding the industry, economics, or competitive landscape.
Vertical farming seems to be taking an ahistorical approach. With both both vertical farmers and VCs ignoring industry knowledge [0,1]
Sticking with Musk, he took an ahistorical appraoch to Tesla's Fremont factory with automation. He learned a very expensive and wasteful lesson that other auto manufacturers had known for decades.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23633298 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23634030
[0] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11606-019-05002-w
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/10/americans-are-drowning-in-me...
As for a well-defined line about abuse, I'll draw from Justice Potter Stewart's utterance about pornography [0]:
> I know it when I see it.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacobellis_v._Ohio#Supreme_Cou...
Appreciate you bringing it up and contrasting with the "small ugly pettiness" of the MJ/Jobs/Musk ilk.
So it's worth remembering that The Last Dance wasn't Jordan's last time in the NBA.
MJ came out of retirement to play for the Wizards. Acted just as he did when he was Air Jordan with the Bulls, but could no longer back up his abusive behavior with his play [0]. Instead of elevating the Wizards, Jordan being an asshole now hurt the team in a number of different ways.
A person may be deemed an asshole for having high standards. They don't have to be abusive to hold those high standards though.
Ed Catmull and Pixar have high standards but are not abusive in the mold of Jordan or Jobs [1]. Kim Scott wrote an entire book, Radical Candor, about how to demand excellence without being abusive [2].
[0] https://slate.com/culture/2020/05/the-last-dance-michael-jor... [1] http://www.bugaj.com/blog/2014/9/14/you-sir-are-no-ed-catmul... [2] https://www.radicalcandor.com/
I've worked in both K-12 and post-secondary education, studied the history of education reform in the United States, and visited schools/met teachers/students/etc that I've connected with across the U.S.
I'm always interested in hearing someone's story about school, how it did/didn't meet their needs, and how it has impacted them.