HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hither_shores

249 karma · joined February 21, 2022

submissionscomments
hither_shores··on Dark Matter Doesn't Exist
Dark matter ratios are not free parameters, because galaxies did not form through independent processes. The evidence for a highly homogeneous early universe is overwhelming, and any dark matter candidate that required large-scale inhomogeneity would be rejected out of hand.
hither_shores··on Dark Matter Doesn't Exist
I don't have access to the paper right now, but the abstract is off to a very bad start.

> any curved Riemannian space must be a subspace of a larger flat host space

This is not even wrong. Yes, you can always embed a Riemannian manifold in a Euclidean space. In fact, there are infinitely many ways to do so. But this is extra structure that you can choose to impose, if you want to - it's not intrinsic.

You might as well say that every string must be a substring of a larger "host" string.

> the 4D Riemann-Christoffel curvature tensor is identically equal to a geometrical tensor associated with the complementary subspace of the host space

Impossibly vague. Yes, sometimes things are equal to other things. What tensor, and associated how?

> Einstein’s field equations are automatically geometrized, with the stress-energy tensor expressed in terms of the contracted complementary tensor

This is a tautology. The Einstein field equations relate the Ricci tensor to the metric and the stress energy tensor, and the Ricci tensor is a contraction of the Riemann curvature tensor. This remains true even if you rename the Riemann curvature tensor "the complementary tensor".

But the deeper problem is this: the entire point of general relativity is that physics does not, in fact, care what coordinates we use. And this is built into the mathematical structure of the theory - there can't be any such thing as the "the coordinate basis vector approach to tensor calculus", because tensors (properly speaking: tensor fields) are, by definition, coordinate-independent objects.

hither_shores··on Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020)
> S, action, is the arc-length of a world-line. L = dS/dt. It is a natural law that systems move along "straight" world-lines, geodesics, in the absence of interactions.

This is a roughly correct description of GR, where the curvature is given by the Einstein field equations. It's not true in classical electromagnetism, or in QM.

> The "future-looking" nature of the least action principle is unsatisfying: sure, the action is minimized over an interval in time. Since L = dS/dt, the E-L equations are that same principle expressed at a single moment in time--right?

Yes, although the global principle is that the action is stationary, not minimal.

> Is there some sense in which L is "orthogonal" to the space spanned by constant energy and momentum?

Not quite, but you're on the right track. Conserved quantities of integrable systems are "orthogonal" to the Hamiltonian H, in that the poisson bracket `{f, H} = -df/dt` and so `{f, H} = 0` for constant `f`. The Lagrangian arises as the Legendre transform of H.

hither_shores··on Noether's Theorem in a Nutshell (2020)
> every system minimizes the action

Action is stationary, not necessarily minimal.

hither_shores··on On pretending to have read books
Moby Dick is what it looks like: the whalers are whalers, the ship is a ship, the whale is a whale. "Deeper meanings" are not as characteristic of literary fiction as your high school English teacher might like you to believe. But whereas stories on the pulpier end of the spectrum create characters to meet the demands of the plot, Moby Dick's plot is a delivery mechanism for its characters.

Ahab, for instance, is exactly what he appears to be: a person obsessed with getting revenge on a whale. But Melville's portrayal of Ahab is psychologically rich enough to contain many elements which are common to questionably-attainable obsessions in general, and this is what people are usually talking about when they talk about literary symbolism. Ahab's relationship with the whale isn't a metaphor for man's search for meaning any more than it's a metaphor for my struggle to get my coworkers to stop throwing denormalized garbage in the schema - but it resembles both of them, and many other things besides.

hither_shores··on 'The best thing we can do today to JavaScript is to retire it’ Douglas Crockford
The main issue is that LISP supports dynamic scoping, whereas lambdas act like lexically scoped functions.
hither_shores··on Monad Confusion and the Blurry Line Between Data and Computation
> there is nothing in the general monad interface that even allows you to go `m a -> a`, so something being a monad doesn't seem sufficient to be able to define that algebra.

You've got the direction backwards: the point is to characterize all `m`-algebras, not to construct particular ones.

This is closely related to the usual duality between types and values. It's very common for people new to TypeScript, for instance, to think that `{a: string} | {b: number}` should be `{a: string, b: number}`, because they're thinking primarily in terms of records as sets of fields, not types as sets of values. But making the type bigger makes the set of things you can say about its values (i.e. the space of functions out of it) smaller. Algebras are similarly the "value-like" counterparts to "space-like" monads.

hither_shores··on Ask HN: Why has quality of YouTube reduced drastically?
> why not introduce you to other things

Because that's not what I told it to do.

hither_shores··on Differentiable programming from scratch
No, the h here is a number, not an operator.
hither_shores··on Study finds Wikipedia influences judicial behavior
There's been an NPOV warning on that page since 2011, and the content has remained substantially the same since 2010. So no, I don't think it is.
hither_shores··on Study finds Wikipedia influences judicial behavior
Browse through https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Wikipedia_neutral_poi... and you'll find plenty.

For example:

> Mohammed Zakir (also known as Meyra) was an Ethiopian Oromo nationalist. Regarded as "legendary Oromo hero", he is noted for his high contribution to keep the lights of Oromo nationalism shining after the martyrdom of his two hero colleagues called Elemo Qiltu and Ahmad Taqi ... the Oromos would never forget this early exemplary hero. And above all, history will always remember Meyra and his heroism.

hither_shores··on Why does nobody seem to know what imperative and declarative mean?
Like other forms of subtyping, unions make type inference much harder - typically undecidable. This is, of course, incompatible with guaranteed termination.
hither_shores··on Propagation of mistakes in papers
That particular bound wasn't. Others were. For example: Millikan's value for the electron charge was about .995 of the current best measurements. That was about a century ago. So either someone was wrong, the average rate of change has dramatically increased recently (in which case the universe is conspiring against physicists and all bets are off), or human biochemistry is significantly younger than human civilization.
hither_shores··on Propagation of mistakes in papers
No, any possible variation in fundamental "constants" is going to be far slower. The fine-structure constant (which is generally what's actually being discussed when people talk about a variable speed of light), for instance, changes by no more than a factor of about 10^-17 per year.
hither_shores··on Why Read Fichte Today?
> From there, logic optimistically assumes a 'flawed' ontology.

Logic doesn't assume any ontology. You're free to treat it as a purely formal string-manipulation game if you really want to.

Approaching math or physics as if it were part of the humanities - close readings of primary sources, "genealogical" work, literary exegesis - is worse than useless. If you can't do math, you don't understand it. And if you don't understand math, productive engagement with the philosophy of mathematics is impossible.

hither_shores··on Why Read Fichte Today?
> Agreed - mathematics is predicated on the idea that there are individual things, but as we are learning, through things like quantum field theory, there are no individual things, hence, no individuated 'things' to count.

Even setting aside the absurdities of reducing math to elementary arithmetic, and of reducing arithmetic to counting particular concrete things - claiming to have undermined math with quantum field theory is like writing an essay that argues against the existence of language. "There are no particles, only waves" is not QFT. It's a reasonable position for which QFT arguably offers some measure of support, but that's not even remotely the same thing. QFT is layer upon layer upon layer upon layer of deeply technical mathematics, with a bit of blind symbol-pushing to round out the rough patches.

hither_shores··on Go generics are not bad
If your code can run IO operations synchronously and branch on the result of previous operations, you've already got an IO monad. The point of being explicit about that is that it allows you to check that a given piece of code can't do those things. Keeping database calls out of the render loop, for instance, is very much a matter of actual correctness.
hither_shores··on Functional programming jargon in plain English
> What does that sign ≍ mean?

Normally, `f ≍ g` means `f \in \Theta(g)`. Here, the author is using it as an equals sign. I have no idea why.

hither_shores··on Why hasn't Middle Earth had an Industrial Revolution?
Arthurian literature is Celtic myth seen through the eyes of medieval Frenchmen: it's British, but not English.
hither_shores··on Lenses
That's exactly what lenses do:

    let new_alice = set (address . city) "Los Angeles" $ over (cart . items) (+ 123) alice
hither_shores··on Lenses
They're using "getters and setters" to refer to reading from and writing to fields, not `get => ... ; set => ...` style syntactic sugar.
hither_shores··on Lenses
A "lens" that only provides a view of something is just a plain function. Prisms are first class constructors: a `Prism a b` can build a `b` from an `a`, or attempt to match on a `b` and `Maybe` get an `a` that could construct it.
hither_shores··on Lenses
> I'd be interested to see a justification for that, given that the usual definition is essentially "A functor which preserves the internal hom functor".

Applicatives are monoid objects for Day convolution of functors (in the same way that monads are monoid objects for composition of functors) given by the coend `F \otimes G (x) = \int^{i, j} Hom_C(i \otimes j, x) \otimes_V F(i) \otimes_V F(j)`. These coincide with closed functors by currying if we have closed monoidal structure, but remain well-defined without it.

Using `<*>` instead of `liftA2` in the typeclass definition is basically a historical accident, and imo a mistake.

> Regardless I hope you can see what I mean when I say the mathematics you need for Haskell is wonky.

Wonky is too strong, but I agree that it's usually not treated with anything near the appropriate level of detail.

hither_shores··on Type-checked keypaths in Rust
For general optics, yes. But lenses and to a lesser extent prisms still work ok in their naive getter/setter and constructor/pattern encodings.
hither_shores··on Lenses
There are infinitely many, so all is out, but the standard ones are covered here: https://oleg.fi/gists/posts/2017-04-18-glassery.html

Page 10 of this paper has a table with references to some more exotic optics, though it's going to be hard to parse without some category theory: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.07488.pdf

hither_shores··on Lenses
> This is why you even have an "Applicative" class of functors for instance, they're the ones that work nicely with the closed monoidal category structure.

Applicatives still make sense with only monoidal structure: they're monoidal functors `C -> Set`, or more generally `C -> V` for `C` enriched over `V`.

hither_shores··on Lenses
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-QwBL9Dia0
hither_shores··on Lenses
> I.e. they can filter among many fields to set, then modify multiple fields at once, and so on.

These generalizations are usually referred to as "optics", with "lenses" reserved for the single-target case.

hither_shores··on Type-checked keypaths in Rust
Most languages with good support for functional programming have lenses, which generalize keypaths. Off the top of my head: Haskell, Purescript, TypeScript, Scala, OCaml, Racket, and Common Lisp all have lens libraries.
hither_shores··on How do poor countries get rich?
> Saudi Arabia's GDP per capita is $20k.

Saudi Arabia's nominal GDP per capita. Their GDP (PPP) per capita is more like $50k - comparable to the United Kingdom, which has significantly better living standards.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →