HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hnbad

3,172 karma · joined March 31, 2021

Isn't this ironic.

(he/they)

submissionscomments
hnbad··on German court declares Karl Marx's teachings unconstitutional
This article and some of the comments suffers from a misunderstanding about the German court system. The court did not rule anything unconstitutional - it only declared it as such in its ruling about the specific case. The decision can be appealed and does not set precedent the way it works in common law systems like in the US. Only the constitutional court could rule Marxism unconstitutional and it hasn't done so in the past and is unlikely to do so in the future.

The argument is also extremely dodgy, at least the way it is being presented here. The court seemingly argues that whether or not Marxism necessarily requires a violent overthrow of the government is irrelevant because the "dictatorship of the proletariat" would be an undemocratic rule to the exclusion of a demographic group (presumably capitalists) but this is paper thin.

Communism would abolish "capitalists" as a concept, not as a demographic group. It's more like the abolition of chattel slavery - it simply stopped providing a legal mechanism to be a slave owner, it didn't "discriminate against slave owners" because that was no longer a thing you could meaningfully be (or at least not more than "human trafficker").

The German constitution does not actually establish capitalism as integral to the "liberal democratic order". It's true that it includes protections of "private property" but it also contains a hierarchy of interests that allows for private property to be socialized for the benefit of the public and ultimately yields to "human dignity" above all else. It does not give special protections to capital and certainly not exceeding those offered to humans (regardless of citizenship or residence by the way - this is why German "sex tourism" abroad is still subject to concerns in Germany like the age of consent, and consent in general).

It's also worth mentioning that the constitutional court has previously ruled that some aspects of the constitution including special protections can be informed by changing cultural attitudes. Specifically this was used to argue in favor of same-sex relationships being included in protections of "family" - a change that certain conservatives also saw as a breakdown of the "public order".

hnbad··on Valve confirms credit card companies pressured it to delist certain adult games
I would like to know where you draw the line for "working democracy".

The German Democratic Republic had elections, it even had political mechanisms that allowed other parties to participate (which the East CDU made plenty of use of btw). It even had a lower rate of incarceration than the US and a far more primitive surveillance system.

Pre-WW2 Germany was a working democracy for the most part despite its court system still having being extremely biased in favor of monarchists and anti-leftism. Most of the violence committed by the Nazis at the time resulted in prosecutions even if many were excused for "being motivated by patriotism". Hitler even went to prison for attempting a coup before being pardoned - and the punishment succeeded in changing the NSDAP's strategy to mostly remain within the limits of the law. Hitler's absolute power was even legally granted through the Enabling Act, passed with the help of the government coalition partners including the ideological precursor to the modern CDU/CSU, the Christian (Catholic) conservative "Center" party.

Post-WW2 West Germany under Adenauer (who btw was a massive antisemite to the point of explaining the necessity of zionism with the need to appease the "very powerful" international Jewish community) on the other hand had the government pressuring its constitutional court to ban political parties, reinstate the Nazi era crime of "high treason" to criminalize any political attempts at reunification other than outright annexation and cracked down on pacifists and opponents to the remilitarization as desired by the US to have a regional power base in the Cold War. It also ran a system of rubber stamp courts to rehabilitate former NSDAP members, even when it required a re-trial after the destruction of incriminating evidence from prior unfavorable rulings.

And of course even after Adenauer German policing only ever-so-incrementally moved away from the traditional authoritarian "peace through power" approach following the bloodshed in its handling of the student protests in the 1960s (which led to the formation of the RAF terrorist group) although German federal and state governments still oppose any outside investigations into police violence nowadays even when it's evident enough to make international news headlines like in Lüzerath. Meanwhile corruption in the federal government has become so rampant there are literally score lists available for each political party showing how many of their representatives are tied up in legal corruption scandals with Jens Spahn probably being the most widely talked about case for funnelling government funds into his pockets during the pandemic only followed by former chancellor Schroeder's close business relations to Gazprom and Olaf Scholz's deliberate intervention in investigations of never seen before amounts of massive tax fraud (i.e. the Cum Ex scandal).

And that's just Germany. So: if interwar Germany and pre-reunification East Germany were not "working democracies" but every "western" democracy (I presume this means anything this side of the Cold War iron curtain) post-WW2 is - what's your yardstick? Where do you draw the line?

hnbad··on EU commissioner shocked by dangers of some goods sold by Shein and Temu
Is that how you think about fixing software bugs too? "You're saying the existing code is broken so we should fix it by writing more code?"

EDIT: Regulations are simply laws. Laws structure legal (this includes financial) interactions. The idea that you can always fix problems just by removing regulations is no less absurd than the idea that you can always fix problems just by removing code. "Good" isn't defined by having less or more, it's defined by what you have being good or bad at doing what it's meant to do. Parent is wording their question in such a way that it can only be interpreted to mock the idea of fixing a bad law by passing a new law (whether that involves replacing the existing law or not is irrelevant).

hnbad··on EU commissioner shocked by dangers of some goods sold by Shein and Temu
The local merchants' profit pays for that. That profit comes from sales. For local merchants this likely means sales to customers like "you". So it's your money paying for those things via local merchants.

If your concern is foreign merchants not paying into the local tax system, it sounds like you're advocating for tariffs (i.e. taxes on imports).

hnbad··on Digital vassals? French Government ‘exposes citizens’ data to US'
> Most software developers I have met have this kind of disdain for their users familiarity and ability and act like they are above that.

This is absolutely true.

For what it's worth, "so-and-so department, room 123" is only a helpful mental model for navigation if you have additional knowledge not present in that description: that the department is probably contained entirely in one specific building, where that building is, that the rooms are likely numbered sequentially following a pattern that also indicates the floor they're in, etc. By itself this is an address whereas "red building, third floor, left then left" is a turn-by-turn route.

In terms of UIs, the latter is more like "left-hand side of the menu bar, 'Edit' menu I think, half-way down the screen, something like 'Modify' or 'Change' or 'Transform' or something, then third item in the list, something like 'Skew' or 'Bend' or something" compared to the first just being "Transform -> Skew". The former is fuzzier and the exact labels don't really matter because you'll know them when you see them. The latter is extremely precise but tells you nothing about how to actually find what you're looking for (is it in the 'Edit' menu? is it in a right-click context menu? etc). It's only really useful by itself if you have a command palette.

hnbad··on Reflections on OpenAI
I don't think it's accurate to say that anyone messed up with Smith or Marx. Smith didn't anticipate modern finance capitalism and his musings apply perfectly well to earlier iterations of capitalism - though he'd probably have had a stroke if you showed him the finance economy. Marx didn't anticipate capitalism's resilience but he had very little to do with the ideologies built on his work let alone their implementations (or attempts thereof).

That said, "I have a bigger stick" wasn't all we had before the present systems. I'm not a primitivist but I think it's a thought-terminating cliché to just look at what we have now and what came immediately before and decide that the local plateau is the best we can have.

Humanity invests a ton of resources in enforcing the status quo of power dynamics - both through overt force (be it military violence or the mere threat of violence necessary to assert contracts and claims to private property) and through more subtle means (e.g. narrative framing in education, news media and entertainment). Maintaining these systems takes immense resources and effort. But in moments of crisis our cooperative human nature can shine through until order is restored and we are ushered back into learned helplessness and mutual distrust as "the authorities" take over.

The problem isn't that the systems "allow corruption". The systems are inherently bad and corrupting. We build hierarchies of absolute power and then try to come up with solutions for the problems those hierarchies cause in the first place.

The problem isn't who rules. The problem is having rulers. Quoth Bakunin: "the people will feel no better if the stick with which they are being beaten is labelled the 'peoples stick'. [..] not even the reddest republic - can ever give the people what they really want."

hnbad··on Valve confirms credit card companies pressured it to delist certain adult games
It's not so much that only criminals use cash, it's more that crash makes it incredibly easy to evade taxes. The archetype is a cash-only restaurant: it's trivial to both launder money by claiming more sales than you actually made and to evade taxes by reporting fewer sales. This is why many countries have strict laws about paper trails for cash sales.
hnbad··on LLM Inevitabilism
What he calls inevitabilism, Chomsky referred to as "manufacturing consent":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent

Sure, Chomsky was specifically talking about how the underlying systems of US mass media manufacture consent among the governed but inevitabilism lies at its core: a thought-terminating cliché that eliminates all alternatives from even being legitimate subjects of the debate.

hnbad··on Reflections on OpenAI
> I'd be more worried about the guy

Or you could realize what those guys all have in common and be worried about the systems that enable them because the problem isn't a guy but a system enabling those guys to become everyone's problem.

I don't mind "Vito Corleone" joking about a volcano lair. I mind him interfering in my country's elections and politics. I shouldn't have to worry about the antics of a guy building rockets that explode and cars that can chop off your fingers because I live in a country that can protect me from those things becoming my problem, but because we have the same underlying systems I do have to worry about him because his political power is easily transferrable to any other country including mine.

This would still be true if it were a different guy. Heck, Thiel is landing contracts with his surveillance tech in my country despite the foreign politics of the US making it an obvious national and economic security risk and don't get me started on Bezos - there's plenty of "guys" already.

hnbad··on New Date("wtf") – How well do you know JavaScript's Date class?
`Date` is based on the original Java `Date` class and its API was mostly copied verbatim, explaining a lot of the quirks and silliness. While JS can't remove things easily because that would break the web, a lot of work has gone into a set of time primitives that will effectively replace it. `Date`'s parsing logic is so bad even Java has deprecated it.

This is one of those cases where the problem isn't language design but boardroom politics - Sun wanted JS not to compete with Java so they had to try to make JS more like Java to present JS as a kind of "Java for amateurs".

hnbad··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
Don't ever look into where the money you make with "passive income" comes from, I guess?

Passive income just means other people are working for your income. At some point, someone has to be poor enough to have to do the actual labor. You can abstract this away with as many financial constructs as you want but it boils down to that. If you can "make money" from mere ownership, we can't all own things that make us money because then we wouldn't have to pay anyone and nobody would have to pay us.

hnbad··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
Sure, because status matters more than finances. Getting rich may be extremely unlikely if not outright impossible. Looking rich to your peers (and "feeling rich") on the other hand may just be a few years worth of small affordable installments away - even if it's completely superficial and short-lived. And entire industries will literally spend your every waking second trying to convince you that buying their product will make you feel rich.
hnbad··on FICO to incorporate buy-now-pay-later loans into credit scores
Whatever you put aside is not going to be enough to prevent complete financial ruin if shit hits the fan. You might be able to cover smaller emergencies like an appliance breaking or your car needing repairs but literally just giving birth or being in an accident can bankrupt you in the US. I'm not at all surprised low to medium income Americans would just give up and accept their inevitable financial ruin instead of trying to be maximally frugal and socially ostracize yourself, forego most forms of entertainment/recreation and still not be able to get out of survival mode.

Desperation is a good motivator - but not for rational actions. It triggers our survival instincts: hoard what you can, feed on what you can get, grow fat, make rash decisions. This is what the modern economy is built on. FOMO, impulse shopping, conspicuous consumption, high calorie fast food, deals and discounts on overpriced goods, planned obsolescence, etc. We need consumers to be perpetually desperate and starving. Credit just means we can circumvent Henry Ford's problem of them not being able to afford to buy anything because they still can't afford it but are able to pay for it until their credit line runs out.

hnbad··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
The funny thing is that this likely isn't even people like dang intentionally yanking that post. The design of how community self-moderation works and the makeup of the site's demographic makes it easy for this to happen without any clear ill intent.

"No politics", I insist, as I push the final commits for the orphan grinding machine.

hnbad··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
The ship has sailed on this one. Arguing that UFO means "unidentified" (i.e. probably not aliens) is like arguing whether the Democratic People's Republic of Korea is democratic or a republic, or arguing that the Nazis were socialists because it's literally in the name (national socialists). Not only can words change meaning over time, labels can and sometimes do actually contradict their literal meaning.

I remember when there were huge online discussions about the incorrect use of the term "HTML5" once non-technical people got wind of it, and before that over the use of "internet" versus "web" (and whether it's "the internet" or "the Internet") and of course everyone knows the copypasta about "GNU/Linux" and maybe even the discussions about what a "meme" actually is, etc etc. None of these discussions are fruitful and by insisting on an older dictionary definition over the de facto majority use of a given word you're not demonstrating superior knowledge, intelligence or expertise but quite the opposite when it comes to language development and human interactions.

Words don't mean anything except what the two people using them to communicate with each other assign to them. In one-to-many and many-to-many conversations this means the majority use of the term generally prevails unless the minority use provides immediate superior utility (which is how a lot of slang enters mainstream use). It's all just sloppy lossy soundwaves and unicode strings thrown in each other's general direction - that we can transport ideas at all is nothing short of a miracle of nature.

hnbad··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
Considering the "Ancient Alien" stuff mostly exists because people find it more plausible space aliens did something than brown people in the past that we find complicated to explain nowadays, I'd say you're not too far off.

There is a lot of projection in a lot of so-called sci-fi media, especially with regard to "alien invasion" tropes. The idea that some foreign group arrives with vastly superior weapons and technology we don't understand to wipe us out or enslave us for some ulterior motives that possibly don't even make sense to us would sound a bit on the nose unless presented in a politically race-neutral way to a demographic of the historically culturally dominant group. There's certainly a degree of fear of revenge to it, though less blatant than in early zombie media (where zombies were more strongly associated with "voodoo" and implicitly a punishment for colonialism) or even exploitation/horror media like Cannibal Holocaust or Heart of Darkness (and a lot of the media inspired by it like Apocalypse Now) where the threat is explicitly more "primitive" (in the case of Heart of Darkness the threat being a form of contagious primitivism itself) but the dominant group (usually white people) are put in vulnerable positions through circumstance. It's no accident that Lovecraft was legitimately extremely racist.

It's important to remember though that humans are not intrinsically racist. Tribalist maybe, but kinship can spread all superficial boundaries of appearances and cultural differences. Whiteness is not a question of a specific skin color or ethnicity but the absence of "non-white" identifiers and thus ultimately just as arbitrary as Roman citizenship during certain time periods in what we now think of as Europe and Northern Africa. And of course just like Roman citizenship, those delineations exist because they benefited the dominant group within (or the colonial administration) by providing an other.

hnbad··on Mikeal Rogers has died
Wow, that took me by surprise. I can't say I've followed his exact involvements closely but his name was definitely one I'd come across a lot, especially in the early years of Node.js. I even met him at a conference once, only recognizing that it had been him afterwards and thinking, he's shorter than I had thought. I can't really say much as the encounter was brief but he seemed like a genuinely nice person.

Fuck cancer.

hnbad··on The librarian immediately attempts to sell you a vuvuzela
If "the government" were to run Google Search, it would be bad because nobody cares about making it good because profit is the only motivating force for organizations.

Because Google runs Google Search, it's instead only bad because profit motivates Google to push its services, increase ad impressions/interactions and incentivize users to not actually leave the search engine result page (e.g. by citing or summarizing content of the related web pages on the result page).

And because competition is good that means Google actively competing with the sites it indexes for the attention of its users is a good thing even if those sites losing out and failing would result in worse search results over time.

Hang on, maybe "content stealing" really already was a problem before LLMs made it their entire MO and those greedy newspaper publishers were onto something when they complained about Google lifting their news feeds even if it provided "exposure" for them.

hnbad··on The librarian immediately attempts to sell you a vuvuzela
Because real libraries are not for-profit enterprises and have a negative (or at least extremely unimpressive) ARR. Incidentally their leadership positions also don't provide anywhere near the levels of compensation you'd expect for a C-level position at an equally large company.

Asking for "the Internet" to be funded the same way as real libraries is quite the contrary to the dominant cultural narrative which asks for public services and entire governments to be operated "like a business", which usually means cutting funding, selling assets, doing layoffs and eventually scrapping it for parts once it has become predictably defunct.

hnbad··on The librarian immediately attempts to sell you a vuvuzela
Or for a more concerning example, GitHub is owned by Microsoft who want to sell cloud services so it stands to reason it would be in their interest to have GitHub Copilot steer developers towards building applications using architectural patterns that lend themselves more to using those cloud services, e.g. service-oriented architecture even when it is against the developer's interests.

This doesn't have to be as blunt as promoting specific libraries or services and it's a bias that could even be introduced "accidentally".

hnbad··on Are the Colors in Astronomical Images 'Real'?
> “False color” was popular for a while but has fallen out of favor because it implies fakery.

I think that's getting the priorities wrong. The people who think those images are "fake" and fraudulent don't think that because of that term, they just see the term as a reaffirmation of their preexisting conspiracy theories. Flat earthers will literally deny the evidence of their own experiments when they don't align with what they profess to believe.

hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
`Temporal` has three main types for this:

- `Temporal.Instant` is a timestamp, the equivalent of a millisecond epoch timestamp or a UTC ISO string.

- `Temporal.PlainDateTime` (and `Temporal.PlainTime`, `Temporal.PlainDate`, `Temporal.PlainYearMonth` and `Temporal.PlainMonthDay`) is timezone-unaware (i.e. they don't represent an actual point in time unless qualified with a timezone, e.g. when you just want to reference a calendar date).

- `Temporal.ZonedDateTime` is timezone-aware (i.e. what you usually mean when dealing with specific instants in time).

There's also `Temporal.Duration` which represents a delta between two instants and can be used to perform date manipulation (e.g. adding exactly one day or year to a given instant).

I guess in terms of Postgress, `Temporal.ZonedDateTime` and `Temporal.PlainDateTime` are similar to `timestamptz` and `timestamp`, `Temporal.PlainDate` and `Temporal.PlainTime` are similar to `date` and `time` (without a timezone) and `Temporal.Duration` is similar to `interval`. It's odd that postgres allows for `time` to have a timezone but I guess that's only meant to be used when storing an instant as a set of `time` and `date` rather than a single `timestamptz`.

`Temporal.PlainYearMonth` and `Temporal.PlainMonthDay` seem like the odd ones out but they make as much sense as `Temporal.PlainDate` if you want to reference specific calendar dates/months with incomplete information. I guess for sake of completeness one could argue for a need to be able to specify a precision for `Temporal.Time` to distinguish between a reference to "8 am", exactly "8:00", exactly "8:00.0" and so on, but that use case seems a lot more niche than those solved by the additional date types.

hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
It's a good talk but it's an even better talk if you actually like JS and understand not only why those things are the way they are but also that you wouldn't ever do them in normal code.
hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
Wait, I thought Americans use M/D/Y not Y/D/M?
hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
It's documented undefined behavior, really. Implementations are allowed to accept other input than ISO strings and interpret them how they like.

The real "bug" in the example is 2025/05/28 being May 28th because the implementation ignores timezones for that format.

The issue with `Date` is that it is based on the original `java.util.Date` class and inherits all of its problems: https://docs.oracle.com/en/java/javase/21/docs/api/java.base... - this is also where the wonky zero-indexed month value comes from. Note that Java deprecated all versions of the constructor other than the one taking a millisecond value or nothing, which JS can't do for backwards compatibility reasons.

Hopefully `Temporal` will solve these problems but how long that spec has been in the works should tell you how difficult this is to get right when anything you put on the web is forever.

hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
I guess some people just want to see the world burn.
hnbad··on Why are 2025/05/28 and 2025-05-28 different days in JavaScript?
Because the alternative would have been VBScript (if Microsoft had won at the time).

JS was a compromise. It had to be sent out the door quick, it needed to look sufficiently like Java to not upset Sun who were trying to establish Java as the universal platform at the time while not being feature complete enough to be perceived as a competitor rather than a supplement. And it had to be standardized ASAP to pre-empt Microsoft's Embrace Extend Extinguish strategy (which was well on its way with JScript). That's also why it's an ECMA standard rather than ISO despite Netscape not having been based in Switzerland - ECMA simply offered the shortest timeline to publishing a standard.

I think what's more amazing isn't just how we managed to build the bulk of user interfaces in JavaScript but how we Node.js managed to succeed with ECMAScript 3. Node.js was born into a world without strict mode and without even built-in support for JSON: https://codelucky.com/javascript-es5/ - and yeah, ECMAScript 3 was succeeded by ECMAScript 5 not 4 because it took vendors 10 years to agree on how the language should evolve in the 21st century - not only did we build the modern web on JavaScript, we built a lot of the modern web on the version of JavaScript as it was in 1999! Even AJAX wasn't standardized until 2006 when Web 2.0 was already in full swing.

hnbad··on Airbnb is in midlife crisis mode
This is a general problem. These things worked before those platforms became successful enough to warrant a cottage industry around them. Nowadays there are "reputation management" companies specializing in getting bad reviews deleted by any means and shady businesses will actively bribe or shame customers into giving them perfect scores. For a while everyone knew that 5 star and 1 star ratings are often fake and that you should check the ratings in between to get the real ones but nowadays those often don't exist or are just as fake (often left by shadier "reputation management" companies to score them an easy win if the business hires them).

What services like Airbnb would need would be direct partners actually testing the listings in person. But that costs money and requires hiring staff, which is antithetical to the business model of "gig economy" apps which exist in order to avoid the overhead of running a real company in that industry by instead offloading all the work to "gig workers" as independent contractors.

hnbad··on Iceland approved 4-day workweek in 2019; six years later, predictions came true
Anecdotally, we introduced a 25 hours (5 days, 5 hours per day) work week at full pay in our company (digital services, creative) and maintained it for several years and observed a reduction of productivity (in terms of output) of 10-20% compared to the reduction of working hours of 37.5%. We also saw much higher employee satisfaction and self-reported mental health improvements. Most of the employees were women so the reduction in working hours also often translated to a significant relative increase in leisure time as much of their non-working hours was otherwise taken up by family, care work and chores (which isn't to say their partners were slobs but gendered expectations still exist in our society and it's not just the men reinforcing them).

Our biggest problem was that this was difficult to roll out to all people working for the company. E.g. you can't really cut the hours for cleaners coming in for a few hours per week because their hours are mostly defined by their workload and a 37.5% reduction across the board also means someone who previously did 20 hours would now do 12.5 hours, which translates to a much greater loss of productivity if spread out across more than two days. The founders also pretty much kept working full time as before.

The reduced number of working hours also really put the spotlight on people who were already struggling with productivity before, which one might argue is a good thing. Also for legal reasons the contracts remained unaffected as this was an open-ended experiment, not a legally binding benefit. The employees were also interviewed before and during the process and most were initially opposed to the idea because they feared they wouldn't be able to handle their workloads in less time.

It's worth mentioning that just like WFH policies, this is something that simply doesn't work for everyone. If you have a factory with a fixed output over time and productivity of an employee is tied to time at the machine, productivity loss will translate 1-to-1 from reduced working hours. Likewise in retail working hours are dictated by opening hours. You can still reduce working hours by introducing/adding shifts of course but there is no economic incentive for companies to keep paying employees the same for fewer hours in these jobs unless coerced to do so through collective bargaining. Remember that while many credit Henry Ford with popularizing the 40 hour work week and he did provide many rationalizations for it at his own company, the 40 hour work week only became law (along with many other improvements of working conditions) after massive protests from unionists and anarchists, including the Haymarket massacre[0]. It wasn't simply handed to workers, and certainly not voluntarily.

[0]: In case you're unfamiliar with the term, the Haymarket massacre or "Haymarket affair" refers to an incident where police shot and killed an unknown number of unarmed protestors and striking workers following an explosion that killed seven police officers and at least four workers. Eight people were charged and sentenced (seven being sentenced to death) for the bombing, though it's not clear if any of them were actually involved in the bombing itself or its planning. The police officers who had shot and killed protestors never suffered any consequences.

hnbad··on Gorgeous-GRUB: collection of decent community-made GRUB themes
I used to dual boot with Windows before WSL was a thing and I agree that back then I'd see GRUB on a daily basis.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →