809 karma · joined February 8, 2011
Rather famously, Amazon in its early days included the cost of fulfillment (shipping, warehousing, etc.) in Sales and Marketing expense, not COGS. As a result, gross margins were thought to be somewhat inflated.
Apparently they also counted their equity investments in the stock of companies including Webvan and Sotheby's as cash and marketable securities.
At the time, analysts were worried about what all this implied for operating cash flow and gross margin.
Discussing the similar case of Faisal Shahzad, who attempted to bomb Times Square, Orin Kerr, a law professor who is an expert on the 4th Amendment wrote:
"Importantly, though, it would not have violated Shahzad’s constitutional rights to not read him his Miranda rights. A lot of people assume that the police are required to read a suspect his rights when he is arrested. That is, they assume that one of a person’s rights is the right to be read their rights. It often happens that way on Law & Order, but that’s not what the law actually requires. Under Chavez v. Martinez, 538 U.S. 760 (2003), it is lawful for the police to not read a suspect his Miranda rights, interrogate him, and then obtain a statement that would be inadmissible in court. Chavez holds that a person’s constitutional rights are violated only if the prosecution tries to have the statement admitted in court. See id. at 772-73. Indeed, the prosecution is even allowed to admit any physical evidence discovered as a fruit of the statement obtained in violation of Miranda — only the actual statement is excluded. See United States v. Patane, 542 U.S. 630 (2004). So while it may sound weird, it turns out that obtaining a statement outside Miranda but not admitting it in court is lawful."
Oops, link: http://www.volokh.com/2010/05/05/shahzad-and-miranda-rights/
One minor quibble, though. Unless you're specifically talking about water tankers sitting unused, most fire engines carry a fairly limited amount of water in their internal tanks (technically, a "truck" has ladders, while, in SF at least, an "engine" has a water tank + a pump + hose lines).
In San Francisco, newer engines have a 500 gallon internal tank. That sounds like a lot, but the rated capacity of the pump is 1500 gallons/min, meaning at full flow (150 psi) you have 20 seconds of water. At best, with a small line at a low pressure, you have a few minutes of water.
Again, not saying you're wrong or repositioning the engines wouldn't have helped. But unless it's a trash can fire, the first order of business at a working fire (structure or wildland) is securing a dependable water supply.
Running a company out of one's back pocket is a very good way to spend a lot of time in the company of IRS agents and enforcement personnel.
Speaking as a former investor regarding the financial situation though...never ever ever ever.
Financial controls aren't important just because VCs are greedy: they keep companies alive and keep you out of court (or jail). I've seen situations in which cash didn't quite reconcile to what was expected; in some, the people involved made restitution and were fired. In others, they went to prison. A company with no effective financial control is flying blind and, someday, will run into the mountain in the clouds.
The article identifies some key warning signs.
1. "...not even sharing the company's financial information with his co-founder, Emily Blakeney. Sources admit that was strange in retrospect. ... Sources say Sherman was the only person with access to the company's bank account and invoices. Only he knew how much cash Ecomom was using up every month."
In many startups, any payment over $X requires dual signatures for exactly this reason. Also, contract bookkeepers aren't expensive (contract CFOs can be, but they're worth it). A second set of eyes--and hands--on the corporate checkbook is crucial.
Also, why aren't investors aren't looking at the cash position every month? That is the one critical number--the only one with sudden corporate death at stake--for every single Board meeting until the company is solidly and predictably cash flow positive.
2. "'There wasn't ever full disclosure, and that leads me to believe there was a reason he didn't want anyone to have full disclosure,' says a source."
Totally 100% unacceptable. The key execs and the board should be looking at the financials, at least at the bank account/quickbooks level, every month and management should be reviewing them more frequently yet. Especially in a metrics-driven business like e-commerce that requires cash investments for inventory and advertising.
3. "He put the company's inventory on his credit card, a black American Express, which caused him to go into deeper personal debt. He refused to get a corporate card, despite complaining to colleagues when AmEx would call and question company expenses."
A huge red flag. If there is intermingling of corporate and personal finances--whether this extreme or just the CEO's sister's law firm does the legal work--investors and co-founders need to fully understand and ensure it's arms-length. Then they need to disentangle the two right away.
If you own 100% of the company, feel free to run it "out of your back pocket." But with outside shareholders, whether employees or investors, such a practice is indefensible. In my experience, intertwined personal and professional finances is often the tip of the iceberg in terms of accounting shenanigans.
I don't mean to imply that investors should have seen this coming or that Jody set out to do this. But every experienced investor who's been burned this way--and many have--makes financial control issues a topic at the first (and every subsequent) board meeting post-investment until adequate controls are in place.
This apparently used to be a bigger deal back when the USPS relied on OCR more heavily for bulk mail delivery, but barcodes have become the method of choice.[2]
[1] http://faq.usps.com/eCustomer/iq/usps/request.do?create=kb%3...
[2] http://smartystreets.com/kb/faq/should-addresses-be-in-upper...
http://www.newrepublic.com/article/books-and-arts/magazine/1...
But if I'm a customer of an admired former startup to whom I pay hundreds of thousands of dollars a month, I'm not allowed to go public with my complaints when I--and maybe hundreds of others--have been deceived and have suffered intentionally worse service than what I was promised?
I find the "enforced positiveness/optimism" of the startup community very disheartening. The essence of engineering is honesty (preferably quantified) about capabilities and limitations of systems. In this case, a former startup owned by a public company deceived their customers and then papered over (my impression) a valid, quantitatively-documented customer complaint once it became public.
Tom should be commended for speaking out. If he's right, dozens of startups have spent far more of their precious and limited capital on excess dynos and monitoring tools that could have been better spent elsewhere. I can't imagine a better service to the startup community than making this sort of thing public.
Why? I don't know for sure, but I would imagine it was because the market for cars was and is an awful lot bigger than the market for tractors, and tractors come with special requirements for durability and versatility (towing, plowing, etc.) that were harder to satisfy at the time.
EDIT: Oops, the link. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fordson_tractor
All that said, my point is that if one bought ads with keywords for 100% of the unique first name-last name pairs found among prisoners/arrestees, "stereotypically black" names would be over-represented relative to the total population and relative to the internet-using population.
In other words, in my view, this is a symptom of the criminal justice system, not a racist policy choice by Google's algorithm. Google's algorithm sees only one color: green.
1. If you charge $15.00 in a quarter, it's free. If you charge $15.10 you owe $15.10. In other words, you don't get a $15 credit if you go over $15.
2. It's actually potentially more than 150 pages, as PACER caps the cost per document at something like $3.00, I think. So one could download five 200 page documents for $15.
3. The PACER system has become a slush fund for the judiciary. It has run huge surpluses (on the order of tens of millions of dollars) for years, even as the cost per page has increased from $0.08 to $0.10. Keep in mind that participants in lawsuits pay non-trivial filing fees for the privilege and that electronic filing has drastically reduced the cost of shuffling paper in courts.
4. Some state courts do make their documents more free than PACER by a long shot. FL and WI are good examples. Some are far worse (UT, which charges $30/month just to search!).
5. The worst part of the PACER system is that it's heavily federated--searching across courts for documents containing particular keywords is essentially impossible. One has to consult a nightly index of cases assembled from each local court's database. The money isn't even being spent to improve the system.
Some state court systems provide excellent access to dockets and documents (WI); others have access policies that make PACER's look open (UT).
Mix of interesting technical articles (most related to search and information retrieval) and tech industry prognostication.
First, he's not on oxygen. Step 1 for a suspected heart attack patient.
Second, he's got a shirt, a sweater and a blanket on top of him. Step 2 for a potential MCI is to expose the chest and get him on a "monitor" (combination EKG/AED), which it appears is at his feet.
Third, unless he fell and injured his head, neck or back, there is no reason to have him in full spinal immobilization as they appear to have done.
This is not a question of not having training or equipment--from the look of the photo, they have both. I'm reading a lot into a single snapshot, but being transported via ambulance in the US would look nothing at all like this.
The SF Weekly (an alternative newspaper here) has published several thought-provoking articles on the state of the city over the years. They are all titled, "The Worst Run Big City in the US."
Those articles include: http://www.sfweekly.com/2009-12-16/news/the-worst-run-big-ci...
http://www.sfweekly.com/2010-04-14/news/the-muni-death-spira...
http://www.sfweekly.com/2012-06-13/news/muni-sfmta-buses-pub...
http://www.sfweekly.com/2010-10-20/news/let-it-bleed/
http://www.sfweekly.com/2011-01-26/news/premium-pay-san-fran...
http://www.sfweekly.com/2011-07-27/news/san-francisco-commis...
San Francisco also has a civil grand jury that periodically issues reports on topics of citywide concern. These are generally ignored, even though they point out significant present and future problems (I'm thinking specifically of looming pension issues).
http://www.sfsuperiorcourt.org/general-info/grand-jury/jury-...
I've lived and worked here since college, so I'm not immune to the city's charms. But we shouldn't be blind to its faults, either.
Edit: formatting
I'm on an old XP machine with very little memory and a slow disk, and I get quite good performance out of it, despite not being able to effectively use mapped or off-heap memory. I expect that moving to MapDB on JDK7 (with its concurrent collections and better memory allocation) will improve performance quite a bit.
http://rules.calbar.ca.gov/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=mKEKxX4... [pdf]
Note that a lawyer referral service is defined as: "'Lawyer Referral Service' means an individual, partnership, corporation, association, or any other entity, or a service or agency of an entity, which operates for the direct or indirect purpose of referring potential clients to lawyers, whether or not the term 'referral service' is used."
I imagine other states have similar licensing requirements.
I see your long answer, and, being a bit familiar with companies like Intelligent Beauty, I raise you a long list of questions. I don't expect you to answer them, but in my mind they can help separate "value-enhancing offer" for customers vs. "revenue-enhancing trick" for the company.
1.) How long does the average customer stay in the monthly program before cancelling?
2.) What percentage of customers opt-out on initial sign-up?
3.) On average, what % of the monthly subscription charged to the customer is ultimately spent on merchandise vs. becomes breakage?
4.) If you changed the text next to the check box to say, "You will be charged $39.95/month," do you think opt-in rates would change? If consumers aren't being misled, you should see little-to-no change in opt-in rates.
5) If I call to cancel after N months, do you refund the unused balance? Do I have to use it as a "store credit?" Do you offer me 100 cents on the dollar or some fraction thereof? Are consumers given incentives not to cancel or to convert the remaining unused balance into merchandise before cancelling?
6) Does the unused balance expire? If so, after how long?
7) Do you email customers to let them know they need to log in every month, or is it their responsibility to remember?
8) What portion of the company's revenues (and, more importantly, gross margin dollars) is in product sales vs. unused subscription dollars as breakage?
9) Why must consumers call customer service to cancel vs. doing it online? Is it difficult or time-consuming to reach customer service?
If this subscription is a value-add for customers, one would expect:
- A high portion of the charged dollars converting into merchandise sales vs. becoming breakage. Consumers rarely find it enjoyable to be charged $39.95 and not to get anything for it (even Columbia House sent you the CDs at the same time they collect the money; you get the money first, and I have to remember to come to you to get the shoes).
- A reasonable % of customers opting-out at initial purchase. If 99% opt in, your disclosure is ineffective, as it beggars belief that people are dying to pay $39.95 a month. Or, if you change the language of the text box as I suggest above, no observed difference in opt-in rates.
- A low churn rate in the % of consumers who call to cancel once subscribed.
- A consumer-friendly policy that allows subscribers who cancel to receive 100% on the dollar for the unused balance either in cash or store credit, at their option.
- The majority of the revenues and gross margin dollars come from shoe sales, not subscription fees.
- Easy, online cancellation. Shouldn't it be as easy to get out of the program as to get into it? If not, why not?
[Edit: formatting, again]
I don't know whether the claims in the article are well-supported or not (or what type of treatment the couch in the video had, as the videos are from the late 80s/early 90s), but I think most people don't realize just how dangerous a working fire in a single room full of ordinary furnishings can be.
The post advocates starting a company in order to build and sell a new software application. If this resembles every other business app I've ever written or used, the developer will quickly run into a complex set of rules and requirements that is almost impossible to fully anticipate or characterize a priori.
The motivation for doing so is admittedly egregious fees charged by an incumbent vendor. Imagine one is successful in building the app, despite all of the unforeseeable obstacles. All the incumbent would have to do is lower its prices, either accepting slightly lower margins to maintain the fee pass-thru to its partners or eliminating such fees as the hypothetical startup would do.
In other words, the proposal is to dedicate years of effort to a problem in order to compete on price by 10-25%. This is generally a losing proposition. If one can achieve a 90% lower price for the same or slightly better functionality that an incumbent will find difficult to match (the famed 10x price/performance improvement), then one may have something sufficient to build a business around, depending on how difficult/capital intensive it is to create the product--ignoring all of the other barriers to adoption that exist in this or another industry.
But faced with a narrow price-performance improvement, incumbents can either lower prices or, if it's a functional improvement, invest a similar or lesser amount of capital (they already have employees, a brand name, a salesforce, etc. that a startup would have to build from scratch) to match to the feature set.
Don't get me wrong: I don't want to talk anyone out of the desire to start a company, to improve a process or an application, or to return excess profits to the consumer in the form of lower prices. But part of being a successful entrepreneur is picking the right battles and bringing an unfair advantage to bear against tough competition, something I and many others still struggle to achieve. In this case, I don't see the unfair advantage or the 10x improvement, and I think we should challenge each other to be hard-nosed realists about where we focus our collective entrepreneurial talents.
I am not a lawyer, but as an investor I have seen this happen before. My guess (no connection to the company, wasn't aware of them prior to today) is that in lieu of filing for bankruptcy, they did an Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors.
But what may have happened is: 1. OnLive recognizes that they're essentially bankrupt. Directors and managers now have a fiduciary duty to maximize the recovery for creditors, not for shareholders.
2. Instead of going through a formal bankruptcy process, the company does an Assignment for the Benefit of Creditors (see a good explanation here [1]). Any price paid for the assets by a buyer above what is owed to the creditors goes to satisfy the liquidation preferences, though it's unlikely there will be much if any recovery of value above the debts owed to the creditors. The value of the common equity is totally wiped out (both common stock and employee options) as the total value of the assets is well below the amount due creditors + the liquidation preferences.
3. A buyer for the assets (the source of money with which to pay off the creditors who now own the assets of the defunct company) forms a new company, call it OnLive Asset Acquisition Corp.
4. OnLive Asset Acquisition Corp purchases the assets (not the stock) of the defunct corporation now owned by creditors. The new acquirer buys the assets so as to avoid any existing/potential liabilities of the defunct corporation from whom it purchases the assets. Imagine there's a company whose only asset is a rack of servers that you wish to purchase. To gain ownership of the servers, you could buy all the shares of the company or you could just buy the servers as an asset with no encumbrances. You would likely do the latter, as buying the stock comes with potential liabilities for past/future money owed or lawsuits. That's likely what happened here, but for IP, etc.
5. The original employer OnLive is no longer operating. The employees are all terminated, as their employer is gone and its operating assets are owned by a new company. The new company may or may not seek to hire some or all of the employees of the defunct company.
6. Even if employees had been able to exercise their options, they were virtually certain to be worthless. There is no way the price paid by the new owner for the assets of the dead company would exceed the debts + liquidation preferences (otherwise the directors wouldn't have liquidated it). Had the employees exercised their options, any cash they paid to do so would have gone to the creditors to satisfy the company's debts and they would have received zero in proceeds.
It's a sad story for the employees, but there are rarely any happy outcomes for a company in bankruptcy.
Again, I'm purely speculating on what happened. But based on the facts disclosed so far, it's not clear that one can conclude that the employees received a specific and unusual screwing by management vs. a typical screwing associated with the liquidation of a bankrupt employer.
[1] http://bankruptcy.cooley.com/2008/03/articles/the-financiall...
Short answer: he recommends a portfolio of low-cost index funds/ETFs covering several asset classes and regular rebalancing to target allocation weights. I have generally followed his advice to good effect using Vanguard index funds.