HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hobbyjogger

207 karma · joined February 18, 2015

submissionscomments
hobbyjogger··on Is developer compensation becoming bimodal?
Your point is a good one, but to me it confirms the comment you are responding to.

> The idea that med school or law school teach you "all the knowledge required to become a lawyer or a doctor" is laughable and a truly absurd statement. The sheer size of the problem domains these subjects cover alone renders this impossible

You seem to be an example of a programmer that can be good and proficient in many different fields, languages, and scopes. You don't really see that in law or medicine. Doctors can't jump around from orthopedic surgeon to psychiatrist to dermatologist. And it's very uncommon (at least for lawyers under 60 or so) to be both a corporate lawyer and a litigator.

As giobox mentioned, the sheer size of the domains of law and medicine all but require doctors and lawyers to specialize. That's certainly true to some extent with computer science but it doesn't seem to be quite as strong in that field.

hobbyjogger··on NY lawsuit asks: Is graffiti art protected under federal law?
Your comments seems a bit tongue in cheek, but the answer is probably not.

This law doesn't protect works made for hire--and presumably the monuments would have been. It also only gives standing to sue to the author of a work, so the general public couldn't rely on it and if the author is dead the right to sue likely died with him/her. Finally, it doesn't prevent taking something down--only mutilation or destruction, etc. of an artist's work.

hobbyjogger··on SEC Shuts Down Munchee ICO
Why do you not consider paper to be an asset?

Pretty much anything that can be bought and sold is an asset. Yes, that includes notebooks and paper.

hobbyjogger··on Oregon punished an engineer for criticizing red-light cameras. He fought and won
The lawyers in this specific case work for a non-profit (Institute for Justice) that did not bill Järlström a single dollar.

http://ij.org/ij-receives-charity-navigators-highest-rating-...

hobbyjogger··on Oregon punished an engineer for criticizing red-light cameras. He fought and won
> force you to pay thousands to lawyers

From the article:

> but Järlström and his attorneys from the Institute for Justice

IFJ is a non-profit (that has received Charity Navigator's 4-star rating for 16 years in a row)[1]. That's not to say that what Oregon has done here is right (not by any means) but Järlström surely hasn't paid IFJ anything.

[1] http://ij.org/ij-receives-charity-navigators-highest-rating-...

hobbyjogger··on Uber’s Losses Widen as SoftBank Launches Bid to Buy Shares
Nearly all insiders (i.e. management, investors, employees, etc.) will be subject to a "lock-up" on an IPO that prevents them from selling immediately. Typically the lock-up lasts for 180 days, but this can vary.

Share price does often drop when the lock-up expires, but usually not as much as you'd expect--the number of restricted shares to be release and resulting liquidity effects of that expiration are well know and disclosed in public filings. So this mostly gets baked into pricing well in advance.

hobbyjogger··on Outlawry, Supervillians, and Modern Law (2010)
We all react much more strongly to stimuli (here punishment but in other cases rewards too) when those stimuli are "swift and certain." That's true even in the face of an alternative that is more severe but also delayed and only contingent (possible jail time, if ultimately tried and convicted).

To me the effectiveness of the police assault is not particularly hard to understand or imagine. It's the same principle that leads many folks to resort to self-destructive behaviors in the short-term (addiction, etc.), even though many addicts completely understand and acknowledge the long-term consequences.

hobbyjogger··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Is Worth a Shot
The term "beneficial owner" also includes anyone who has sole or shared voting power over the security (not just those with sole or shared "formal title", economic interests and/or power to sell or transfer the security).

A major reason for that is trying to prevent "gaming" of votes, along the lines of your footnote [1]. Just like right now, I don't think the LTSE proposal would require an outright ban on these arrangements--it just requires the issuer/exchange to make sure the disclosure requirements for "beneficial owners" are sufficient for them to "reset" the voting clock if/when voting power is transferred.

hobbyjogger··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Is Worth a Shot
Not your fault--I didn't make this clear enough: there is absolutely no way to legally engage in what you proposed without being a qualified securities professional who is very much "subject to these regulations" from, e.g., NYSE, NASDAQ, FINRA and the SEC.

You can't just buy shares from a registered securities professional (e.g. broker, dealer or underwriter) and then start engaging in "off the books" securities transactions. That is, unless you don't mind a lengthy prison sentence.

The activities you are describing (buy securities and then sell "stakes" and/or profits interests and/or voting rights) fall very squarely within many of the various definitions of securities professional required to register and comply with these extensive regulations. For example, see definitions 11 and 12 here [1]. Also note that the definition of "sell" includes selling any interest in a security--not just selling an entire security outright.

> (11) The term “underwriter” means any person who has purchased from an issuer with a view to, or offers or sells for an issuer in connection with, the distribution of any security, or participates or has a direct or indirect participation in any such undertaking, or participates or has a participation in the direct or indirect underwriting of any such undertaking; but such term shall not include a person whose interest is limited to a commission from an underwriter or dealer not in excess of the usual and customary distributors’ or sellers’ commission. As used in this paragraph the term “issuer” shall include, in addition to an issuer, any person directly or indirectly controlling or controlled by the issuer, or any person under direct or indirect common control with the issuer.

> (12) The term “dealer” means any person who engages either for all or part of his time, directly or indirectly, as agent, broker, or principal, in the business of offering, buying, selling, or otherwise dealing or trading in securities issued by another person.

Here's just a random example from Google of the penalties your hypothetical "off the books" broker could face [2].

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/77b

[2] http://companycounsel.net/2010/01/21/you-dont-have-to-know-t...

hobbyjogger··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Is Worth a Shot
> The problem is that there is a financial incentive for someone else who is not working with them to buy up the stock, immediately resell it with the normal guarantees (that they will pass on dividends, allow voting by proxy etc.), but not pass on such re-sell information to the exchange/company. Does the exchange/company have some sort of a right to prevent resale unless tenure information is tracked?

Yes, absolutely. That same financial incentive already exists in all sorts of variations. As a result, brokers (i.e. your hypothetical entity that gobbles up all the shares and then loans them or sells economic/voting rights) must be registered with FINRA and are subject to very extensive regulations, including rules from FINRA, the SEC and the public exchanges.

For an example, look at how long and complicated the NYSE rules are, mostly involving member organizations like brokers (click on "Operation of Member Organizations" or any of the other subheadings at the link below and then see, for example, rule 402):

> .30 Securities Callable in Part.—Member organizations which have in their possession or under their control bonds or preferred stocks of issues which are callable in part, whether specifically set aside or otherwise, shall identify each such bond or preferred stock so that their records shall clearly show for whose account it is held, except in the case of [two limited exceptions]

http://wallstreet.cch.com/NYSE/Rules/

hobbyjogger··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Is Worth a Shot
To oversimplify, property rights are often said to be good against the world, while contract rights are good against specific others.

A share of stock is itself a set of contractual rights, but the record owner has a property right in the share (and often a physical certificate). It doesn't matter if someone takes your share or inadvertently/accidentally sells it to an innocent buyer. It's still yours and you have a better claim to it than any buyer or later holder.

But a beneficial owner of a share held in "street name" has only a contractual right to his shares--essentially a promise from his broker that the broker will have at least [x] shares for him (note this means he does not have a claim to any specific or identifiable shares and his broker surely holds many times more since they'll have many other clients). And on top of that, his broker has an account with DTC that involves a second layer of contractual rights to the stock--essentially a promise from DTC to the broker that DTC will have at least [x] shares for the broker (again not specific or identifiable shares and DTC certainly has many times more shares since DTC holds nearly all shares held in "street name")

If your broker or DTC accidentally or inadvertently disposes of too many shares (and this can happen surprisingly often) you only have recourse against your broker or DTC. The agreements between [you and your broker] and [your broker and DTC] do not bind the new owner of the shares, who has no obligation under those agreements and, as a bona fide buyer + current holder, also has a better claim to the shares than you do.

If that wasn't specific enough, here's a very detailed summary and analysis of the current stock ownership structure and mechanics:

http://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article...

hobbyjogger··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Is Worth a Shot
>Yes, this strikes me as the obvious problem. The equilibrium is for third party to buy and hold all the tenure-voting stock and then sell stakes in the dividends of the company plus allowing voting by proxy. Basically, the third party becomes an exchange, and all stock effectively has maximal tenure.

You've essentially just described the current system. Most shares on NASDAQ and NYSE etc. are technically held by Depository Trust Company via its nominee, Cede & Co. [1]. Through a complicated set of regulatory and contractual arrangements, public companies, the beneficial owners of their stock (i.e. the investor at the end of the chain) and each intermediary (banks and brokers, etc.) all maintain a sort of legal fiction that the shares are "owned" by Joe Schmoe, even though all he really has is an attenuated set of contractual rights that flow through the various intermediaries between him and "his" shares held by Cede.

Joe Schmoe does not technically or legally own those shares. Cede does. Believe it or not, you were spot on in predicting that the third party would allow "voting by proxy." That's exactly how Joe Schmoe (i.e. all of us) must vote our shares if we want to participate in a stockholder vote. We can't just show up at the meeting (or fill out the company's proxy card). You send a "voting instruction form" telling your broker how you'd like to vote, and your broker then tells Cede & Co. how to vote your shares at the stockholder meeting.[2]

To address your specific point, tenure voting would surely be based on the tenure of the beneficial owner (i.e. the person at the end of the chain who gets to vote) not the nominee holding the shares in "street name" on the beneficial owner's behalf. This might take some reworking of the arrangements between the brokers, DTC, clearinghouses, etc. (likely needing to be be built into the financial systems that log transfers and ownership, if not already provided for) but would not really pose a significant barrier.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-07-14/banks-for... [2] https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/proxymatters/proxy_materials.s...

hobbyjogger··on Google Pixel 2 and 2 XL announced
My experience with Nexus 6p support was very different. I bought my 6P at launch in 2015, it ran perfectly for a year and a half and then I noticed that it shut down at around 15% battery a couple of times. One phone call to Google, despite the fact that I was out of warranty, and then 2 days later a brand new Pixel XL (last year's model) showed up in an overnight FedEx. Could not be more pleased.
hobbyjogger··on Uber Founder Travis Kalanick Resigns as C.E.O.
You are confusing a down round with a small exit event (here and in other places in this thread). Liquidation preferences don't come into effect until a sale of the company - so no one is "crammed out" by them in a down round.

Though these two types of events are obviously correlated (a down round makes a smaller exit more likely) they are not the same and should not be confused. A financing at a valuation that is a billion dollars less than the last round would be a down round, but a sale of the company at that same valuation would still far exceed the liquidation overhang.

hobbyjogger··on iOS 11 Location Privacy: "Only While Using" is now always an option for users
I agree. This link came at the perfect time.

A car dealership who botched a warranty repair on my vehicle is stonewalling me - once they realized the error was likely to cost them $2k - $3k, their service department deleted my file and began claiming no evidence exists that I had ever been to their location. I got the scheduling department to confirm my appointment and just found my location history for that day showing that I was at the dealership right on time during the appointment. Going to send this to the manufacturer's corporate complaints departments. Thanks for the heads up.

hobbyjogger··on Options vs. Cash
Unless you are a sought-after C-level executive, hardly any legitimate companies are going to even consider your "clever hacks."

The first one blows up 409a (requires optionholder to pay fair market value for the shares). As to the second, very, very few investors are going to allow "their" money to be used for a common stock repurchase (at the same per share price) instead of going toward's the company's operations/development/whatever.

hobbyjogger··on Study: carpooling apps could reduce traffic 3x in NYC
From my perspective, the worst months in Austin (July and August) could be doable with a shower at work. Without one--totally unthinkable unless your job involves outdoor labor. I biked daily for 3 years when I lived in Boston but there's just no equivalent to putting on a big jacket for heat/sweat.

Look at the dew point (which far better comparison than humidity because it doesn't fluctuate with temperature). Here are the August daily averages for Austin[0] and Toronto[1].

Toronto's dew point range (~53-63) has a max that is right around our minimum (Austin range: ~63 - 72).

Also keep in mind that, Toronto's daily high temps in August (~77F) are right around Austin's lows (~76), with our highs reaching around ~97F.

I'm going to suggest that you may be misremembering how humid it felt - in my opinion there's no way to bike any reasonable distance for the majority of July and August (and often June and September as well) without showing up a sweaty mess. At least I haven't figured out how to do it--even though I bike commute regularly from October - May.

[0]: https://weatherspark.com/averages/29672/8/Austin-Texas-Unite... [1]: https://weatherspark.com/averages/28390/8/Montreal-Quebec-Ca...

hobbyjogger··on Study: carpooling apps could reduce traffic 3x in NYC
Yeah, people tend to overlook the role climate plays in these comparisons. There's an enormous difference in cycling's viability as a primary means of transportation in a place like the Netherlands where average high temperatures rarely exceed 75, as opposed to Texas where a typical summer will have a prolonged period of temps in the 90s and multiple 100+ days.

The average high temperature in Amsterdam's warmest two months is 70F.[0]

Austin's average high temp is warmer than that for every month except December, January and February. In the warmest months, the average highs are 96 and 97. [1]

[0]: http://www.holiday-weather.com/amsterdam/averages/ [1]: https://www.currentresults.com/Weather/Texas/Places/austin-t...

hobbyjogger··on Why We're Living in the Age of Fear
That's the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution.

Some parts of the Constitution apply to non-citizens, some parts don't. For example, the 14th Amendment makes a distinction on this point--note the use of "citizens" vs. "any person":

No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

hobbyjogger··on Suspicious court cases, missing defendants, aim to get webpages taken down
Any lawyer or law firm who intentionally presented fabricated documents with forged signatures to a court under these circumstances would almost certainly be disbarred. Reputation management firms don't face that risk -- but they are subject to punishment in other ways.
hobbyjogger··on Why Law Firm Rankings Are Useless
So you sue me and get a judgment for $100,000.

If I felt that I owed you nothing, surely this counts as a "loss" for me at trial.

If, however, you had originally sued for $50M and I felt I might owe you some money but no more than $1M so I decided to fight it, the $100k judgment would be considered an enormous "win" for me.

What data does your analysis use to distinguish between the two scenarios given that the verdicts are identical?

hobbyjogger··on Louisiana Judges Issue Harsher Sentences When the LSU Football Team Loses
The study you're referencing assumed that the order in which the parolees appeared was random, which turned out not to be the case. More info here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12463053

hobbyjogger··on Louisiana Judges Issue Harsher Sentences When the LSU Football Team Loses
The Danziger study assumed that the order in which the parolees appeared was random, which turned out not to be the case:

"Danziger et al. (1) concluded that meal breaks taken by Israeli parole boards influence the boards’ decisions. This conclusion depends on the order of cases being random or at least exogenous to the timing of meal breaks. . . [But] case ordering is not random ...the board tries to complete all cases from one prison before it takes a break and to start with another prison after the break. Within each session, unrepresented prisoners usually go last and are less likely to be granted parole than prisoners with attorneys...

[O]ur data indicate a success rate of 67% for prisoners with counsel and 39% for unrepresented prisoners. Excluding deferrals in the authors' data yields very similar success rates, beginning at about 75% and dropping to 42% at the end of a session. Thus, we strongly suspect that the pattern of declining success rates is a result of hearing represented prisoners first and unrepresented prisoners last."

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3198355/

hobbyjogger··on How Startup Options and Ownership Work
> So the vast majority of startup employees don't have the fancy tax-avoiding scheme that founders and investors have.

Investors never have vesting on their shares so 83(b) has nothing to do with the preferred stock investors receive. Founders of course do often have vesting and can benefit from filing an 83(b).

hobbyjogger··on American Bar Association votes to DRM referenced material made public
Which is exactly how eminent domain works. If the government takes your farm to build an airport, they pay you for the value of the pre-takings farm, not the value of the post-takings airport.
hobbyjogger··on The law depends on compute power
Great point and well said. Except I'd add that the LSAT is heavily focused on deductive, formal logic (particularly the logic puzzles section) and most of the rest is semantics. That's very removed from what lawyers actually do (which I think you described well, it's just that the LSAT isn't very representative of that).
hobbyjogger··on The law depends on compute power
Legal rulings and statutes, etc. are pretty far removed from the type of deductive logic that can be "openly defied" in the sense that busted math calculations or if>then statements can be self-evidently wrong.

For example, the case Olmstead v. U.S. was a big deal in the 20s when the Supreme Court said the fourth amendment protection for "persons, houses, papers, and effects" didn't apply to taps on telephone wires. I disagree with that result not because it "openly defies logic" but because my understanding of the underlying importance of privacy is at odds with those of the justices. That's not a dispute about logic, it's a disagreement about values.

hobbyjogger··on Show HN: Hacking airplane headphones
Definitely figure eight. He says as much in the article.
hobbyjogger··on Who pays when startup employees keep their equity?
Seems like a pretty good investment thesis (especially if they were truly ahead of the curve here).

Except I doubt the last bullet is accurate. I'd be very surprised to find that even 10% of tech IPOs have significant preferred investors not subject to a lock-up. Underwriters really, really don't like holders (even small ones, but especially big ones) being able to sell right off the bat. And if the market is flooded with VC investors dumping shares just after the offering, then there may well be no "pop" to participate in.

hobbyjogger··on Boaty McBoatface and the False Promise of Democracy
Habit is a powerful thing.

It's been nearly a decade since Austin's "Town Lake" was renamed by the city council as "Lady Bird Lake" (in honor of Lady Bird Johnson). To this day, I'm not sure I've ever heard it referred to as anything other than Town Lake. I certainly can never remember to use the new name.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →