HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hobbyjogger

207 karma · joined February 18, 2015

submissionscomments
hobbyjogger··on Runscope acquisition falls through
> If you have Board control you will be able to issue dividends

Most VCs insist on a protective provision that requires their approval to issue dividends to the founders/employees (i.e., common stock). So yeah--focus on either building a company that will sell for more than the liquidation preference or at least push for a comfortable salary.

hobbyjogger··on The Immobile Masses: Why Traffic Is Awful and Public Transit Is Worse
I worked on a cattle ranch one summer in high school in West Texas and it was easily a 15 - 20 minute drive to get to the mailbox on the highway (the ranch was 11 miles from end to end, all rough dirt roads and gates every quarter mile or so).

Walking to get your mail in 105+ heat and back would have taken(no exaggeration) almost all day.

hobbyjogger··on Justice-as-a-Service
Ha, maybe these guys need to team up with http://snailmailmyemail.org/ so that the recipients can't reliably identify and block their LWAAS.
hobbyjogger··on Justice-as-a-Service
> At what point does JaaS stop scaling? Perhaps this one stop on the way to fully digitized contracts?

Think about the difference between an "AI" capable of checking flight data and identifying delays greater than (X) minutes vs. "true" fully-digitized contracts (i.e., an AI that can reliably determine whether Party Y did indeed use its "reasonable best efforts" to market Product Z).

Those two things are actually more distant from each other than an "AI" capable of playing Rock-Paper-Scissors vs. an AI that can pass the Turing test.

hobbyjogger··on Justice-as-a-Service
Yeah - calling it "justice"-as-a-service seems a little ambitious. More like "(semi-)automated emails/letters asking for refunds"-as-a-service.

These emails/letters are, for the most part, only going to be as effective as corporate policy allows.

hobbyjogger··on SeedRamp
They might not like it (especially if there's a large effective discount), but that's not why.

If you raise a next round the SAFE never gets paid off - it converts into equity in the round. None of the equity investors' money is at risk of being used to pay off the SAFE.

hobbyjogger··on SeedRamp
A SAFE is basically a convertible note developed by YC[0] that is better for founders (at least mechanically) than most traditional convertible notes. As with other notes, the investor basically gives you money now in exchange for some equity at your next round TBD by a fixed formula.

As I noted elsewhere, the devil is in the details and the SAFE could be a good deal or an awful deal depending on the relationship between the SAFE's valuation cap (which is left blank and would be negotiated with each company) and the eventual pre-money valuation at the equity financing. I'd be surprised if SR is giving very high valuation caps.

[0] https://www.ycombinator.com/documents/

hobbyjogger··on SeedRamp
The agreement has a blank for the most meaningful term: the valuation cap. If you raise a round below that cap (or just above it) the SAFE ends up being a good deal. But if you raise the next round at a valuation significantly higher than the valuation cap, you could take a haircut. For example, a $1MM cap that's followed by a $15MM pre-money valuation at the Series A would give SeedRamp a 93% discount on their equity. That's the risk.

TLDR: No way to tell what they might get for their investment until they offer you a valuation cap (and even then it still depends on the future valuation put on the company by the next equity round).

hobbyjogger··on Show HN: Stripe Atlas with a Lawyer
I didn't state anything. That's a direct quote by the guy who runs what is, by leaps and bounds, the most advanced project applying AI to legal analysis.

They're doing some incredible (and incredibly interesting) things, but even they don't see AI taking over courtrooms any time soon. Think about the two problems Professor Genesereth noted above (even in the context of the most laughably simple example imaginable). These problems aren't just of a different magnitude compared to the problems we are working on with AI right now--they're of a different character entirely.

Do you know of any AI programs that can generate analogies to every possible thing/situation/event and choose the most "well-suited" among those alternatives based on a holistic, "all important things considered" balancing approach? Do you know of any AI programs that are able to rank human values/morals in a heirarchy, in a way that would be acceptable all (or even most) of us? Until the answer to those questions is "yes", you're not going to see AI sitting behind the bench in an American courtroom.

A brief aside: the common law is used as a lazy evaluation strategy[0], whereby we can defer filling in the full content of any idea/word/phrase/whatever until it actually becomes a problem. So the legislature can pass a law "no pets allowed" instead of spelling out a full and comprehensive list of every imaginable item to be banned: "No Mesocricetus auratus [golden hamster], Mesocricetus brandti [Turkish hamster], Mesocricetus newtoni: [Romanian hamster]...and so on for the next 10,000 pages."

AI could easily handle some of this filling in of content but not so much items like "reasonable search" or "malicious intent" or even, apparently, "vehicle." Those types of decisions often fall, not to logical deduction, but to induction from incomplete, conflicting and messy human theories about goodness and justice and truth. Just as most wouldn't outsource their decisions about who to love or what god to believe in, they're not going to let AIs make these types of decisions (assuming, of course, that AIs are even eventually capable of doing so--which remains an open question).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lazy_evaluation

hobbyjogger··on Show HN: Stripe Atlas with a Lawyer
Meh, not so fast. Here's the Stanford CS professor who runs the Stanford Center for Computers and Law[1]:

"One technical problem with Computational Law, familiar to many individual with legal training, is due to the open texture of laws. Consider a municipal regulation stating "No vehicles in the park". On first blush this is fine, but it is really quite problematic. Just what constitutes a vehicle? Is a bicycle a vehicle? What about a skateboard? How about roller skates? What about a baby stroller? A horse? A repair vehicle? For that matter, what is the park? At what altitude does it end? If a helicopter hovers at 10 feet, is that a violation? What if it flies over at 100 feet? The resolution of this problem is to limit the application of Computational Law to those cases where such issues can be externalized or marginalized. We allow human users to make judgments about such open texture concepts in entering data or we avoid regulatory applications where such concepts abound. A different sort of challenge to Computational Law stems from the fact that not all legal reasoning is deductive. Edwina Rissland [Rissland et al.] notes that, "Law is not a matter of simply applying rules to facts via modus ponens"; and, when regarding the broad application of AI techniques to law, this is certainly true. The rules that apply to a real-world situation, as well as even the facts themselves, may be open to interpretation, and many legal decisions are made through case-based reasoning, bypassing explicit reasoning about laws and statutes. The general problem of open texture when interpreting rules, along with the parallel problem of running out of rules to apply when resolving terms, presents significant obstacles to implementable automated rule-based reasoning." [1] http://logic.stanford.edu/complaw/complaw.html

hobbyjogger··on What the literature says about the earnings of entrepreneurs
Sort of. An example mentioned in the paper is etoys.com, presumably the first major online toy retailer.

According to this theory, etoys.com would have only captured some small % of the online market for online toys before they went under. So, yes, it's true that the "producer" here didn't capture much of the value of that market. But it's equally true that other entrepreneurs (most notable among them Amazon) captured a huge chunk of that market because etoys.com's "technological advance" simply wasn't all that technically difficult (or advanced) and wasn't different from what plenty of other entrepreneurs were doing in other online markets.

So the outcome seems entirely logical and fair. Sure, etoys.com launched the first toy site but didn't capture much of the "value" of selling toys online. But etoys.com wasn't very good and it got beat out by similar but better sites. Would you rather strengthen our (already fundamentally overbearing) IP laws so that no one else could compete in selling toys online? That's the only way I can imagine to ensure that etoys.com could take much more of the profits and not get out-margined by Amazon and the like.

hobbyjogger··on How I Simplified My Phone (2015)
Might be worth giving it another shot. Doze in Android Marshmallow drastically improved my standby battery life[0]. Doze handles wake locks much like iOS--not quite as well but it's night and day from my previous Android phones.

Here's more detail on how it works[1].

[0] http://i.imgur.com/tQyNJXD.png [1] http://developer.android.com/training/monitoring-device-stat...

hobbyjogger··on Expect Some Unicorns to Lose Their Horns, and It Won’t Be Pretty
Just thought I'd point out that the example given doesn't tell us anything about liquidation preferences (though of course you can assume they would be involved, since we're talking VCs here, but they don't matter).

The relevant financing term here is anti-dilution. Here's Feld: http://www.feld.com/archives/2005/03/term-sheet-anti-dilutio....

hobbyjogger··on Are IPOs the New Down Rounds?
In the vast majority of deals, collecting your liquidation preference is a sort of soft landing - the VCs just get their money back (without interest). It's much better for everyone if there's a big exit (either a high priced acquisition or selling shares on NYSE after an IPO) in which case the VC will convert to common and get 5x or 10x or what have you.

That's not to overlook the host of differing incentives between preferred and common-which are numerous and often even intentional. Ratchets are closer to antidilution than they are to liqpref.

hobbyjogger··on Are IPOs the New Down Rounds?
Yes, whoever VC deal lawyer is needs to work on more late stage deals. An IPO is not a liquidation event - it's just another funding round. There are no liquidation proceeds for the preference to apply to.

Here's Brad Feld[1]:

Jason once had an entertaining (and unenjoyable) debate during a guest lecture he gave at his alma mater law school with a partner from a major Chicago law firm (who was teaching a venture class that semester) that claimed an initial public offering should be considered a liquidation event. His theory was that an IPO was the same as a merger, that the company was going away, and thus the investors should get their proceeds. Even if such a theory would be accepted by an investment banker who would be willing to take the company public (no chance in our opinion), it makes no sense as an IPO is simply another funding event for the company, not a liquidation of the company. However, in most IPO scenarios, the VCs “preferred stock” is converted to common stock as part of the IPO, eliminating the issue around a liquidity event in the first place.

[1]http://www.feld.com/archives/2005/01/term-sheet-liquidation-...

hobbyjogger··on Are IPOs the New Down Rounds?
Liquidation preferences are wiped out in an IPO. What's more relevant are "ratchets" which were mentioned in the article.
hobbyjogger··on Liquidation Preference – Yesterday again tomorrow?
If the employees have stock, they'll be entitled to see the amended and restated certificate of incorporation, which would show liquidation preferences, etc.

If they only have options, they're not entitled to anything, though they could pay to download a copy of the certificate of incorporation from Delaware (it's a public document).

That said - your point is well taken. Most employees likely have no idea what terms the Company is raising money on at any given time.

hobbyjogger··on Liquidation Preference – Yesterday again tomorrow?
Great analysis (and interesting idea regarding large funds recently raised by accelerators, etc.).

However, if the implication is that this situation is even somewhat common--your analysis doesn't match the data.

If you look at Fenwick's VC Survey on Unicorn Financings[1], a paltry 5% involve participating preferred while even less (3%) involve multiple liquidation preferences.

Has OP identified a possible strategy to "fudge" one's way to a Unicorn valuation? You bet.

Are many companies using this strategy? Absolutely not.

[1] https://www.fenwick.com/publications/Pages/The-Terms-Behind-...

hobbyjogger··on Atlassian files for IPO
The prices on Page 10 (I actually see similar but slightly different numbers, the document may have been updated) are weighted-average exercise prices for all outstanding options. Since many of those options would have been issued years ago (presumably with low strike prices) the average option price bears little relationship to the IPO price (which we won't know until the IPO is priced by the underwriters--note the blanks throughout).
hobbyjogger··on For the First Time, a Prosecutor Will Go to Jail for Wrongfully Convicting
1. It doesn't tell you at all that you "must" accept a plea bargain. It very well may tell you that you should bluff and proceed to trial so the prosecutor will drop your case in order to preserve his conviction rate.

2. Again, the metric is too coarse. It's not a random representative sampling of all accused criminals who make it through a full trial - the prosecution is like a football team that has the power to call off the match at any point up until the last minute if it looks like they might lose. We shouldn't be surprised that they tend to win when they choose not to do so.

3. This is well-studied and very intuitive: the more serious (and newsworthy) the charges, the more personal and political pressure to pursue a case, even a marginal one. You don't consider this possibility when speculating why federal courts have lower conviction rates.

4. A bargain requires both sides to give something up - if the prosecutor would only let you plea to the charge/punishment he thinks you'd get at trial no ones would ever plead out!

hobbyjogger··on For the First Time, a Prosecutor Will Go to Jail for Wrongfully Convicting
Sure, but again "conviction rate" is too coarse of a metric to make any meaningful conclusions about guilt/innocence or why the rate is so high.

Japan, for example, has a 99% conviction rate but Ramseyer attributes much of that to the fact that prosecution offices are so understaffed and under-resourced there that they can manage to bring only the strongest of cases.[1] So you're much better off in a place like that because if you have a marginal case you won't even have to go to trial to be acquitted--the charges will be dropped beforehand.

[1] http://legalombudsman.up.seesaa.net/image/199820Why20is20the...

hobbyjogger··on For the First Time, a Prosecutor Will Go to Jail for Wrongfully Convicting
Caveat: this study is for federal courts (which tend to see more serious crimes) but the data on acquittal rates is nowhere near what you are suggesting.

http://openscholarship.wustl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article...

55% conviction rates when tried in front of a judge, 84% conviction rates when tried in front of a jury.

Acquittal rates will also tend fall as the gravity of the charges/court falls--but a lot of that is explained by the prosecution being far more ready to drop charges (or choose not to charge at all) in close cases when the crime is seen as less serious. A marginal murder case, for example, might be pursued even though a just as marginal shoplifting case would not be.

hobbyjogger··on Pro Rata
Eh, it's really not such a big deal. Maintaining 7% in a round for 20% total only lets YC buy 1.4%. As sama said elsewhere, the difference between 20% and 18.6% (with an equivalent reduction in their $ invested) shouldn't change much for a serious VC.

Given YC's history and reputation of being very supportive of founders, any founding team is also probably better off with YC taking a cut in a round that would otherwise go to another investor, especially given that the list of investors who are as founder-friendly as YC is pretty short.

hobbyjogger··on Pro Rata
It depends on how the YC pro rata rights are documented. It's entirely possible that their pro rata right will be completely independent of any later pro rata right for major investors (i.e., the major Series A investors might get their pro rata rights in addition to the continuing YC pro rata).

That blog post is helpful but not the best source of info. For one, it confuses preemptive rights (right to buy a % of future financing) with first refusal rights (right to buy shares from other current stockholders who try to sell). And second, it's rather one-sided. Companies understandably want to limit these rights to only big investors for a number of reasons but especially because (1) it really can be expensive/time consuming to continually contact or chase down signatures from an investor base that eventually might include dozens of people/entities, (2) it can make it really hard to convince new investors that the investment will be worthwhile when there are pro rata rights to buy up a huge chunk of the round and (3) there's a major signalling problem when the prior angels have these rights but choose not to use them (the author mentions that he always demands these rights but doesn't always use them, which can scare off other investors and, what's worse, many angels will decline for innocuous reasons such as a seed-stage only investor who never does follow-ons or a smaller angel who is priced out by a high valuation).

hobbyjogger··on Pro Rata
Your dollar value should actually increase (assuming we're not talking down rounds). You still have the same amount of shares, but an "up round" means that each share is now theoretically worth more than it was when you bought in. Practically, however, it's hard to put a true "value" on the shares until an actual sale of the Company or IPO.
hobbyjogger··on YC startups that are hiring
Good discussion of this little logic puzzle here:

https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/76491/multiple-choi...

hobbyjogger··on How to Word a Profit Sharing Agreement
Yep. So can corporations (at least in DE). Check out Delaware Gen. Corporate Law § 122:

"Every corporation created under this chapter shall have power to:

...

(15) Pay pensions and establish and carry out pension, _profit sharing_, stock option, stock purchase, stock bonus, retirement, benefit, incentive and compensation plans, trusts and provisions for any or all of its directors, officers and employees, and for any or all of the directors, officers and employees of its subsidiaries

...

http://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc02/index.shtml

hobbyjogger··on Supreme Court denies review of Google v. Oracle API copyright case [pdf]
Here's what the project's executive director has to say on the matter[1]:

"One technical problem with Computational Law, familiar to many individual with legal training, is due to the open texture of laws. Consider a municipal regulation stating "No vehicles in the park". On first blush this is fine, but it is really quite problematic. Just what constitutes a vehicle? Is a bicycle a vehicle? What about a skateboard? How about roller skates? What about a baby stroller? A horse? A repair vehicle? For that matter, what is the park? At what altitude does it end? If a helicopter hovers at 10 feet, is that a violation? What if it flies over at 100 feet?

The resolution of this problem is to limit the application of Computational Law to those cases where such issues can be externalized or marginalized. We allow human users to make judgments about such open texture concepts in entering data or we avoid regulatory applications where such concepts abound.

A different sort of challenge to Computational Law stems from the fact that not all legal reasoning is deductive. Edwina Rissland [Rissland et al.] notes that, "Law is not a matter of simply applying rules to facts via modus ponens"; and, when regarding the broad application of AI techniques to law, this is certainly true. The rules that apply to a real-world situation, as well as even the facts themselves, may be open to interpretation, and many legal decisions are made through case-based reasoning, bypassing explicit reasoning about laws and statutes. The general problem of open texture when interpreting rules, along with the parallel problem of running out of rules to apply when resolving terms, presents significant obstacles to implementable automated rule-based reasoning."

[1] http://logic.stanford.edu/complaw/complaw.html

hobbyjogger··on The performance and physics of the fish kick
Fosbury flop, mediocre example. High jump was a relatively new sport (~a century vs. humans swimming for 20,000 years) and his technique was only made possible by the then-recent addition of a very soft and raised landing pad. The Fosbury Flop wasn't really an option before that, when you tended to land on dirt 6 or 7 feet below the bar.[1]

Cliff Young, bad example. Young won because no one had ever done a race that long before (that was the first year) and the other competitors slept way too much. Once everyone else caught on the next year, Young never won the race again.[1] The "Young Shuffle" had little to do with it and is definitively not "transformative" or even used by any modern elite distance runners. In fact, the "Young Shuffle" is how anyone runs if forced to slow down to walking pace -- you can watch the "Young Shuffle" live anywhere you can find some elderly hobby joggers out for a cruise.[3]

[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/07/1912_Kon...

[2] http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/11/07/1068013394824.h...

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OD96zocXRU

hobbyjogger··on Same-Sex Marriage Is a Right, Supreme Court Rules
In an odd way, your constitutional amendment (b) would outlaw marriage altogether.

When you have an inalienable right to something, you can't bargain that right away through contract.[1] An inalienable right to define who is family would make it impossible for anyone to enter a "contract" for an exclusive relationship (which alienates your right to marry others you want to have in your family).

You couldn't get married (at least as that term is used now) any more than you can enter a contract to become a slave.

[1] http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Inalienable+ri...

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →