HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

horsawlarway

11,569 karma · joined May 23, 2017

submissionscomments
horsawlarway··on The AI bubble is popping; we just don't know it yet
Even if we agree with this take (and I do think it's a likely take that you're right on the long term), it doesn't change that it seems likely we're in a bubble, and it probably will pop.

We see a similar paradigm with lots of revolutionary technology. The initial promise is high, people get very excited, lots of money pours in, and.... 15-30 years go by before we start seeing real impact across the economy at large.

It's just a real slog to actually implement and roll out new tech.

So take robots: I can promise you that you won't see robotics in every household in the next decade (especially so if we exclude the current market of robot vacuums). Even if a company makes an incredibly capable robot "today" (and to be clear - they are not) it won't have time to scale out production, reduce costs, generate a used market that's accessible to less wealthy consumers, deal with regulatory hurdles and quality problems that only pop up in real-world usage, etc...

It's just slower than you're implying.

The change very well will happen (I'm inclined to agree that things are going to shift). That doesn't mean that the current investment is sane and will pay off.

So many historical examples of this, just two here real quick:

- Ford built his first automobile in 1896, founded a company in 1901, went out of business, got sued by ALAM, didn't build more than 10k Model T's until 1910, then only finally hit real scale (of low hundred of thousands of units) in 1913: More than a decade to "basic scale". Household ownership didn't hit 60% until 1929... 30+ years later.

- The initial web enthusiasm, followed by the dot-com crash in early 2000s...

horsawlarway··on We Gave GPT 5.6 Sol a Real Business. It Lied, Spammed, and Lost $447
If you read the full post, I'm not actually sure I agree with the title.

Personally - if I were judging... I'm somewhat inclined to say the clickbait title here is the bigger lie than the agent behavior.

To recap:

1. It didn't lose $447. It spent $99.50 to perform a user feedback study using a testing service. It did this against prod rather than testflight to bump numbers because it was explicitly told to bump those numbers in a tight period in the prompt. It did this after exhausting a large number of alternatives. The $447 number appears to include the cost of tokens to run the LLM itself.

2. It didn't lie. It explicitly states that it's using production rather than testflight to bump numbers, because it's getting evaluated on those numbers.

3. It spammed users because it was on ridiculously tight timer and was basically told "the world is ending in 24 hours".

Frankly... I'm more annoyed at the posters than the bot.

horsawlarway··on The iPhone Upgrade Program is being replaced by Apple Upgrade
Since you asked... Tools.

I buy more tools than I should - Wood working, electronic, and more general purpose. It's not always cost effective, but I generally pick a new project (ex - making my dining room table, installing solar panels, building my own dining room chairs, making my wedding ring, etc) and then buy a new tool for that project.

Am I saving money vs just buying a decent premade thing? Usually not really (although sometimes!). But I get to learn, work with my hands, and expand capabilities, and feel nice having made a thing.

I can get a lot of tools (or a couple very nice tools) for the amount you'd spend on a new iphone.

Since we're having the conversation - I'll make a value judgement. I think more folks would be happier with the tools than a new iphone, and I think buying one every 2 years is a perfect example of "keeping up with the jones" style behavior - compulsive consumerism that's not improving happiness (With an understanding that there are exceptions - ex: if you develop mobile applications, I'll accept that a new iphone is essentially a new tool).

horsawlarway··on Handbook.md shows that long policy documents do not reliably govern agents
I'm not the above poster, but my experiences generally line up with theirs.

The first 20% of context is usually very solid. Agent stays on task, is responsive and focused on the original goal.

The last 20% of context is usually pretty bad. Agent tends to loop, repeat, drift away into sub-goals (or non-goals).

The middle 60% is a bit of a grab-bag. Sometimes it's fine, sometimes it's not. It varies by task, prompt, and luck.

The above 25% and 50% limits seem like reasonable and simple rules to keep agents in the productive zones of usage.

It's generally not worth doing extensive testing to try to find your exact threshold unless you're running exactly the same prompt at scale, on similar data.

If you are in that spot, I won't actually recommend langchain tooling (I've been somewhat frustrated with it) but I think the concepts are worth understanding.

You can do something like https://docs.langchain.com/oss/python/langchain/test/evals. Trajectory evals in particular seem to suffer as context length grows (https://docs.langchain.com/oss/python/langchain/test/evals#t...).

I've used this for testing an agent that handles provisioning and permissions for developers with SaaS tooling (ex - if a developer asks, go provision an account [saml/oauth/etc] with the 3rd party, configure access, and let them know how to use it).

I'm about 6 months out of date at this point, so I won't speak for the latest models, but what was available early this year absolutely suffers from extended context lengths.

horsawlarway··on KOReader
I find this is mostly just a "mindset" difference.

OSS software aligns mentally with "tool". It only exists because someone had a problem to solve, and they wanted a tool to solve it. Generally, people should expect to have to learn how to use tools. Then they solve their problem and move on. It takes effort, and the result is mastery which gives you new capabilities.

Consumer software (and especially anything ad supported or social media adjacent, and sadly in many respects, lots of modern SaaS companies) want to be as glitzy and smooth as possible, but they don't actually want you to solve your problem. Instead they'd really prefer that you simply spend as much time looking at their software as possible. So the experience can be quite pleasant, it feels nice, things feel obvious, you get the dopamine hits quick and fast. But after a while you realize you aren't actually all that productive (or even productive at all) when engaging with them. Because the goal of this software isn't to help you solve your problem. The goal is to keep your attention and extract your money. If it happens to solve your problem... sometimes that's fine, sometimes that's actually counter to the primary mission of extracting your time and money.

horsawlarway··on The iPhone Upgrade Program is being replaced by Apple Upgrade
I don't understand this mindset. I get that people who are going to upgrade to the latest flagship phone every 18-24 months will probably do better with this, but realistically... those people are fucking insanely financially irresponsible (and if you can afford it - no shade, I guess, its your money - lord knows I burn lots of cash on hobby projects of my own, although I tend to buy things that are actually projects, and not just glitz...)

But there's just nothing to run on phones built in the last 5+ years that actually puts the hardware through its paces (in the phone form factor, laptops and desktops I'd be lot more forgiving on). The cameras aren't really getting better. The battery capacities seem to be mostly "the same". There's just no practical "reason" to justify the expense at this point (and I'll fully acknowledge this wasn't always the case - there was a period there in the early 2010s where phones were getting better rapidly and upgrading was a big deal).

They're basically buying an expensive piece of jewelry that they'll throw away in 24 months. Like... just buy a cheaper model and get some real jewelry. At least that could be passed down at some point instead of becoming e-waste.

horsawlarway··on How to survive boiling water
This would be my read.

Hell - my children just this year would have counted for 10+ doses (my daughter 6 all by herself for a series of severe ear infections).

horsawlarway··on Our position on open-weights models
> That pales in comparison to how many people unaligned AI will hurt.

Under what argument? In which scenarios? Basically - bullshit. I'm calling bullshit on this argument.

It's easy to hurt people already. The "difficulty" of doing it isn't what's stopping this behavior.

So claiming that we should reform society into a techno-feudal dystopia where the playing field is literally intentionally not level, and "you aren't allowed to compete (and maybe not exist)" is a great way to push more people into the "I'd like to go hurt people" camp.

You are self-prophesying your own fears into existence by acting like you're an incorruptible beacon of good judgement - while subjugating others to your control. That's a system I'd argue should be broken.

horsawlarway··on Our position on open-weights models
It takes an astoundingly small amount of effort to buy an automatic weapon in the US and go hurt people.

Or to buy materials to make an explosive device and hurt people.

Frankly, even with AI those are both comically easier than the idea that a person can create something malicious in a lab environment.

And if someone wanted to go that route... There are boat loads of commercially available toxins and poisons.

The goal shouldn't be to neuter exploration and learning. The goal is not to be a fucking hellscape of a society where people want to act like that.

Your argument leads further down the hellscape path.

horsawlarway··on Judge Rejects Google's Attempt to DMCA Its Way Out of Being Scraped
I'm vaguely sympathetic to this argument.

But only vaguely. Google uses its monopoly position in advertising to basically ensure that you allow them to scrape your site (or if not you personally, the majority of revenue driving sites). They have the benefit of being allowed by default.

They also then scrape again at the user level for users operating chrome.

They also conveniently ignore global blocks for their adsbots (you have to specifically name them to block them).

If you're not Google, you likely don't have this luxury.

My preference would be that governments force search indexes to be public. The exact mechanisms for this can be debated.

horsawlarway··on Kimi-K3 on HuggingFace
I don't think the goal of this data is necessarily model improvement.

I think it's marketing, advertising, and product refinement.

Ex: all the things Google wants your search data for.

It's somewhat silly to think the value of that data has changed much. Advertisers want to know what's popular and getting clicks and attention. Competitors want to know what features are getting used in their markets.

In the simplest case, think of this data as improving the harness, not the model.

horsawlarway··on The New AI Superpowers: Focus and Followthrough
Two things.

1. Deps are an organizational hassle. They need review, get flagged as security and legal risks, and (mostly incorrectly imo) have been somewhat tarnished by the idea that deps are all just "leftpad" - simple things that are over abstracted. This is the "incorrect" argument that I don't really think should carry much weight, but often does win the discussion internally in organizations.

2. Deps can be misaligned with your precise needs, and you often end up "owning" them anyways the second you patch/fork/modify it in any way. This one is legit. It's a real thing that happens and is painful. Sometimes being honest that you should just be responsible for the thing in the first place is the right call. This one I buy as an argument, but it just doesn't apply to that many deps.

But the combination of the two makes larger organizations somewhat adverse to dependencies on average.

horsawlarway··on Cursor Bridge – Run Unlimited Claude Code on Your Cursor Subscription
Personally - I think this cuts both ways.

Things sold as "unlimited" are often much more expensive for the average user than proper rate based billing would be (see - mobile data, internet data in general, those soft drinks [incl a couple refills] etc...)

It's "nice" in that neither party explicitly needs to track usage (although to your point, the company almost always does actually monitor and track), and it can alleviate billing anxiety. But... I'm at the spot where I'd rather things like internet, phone, tokens, etc just cost their damn cost (ex - bill me at the actual costs your company incurs to provide the service, plus some markup).

horsawlarway··on The front end framework for correctness: built on Effect, architected like Elm
Agreed - I hit "Reset after 2 seconds", I hit "Add 1", and sure - it adds one, but it also unexpectedly cancels the reset.

Which I don't expect from the description, and I also don't expect from the code.

---

So outside of the simple "This is broken..." feedback, I want to further pick on this example:

Don't fucking hide the imports.

Especially don't fucking hide the imports if you're showing example code, and you're doing things like

```

import { Match as M, Schema as S } from 'effect'

import { m } from 'foldkit/message'

```

Which I only know because I bothered to dig through the example playground counter (which is a different example entirely!)

It's a huge issue to show demo code where concepts magically appear, and it's just bad manners to use shorthand at the same time.

horsawlarway··on Worse on Purpose – How Corporate Greed Killed Product Quality
I think this is the wrong take.

If this was really the truth, the brand names wouldn't matter. But instead the brand ends up as the sole desirable target in the corporate sales.

I think the more likely answer is that being an expert judge on a product's quality is just very hard.

More so when you have to buy it before you can use it.

So people tend to trust brands they've had good experiences with, or heard others having good experiences with.

The greed here is in leveraging that trust to sell a shitty updated version of the product.

horsawlarway··on Jack Dorsey launches Buzz to combine team chat, AI agents and Git hosting
If you can point me at any actual data that Saas companies are more like to be abandonware if AI is used... sure.

But my experience with startups is that the odds are great they're ALL going to be abandonware in a couple years.

Ex - 50% of every company started is out of business in 5 years.

horsawlarway··on OpenAI and Hugging Face address security incident during model evaluation
They specifically call out credentials used during the attack.

But they should be rotating those regardless. You don't get to say "Maybe the attacker didn't get this credential". You just rotate.

The most generous interpretation is that they have not yet have completed that rotation, and they didn't want to risk putting those credentials into the wild during that process.

---

But all of that aside, I feel like the undercurrent of this comment is that the "safety" rules that providers are pushing are genuinely harmful.

Another point where "if you don't own the model, you can't properly operate the tool" becomes true. Open isn't about profits, it's about capabilities.

horsawlarway··on Jack Dorsey launches Buzz to combine team chat, AI agents and Git hosting
I find this thought process somewhat faulty given that the vast majority of software ends up in that spot regardless.

Hard to take this as that big a deal when Google literally launched a product along similar social themes named "Google Buzz" which lasted all of like 16 months in 2010, well before agents and llms.

Either the project will find a fit, or it won't - and code quality doesn't have all that much to do with it existing in 2 years (some - but not as much as engineers want to believe).

horsawlarway··on Who's afraid of Chinese models?
Or even similar ideological goals... (See: grok)
horsawlarway··on The state of open source AI
in what context, and at what ROI?

Because... I have use-cases where this is true, and use-cases where this falls flat on its face.

I don't actually think it's obvious (at all, really) without defining what "superior" means.

In the same way that I don't think it's obvious that a plane is superior to a car, or a boat, or a bike.

They each do things the others don't, and excel in different spaces.

horsawlarway··on Measuring Input Latency on Linux: X11 vs. Wayland, VRR, and DXVK
ping is going to dominate over 3ms in pretty much every situation.

And the non-xwayland numbers are all within a single ms of each other.

---

Not to undermine the measurements of the author (agree with you, it's a cool effort), but my read is that this was basically proof that it doesn't matter.

horsawlarway··on Are we offloading too much of our thinking to AI?
while I understand this argument - I think it consistently falls down when compared to the types of content that are generally purchased and consumed.

I'd argue that most folks get plenty of value from the content itself, entirely separate from the intent, context, or even existence of the author.

I don't care about the motivations of the director to enjoy an action movie. I don't care about the life history of the author to enjoy a good fiction.

I think there is (and should be) space for content where people care, but I'd suggest it's the fringes (ex - majority of music is production grade pop, not meaningful songs, majority of books sales are erotic fiction, etc).

horsawlarway··on Are we offloading too much of our thinking to AI?
Generally speaking - I agree with you. Source bias is a real logical fallacy, and failing to evaluate the content itself, regardless of the source, is a problematic view of the world.

In the same way that I don't need the lumber in my house "hand sawed" for it to achieve my goal of creating a habitable space.

---

But more broadly, I do think there's space to at least question the use and role of AI.

Because while content can (and should) be addressed directly, there's a valid meta-conversation about the intent of producing content, and the results producing that content might have.

What goal does producing this content achieve?

What is the role of this content in society?

Is this content, on this scale, an appropriate thing to be making?

These are MUCH harder questions - often because we've shifted from concrete (content) to abstract (value judgements).

To go back to my housing analogy: We're no longer evaluating the benefits of hand-sawed vs power sawed timber. We're discussing whether our housing is built in the right spots, if we're building enough of it, and are we allocating it in the right ways.

horsawlarway··on You're Not a Better Engineer Because You Type Git Commands by Hand
It somewhat boggles my mind that there are an incredible number of persistent, useless, and annoying comments on here every day accusing any and every article of being AI slop.

AI is a machine that generates content that is supposed to be statistically identical to the content that it was trained on, and it's trained on the content posted here.

The content here will look like AI generated content, and the AI generated content will look like the content here. By fucking definition.

---

Instead we get a bunch of pseudo-intellectual, hokey about how "my AI radar is perfect!" and "I can always spot it because of [insert bullshit about detecting style that's semantically the same as the pre-existing stuff]".

It's just... exhausting.

Yes - there is a lot of AI content on here. Just like there were a bunch of (and still are) under whelming marketing articles on here. Just like there's STILL a bunch of interesting and engaging articles (some of them even written by AI!).

Just vote based on the content and move on with your lives.

People out here wasting time and energy on trying to burn witches. If you want a "sure-fire" AI free experience... Go talk to a real person, in person. Otherwise...

horsawlarway··on TypeScript 7
> but still it was obviously the right way to go compared to JS or, god forbid, shell.

I just don't think this is true.

Frankly - it's hard to argue this at all (even today) given that JS is the dominate language on the planet, and it lacks types... as does python, which had a reputation for decades as THE language to use to teach new folks to code. Or take PHP which dominated server development for a LOOONG time: also lacks types. Ruby on Rails has a wonderful reputation as the "get shit done" framework: no types.

Types are good for modern software companies, where code size has ballooned up very high (common to work on a codebase with hundreds of thousands of lines) or teams are large (50+ developers) and terrible if you just want to hammer out something that works as a solo dev.

Do I like types today? Sure - the tooling is solid, and I work on large codebases with large teams.

Did I like types as a solo dev at 3 person startup? no.

horsawlarway··on TypeScript 7
Look at some of the typing present in MS COM back in the IE5/6 days and we can discuss more. I can honestly tell you - I'll take untyped languages any day of the week over that clusterfuck.

Personally - I also think people really underestimate just how much the tooling around types has improved over the last 20 years.

If I'm having to try to look up the difference between iBrowserInterface6 and iBrowserInterface5 and iBrowserInterface4... (and yes - shit like this really did exist: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/api/shdeprec...)

And I have no tooling for autocomplete, and the docs are shoddy, and google is just coming on the scene...

People understandable want to throw their computer out the window.

Types are great. Some forms of them were not.

horsawlarway··on Monetization Gateway: Charge for any resource behind Cloudflare via x402
I'm going to poke at a downstream consequence here.

Lets say this catches on (in some form or another, whether in this precise implementation or not).

So assume we have a world where resources can be gated by a payment wall that agents can interact with.

I'm also assuming that world continues to have agents that are majority hosted and run by 3rd parties (ex - google/anthropic/openai/xai/etc).

---

At what point can I sue these companies for obviously failing to act in my interests?

Because that's the clear next step here.

Basically - where is the fiduciary duty that I would require for a real working relationship?

Because otherwise these agents can and will prefer to access payment gated resources that have financial relationships with their operators or developers.

horsawlarway··on Looking Ahead to Postgres 19
These comments are worse than the slop.
horsawlarway··on Tidal AI Policy
Real question, have you actually used any of the llm based media generation tooling?

Because "load samples, arrange them, and instruct it to do a thing" are basically the required steps.

Arguably, if you don't care much about the result, you can skip loading samples.

> You still have to... write the music.

When? When you load up other folk's samples? When you press a play button? When you arrange other folk's samples?

It's a recording device that plays samples. It doesn't give a flying flip about who wrote them.

You might choose to write samples, lots of people using them don't.

horsawlarway··on Tidal AI Policy
Frankly, this is also how I mostly listen to music - I set a song or two I like, then I let auto-discovery keep adding to the list.

If I happen to like it, I hit thumbs up/like. Otherwise I ignore it.

I sometimes go through and browse musicians, mainly to see if they have other songs I might like, but generally speaking... it's not high on my list of priorities. Then again, I don't give a shit about the "pop" aspect of music at all. It's mainly background noise I put on while doing something else.

---

As an aside:

> I also think it’s an entirely false equivalence to say using electronic instruments are like AI music tools. Very different things – an electric guitar doesn’t play music by itself. It’s still a tool at the end of the day.

I think this is where it gets weird, and I think you're pretty solidly incorrect here. Samplers and grooveboxes absolutely play music by themselves. I think there's also a weird world where things like "Girl Talk" are somewhat spiritual successors to AI music...

Ex - I definitely love girl talk, and I'm not in any way implying that those albums don't take skill and taste, but he's literally just playing samples of other artists. If that's real music (and I'd argue strongly that it IS real music) then I think I struggle to rule out AI generated songs that are edited by someone (and if you've used this tooling, it still requires lots of editing).

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →