HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hotdogscout

268 karma · joined July 7, 2023

I'm tall
submissionscomments
hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
>1

I'll need to look at data on that before conceding or disagreeing. (Not your job I'll look later)

>the people organising or allowing the events in the first place are the one in charge

How come? If I go to a town square to speak and I get lynched, am I the one in power because I organized my speech?

You're extrapolating a lot of power from being able to allocate time in a anphitheater from the University.

>3

Sure but it's been some years since leftism has been the worst offender when it comes to harassment in universities. I very much am against when it is the right doing the harassment (Dylan Mulvaney comes to mind).

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I was talking about "and the 2023 Whitworth University disinvitation of Xi Van Fleet, a Chinese dissident who grew up during Mao’s Cultural Revolution."

The comment claimed only the most vile ideas get deplatformed and a lot of the examples in that article cite people that are not vile but inconvenient to the left.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
I don't think they're equivalent on the west (why is it relevant?) but I do think you're softening a lot the harm of the academic example because the violence against the speaker is just the tip of the iceberg. If a victim of socialist violence can't speak, can you acknowledge that phenomenon in that institution? Will grants or even studies that acknowledge that socialist state violence be taboo when recruiting students and researchers?

Corrupting an institution that's (unfairly) used as the arbiter for scientific truth is not insignificant.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
This is a loaded question and I can't see how it's related.

A victim of Maoist violence was deplatformed by socialist students. Do victims of socialist governments represent such an abhorrent ideology?

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
That's a far cry from the context he painted. Socialists were absolutely not under that kind of violent lynching level of abuse and it was quite the opposite in Academia.

[Just to be clear, did not know about Red Summer and I concede that point.]

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
different spaces have different harassment problems.

Academia can have an extreme concentration of leftist dogmatism while political society can have a far right one. Both can happen at the same time in different communities.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
A victim of Maoist violence represents an "ugly hateful ideology"? This shunning bar has been moved from fascists for some years.
hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
Implying?
hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
>some deplatforming attempts are themselves an exercise of free speech, where people who feel excluded from the platform are trying to rebalance the debate by asking that we stop focusing on debunked theories.

Bizarre paradox where a group is disenfranchised enough in academia it needs to protest dissent yet it can consistently expel people from it for disagreeing.

hotdogscout··on Campus free speech was in trouble in 2018, and the data shows worsening
In 1924? What?

Socialism was extremely popular in academia during that period. The US had the Espionage Act but I cannot think anywhere the stoning of socialists would happen, let alone in academia.

Stoning black people was never a thing as far as I know. Do you have any pointers?

hotdogscout··on House passes bill to force TikTok sale from Chinese owner or ban the app
Considering Israel also has horrible videos of egregious violence being committed at them by Palestinians it's concerning that you don't think that's grounds for propaganda or manipulation.
hotdogscout··on BYD launches cheaper Seagull EV with $9,700 starting price tag
I'm sorry but you have no grounds to claim you know Chinese people's political outlook based on a visit.

Mainland China is still cut off from knowing a big chunk of human thought. Realism - the school of thought you're describing - is the Marxist mode in a place you can't vocally disagree without serious consequences. No wonder it's what you heard.

hotdogscout··on IBM and NASA build language models to make scientific knowledge more accessible
Peer review isn't all that and a lot of subjects are censored and even disinformation is accepted if it flatters the ideological inclinations of the publication. See: Proximal Origins from Nature
hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
>half of them make less than 22k euros a year

I'd be extremely happy making this amount. Some people are just accustomed to easier lives.

>while some code monkey makes 300k+/year coding memeojis at apple.

Meme position for a privileged caste statistically irrespective of skill in an institution that can piss money on anything and still succeed.

hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
Yes you missed retail, read it again.

https://uk.indeed.com/career/warehouse-worker/salaries

Do you really need me to Google every single essential position known before conceding that society is not maintained by minimum wage workers?

hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
Essential and non-replaceable are different concepts.
hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
Not all of the work you cited is essential. Would society crumble without retail?

Minimum wage in Spain is significantly more money than anything I've made in my life. It's a very comfortable position for the vast majority of the world.

>There is a lot of low skilled labor that goes into making what we eat today. I'm not sure how you could possibly claim that none of those people are on minimum wage.

People doing essential work that isn't trivially replaceable have the bargaining power to charge more than the minimum wage in a moderately free market of human work, usually they do.

hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
Are any of the positions you cited minimum wage workers where you live? Again, assuming US:

https://money.cnn.com/2016/02/24/news/economy/trash-workers-...

https://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/garbage-collector...

>You could delete facebook, openai, instagram, twitter, netflix, tesla and 90% of startups from the face of the earth right now and I'd have the exact same life as yesterday. Remove any of the people I mentioned above and society would crumble in no time

Yes because you picked non-essential work. (?)

hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
Also not true, I know the big farms of my state and they don't depend on minimum wage workers and I live in a third world country.

I doubt agricultural wages or truck drivers are minimum wage jobs where you live. Assuming US https://www.nass.usda.gov/Charts_and_Maps/Farm_Labor/fl_allw...

hotdogscout··on OpenAI – transformer debugger release
>I think the HN crowd forgets that what really runs the world are min wage workers running around and doing real world things, not code monkeys and glorified type writers filling excel sheets.

This is not true at all. How many products do you use that come primarily from minimum wage workers?

If a few people responsible for Google maps running stopped working the GDP loss would be much bigger than if magnitudes more minimum wage workers did the same.

hotdogscout··on Sora AI Can Enhance Chatbots
Ad
hotdogscout··on Google to pause Gemini image generation of people after issues
The fact they have so many upvotes on blatant bigotry... and people say this forums moderation (or tech) doesn't have an issue of leftist radicalism.

What happened to treat others like you'd like to be treated?

hotdogscout··on Google to pause Gemini image generation of people after issues
I don't know what kind of damage you developed to wish harm on others based on their race or gender but you are a horrible person.
hotdogscout··on Scientists discover underlying cause of "brain fog" linked with Long Covid
Oof.

I quickly skimmed the article. Any chance of treatment?

hotdogscout··on Google to pause Gemini image generation of people after issues
It's almost like the "socialism" part of "national socialism" was not in fact irrelevant. See: Ba'aathism.
hotdogscout··on Scientists discover underlying cause of "brain fog" linked with Long Covid
I thought my blood brain barrier was faulty because of COVID but this makes sense too
hotdogscout··on The Far Right's Favorite Web Host Has a Shadowy New Owner
I'm not American or live in a western country. I wish I did.

I don't agree I have more in common with a BLM protesters than someone from China or Eastern Europe. That's probably true for most people on these samples but surely not all.

I despise the Chinese government. I despise most Eastern European governments, I don't know them all by heart. A lot of people under their governments do too.

I agree with your ideals, those should be the rule, but they aren't. It's been quite some time since Obama's "when they go low we go high".

I agree talking on the internet is mostly a mistake.

hotdogscout··on The Far Right's Favorite Web Host Has a Shadowy New Owner
I care because it's been increasingly impossible to say these "oddballs" are being extremely shitty people and should stop. The message they get and the message they have been getting is they are "agents of change". There has been a few terrorist events with this kind of radicalism (Audrey Hale being the worst case) but the left is still allergic to criticizing this. Just how bad do things need to get?

I agree the republican party is worse than democrats. I'm not American, I don't live in a first world country but I would vote for them. I think electing Trump was horrible.

I don't think Bernie is an antisemite, I think the people on the left who hate Bernie for having empathy for kidnapped, tortured Israelis are, of which there are many.

Gamergate and the alt right were fringe until Trump. The media and culture moved at a glacial pace before it started seeing them as a problem. Will we see the same thing happen on the left? A president that supports terrorism and violence against the "opressor" race and talks of guillotines? I think that's an improbable nightmare scenario but so was Trump at gamergate times.

Again you went from "this never happens" to "of course it sometimes happens, but it doesn't matter".

All Ivy League representatives in congress calling defending the eradication of Jews not hate speech?

No instance of antisemitism on the left at all?

This is why I'm suspicious of oddballs not mattering. They don't matter until they do and when they do they're correct and me and others are being insane.

This boundary pushing of violence and bigotry is exactly how we got Trump and I really wish there was only one group of stupid violent demogogues running around to deal with, not two.

hotdogscout··on The Far Right's Favorite Web Host Has a Shadowy New Owner
Most recent one I could find:

School board member claims on twitter whites are more dangerous than animals and is hailed by some as "an agent of change".

https://www.mlive.com/news/jackson/2023/01/whiteness-remarks...

I've been a part of leftist circles since 2012, I envy that you can go by without seeing this stuff.

Again, on mainstream social media.

hotdogscout··on The Far Right's Favorite Web Host Has a Shadowy New Owner
Whites deserve violent retribution for slavery discourse. Cultural appropriation. Denial of bad things done under socialist governments or those useful for the left. Race traitor discourse (if you're a racial minority but don't subscribe to radicalism). Discourse of whites being genetically inferior. Apology and support for racially motivated terrorism against white people. Virulent antisemitism.
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →