That doesn’t mean that modern society has nothing to learn from its antecedents, though.
182 karma · joined July 6, 2021
That doesn’t mean that modern society has nothing to learn from its antecedents, though.
People are trying to interpret the analogy outside of the theological context in which Chesterton wrote, and therefore either reduce it to the kind of relativistic conservatism that GP rightly decries, or else deny what Chesterton actually wrote.
Chesterton’s point is that change can be good or destructive. Since evil is not a positively existing thing, but merely a lack of goodness, a lower goodness mistaken for a higher goodness, or vice versa, if I am to act upon something in order to bring it to its full goodness, I have to understand the goodness already in it, otherwise I act in a way that is destructive. In short, I can only be trusted to change a thing if I am able to love it.
The Mayans were very gifted astronomers, and built their temples such that the sun would shine exactly through a small portal at the top of the temple on the equinoxes. Christian basilicas and Jewish temples had similar timekeeping functions.
The Greek and Roman pagans saw time as turbulent and cyclical, subject to the caprice of the gods.
The pre-modern, Christian worldview saw time as a story with a beginning, a middle, and an end, but also as a vertically-structured fractal of cycles within cycles, and our orientation within was ascending upwards to an eternity outside time and space.
The Protestant fathers saw the linear progression of time forwards towards salvation as the true content of the gospel — that our orientation is forwards, towards the future.
Some Maori saw our orientation in time as backwards, that we walk with our back towards the impenetrable future, with the past visible in front of us.
None of these, however, saw time as an infinitely critiqueable, totally relative social construct with no given reality outside of humanly mutable, intersubjective power relations. This makes the author of the article, in my sincere opinion, the “whitest” of them all.
One area of commonality is that we both believe that society is natural. I’ve already mentioned Book II of Suarez’ Against the Errors of the Anglican Sect in this thread. Anarchists who read it will find it, in turns, dazzlingly profound and infuriating, yet astonishingly satisfying as a whole (just as I do with Graeber).
A second area of commonality is that we both believe in a horizon beyond politics. Graeber is especially good about this. For him, anarchism is an interior disposition — a mode of being — prior to any political program. He therefore avoids the infallible symptom of political atheism, the absolutization of politics. His books are about human life, and in particular about how politics can take place within life, rather than life taking place within politics. The intellectually fearless anarchist can read Andrew Willard Jones’ Before Church and State, and see the commonalities.
As for substantive content of dialogue, the anarchist can help the Catholic to see instances where the Church has, in practice, confused the eternal, Divine order for a particular, temporal order (see Pope Benedict XVI’s discourse on the temptations of Christ and the Kingdom of God in Jesus of Nazareth, Volune I for how to approach this with orthodoxy and openness). This will help the Church more authentically pursue its mission.
In turn, the Catholic can help the anarchist to resolve the power-authority distinction, which lies at the heart of the anarchists’ inability to sustain any positive ideal (see various 19th Century failures, Occupy Wall Street, and the more recent corporate co-optation of radical culture). From there, it is not hard to offer the highest authority, the Lord who stands in judgement of all Lords; sin as the universal oppressor, and oneness in the body of Christ as true freedom.
Some other texts I think we would all like:
St Cyprian of Carthage: On Almsgiving
St. Thomas Aquinas on the Universal Destination of Goods (Summa Theologica)
St. Thomas Aquinas on Distributive Justice (Summa Theologica)
Pope Francis’ Laudito Si
Anything by or about Bl. Oscar Romero
St. Augustine’s City of God
Most of Pope Benedict XVI’s scholarly work, Jesus of Nazareth already mentioned as a highlight.
I’ve changed my views about a lot of things in the last decade or so, but seeing Hobbes as something of a villain has been constant. As a secular progressive, it seemed an overly pessimistic take on the possibility of political change. Today, as a (Catholic) Christian, and also a big David Graeber fanboi (these are not as radically incompatible as they may seem), I think that the State of Nature postulate, which forms the basis of Hobbesian thought, is not justified by actual human experience.
I used it for a data visualization tool for a large wireless network and it was a joy.
Polanyi is easy. He wrote a trio of short, accessible, and engaging books outlining his ideas: Science, Faith, and Society (1946), Personal Knowledge (1958), and The Tacit Dimension (1966). He was a true polymath, and very up-to-date with psychological science of his day; I would be interested in your thoughts as a specialist.
Rosmini is hard. He was a very bad writer, and wrote very long books, all of them referring to each other, which caused him a lot of difficulties[0]. His magnum opus is Theosophy, and all of his works will eventually lead there. My first book of his was Principles of Ethics, which convinced me of the value of his work, and I’m still trying to untangle the others. If I had to summarize his idea of intuition, it would be “analogical participation of the subject in the objective order of being.” Also crucial is that this capacity is innate.
[0] You can read his biography, he was extremely controversial in his time. His work was (exhaustively) consistent with the ancient and medieval philosophy of the Church, but was absolutely devastating for a certain kind of neo-scholasticism which was the dominant mode of exposition in the Church at the time. This led those theologians to accuse him of liberalism, modernism, secularism, Deism, freemasonry, etc., and all of those groups were happy to claim that the most ambitious corpus of philosophy and theology that the Church had produced in the modern era was an endorsement of their views. Since his work is so difficult, it took a very long time for anyone to recognize that neither of these interpretations were true.
EDIT: in my view, the most rigorous examination and definition of intuition comes from Rosmini, and overlaps with that of Polanyi, but the latter is much easier.
I have a close friend who briefly flirted with (actual) extreme right wing beliefs, and has, thankfully, settled on a less warlike disposition. The question he asked, and which was never given a straight answer, was (in paraphrase), “why are others allowed to say, and even wish and will evil things upon my identity, but I am forbidden from even mild criticism of other identities, under pain of real material loss?” It is a real question, describing a real phenomenon, and since no one “respectable” could give him a straight answer, or even acknowledge the legitimacy of the question, he turned to people who did, even as they answered wrongly.
EDIT: the original essay also had a question mark at the end of the title.
I’m partial to interpretations which treat the Twentieth Century megadeaths, and subsequent rise of the contemporary, technological society as a unitary problem.
Unless you have a very compelling reason to stick with Python (e.g., dependence on its excellent data science libraries), there are almost always better choices if your project has to coordinate many things happening at once.
Is there any benefit to legalized pornography that outweighs the horror of things like this?
Does the amount of bureaucratic scaffolding and invasive surveillance by corporate and government actors required to police the boundary of consensual and non-consensual pornography leave you substantially more free than just punishing platforms which permit the dissemination of pornographic images?
Some organizations are able to accommodate people like this effectively, but the organization has to be set up for that.
EDIT: The only other engineer that I would consider a “superstar” that I have encountered was nowhere near as prolific as the person above, but had an ability to make any project go smoothly. He was technically excellent, but also had the soft skills to help people converge on good solutions and motivate people to contribute. So, N=2.
If you are open to a compelling, non-Marxist analysis of the present malaise, I would recommend the writings of Augusto Del Noce.
The past seventy years have made something of a prophet of Del Noce. He predicted, as early as the 1950s, and among other things which were — at that time — unthinkable: the fall of communism, the sexual revolution, and the global supremacy of a new stage of capitalism, which he believed would become its own, existentially suffocating form of totalitarianism.
He wasn’t magic, he just had a very logical way of thinking through the consequences of ideas. He didnt have a philosophical system, but drew heavily from Vico and Rosmini, who did. He was also influenced by his own experience with totalitarianism in the early 20th Century, where he briefly became a Catholic Communist in response to the rise of Fascism, before rejecting both. He was also conversant with modern and contemporary philosophy in a way not paralleled by other Catholic thinkers of his time, excepting Ratzinger.
If this sounds interesting, a good introduction is this book review[0], written by him shortly before his death, but after having been vindicated by the collapse of the USSR and it’s aftermath. It touches on a number of Del Nocean ideas: the suicide of the Revolution, the heterogenesis of ends, Occidentalism as ideology, Neo-Capitalism, and traditionalism as an ideological reduction of religious tradition. His books are even better — every bit as clear-eyed and unnerving as what I’ve read of Fisher, but with a glint of hope.
[0] https://churchlifejournal.nd.edu/articles/marxism-died-in-th... (don’t be put off by the cold-warrior title, I’m not sure that it’s his own).
My company recently switched from a code submission to a hackerrank type thing. As part of that switch, several engineers of different ranks (junior, contributor, senior, staff, etc.) took the quiz to benchmark the platform. My score was second-to-last, despite being the highest ranking engineer.
Otherwise, it basically lined up, so we made the switch. It’s certainly possible that I’m under qualified for my position, but I also suspect that these assessments have significant false-positives and false-negatives, the consequences of which will be hard to measure, and therefore ignored or mis-diagnosed.