HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hwbehrens

1,437 karma · joined October 10, 2019

https://behrens.dev

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens; my proof: https://keybase.io/hwbehrens/sigs/dLHJ81Px5e89QVjFDYNRo6_ogUJozHWtgGR9MK3AYQQ ]

submissionscomments
hwbehrens··on Crypto exchange AAX suspends withdrawals
The best large-scale example of Chesterton's Fence that I've seen so far.
hwbehrens··on US annual inflation declines to 7.7% in October vs. 7.9% expected
It's hard to find contemporaneous evidence, because it was apparently revealed by an internal company focus group, but here's [0] the page from the company themselves with the claim.

It wasn't revealed at all until the founder's memoirs in 2007, and it wasn't reported widely until this [1] 2014 article.

0: https://awrestaurants.com/blog/aw-third-pound-burger-fractio...

1: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/27/magazine/why-do-americans...

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: How can techies influence companies to stop implementing SMS/phone 2FA
One way that you can influence the situation is by addressing the PHB directly, in a language they understand: NIST 800-63B [0].

To reach Authenticator Assurance Level (AAL) 2, there are restrictions placed on PSTN-delivered OOB verification as described in Sec. 5.1.3.3. They explicitly state (in Sec. 5.2.10) that the validity of restricted authentication can change at any time, AND that organizations "SHALL" offer alternative MFA options that are not restricted.

Specifically: "The use of a RESTRICTED authenticator requires that the implementing organization assess, understand, and accept the risks associated with that RESTRICTED authenticator"

So now when you go to the PHB and say, the government says that we are potentially opening ourselves up to legal liability according to such-and-such document subsection whatever, you're much more likely to get allocated resources to implement alternative options. Plus, the government could potentially disallow phone-based 2FA at any time! Imagine how the board will react when they find that we didn't plan for this contingency and suddenly can't comply...

[0]: https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html

hwbehrens··on Salary Transparency
> These are two common scenarios I see:

There is a 3rd scenario that I've occasionally seen: Two employees with the same title on the same team. Employee One is unhappy because they are paid 10% less than Employee Two, despite same experience and title. Employee Two ALSO unhappy because in practice they do 50% more work than Employee One for 10% more pay.

I still don't see the parent's connection of transparency to lower pay, but there is a rich scientific literature on the concept of "Comparison is the thief of joy" -- I hypothesize that turnover rates might positively correlate with transparency because they could promote intra-team competitive feelings.

The exception would be if there were a rigid structure that you know going in, similar to how e.g. government pay scales work. Since you know going in that the only input is seniority, you won't care that exceptional work is not rewarded because that was made clear from the get-go, and if that would have bothered you you wouldn't have accepted the offer in the first place.

The natural counterargument to that is that if the only input to compensation is seniority, then there is reduced incentivization for performing "above and beyond", possibly cultivating a culture of mediocrity.

It also would promote pay equity, however, since e.g. employees' implicit biases and social conditioning would not come into play under subjective evaluations.

hwbehrens··on macOS Ventura is now available
> how is this not the default?

This is just speculation, but based on a conversation with my partner, there are two types of computer users. The first group makes use of hierarchical storage, consistent naming conventions, and other organizational tricks to give them a rough idea of where any file might be. The second group has never heard the term "file systems" and just stores everything with an arbitrary name in whatever location the originating application uses by default.

The first group would prefer to search the given directory, because the supplied context (of which folder to start the search in) drastically improves/speeds search results. The second group prefers to search the entire disk, because supplying that additional context is impossible - any file might appear anywhere.

The set intersection between the first group and "people who change their default settings" is much higher than it is with the second group. Consequently, the whole disk search is enabled by default.

Additionally, given the addition of an "All My Files" view in Finder (a feature which the first group would probably find baffling), Apple may also believe that the latter group outnumbers the former.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: HN, but for Scientists?
There are a fair number of scientists on HN actually, obviously with a bias for more computationally-heavy fields.

If you had a specific (sub-)field of science that you were looking for, you might have better luck with your search.

hwbehrens··on The rise of robots increases job insecurity and maladaptive workplace behaviors [pdf]
I think what made the parent comment "shallow" was because you didn't justify your claim with any supporting context. For example, claiming the APA has a track record of misleading claims (ideally with supporting evidence) would have added some depth to your comment. Or perhaps you feel that all academic communication is biased by misaligned incentives, who knows? The reader can't extrapolate any further discussion topics from the initial comment, and as such it does not effectively promote discussion.
hwbehrens··on The rise of robots increases job insecurity and maladaptive workplace behaviors [pdf]
I suspect that it will vary by field -- perhaps this is normal for psychology, but looking at recent accepted papers from the same journal, they mostly had 60-70 citations. Such a dramatic deviation from the "norms" of the venue is at least a yellow flag, but I would hesitate to say that it's necessarily a red one.

In CS research, this many references in a peer-reviewed work would be a red flag for me, however.

If it were an NSF grant proposal, then it would actually be fairly few -- for whatever reason grant proposals might have 300+. So, the context is very important when evaluating citation prevalence.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: Do I publish code that affects millions of wireless security cameras?
One aspect that other commenters haven't addressed is that, if you do publicly disclose, it's likely (or at least possible) that the company would close the hole and remove the functionality that you're currently using, which you might not want.

Of course, if you keep the approach private and use it for yourself, there's no guarantee that someone won't find it in the future and either exploit it or report it themselves. Do you feel comfortable having cameras in your house that could (in theory) be accessed silently by an unknown 3rd party?

hwbehrens··on Matter – Protocol to connect compatible devices and systems with one another
My kids were scared of the dark, and letting them control the bathroom and hallway lights by voice (from their cozy beds) saved me from many late-night wakeup calls.

A smart home is just a problem solver, and everyone has different problems.

hwbehrens··on Amazon’s Kindle Scribe is an E Ink tablet for reading and writing
> * why anyone would *

Just to give you some context as a counterexample, I often need to read 10-50 pages of dense, size 10, double column scientific PDFs with many graphs and figures. These documents, which are typically either A4 or letter size, look abysmal at nearly any scale <90%. Color is also regularly required to parse many graphs properly.

I use my Kindle exclusively for reading documents which are primarily lightly-formatted text (e.g. novels, textbooks, etc) but it's atrocious for PDFs. When needed, I switch to an iPad Pro that I use exclusively for reading (and annotating) these PDFs, which is likewise horrible for reading "regular" text.

hwbehrens··on Amazon’s Kindle Scribe is an E Ink tablet for reading and writing
I believe only the Kindle Oasis has physical page-turning buttons, and it (inexplicably) still uses Micro-USB. I suspect this situation is what the parent is referring to.
hwbehrens··on Ken Thompson really did launch his "trusting trust" trojan attack in real life
The readability of CMU Serif for high-density text cannot be denied.
hwbehrens··on Open Source PC That Fits in Your Pocket
Are there any devices that fit the bill of an "anti-laptop"? I despise working on tiny (<27") screens, but I often need to work both from home and from the office. Currently I have a docking station in each location and move a laptop between them. However, I never ever open the laptop or use it on battery power.

It seems silly that most of the volume and weight of the device I carry around daily are totally unused, and that most of the tradeoffs it makes are irrelevant to me, but most small desktop machines are either too large or too slow (to meet a price point, presumably?). None that I know of is designed to operate from a single Thunderbolt cable like a docked laptop can.

Does such a product exist? I understand that this is a small fraction of a fraction of a use case, and until recently connectivity options weren't really there to support such a device, but I think there is some promise in this idea.

The Framework desktop case seems to come the closest so far, but it still doesn't (I think?) address the single-cable connectivity question. There's not too much info about it on the website so I couldn't answer all my questions about it.

hwbehrens··on Outdated vs. Complete: In defense of apps that don’t need updates
> feature complete with no bugs

I suppose for simple libraries this might be possible (e.g. left-pad) but how would you know in general that something is bug-free? `units` was introduced in 1979 and is still one of the canonical examples used in automated program repair research to show that new bugs can be found even in extremely well-studied codebases.

I think people might be:

1. Implicitly assuming that all nontrivial code has bugs, and 2. Using recent commits as a signal that means, "If I ran into a bug, there is someone who might fix it (or at least accept a fix PR) to take away my immediate pain.

hwbehrens··on Mcmaster.com is the best e-commerce site I've ever used
> there's no brand or product selection decisions

> How would this work for cars or couches or headphones?

This would be great for many things! I'm sure there are plenty of people who just want a good quality, reasonably priced -whatever- and would be fine with this model. Actually, that seems like it's basically just the business model for Kirkland.

If there was a retailer who just sold one carefully-chosen thing in each category, I think they'd do pretty well. They wouldn't be able to capitalize on market segmentation, fashion trends, etc. which would hurt their profitability, but they'd also benefit from being the "default" choice for many people.

hwbehrens··on Meta and Google are cutting staff
Given the context of their message, I think the parent switched perspectives mid-stream: ultra-competitive from the perspective of the employers (very hard to hire) to competitive from the perspective of the employees (somewhat hard to be hired).
hwbehrens··on AirPods Pro (2nd Generation)
I have an ultrasonic cleaner that I use for 3D printing, and they have a similar effect on my AirPods. I wonder what could cause this interaction?
hwbehrens··on California to ban the sale of new gasoline cars
This study [0] suggests that depending on adoption rates, the induced demand from commuting alone would be closer to 35-45%. The authors don't address how challenging scaling generation by that much would be, however.

Another article [1] suggests that it's not actually raw generation that will be the constraining factor, but actually power quality -- the authors suggest that cleaning and converting the power for high-voltage DC charging could be a much bigger task than scaling generation.

[0]: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=883...

[1]: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=933...

hwbehrens··on Smart thermostats inadvertently strain electric power grids
In my experience, it was not nearly sufficient. If your AC is appropriately sized (or undersized) for your house, you can't just drop several degrees in 2 hours during the hottest part of the day. Going from 78 to 72 to 84 in set temp looked more like 78 to 77 to 83 in practice. Granted this was in AZ in an older house, so extremely high outdoor temps combined with marginal insulation didn't help.

If they pre-cooled the night before it might be a different story.

hwbehrens··on Ask HN: I'm disabled and out of money. Now what?
I think the parent's question may be insensitive, but not inappropriate. The core problem OP seems to be facing is a mismatch between their incoming and outgoing cash flows. If we take it as given that they cannot work, e.g. that their incoming flows are fixed, then I think it's a natural step to examine ways to decrease their outgoing flows.

Of course, that oversimplifies the problem somewhat, since any changes could worsen the situation overall, e.g. decreased mental health. Sitting in a bare room paid for by someone else and watching the wallpaper peel away has very little out of pocket cost, after all.

The counterargument is that homelessness and loss of medication would probably be far worse -- for example, it could be wiser to sell the car and live an ascetic lifestyle for 16-24 months until the disability appeals are processed, at which point the OP could return to an equilibrium. Stretching out the runway, so to speak.

Forming any actionable advice in this vein is impossible without a better understanding of the OP's costs, however.

hwbehrens··on Why I’m Cryptophobic
> But that's just it: bad choices in the social layer become nearly irrevocable once a self-interested, powerful elite emerges. The bad choices put them on top and they will do anything to stay there.

I would argue that this trait is not unique to blockchain systems -- in fact, if you presented this argument without context, I doubt many readers would put blockchain in the top 5 potential referents. See: economic systems, political power struggles, social structures, etc.

hwbehrens··on Apple is not defending browser engine choice
> "What makes Chromium the best?"

I can't speak for the parent, but when most people say this they mean "least likely to break my websites", completely ignoring that this is a symptom, not a cause, of Chrome's dominance. Even my health insurance website breaks in Firefox, and their error message suggests that everyone should just use Chrome. We'll end up back in the early 2000s Internet Explorer situation eventually before the pendulum swings around again.

hwbehrens··on Webcams aren't good enough
> I don't think it's that the C920 is particularly brilliant

I used to sit in a cubicle under fluorescent lights, and I often received compliments on my webcam quality when I used a C920e, which I think has the same quality as the C920.

Don't underestimate absolutely horrendous laptop webcams becoming normalized, especially after stream compression.

hwbehrens··on The Great Decentralization? Geographic shifts and where tech talent is moving
I feel like the dataset they've chosen is extremely noisy at the tail, but they've obscured this in their analysis. An 11% increase in Portland should be a lot more impactful (in absolute terms) than a big decrease in El Centro, which I can imagine could be caused by a single company moving.

I guess it's probably unrealistic to expect P-values in a blog post, though...

hwbehrens··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
I can't be sure, but my interpretation of the parent's comment is that the USB-IF would never have thought to work on USB-C at all until Lightning's release two years earlier. The whole forehead-slapping moment of cables that didn't need to be flipped was a pretty big divergence from the USB-A, -B, mini B, micro B, etc. that has prevailed previously. The kernel of the argument being, Apple's "innovation" by rejecting the status quo is what allowed for the (eventual) development of the USB-C standard.

This is actually fairly common in Apple-land, now that I look:

- ADB (1986) to PS2 (1987) to USB-A (1996) for HID

- Firewire (1995) to USB 2.0 (2000) to Firewire 800 (2002) to USB 3.0 (2008) for data transfer

- VGA (1987) to ADC (1998) to DVI (1999) for video

A lot of the connectors they proposed are now lost to the mists of time, but I can at least understand the argument that some of these changes were plausibly driven by Apple's rejection of the then-standard in favor of some new benefit (faster speeds, better UX), which lasted only until a new standard was developed to incorporate that benefit, and the process repeats again.

hwbehrens··on Hate paywalls? 12ft.io is the answer
I have tried this site multiple times and never been successful. I find archive.ph to be much more reliable.
hwbehrens··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
I want a game that is a spiritual successor to Bullfrog's Gene Wars -- something that builds on an ecological / biosphere motivation. Seeding new plants to change local ecologies, breeding creatures (units) to select for needed characteristics, base building reflecting on the environment... I think there's a lot of interesting gameplay in that area that hasn't been explored yet.
hwbehrens··on PhD students face cash crisis with wages that don’t cover living costs
> Note that this applies to biology PhD.

While the article specifically calls out biology programs, at my university the CS department is similarly affected. (Stipends are set at a standard rate for all engineering depts.)

If your stipend is $19K, a single student's take-home pay is $16,734, less ~$1,600 in required departmental fees. So, you've got about $1261/mo to pay for everything. If you split a 1-bedroom for $2.2K (not including utilities), that means you've got $161 for electricity, food, phone, internet, fun, literally every other expense for the rest of the month.

The rapid rise in rents is the big killer here -- the difference between $500 and $1000 for a shared room is more than enough to break the bank.

hwbehrens··on Lets talk about blockchains
This is not a constructive response (in terms of HN commenting guidelines), especially given that the parent provided concrete examples. If you disagree with their examples, or if you think that the cons outweigh the pros, a better approach next time would be stating that and making your counterargument.

The effort we invest to encourage thoughtful dialogue is paid back in the long run by keeping the quality of discourse high(er) and making less work for dang.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →