HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hymanroth

200 karma · joined October 26, 2008

David Semeria

Founder of lmframework.com

david at (domain as above)

submissionscomments
hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
Shirky was talking about micropayments for content in that article. An endless stream of little decisions. I agree with him.

However, as I pointed out in a comment above. The one-off mental transaction cost for agreeing to be micro-billed for a continuous service is less than that required to sign-up for a premium version of a service.

As to my supposed abuse of language, I don't understand what you mean.

hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
Yup. The trick is to get consumers to embrace it.
hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
The mental transaction cost is certainly an issue with content. I wouldn't want to have to decide every time I start reading a news article whether I want to pay to get to the end.

However, the one-off mental cost of deciding whether to allow a web service to bill me for future usage is not a big deal, and, anyway, it applies even more to the choice of upgrading from a free to premium version.

In fact, it applies to any instance where the user is faced with having to pay for something.

What do you propose? Everything should always be free?

As for the scarcity argument, charging for support is a horrible business model. Look at Red Hat's revenues per user vs MSFT's. The key is to leverage the negligible marginal distribution costs of digital content.

hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
Good point. But not every web service benefits from the network effect. The spreadsheet example was not chosen at random. As long as you can save you spreadsheet in a common format, would you really choose a service with a higher user base over one that offered much better functionality but with fewer users?

There is space for both models. But for web applications I think microbilling has significant advantages

hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
I hope you meant 'micro-billing is much better'....
hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
The cost of the paid versions are artificially high wrt to the additional benefit they provide and to what they would cost if all the users paid up.

As web apps become more prevalent, people will be less willing to giving up their acreage to ads.

Agree that microbilling needs critical mass before catching on.

hymanroth··on Ask HN: Any Javascript Framework specific Selenium Version?
@mahmud - what a useless, unconstructive comment. There's no reason why you can't create rich webs using an Ajax framework - in fact that's the whole reason they exist.

As regards the original question, I'm sorry I can't help. You should try the ExtJS website, they have a vibrant community there.

hymanroth··on Ask HN: Please review LM, an experimental ajax framework
It's not stable enough to download at the moment, sorry.
hymanroth··on Drag Flickr photos straight into Twitter [video]
Thanks Jimmy - knew I could count on you.
hymanroth··on Twiggler: Awesome AJAX Twitter Client-Drag&Drop, Folders, multi a/c, the lot..
Thanks very much. Remember - it's all in the browser!
hymanroth··on Twiggler: Awesome AJAX Twitter Client-Drag&Drop, Folders, multi a/c, the lot..
I don't what happened, the link is good.
hymanroth··on Goodbye Stallman
In a way you're right. But I do know what Stallman stands for and respect what he's done. I was just hoping he would lay off the web.

The web is open, by definition. Anybody can view a javascript file in the browser cache, and it's not hard to work out how it works even if it is minified/obfuscated.

I just don't see the need to start blocking scripts because the developer doesn't subscribe to his radical views.

In the unlikely event of his idea taking off, it could dampen innovation rather than encourage it.

hymanroth··on The Javascript Trap
[Calmer now] Open source is fantastic. It is a stunningly efficient and elegant way to create software. I love open source.

What I don't love is the notion that either all software should be free (gratis) à la Stallman, or the less extreme view that you can make money from it as long as you do so in a very inefficient and non-scalable manner (basically charging for support).

Also, I find it quite ironic that some people describe (with a straight face) the supply of proprietary extensions to open source code as an 'open source business model'. That's akin to funding a peace march with the proceeds from arms sales.

And whilst I have lots of respect for what the community has achieved, and the people who helped make it happen (including Stallman and Raymond) I would argue that there is no inherent conflict between open source ideals and the notion that some users should pay for the code. If a developer wants to give his code away for free, then that's his or her choice and I respect that. But if another developer decided that his code is not free for commercial use, then I respect that position as well.

I hold the view that a low-friction and equitable licensing system for open source software would have a further galvanizing effect on this already vibrant sector.

DS

hymanroth··on The Javascript Trap
Whilst respecting what Richard Stallman has achieved in the past, I just couldn't read his latest post on javascript without getting a bit hot under the collar.

His position is, in my mind, completely untenable. He sees everything through his 'free software' glasses, the same way a dyed-in-the-wool communist sees everything through his Breznospecs. It's not enough for him that a Google Docs javascript file be free (gratis) – he objects that the file is not easy to read and has no comments. The fact that removing unnecessary white space is a commonly-used practice in speeding-up page loading is not mentioned, even in passing. What is this guy on?

I have in mind a special device for Stallman, Raymond and the other gratis software nutters. It consists of a big plastic bag that envelops their heads and into which is pumped the aroma of roasted coffee beans. It is required that they use this apparatus until such a time as their eyes light up and they utter the required phrase.

Today, more than ever, we live in a world of economic reality. In the recent past it was easy to find some chump to lend you all the money required to buy that house/car/tv you really couldn't afford, or finance your startup based on a 10 page deck and the words “web 2.0”. But things have changed. And perhaps for the better.

The open software movement cares more about its users than it does its developers. Hacker kudos doesn't pay the fucking rent. I want to know whether all the people writing iPhone or Facebook apps would have tried so hard if they knew their expected return would be exactly $0? Somehow I don't think so.

We've got to move away from this notion that software should be free (gratis). If you use it and can afford to pay for it then why should I give it to you for free? Note: I'm not arguing against open-source, I'm arguing against working for free. If I spend a great deal of time writing a funky database application and big_multi_national dumps Oracle in favor of my code and saves itself $20million in the process, why shouldn't I get my sniff? There's nothing wrong with making an honest dime...

If the same code is used by some charity or someone's personal website then I'm happy to tip my hat and say 'glad to be of service', but not if they're Coca Cola, or Hertz, or... (you name it).

If there existed a fair and balanced way of rewarding open source developers then I believe the whole sector would explode with a level of commitment and energy that would dwarf the already impressive achievements seen by the community.

That time has come.

It's time for revolution's founders to retire gracefully, and for a more realistic (though still ethical) guard to take its place.

David Semeria Milan, Italy

hymanroth··on Rough Type: Nicholas Carr's Blog: What Tim O'Reilly Gets Wrong About the Cloud
Nicholas, you're splitting hairs here.

Where do all the links which make PageRank work reside?

The biggest network of them all: the web itself.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3