HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hysan

3,103 karma · joined February 28, 2012

Software Engineer · QA Engineer · Teacher for Life I enjoy teaching, mentoring, and learning new things.
submissionscomments
hysan··on Bazzite Post-Mortem
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/09/linus-torvalds-apolo...
hysan··on Young adults report lower life satisfaction in Sweden
I’ll be honest and say that while I agree, I’d be one of those who’d get significantly burned financially if this were to happen. Having made significant lifestyle cuts to eventually get our foot in the door and now dealing with one of us being laid off (100% due to the current administration), devaluing housing would essentially lock us into where we currently live for the rest of our lives and prevent us from moving to a lower cost of living area near retirement (which was part of our original financial planning). Combined with the fact that our generation is unlikely to see social security as a viable pillar of support (ex: retirement age requirements increasing), I want to support the idea but I have yet to see a solution that won’t burn the population of people like myself. To support this would be to offer ourselves up as sacrifices and that is something I don’t think I could ask of someone. If someone could crack that nut and have a “soft landing” for those who are going to get screwed, then I think there’s a fighting chance that we solve this before it all becomes untenable.

(Edit: To clarify, when I hear devaluing housing, I’m interpreting that as an enormous price decrease. The impact to us is that we wouldn’t be able to sell our house for anywhere near the cost we paid for it. We didn’t buy as it as an asset but we also didn’t plan for it to become a huge loss that could have instead gone into retirement savings.)

hysan··on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues
I’m guessing this is related to and corroborates this early flagged article? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46777652
hysan··on Yes, It's Fascism
I think it isn’t mod actions but rather the very likely fact that there is a small, but large enough group of flaggers who will act in unison to remove any such post from the front page. If you want an affirmation of the efficacy of the moderation system, what you should want is transparency into the voting behaviors of the population. If you see a heavy voting correlation between flagged posts and either a specific set of users, voting timing (these types of posts get flagged much earlier than those that lean the other way politically), or both, then there is cause for concern that the algorithm of HN’s self moderation tools is being gamed. My bet is that it’s not the mods doing anything, but rather that there is already a critical mass of flag happy users that are controlling what gets to stay on the front page. I think it would be very interesting to see a write up on this topic, but it’s highly unlikely because I think it would violate privacy and user expectations of anonymity.
hysan··on FOSS "just fork it" delusion
This is now my favorite explanation of how I feel when people default to “just fork it”. I’ve always had trouble expressing how I think that is a symptom of a community problem. One that is endemic in many Linux communities. The next time I want to explain this, I’ll be linking to this post.
hysan··on Ask HN: Unemployed almost a year after graduating MIT – a rant
I think hitting the flagging threshold is probably the most tangible power as having enough accounts with that power will let you “suppress” certain topics. At least until a mod intervenes.

(Unless I’m misremembering. I think flagging required some level of karma. Or was that vouching?)

hysan··on KDE Plasma will no longer sleep when your controller is plugged in
Link to the source KDE blog post: https://blogs.kde.org/2026/01/03/this-week-in-plasma-new-yea...
hysan··on Report: Microsoft kills official way to activate Windows 11/10 without internet
Wouldn’t that leave out the set of people who have no income? For example, long term unemployed, adults switching careers and needing to take a long time off for education, etc? While the solution gets close, I don’t think it’s strictly the same thing. Add on top of that our unnecessarily complicated tax system and this sounds even less equivalent.
hysan··on Why your early 2000s photos are probably lost forever
Huh? I’ve been backing up my iPhone photos to my home server (running ZFS) since my first iPhone back in 2011. And Linux was my primary OS too. Not sure where that iPhone Air comment comes from.
hysan··on What Happened to Abit Motherboards
This brings me back. My first DIY PC used an Abit motherboard. It was a great computer and was still functional after 5 years before I upgraded. I never knew about the poor quality capacitors. I guess I lucked out.
hysan··on Show HN: Picknplace.js, an alternative to drag-and-drop
This doesn’t appear to always work? Sometimes the placed item gets sent back to the original position even though it’s clearly being placed in a new spot (at least from what I can see visually). The UX idea is nice.
hysan··on Mozilla's new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox
> However, we've got a new CEO, and one from the Firefox side who openly talks about Firefox being the core focus for Mozilla. This is exactly what we've been asking for! I think we should give them a chance.

You know the saying “fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me”? Mozilla is well beyond a count of 2 for me and I assume everyone else who is generally pessimistic about every new plea for giving Firefox another chance. While I understand the angle you’re coming from, I think this argument will read as disrespectful to those who have given Firefox multiple chances.

Actions speak louder than words. I think that Mozilla has to make multiple moves in the right direction before this type of plea can be made.

hysan··on Electron vs. Tauri
Good to know. Every time I gave Tauri a shot, issues with the state of WebKit on Linux was always my first hard wall. I never got to even trying to make a production executable. Sounds like it’ll be a long time before this ever becomes viable for fully cross platform use cases.
hysan··on Electron vs. Tauri
Yup, came here to say this. After reading the article, it became abundantly clear that the author doesn’t support Linux and most of the article is just a summary of the common Tauri talking points that are out of date. To add data to this - Tauri is looking to allow embedding chromium as an option because the creator of Tauri acknowledged that it doesn’t work well on Linux. To the point where if Linux is a serious target, they don’t recommend Tauri: https://github.com/tauri-apps/wry/issues/1064#issuecomment-2...

The upstream projects aren’t in a place to support this yet so this feature didn’t make it into Tauri v2. I’ve been tracking this for a long time and hope that they will make it possible in v3.

hysan··on Markdown is holding you back
> I think comparing markdown in general to something like DocBook is comparing apples to oranges.

Hmm let me rephrase the issue I have with the comments in this thread. If your position is that markdown doesn’t belong in the same category as the others, then yeah, I agree. But I also think that’s basically rejecting the premise of the article and there isn’t a discussion to be had. If you disagree with the core premise, then it doesn’t matter what is said, there’s no discussion to be had.

However, the original parent comment is stating that the author’s assertion is false because you can extend markdown. I don’t see how that logic doesn’t run into the semantics and “portability” problems that the author is writing about.

hysan··on Markdown is holding you back
Maybe portable isn’t the right word. I read portable as meaning the format’s semantics are consistent across platforms. The way I read the author’s complaint was that once you start tacking on extensions to markdown, you run into the problem of seeing if other markdown platforms being able to support your variant of markdown. Hence the part about CommonMark vs GitHub-Flavored Markdown vs etc. Having actually run into this before when working on CMSes in the past, I get why the author sees this as a problem. I don’t think everyone will agree with the authors viewpoint, but I just happened to think that this thread is completely missing the point that the author is trying to make.
hysan··on Markdown is holding you back
The author addresses this too. Once you start down this path, you go down the road of non-standardization which means losing portability, etc. I don’t see how this is a point against the author?
hysan··on Guests ejected mid-stay from bankrupt hotel chain Sonder
Not surprised. Our one experience using Sonder was horrible. Toilet didn’t work and was constantly flushing water. Took forever to get connected to someone. Then they said that they didn’t have maintenance to send until the next day. Asked to be moved. Next room was much worse (other broken stuff, visibly poor condition) but at least the toilet worked? They didn’t have other rooms to change us to. At that point it had been several hours on the phone, so we said fuck it. We need to eat and sleep after our day of travel. Not get hot potatoed around between clueless customer support. The only other two people I know who tried Sonder had similarly shitty experiences that swore them off too.
hysan··on The US Do Not Call registry is offline
Doubt it. I used it for several years and then forgot one year. Same amount of spam. Decided to see how it would go if I stopped and I see no difference in the amount of spam calls since.
hysan··on Who still uses cash?
At least when I lived there, Japan was a heavily cash centric culture. Due in part to the difficulty of getting a credit card and how little benefit there was to having one for day to day consumer interactions (edit to mention that I’m very much simplifying here; I know it’s more nuanced than this). 60% is lower than I would have expected but it has been almost a decade since I lived there. I closed the article once they threw that huge pop up in my face, but I did see that they only mentioned that Japan was an outlier. If you knew anything about Japanese economics and culture, this wouldn’t have been surprising to see. I’m guessing the rest of the article didn’t provide any depth to their visualization.
hysan··on The RSS feed reader landscape
Article feels AI generated and misses some big ones. Given that this is advertising for their product, I don’t feel like this is actually useful (meaning unbiased and comprehensive) content for anyone who wants to figure out what RSS reader fits their needs.
hysan··on A Mac-like experience on Linux
For the most part, I agree. But sometimes you come across ones like this that clearly go into the actual UX elements of an UI: https://old.reddit.com/r/unixporn/comments/1l5ll27/hyprland_...
hysan··on A Mac-like experience on Linux
This mirrors my thoughts but as someone who has/is trying to bend KDE into a mac-like experience, there are other big road blockers to getting the same smooth workflow:

- the global app menu doesn’t work for most apps because GTK based ones yanked support and generally don’t implement it. With Firefox being the most commonly recommended browser and it still not supporting this, you have a glaring hole in having a unified UX in daily usage

- consistent and common shortcuts for main functionality. Having everything tied to CMD and being the same in all apps makes for a predictable UX. While you can achieve it with remapping (ex: toshy), I’ve found the experience to have just enough rough edge cases that it breaks me out of my flow constantly

- configurable 1:1 gestures and other non-keyboard centric accessibility features. At the end of the day, every Linux DE is keyboard centric. If you have disability issues that make it hard to stay on your keyboard, then I think macOS generally has the nicest feel (meaning lowest chance of hitting an edge case or bug). GNOME has stability but lacks the breadth of UX features while some other DEs have a greater breadth and configurability but lacks the stability

Overall, you aren’t going to ever get a truly mac-like experience on Linux because no one is specifically targeting the same UX design goals. You can try to tweak things endlessly, but you’ll end up spending more time working out bugs than actually using the system. If you plan to use Linux, be prepared to change your workflow and pick the DE whose design goals most closely match what you’re willing to adopt.

P.S. - I don’t mention aesthetics because I think everyone who brings that up detracts from the actual UX differences. At the end of the day, if you can match the UX entirely, then how the DE looks doesn’t matter. I mean look at how Liquid Glass is changing the look entirely. Yet the core UX principles are still the same and that’s what really matters (for those looking for a mac-like experience).

hysan··on Yt-dlp: Upcoming new requirements for YouTube downloads
I also have YouTube premium and watch mostly on my iPad and TV. YouTube constantly logs me out at least once per day. I notice because I’ll randomly start seeing ads again (I open videos from my rss reader, never their site). This never happened when I wasn’t on premium. I don’t get what they’re doing, but my impression after almost a year is that it’s only slightly less annoying than getting ads. At this point, I might as well not renew and just use ad block.
hysan··on Dear HN. Please make the Hacker News header stick to the top of the browser
Also voicing my opinion to please not do this. As a small phone + large font user, this would greatly reduce the amount of screen real estate. I think it would be a backwards step in accessibility for those with sight problems.
hysan··on 'Make invalid states unrepresentable' considered harmful
I mostly agree with the author but I think there's a very important distinction to make. It's important to think about this in two layers - the domain and the UI (whether that be a CLI, an API, a full blown GUI, etc). The author very clearly is talking about the domain layer, but the area where I see "Make invalid states unrepresentable" having the greatest benefit is in the UI layer. That is where you want fine grain control over what capabilities of your domain layer that you expose and is where you have a lot to gain by architecting your types/system/etc to be strict. It makes for easier to reason about code and reduces the amount of edge cases you need to QA. The constraints you put in the UI layer are product constraints, not technical ones. In my opinion, when you think about it that way, that adage isn't harmful but rather a very useful guide for technical folks to use when trying to mental model what product is asking you to build.
hysan··on What to expect from Debian/Trixie
Depends on your filesystem. For example, I certainly can as I’m using btrfs. I’m also using Timeshift for easy management of snapshots. As others have mentioned, there are other choices too like Snapper that all work well.
hysan··on Bans on gas-powered leaf blowers are spreading around the US
Just enforcing it at all would bring about a huge amount of change. I literally see police chilling in their cars while obnoxiously loud cars & motorcycles drive by and they do nothing even though my city has noise ordinance laws. The biggest problem isn’t the lack of laws but the enforcement of them. I’d wager that many of those people feel like they can get away with it not because the police will arrive too late, but because the police don’t care to enforce what’s right in front of their faces.
hysan··on Samsung embeds IronSource spyware app on phones across WANA
> "unremovable"

> you can't completely remove it

Maybe my English isn’t very good but that sounds like the definition of unremovable.

hysan··on It's true, “we” don't care about accessibility on Linux
Yup, and now it’s regressing so totally understandable that for those who somehow made it work, this is the straw that breaks the camel’s back. Personally, when I developed RSI and other health issues (that made me seriously consider giving up programming or anything computer related as a career), I found that I didn’t want to put up with the state of a11y in Linux and switched to macOS. That was worlds better even though I missed a ton of features from Linux. After a lot of time and money, I’ve made my way back to being able to continue my career, and thankfully don’t need those tools anymore. I still give Linux a try for a few months every year to see if it’s time to switch back. For certain users, I can understand why Linux feels like it’s not there and even regressing.
← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →