HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

i_made_a_booboo

206 karma · joined February 21, 2018

submissionscomments
i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: Ex-FAANG developers, where are you now and why?
That's brutal.
i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: Ex-FAANG developers, where are you now and why?
Mike and Tyson. Mike Tyson.
i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: Ex-FAANG developers, where are you now and why?
The education system isn't flawed. It's working as intended. You just don't see what its design goals actually are, or you disagree with what they should be.

I would argue if you aren't able to see why the education system produces that result on purpose then you don't understand how the economy works.

i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: Ex-FAANG developers, where are you now and why?
TL;DR - there are other things to optimize for than the maximum amount of money possible. It might not even be a sensible goal.

An extremely common theme heard from people with a lot of money is to get your money working for you.

Another extremely common theme is you hear from the same people is after a while they realized it just didn't make them happy like they thought it was going to.

Theoretically there is a certain maximum level of feeling good that's possible in a day. My goal these days is to optimize for that. I'm not there yet, but I can see a path to it. At some point the pursuit of money puts pressure against some of that happiness in one form or another. At least that's been my experience and observations. It's not an absolute rule but a reasonable hueristic.

If from an emotional perspective it wasn't possible to feel any better than you did, what would more money actually do for you?

IMO a lot of people need to dig much deeper on their 'why' for chasing the maximum amount of money possible. It's not 'wrong' to do so, nor am I judging anyone for doing it, I just think it's quite a one sided perspective that that should be the goal and that alone.

It's mostly about status and getting laid at an instinctive level. I realized this after already having a child, so I've technically passed on my genes and recently a vasectomy, so I can't even pass on any more genes. Yet my instincts are still the same. Chase after status, position yourself to be the fittest mate possible. We just can't turn those drives off, so once we've earned enough money and our happiness is no longer increasing as a function of getting more money at some point after that we actually hit an inflection point and things start to go the other way.

I can totally see how a roof over your head that can't be taken away from you and low AF overheads makes life feel like a breeze. That's actually worth a lot, just not in Dollars.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
It's not about 'imposing' a 1:1 mapping. It's about assuming a mapping exists at all for every case. It doesn't. While it does for the vast, vast majority of cases every language pair will have a non zero percentage of things that have no possible mapping that one could construe as a translation.

The problem most people seem to have understanding this is two-fold:

1. They assume if you just had more data and better algorithms you could get better results.

2. They have never translated things themselves and come across a case where something didn't have a translation.

Remove the machines from the equation entirely. It's not always possible in 100% of cases for people to do it.

Naturally linguistically similar languages have more overlap and hence better success overall but that's really just a nice to have.

No matter how similar English and French are, if you ask someone to translate a meme that started in 4chan or Reddit into French you will quickly encounter a case where attempting to do so just doesn't work. I'm sure there are plenty of better examples than that but I don't know French.

It's an elephant in the room and stunningly few people seem to see it standing there.

それは部屋の象で、驚くほど少数の人々がそこに立っているのを見ているようです。

Lol Google really??

In fact case in point 'elephant in the room' if it were used inside a joke that relied on using the elephant as part of the joke would not be possible to translate. It just wouldn't make sense.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
This presumes you can translate all strings straightforwardly. You can't. There are times where I've been given a string and had to have an in-depth 30 minute discussion to understand enough of the surrounding context to be able to spit out a result. In certain cases no mapping exists.

Also, anyone who is able to verify that a translation conveys a meaning in enough of the same direction as the original utterance by definition doesn't need a translation as they know both the source and target language.

It's everybody else who is not able to verify for whom the accuracy matters for they have no recourse but to trust it.They are frequently led astray.

A couple of examples to illustrate.

掘り炬燵 (horigotatsu) is a noun referring to "low, covered table placed over a hole in the floor of a Japanese-style room"

Now, given this is something that doesn't exist in any Western, English speaking country it simply doesn't have a mapping in English. The best that can be done is to give an explanation of what it is.

Google translate "translates" it as "digging". Welcome to the last mile. In this case Google should just spit out an explanation of what it is. Digging is entirely incorrect and unhelpful.

But it gets worse. Imagine if it's used in a sentence. Here is a good example of a last mile issue in translation. It's impossible for you to translate it directly, so you have to fall back to a best effort attempt and either simplify and lose some information or stop mid-sentence and give an explanation of what the thing actually is.

掘り炬燵に座ってご飯を食べてた。

This sentence is all kinds of problematic from a translation point of view.

Google translates it as: "I sat on a digging stone and ate rice."

That borders on D+/C- in terms of quality for me. But there are a few good reasons as to why.

The original Japanese doesn't give the context of who is performing the action because that's simply not necessary to say in Japanese it's almost always just inferred from context in the moment and that gets lost when you only have a string. Thus it's possible this could be a "he, she, it, we, I, they". If the machine is forced to pick one option then it will pick one option.

Then there is the horigotatsu part which gets "translated" as "digging stone". What the hell is a digging stone? It ought to just say horigotatsu* and have a footnote. Machine translation today doesn't do footnotes. I wish it did.

Again there is a lack of context as to the meaning of ご飯 (gohan) which technically can mean cooked white rice but in this case most likely refers to a "meal". Though which meal is not specified and it could be breakfast, lunch or dinner but I'm going to guess it's dinner.

But what should the translation actually be? Is it even fundamentally "translateable"?

One valid translation would be "we sat in the horigotatsu and had dinner". That still requires an explanation.

Anyway, I hope it's a little clearer what I mean that it's not actually always possible to translate things.

I think we can hit parity with humans one day, but it requires fundamentally rethinking certain things at a UX level. For instance if instead of just an input form Google translate was more like a chatbot that could probe for more context when needed that's more my idea of where things need to ultimately wind up. Perhaps a model like rap genius where annotations contain extra details around possible alternatives and why the current word was chosen.... This is my 2 cents on the issue.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
I'm saying the current techniques will only take us so far and they break down in hilarious ways when they reach these edge cases.

My point is to reach true parity with human capabilities machine translation needs to reach the point where it can also recognize "I can't translate that" instead of always trying to spit out an answer and returning hilarious garbage in such situations.

Another behavior I would expect to see is sometimes returning multiple possible results. This is common when a translator doesn't know the exact context but can imagine the range of possible contexts in which an utterance can occur and conveys them all in order to get the message across.

Currently I don't see anyone trying to take this approach. It's all simple one string in gives one string out.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
That is the only end game I would consider to be a full implementation of machine translation on par with human capabilities.

In cases where there is no direct equivalent or even an appropriate localization we usually resort to giving a long form explanation. If the machines can do that, they've won.

I can't see the current techniques getting us that far. It's going to require some new, creative thinking to really push the envelope.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
The last mile isn't solvable. Some languages contain concepts, set phrases, vocabulary and pop-culture references entirely unique to that language. There isn't a translation in every single case. Machines however will always try to come up with one and the results are amusing.

Also people make the assumption that as soon as we make strong AI comparable to a human we will be to translate anything and everything (let's say we are excluding the last mile for arguments sake). That assumption ignores an important fact that sometimes translation is a team effort where certain words, phrases or concepts are debated among multiple translators to reach a consensus. It's not always done by a single intelligence.

Some people might argue that's because people have far more limited capacity to consider all the examples in the corpus whereas a machine can consider all of lightning fast and thus can arrive at the right answer.

A perfect edge case that illustrates why that doesn't matter and where multiple human intelligences will often grapple with how something should be translated would be what name to give to a movie you are translating to an international audience. The same movie often has quite different names depending on which language it gets translated into. There isn't actually a correct answer there is just answers that are deemed 'good enough'.

i_made_a_booboo··on Building a language translator from scratch with deep learning
Machine translation has made some pretty impressive progress over the last decade. Unfortunately no methods will ever cover the very last mile as languages don't have perfect 1 to 1 mappings. Though it is amusing watching the machines try.
i_made_a_booboo··on The Japanese traffic light blues: Stop on red, go on what?
It's not just the traffic lights in Japan, it's the traffic lights all around the world, if you're a Japanese person. My wife and I always refer to it as blue when speaking Japanese and we live in my home country. It's jus St a cultural norm and the truth is not actually important to human beings, so it doesn't surprise me.

They call grass 'blue' too. There's even a familiar expression with a Japanese twist that goes "The grass is bluer on the other side".

Apparently "blue" used to be a pretty wide range of colors ranging from quite very dark, almost black blues to normal blue and the kind of green that is often referred to as blue. Japanese has a fairly large number of loan words for colors indicating some colors were introduced to their lexicon through contact with foreigners. Pink is an example of that. They have 'sakura-iro' which represents the color of cherry blossoms but it's not a proper representation of pink by itself as you wouldn't use it to refer to say a hot pink.

The level of cognitive dissonance I have to endure every time we're stopped at the lights still irks me.

i_made_a_booboo··on Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers
Plus it's heavy as hell so having to move it far is big driver of this too.
i_made_a_booboo··on Tech Workers Now Want to Know: What Are We Building This For?
Interestingly, I think it was in the book The Elephant In The Brain, it remarks that sometimes people are depressed because they stop looking at the world through the normal veneer of self-deception and start seeing it for what it is and they realize how horrible, sad and shitty humanity and the world actually is.
i_made_a_booboo··on The Tyranny of the U.S. Dollar
Bingo.
i_made_a_booboo··on The Tyranny of the U.S. Dollar
Human nature is remarkably constant.
i_made_a_booboo··on Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for Raises
>In an unregulated market, there are no bad actors, only inefficient ones.

The history of planet earth is full of bad actors in all kinds of markets, regulated or not. The animal kingdom is full of examples of deception. Seeking personal gain at the expense of others is a very deep feature of life.

i_made_a_booboo··on Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for Raises
Then you wind up with a union cartel. I would bet good money on that.
i_made_a_booboo··on Governor signs bill requiring California corporate boards to include women
What if you can't afford to?
i_made_a_booboo··on Coders Automating Their Own Job
What if you were born in Puntland, Somalia and you were shit out "luck".
i_made_a_booboo··on I lived in a Tokyo coworking space
Forcing your employees to stay at work until the boss leaves at 11pm is treating them like humans?

Japans work culture is completely toxic and dysfunctional. I have one rule that I stick to these days: "Never work in, with or for Japan."

i_made_a_booboo··on The annoying habits of highly effective people
bingo
i_made_a_booboo··on When Do We Have Empathy for the Mentally Ill?
>it's a circle of it's own hell

True and true.

i_made_a_booboo··on When Do We Have Empathy for the Mentally Ill?
>since that's clearly not fair behavior/right, what do we do about it?

Is there something that can be "done about it"? Well someone will probably build an app for it because that's just how people in tech like to solve problems but these kinds of bias just seem to be a naturally built in part of the operating system as I see it.

i_made_a_booboo··on If You're Not Writing a Program, Don't Use a Programming Language [video]
I've had equal misery both typed and untyped on large, old, legacy stuff.

Maybe programming just sucks.

i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: Best alternative to Gmail?
Because if you have 10,000 customers paying $50 that's much nicer than having 100,000 customers paying you $5.
i_made_a_booboo··on Ask HN: How much did you, as an employee, make when your startup exited?
This genuinely made me chuckle. So damn accurate.
i_made_a_booboo··on AI Company Accused of Using Humans to Fake Its AI
Nailed it.
i_made_a_booboo··on Making a racist AI without really trying (2017)
Ergo human beings are inherently garbage.
i_made_a_booboo··on Don't learn Dvorak
Colemak is where it's at because cut/copy/paste and the punctuation is all still in the same place as QWERTY but on Dvorak that's all fucked which makes it an impractical nightmare.

I still use qwerty on my keyboard but I started learning both to try them out. I accidentally left my phone's keyboard layout in colemak and didn't realize until months later when a friend tried to use it. It's kinda funny how your brain just adjusts.

i_made_a_booboo··on Australian firm Meriton fined $3M for misleading consumers on TripAdvisor
The EU will go after this next. Technically it is a deceptive thing to do.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →