256 karma · joined May 7, 2024
I don't believe this is the case. Apple generally prefers to diminish the importance and risks of specific actions unless they have some monetary advantage. e.g. Apple is happy to warn you (multiple times) that an alternative marketplace is "dangerous" and yet iMessage iCloud Backups are just a click away with a friendly "so your messages are available everywhere".
Another example is Photos - Apple has no problem activating features that collect "anonymized" information from my pictures. Yes, there is an opt-out, but having all that on by default is not in the spirit of a privacy-minded operation.
And about the choice - someone already pointed out in other comments, there really is no way to replace iCloud with anything else for backups and app data sync. So the choice is not really a choice.
There have been so many dystopian movies about this kind of tech, it's a good insight of what comes next.
I think the pursuit of some kind of semantic purity in the Swift language overshadows more practical needs and concerns. Making Swift too different from its neighbours like Kotlin and Rust also makes it harder to context switch. It now takes a lot more time and effort to get into the flow of developing native things for iOS...
Also, your page needs to disclose any content filtered by or generated by a model.
Apple is not in a position to be the one evaluating security of 3rd party offers. Apple markets itself as one but the reality is that it’s a conflict of interest for them to perform this function.
It’s also not up to Apple to decide what privacy is and later change their minds because for example Apple Intelligence needs access to “personal context” or they receive information requests from the US government, or similar.
All companies operating within the EU are subject to privacy and consumer protection regulations and allowing for interoperability doesn’t change any of that.
Just for the record, a large number of Apple services do not work consistently across the EU. Everything from Fitness and News to translations and Siri. Not to mention the mess with languages and subtitles if you want to watch a movie on ATV+ or buy it on the iTunes Store. Also forget about Family or gift cards spanning multiple countries. Apple outside the US is very different from Apple US.
I believe op means Swift is different because Apple is the gatekeeper at the top of the Swift project https://www.swift.org/community/#project-lead
By contrast, other open languages usually have elected leadership and aren’t directly subject to a specific corporation.
This was also discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42864919
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#spa...