HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

imagine99

886 karma · joined December 26, 2018

submissionscomments
imagine99··on Student Surveillance Vendor Proctorio Files SLAPP Lawsuit to Silence a Critic
Those folks are obviously beyond having any sense of irony even if it slaps them in the face ("Honorlock" was mentioned as another piece of such software above), let alone an etymological understanding of their company name.

I completely agree with you that any form of exam in which such a system would even theoretically add any value is broken, meaningless and should not be used in the first place.

Ironically, nowadays Chinese schools (don't know about unis) are also among those who employ extremely invasive methods against cheating. Competitiveness for coveted spots at some institutions is orders of magnitudes higher than in the west, the tests are all completely standardized and students have shown remarkable inventiveness in finding ways to cheat.

Don't say: "Undress to impress & show your proctos to your proctor."

Say rather:

   The cloakroom pegs are empty now, /
   And locked the classroom door, /
   The hollow desks are lined with dust, /
   The students here no more.

   They sit at home, get perved upon / 
   by proctors via cam. /
   I raise my glass and praise the fact /
   At school I no more am.
Am I qualified to do pretty much anything? ;-)
imagine99··on Student Surveillance Vendor Proctorio Files SLAPP Lawsuit to Silence a Critic
I'm sorry but reading all this, at a certain point I have to ask: Why are people (students, faculty) playing along with that? Is there not a point where people are willing to stand up for themselves and say: Enough is enough?

Imagine, students would be asked to appear in the nude to write the exams and undergo invasive checks to prove that they haven't got any miniature transmission devices hidden on their body. Would they just agree to this as well? Would the faculty that's tasked to check the students' orifices play along happily?

I wonder what a degree from an institution that treats students (and faculty forced to use this) with such a level of contempt, treats them as a priori cheaters and crooks instead of teaching them honor and responsibility, is actually worth? The name "honorlock" alone is beyond ridiculous for obvious reasons.

In my days (at one of the Ivies), admittedly a long time ago, I seem to remember that we had to complete a lot of coursework at home and most if not all our exams were open-book. I even remember a test or two where we could bring all our notes from class (not that it did you much good at all, the skills they asked for just weren't in the notes). Not one exam was proctored in that sense, I think, although I remember often longing for one as I imagined them to be much easier: Just regurgitate some knowledge onto the page and go home. No days and weeks refining your arguments and making a case for yourself.

Professors also always knew if someone hadn't done all the work by himself. I remember a girl breaking out in tears during a presentation because she couldn't explain the meaning of a rather boastful technical term she had used in context (and apparently just copied from somewhere).

I think, if I had been asked to install this kind of malware on my PC back then so that some incompetent perv could watch me answering stupid multiple choice questions, I would've laughed in their faces and just quit then and there (I did eventually quit anyway but that's because the offer was just too enticing). Maybe I would've set up an elaborate sound stage with green screen etc. and spliced it into the camera feed to fool the proctors first before turning on some holograms or dirty movies, I don't know (this stuff wasn't so advanced and readily available in those days).

The point is, these setups can always be fooled. Always. You should therefore create an environment where you don't need them. Where people are proud of the work they do themselves, where the skills taught and asked aren't "replayed" in a manner that needs such proctoring, and where people adhere to an honor code that doesn't require them to cheat. If you can't teach people that nowadays, then what are you good for?

How broken must the current educational system be that a) such software exists and is widely used and b) its vendors aren't simply laughed out of the room straight away and c) both students and faculty don't complain at least as loudly about that stuff as they complain about certain other things...

imagine99··on Microsoft Sculpt Wired Conversion Mod
Hey, thanks for the list. I'm actually into "non-ergonomic" (traditional) full-size mechanical keyboards, and even there, I haven't really found one that does fully customizable work (keys, colors, switches - no manufacturer logos) and is wireless. Do you have a recommendation for this, too? If so, I'd be grateful!
imagine99··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
That is correct, but for boolean expressions, logical operators etc. it's just the one equal sign. E.g.

  if pilot.sleeping = true then alarm.playing := true; 
// This will check if the property "sleeping" of pilot is true and will then set the property "playing" of alarm to true as well. You could also do a "while" or "repeat .. until" there which would probably better to stop the alarm if the pilot wakes up again (... then alarm.playing := false).

It could totally work this way if you programmed a simple flight simulator with Delphi, even today.

BTW, one exception to := in assignments are initialized variables inside a var section:

  var
    announcement: string = 'Wake up!';
imagine99··on Google Scans Your Gmail for Invoices and Receipts to Track What You Buy Online
The following post might sound somewhat paranoid but it isn't. I (try to) just report facts which another commenter said "everybody knows already anyway".

So: All email are parsed for shopping info (price, product, quantity), shipping/tracking numbers (UPS, FedEx etc.), upcoming bills or reminders, what they are for and in which amount, dates & events (flight numbers, passenger names, booking codes, events, invitations, collaborations). How you deal with each email (delete it unread, categorize it or send it to spam) is also recorded and over time influences the behavior of your inbox (depending on your settings as well). Who sends you email and which groups of users you send email to (this will be used to identify your peer groups and Google will recommend you add a person if it thinks you forgot to CC them in an email).

All your attachments and all their contents are processed (to search for malware and/or illegal content).

All files you store on Google Drive are continuously monitored for size and content which might be illegal (such as porn) etc. and how many people look at them (if you share it with too many people, your account may be closed).

All your photos uploaded to Google Photos are used to train machine-learning algorithms for facial recognition and item identification.

All files on Google Drive that you delete, are not deleted right away.

All the Wi-fi passwords of networks you connect to on the phone, all Wi-Fi networks you pass but don't connect to and all the Bluetooth devices you connect to will also be stored (Google uses these for better location information if or when GPS is unavailable).

By default, if you are logged into your Google account while surfing the web and/or using Chrome, Google will also collect, store and connect with your identity

- each and every phrase you search (this feature is called Web Activity)

- all the apps you use, how often and how long (App Activity)

- every video you watch on YouTube, how long and whether you skip certain parts (this feature is called YouTube Search & Watch History)

- every location you visit with GPS enabled on your phone and/or navigate to using Google Maps (this feature is called Location History)

- all voice commands you input into Google search or Google assistant (this feature is called Voice & Audio Activity)

- any voicemail you receive on Gmail (through Google Voice) will be transcribed

This will be used to show you personalized ads but it will also be aggregated and used to analyze trends and patterns.

This is all on top of the usual stuff that Google collects by tracking you regardless of whether or not you are logged into your account, by virtue of having the largest ad network in the world which is embedded on all major websites.

You can find much of that information on myaccount.google.com and more if you order a "Google Takeout" which will allow you to download all the info that Google has about you.

If you use Google Enterprise accounts, your admin can additionally configure it so they can:

- see and read all emails you send and receive, and whether you opened them

- see any and all email you have deleted (they will be hidden from you but not deleted)

- see all chats (Hangouts), their contents, times and who participated.

This feature is called Google Vault, Litigation Hold and eDisovery and costs extra (but is included in some of the higher tiers). Note that using this feature to access emails other than your own is illegal in some EU countries but not in the US.

What Google does NOT track:

- Recordings from your cell phone's microphone or camera. People occasionally claim that they get ads for a certain product just because they talked about it with their phone in the room. But that's coincidence or due to the fact that advertisers know which people are in vicinity of each other (family, location, same IP) and one of their peers searched for it, so the ad is shown to all people in that network etc. (more complicated than that but that's the gist).

Whether or not the tracking appears malicious to you probably depends on whether you think Google is evil or not. Better hope that they aren't ;-)

Disclaimer: Some of the info I mentioned might not be up-to-date. You can switch off some but not all of those "features". You can set auto-delete time frames for some but not all of these, too. Whether they are actually deleted or just hidden, who knows. If I made an error or you disagree, please don't mindlessly downvote but reply and correct me. Thank you.

imagine99··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
That's just because the above code is in Pascal. You see, it would be much more complicated if written in C++ or distributed real-time Java.
imagine99··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
Might be just the one... if pilot.conscious = false then flyto(base);
imagine99··on Google Scans Your Gmail for Invoices and Receipts to Track What You Buy Online
Maybe on HN but outside of our bubble most people have no clue what data is collected about them on the regular and how it is (mis-)used. If you tell them they act offended and tell you that surely you must be paranoid, have something to hide or be joking, and that it would never be allowed by the government (or whatever)!!1

Unfortunately, in fact it has nothing to do with whether you're paying for Gmail. Your data is still more valuable then your the 15 bucks or whatever you pay per user for Google Workspace these days. Google do it with the paid Enterprise accounts, too. Admins have some (limited) influence over it there (in that they can switch of certain things but that's actually a brand-new option) but of course that doesn't mean that Google stops collecting and aggregating that data anyway. They just hide the (marginally useful) front-end from you that's their fig leaf for justifying the data analysis in the first place (like the automatic flight reminders, calendar integration, parcel tracking or text completion).

imagine99··on Google Scans Your Gmail for Invoices and Receipts to Track What You Buy Online
This is why Amazon stopped mentioning the product name in shipping confirmations a while ago. It just says "Your order no. XXX of n items has been dispatched" and they don't say which items. In the order confirmation, they do list the product name but no longer the product number (ASIN). Looks like they don't want Google to have access to the same extremely valuable data on what items shoppers actually order and when. The unintended consequence is that the messages are now quite useless to me (it's literally useless spam if you order more than 1 thing per week), as you never know from the email itself what item was actually shipped...

I thought this was a privacy setting that you could toggle somewhere (so as to get useful information if you're not using Gmail) but that isn't available.

Quite annoying on one hand but on the other, good on Amazon (I am saying this fully aware of whom I applauding) for frustrating Google's data hunger a bit.

imagine99··on Who Is Still Buying VHS Tapes?
You don't need Veeam of course but you should definitely try it out if you really want to manage your backups properly. It works really well and is pretty sleek, also for restore processs and when working with VMs or endpoints. You should certainly use it instead of any other commercial backup software like BackupExec (most of which are just... bad in comparison). Veeam offers a free Windows agent but I don't think that one works with tape drives (I might be wrong, especially in combination with LTFS, see below).

You can't generally use tape like a USB stick, that is, write and delete files to and from it willy-nilly ;-) As tape is linear, that would require a lot of going back and forth. Imagine random I/O when you can just go forward or backward with the read head: That's annoying and slow at best, at worst it could destroy the tape or machine quickly.

HOWEVER: They have come up with something called the "Linear Tape File System" (LTFS) which does in fact allow you to access a tape in a way that looks (from the outside at least) pretty similar to any external storage device. In fact, sustained read speeds can be much faster even than traditional storage in the right circumstances. There are some tricks they use, obviously, to get around the physical limitations I mentioned above. One of them is, I believe, that space is not freed up if you delete a file (it is simply marked as deleted in meta data - but that's the "modern way" to delete things anyway, right? :-D).

Also, your drive has to support it and the tape also has to be formatted in a specific way. It might only work with new tapes (again, I might be wrong or this may have changed). I've actually never used LTFS in production, so I can't help you with the details or tell you what this means for the lifespan of the tape if you use it in this fashion. I also don't know what software you need to use this under Linux.

Feel free to report back if you go down this route, I'd be curious to hear whether you get it to work and whether you like it for everyday use.

imagine99··on Show HN: Generate a 3D model that looks like you and apply AR animation effects
Thanks for responding! No specific issues, just lack of access to a suitable (non-corporate) mobile testing device as I'm at work ;-) Yes, I will definitely check it out as soon as I can.

Which actually leads me to another feedback point: If you want to strengthen your B2B prospects, a Windows app (or web app) would probably be most helpful. Most people you will encounter in that space (especially as soon as it's gaming or rendering-related in any way) will be sitting at large Windows workstations rather than on mobile devices, and having your service accessible a click away while they have their 3d modelling software open on their main screen would be most welcome.

The UI could be as simple as a front-end where I can drag & drop the three necessary pictures (or four, if you include the backside at some point) which I took with a DSLR (instead of my cellphone cam), then it displays a 360° preview for me, allows me to click "add high-res textures for fbx" and then "buy it now". I enter my CC or PayPal and it spits out the fbx files. Done :-)

What would be the best way to contact you about obtaining an fbx file of a character? What would be the price point for a non-commercial hobby project? Would you be able to add an option for high-res textures for export only (non-AR use) that would look good when added to a full-HD video in Adobe AE?

I agree that purchasing should be automated in the long run, with as low a barrier as possible (to allow for "impulse purchasing" as well) - certainly no "contact us for a quote" please :-)

Anyway, awesome project, so much potential, I will certainly keep an eye on it and spread the word!

Cheers.

imagine99··on Show HN: Generate a 3D model that looks like you and apply AR animation effects
At first look, this seems to give much better results than e.g. Character Creator's Headshot, which to me has never yielded one recognizable result out of the box that didn't take hours and hours of refining.

The textures (except for the face) here are obviously very low-res and sort-of generic but that's not all that important - the head and face sure look great, at least in the demo video. The person is recognizable and that's pretty awesome.

I wonder if you could add a feature to export these models for productive use (such as .fbx files) so they can be creatively used in other software (like Adobe AE, Cinema 4d etc.). Having a one-touch solution to create rigged, realistic 3D models, export them and only maybe having to refine the textures on the hands a bit and adjust clothing would be such a time saver. To me, that would add much more value to this technology than the gimmicks displayed in the demo (though they are quite funny). I could also imagine that this is a much easier (or at least a strong second) path to generate revenue. If priced competitively (between $5 and $20 per created character, let's say; I'd differentiate between commercial and non-commercial use), a lot of (semi-)professional animators, graphic designers and marketing people might buy that.

I mean, apart from Character Creator I'm not really aware of a software that even claims to do this properly outside of academic PoCs. And as I said, CC doesn't really work that well, unfortunately.

So that would be my feedback. Disclaimer: I've only seen the demo video, as I'm unable to install the mobile app at the moment.

imagine99··on Microsoft Sculpt Wired Conversion Mod
I'd actually like a mod the other way round: There are a bunch of great mechanical keyboards (such WASD V3, daskeyboard prime or many other amazing custom builds) but they are all wired. I don't know why they don't make proper mechanical wireless keyboards (they are bulky enough that a battery should easily find space). But a wireless conversion mod would be the next best thing.

Due to my (unchangeable) desk situation, wired keyboards aren't really a possibility, so this is a real gap in the market for me and I was quite surprised, given the extreme multitude of keyboard models in the world, that I wasn't able to find one (or even have one custom built within a reasonable price range) that ticked all the boxes.

Unfortunately, my electronics talent is by far not good enough to attempt something like the linked article (but in reverse, as it were).

imagine99··on Who Is Still Buying VHS Tapes?
Sure. I like the Tandberg NEOs StorageLoader for smaller deployments. It has slots for 8 tapes which it can automatically change and spit out as you want. It's pretty small as far as tape loaders go in that it only takes up a single rack unit (but it's still very deep, so you need a full-depth rack to properly store it). It's currently sold with drives for LTO generations 6 to 8 built in (the drive comes with it and is mounted in the back but it can be removed and you can upgrade it after some years; the loader itself basically only does the job of feeding the tapes from the magazines into the drive and unloading them again after, or putting them in the mailslot for removal). It's like a tiny robot living in your server rack which I think is neat.

If you need to back up 4 TB of data, I recommend you go with LTO-7 tapes whose native capacity is 6 TB (uncompressed). LTO-6 only has 2.5 TB native capacity, so that might not be enough for you, also it's a bit old (LTO-6 was released in 2012). Note that you'll always find the compressed capacity in the marketing material but that's not very useful to calculate with unless you know the data that's to be backed up very well.

Tape capacity usually doubles every four years (more or less) when a new generation is released (to an extent it's a scheme, but technical progress does play into it as well). Backwards compatibility is limited as I said, usually drives can read two generations back and write one generation). Due to some shenanigans this does not currently hold true for LTO-8 drives (the latest gen that's widely available), which can only read back LTO-7 and LTO-8 tapes but not the older LTO-6 tapes. So you have to remember that if you have very long archival cycles to consider (thinking in decades).

LTO-8 is still somewhat more expensive, as it is the latest available gen. While LTO-9 was technically released late last year, I haven't seen it anywhere in the wild yet. They're pretty slow on the uptake, last generation it was the same and there weren't enough LTO-8 tapes for almost two years after "release" which is why they "invented" a stop-gap standard called LTO M-8, iirc, which used LTO-7 tapes but you could write 9 TB on them when using LTO-8 drives).

Long story short, LTO-7 (drive and tape) is probably your best bet in terms of economics and availability (although, if you're sure you'll be fine with LTO-6 for the foreseeable future, you might be able to save maybe $1-2k that way).

The NEOs series devices (incl. the NEOs StorageLoader) come with SAS or Fibre Channel interfaces, I recommend you use SAS, as it's cheaper and easier to get HBAs (adapter cards for your storage server) for SAS. If you use ESXi/vSphere, get an HBA that's on the compatibility list and you can pass it through to a VM to host the backup software on there and control the storage loader (not officially supported by all companies but works very well in my experience).

You do need a server to "control" and "feed" the StorageLoader and this can be pretty much anything you can put a SAS card in (as I said, incl. a VM). I recommend you combine it with Veeam Backup & Replication which is the best backup software currently out there imo, works beautifully with VMs and a diverse range of endpoints and natively supports backing up on a tape loader as the ultimate target (you can get creative there, do hourly backups to disk and send one batch to tape every evening for example).

One caveat: Tapes must be fed at constant speed while writing or they do something called "shoe-shining" which isn't good for the longevity of the tape. You'd have to look up the exact numbers but feeding the tape directly over 1 Gbit Ethernet via iSCSI from a backup appliance with the server as a proxy... that's probably going to be too slow (if you use Veeam, it will show you what the bottleneck is during the backup process). 10 Gbit would be better but you can also fill the storage server with a few TBs of HDDs, let the agents backup there directly and then go from there to tape which would solve any speed problems and will be sufficient for small to medium-sized setups. I recommend you combine that with ReFS if you run Windows Server 2019 (which is trippy but can save a lot of space).

You can fill LTO-7 tapes with a max. speed of 300 MB/s uncompressed, which means backing up your 2 TB would take less than 2 hours. If your files compress well and your backup source can handle it, write speeds may increase up to 750 MB/s, so you will be that much faster.

The price you're looking at for the NEOs is around $4k. For the SAS HBA you can calculate about $200, add the cables and a Veeam license and a few tapes to get you started (LTO-7 tapes can be had for around $50 currently, doesn't matter which brand you buy) and you're at less than $5k all-in, if a storage server or VM host already exists. That's not too bad for total peace of mind and the level of flexibility and safety that tape backup gives you. You should get yourself a cleaning cartridge, too, as this is a highly mechanical technology and the drive needs cleaning cycle every once in a while (if you keep it in the storage loader it will use it on its own when necessary).

If you keep a few tapes in rotation (which I recommend), you'll find that some SSDs or HDDs in your org will die on you before you need to replace a tape for the first time. So the value for money is very good. You can reuse a tape many times (up to 250 full rewrites) and if you fully encrypt all your backups (which of course you do), you can sell on your used tapes later, there are companies who buy them up, so you don't have to throw them out (you can degauss them but then they're usually trash).

However, I strongly recommend that you regularly physically remove the tapes from the loader (even if you have one with 48 or more slots), as not doing so negates one of the major advantages of tape which is offline backup and off-site storage (= fully disaster- and ransomware-proof without much additional thought). Also, keep your storage server secure as the baddies are wising up to this and I know at least one recent case where they got into the storage server and issued commands from there to the tape loader to load all tapes from its magazine and overwrite them one by one (the failure here is obviously more than a technical one). Again, you can use WORM tapes (write once, read many) to prevent that also but imo that's a waste of tape.

As for the loader and drive themselves, they are mechanical, as I said, but typically very stable and come with long warranties. I've seen tape loaders run for well over a decade without major issues (most are replaced or upgraded before they break). You have to treat them well though, so data-center climate is very much their natural habitat (no vibrations or movement, not too much or too little humidity, not too much heat, no dust or corrosive climate etc.).

If space is at a premium and you don't have a rack available (e.g. at a tiny branch office), there are external LTO drives as well (without a tape loader). These are usually in the 5.25 form factor (like those old CD drives) and function not unlike old floppy drives, you pop in a single tape, write on it, pop it out again. You can technically connect these to your workstation directly. You still need an SAS interface though, because as I said, alas I am not aware of one with a more modern interface like Thunderbolt. So connecting one to a laptop is pretty much impossible (there are adapters out there but very expensive and I've no idea if they work). Bottom line, I would not recommend you get one of these. They have none of the convenience of the a tape loader where you can just drop in a handful of tapes and forget about them for a while, as they can only handle the one tape at a time (it's really just a simple drive). And they are severely overpriced for that. You can have a look at the HP StoreEver 15000 (exists as an internal or external device) which isn't bad but clocks in at $3.5k - for just $500 more you can get the full NEOs incl. drive, so it really doesn't make much sense unless you can get one cheap/used (you can find the LTO-6 version for around $1500).

Right. I hope that "little" overview helps you in some way :-)

imagine99··on Who Is Still Buying VHS Tapes?
To my knowledge, there is still no alternative to tape backups that comes close in terms of price per TB, size/capacity, resilience and safety/security. Even for a smaller or mid-sized business, if you want to make sure you have a copy of your files that you can keep 100% safe in a ransomware attack, or that you can get out in a jiff during or before a disaster, a small tape loader for 3-5k that can keep up to 8 tapes in automatic rotation will get you there and is money well spent.

End of each day (or work week) you let the little robot inside the loader drop one tape drop into the "mail slot" and remove it, quick and easy. You now have a full offline backup that won't even be destroyed if you drop it (usually). I think, if every company did that, we'd see a lot less impact from ransomware attacks. (There are also WORM tapes for archival purposes that can't be overwritten, so if you don't want to remove tapes every so often, you can just use these.)

The only thing that bugs me is that there is very little innovation in that field, it's basically one or two companies that manufacture tapes, drives and loaders and they have some clever practices that force you to upgrade every 5 years or so (new drives are only backward-compatible for one generation usually). The market is really geared extremely towards large enterprise only. The loaders have ancient web UIs from the 90s, the connection ports are also legacy or datacenter-only (SCSI usually), unfortunately you won't find a tape drive with USB3/Thunderbolt (I'd probably buy one for my home if they existed, I'm imagining them in a nice form factor similar to the old Zip Drives).

I've never understood why tapes as storage and backup media aren't more popular. In practice, they really don't have many downsides that I have noticed. That whole technology is incredibly mature and therefore very reliable.

imagine99··on My Life in E-Ink
I've long wrestled with myself whether to buy a remarkable (2) and have finally decided against it because I expect that I will own another technical device that will be obsolete and an expensive door stopper in a couple years time (made that mistake with a 1st gen Kindle). Also, while it's extremely sleek, my main use for paper & pen these days is for editing and it's just no fun without a red pen ;-)

My expectation (and sincere hope, ngl) is that we will see a major innovation push in e-Ink displays and devices over the next year(s) and I have now resolved to buy a remarkable 3 (or 4) which will hopefully be available in color (and fully usable without any mandatory public cloud tethering). And maybe with some saner pricing options. I mean, a cover for $150? That makes it clear that this is a veblen good, not a workhorse for a wide audience (like schools, students etc.) - or it's Apple-monitor-stand-style consumer rip-off, who knows. I'd much prefer a faux-leather option anyway (not too comfortable with wrapping my tablet in dead cow skin, but don't like the $79 grey option either) but they unfortunately don't offer that.

imagine99··on 26 Years of Delphi
Care to share some examples of what you're doing? I'm always curious...
imagine99··on 26 Years of Delphi
> for most the time of the Desktop computer has passed Might I respectfully disagree? Whenever I walk into a business, especially a larger one with open floor offices (and I admit, it has been a while, for obvious reasons), I see exactly one thing: Rows of desktop PCs (incl. laptop). Not tablets. Not smartphones. Desktop PCs (whether they run VDI or aren't much bigger than a CD case is immaterial). I'd strongly argue that most productive work on an electronic device is still performed at desktops (or laptops, which in this case are the same thing).

I get that when it comes to consumers, mobile is king and all that. That might be true. But for businesses, the choice of developing an internal tool web-based rather than cranking it out in Delphi and copying the exe on a network share, is simply down to the availability of developers. Not many decision-makers today still know about Delphi as a viable alternative (even for web and mobile development btw!) and when you can get much more developers at reasonable rates for React projects and don't have to fork over thousands to an unsympathetic company called Idera, well, it's almost a no-brainer.

But I'd still argue that you can get more done in an afternoon with Delphi than with Vue if you start with a blank slate - and at a fraction of keystrokes, too! ;-) ~> change my mind :-)

imagine99··on 26 Years of Delphi
Oh, I can answer that one: By purposefully ruining - and continuing to ruin - a great community of developers around Delphi.

I apologize in advance for what will be a salty (but truthful, I hope) statement, and it was invited, so I would like to give it in the hope that it might be heard by someone who can do something about it.

You, Idera, just can't get it into your heads that the success of a programming language is measured in how many people are using it, learning it, messing around with it. Not how many Enterprise customers you have that you have locked into buying upgrades.

There are statements out there (even from veteran Delphi people I really respect) who seriously argue that "we can't put out a free version of Delphi because it will be abused". I can barely respond to that in friendly words, I'll only say that's total madness. Even purveyors of software orders of magnitude more expensive than Delphi (architecture and 3D modelling come to mind, even some movie and music producers) have understood that if you make it available at no charge to students and young people, to groups who just don't have the money, they will be the ones that will buy it at full price as soon as they have the chance.

It happened to me. I think I can admit it here, as many have: My first steps into programming where with a copy of Delphi on an unmarked CD decades ago. It was a rush, a high like I've never experienced again. Truly my first love. And when I later got some job responsibility, I actually got a purchase order through for a Delphi Architect edition (the most expensive SKU). But these times are long gone and are unlikely to repeat because today's students don't have the Delphi community anymore that I had to teach me.

But Delphi's current (and previous) owners just don't get that. To them, Delphi seems to be something "elite", something only people paying thousands of bucks should get access to. Taking free money from a few legacy firms, who's going to say not to that?

No, you will not extract a couple thousand bucks from a small student programmer. No, you will not get programmers in poorer countries to buy your software at these prices. You will especially not stop bigger organizations or people who truly want to abuse it. If they need it, they will pirate it, just like they do with Adobe, Microsoft etc. Don't think you're better and cleverer than those guys. The joke is probably (I suspect) that pirated versions are still easier to install than getting the dated 12-months community edition of Delphi with all its nagging.

One could probably find an argument where it would be fair to pay good money for new Delphi versions every now and then. But you don't put nearly enough effort in improving the IDE (the object inspector is still horrible to use if you're doing UI-heavy work - there is e.g. still no "favorites" tab), you still don't support PNG and JPG across the board or make it possible to play an MP4 file in the mediaplayer component. No transparent TEdit, TMemo, a lot of new component implementations are half-hearted at best. The list of little buggy, annoying things that are unchanged for 20 years is endless. You just don't care.

The only one you hurt with this, Idera, is yourself and the community (and by that, again, yourself). The Delphi community was one of the most vibrant and multi-faceted in the world. Thousands of components for anything you could possibly imagine. Great forums and message boards that put StackExchange to shame. All that was literally choked off because Embarcadero wanted to make an extra buck. It was not because of Python or Java. Those just filled a void you purposefully created.

And now Delphi 10.4 has been out for almost 10 months and you still haven't been able to publish a free community edition for it, still insisting on rubbing it in everybody's face that you consider community edition users to be barely legal freeloaders who can do just well with an old and buggy edition (which e.g. still doesn't support the new Chromium Edge browser component afaik).

So, shame on you Idera/Embarcadero. And, frankly, shame on the old Delphi guys supporting this behavior and not taking a stand for a great language and a great community and for not forcing Idera to do things differently. You guys still have a voice, still have name recognition in the community, use it to talk sense and reason, effect change!

I for one still think, like several others here, that Delphi even today remains unsurpassed in several aspects (especially in the rapid development of UI and Windows-heavy apps). But that's thanks to a lack of great alternatives, not thanks to Idera's innovation, that's for sure. So don't pat yourself on the back.

All is not lost but we'd have to see a major offensive in terms of openness from Delphi's current owners. It sure would be awesome to make Delphi just half as great as it once was. But why not start small: Put the Community Edition on the same release cycle as the paid versions. Update the UI a bit with some irresistible great features. Then fix bugs and innovate, go into schools and invest, invest, invest in community. It might just pay off...

imagine99··on Read the column The New York Times didn’t want you to read
Another thought, and yes, I am going full Godwin here, because I think it's an important intellectual leap to make: In many European countries, using Nazi symbols such as the swastika is a criminal offence, so you can't use the symbol in games, in advertising or as a bumper sticker. However, it is not a criminal offence to show the symbol in a history class; to display it in a museum; to show it in a PowerPoint presentation during a lecture on WWII at university, to print it in a newspaper showing a defaced building etc. It is, above all, not a crime to say "Hitler" or "swastika" out loud. There is no "He said the H word". Even though these are arguably the most universal signs of hate and murder, you are allowed to discuss them. "Lest we forget", I believe is the saying often used with this rationale: If you prohibited anybody from ever talking about it or mentioning it, it would be forgotten after one generation at the latest, and with it all the important lessons learned from that terrible period of human history.

"He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named" in Harry Potter is another example of a rhetorical device used to instill bloodcurdling fear and larger-than-life authority of a a Wizard-of-Oz-style villain. Note that this is a children's book. Every adult person should be able to see through that.

And so - I am sure, there are many other examples - I ask again: Why do such things keep happening? Why, when individuals are clearly able of rational thought, as the editor's initial reaction shows, does there seem to be a hive-mind or "invisible hand of the market", or whatever you call it, that seems to get large groups of people to come together and stone someone for saying "Jehova" because his wife's cooking was so excellent.

I ask this sincerely, even though I use comedic examples. For me, this is an existential question of one's own sanity, that I struggle to comprehend what really is going on here, and I would love to hear what others think about this.

Could a possible answer be, and I realize I might be getting controversial here, could it be that modern American society, lacking a nuanced way of looking at difficult historic matters - because it always seems to be either "Free Speech" or "Death" with no middle way - has chosen this visceral reaction because it never learned to deal with or discuss its history in a non-confrontational, level-headed manner? Clearly, using $badword in normal everyday conversation is unacceptable. So it follows from there - using this logic framework - that any use whatsoever is unacceptable? Just spitballing here, looking for answers. Could very well be that I am wrong. If so, please don't downvote me but instead explain. Thank you.

imagine99··on Read the column The New York Times didn’t want you to read
There's this famous scene in "The life of Brian" where they gather round to stone an old man to death because he said "Jehova". The judge, in speaking to the condemned, himself mentions the word "Jehova" and promptly gets stones thrown at him by all the wom---, uh, men in the audience.

This scene immediately comes to mind because in the film it is obviously ridiculous and everybody can see that. The judge had no other way to express himself without going through some weird verbal contortions. He could, I suppose, have said "Look, he said the J-word!" but that probably was too ridiculous a thought even for Monty Python. He wasn't using the word maliciously, he reported a fact, yet he was in the end seen to be no better than the convict himself.

I wonder if the person who reported the Times journalist to the editor-in-chief also said "Look, he said $badword", and was himself promptly fired.

My point is, every individual person who looks at that situation this way will probably find it comical or at least clearly not to be a firing offence. The Times itself has printed the word in question many times in its reporting, even in recent times. Do they now get to fire themselves, retroactively, as seems to be so en vogue these days? Of course not. Will they print apologies for printing $badword in their paper as recently as 2019? Unlikely.

It is also plainly obvious that "bans on words" that go so far as to be "bans on thoughts" can therefore never serve any good purpose and are a hallmark of totalitarianism.

So why does this keep happening? Why are people getting fired for Monty-Python-level "offences"? Has reality (once again) surpassed satire? Are people getting stupider, weirder, more irrational? Or is there something else at play here?

My point is, most individuals for themselves will recognise the behaviour here as "not horrible", not worthy of a career-death sentence, and judge accordingly, even if only preserve a modicum of nuance and differentiation in handing out sentences. Nobody will probably question the importance of having some steps available inbetween "You are innocent" and "You shall be put to death".

Nobody disputes that the reporter didn't use the word in any bad way; on the contrary, it was used to help and advise someone, a 12 year old student, on the matter: "Look here, young child, it's better if you don't say Jehova". Done. Stoned to death.

Even the editor-in-chief, Baquet, initially said the same in a staff memo: There was no bad intent, all is well. A sane, tempered reaction, level-headed analysis, case closed. Then a few days passed, some meetings happened, he changed his mind and the journalist got fired. Say what?

The more I think about it, the more confused I am, like I am missing a big piece of the puzzle here. Why does this keep happening? Why are people acting like they have been "neuralyzed", Men in Black-style? What an odd situation.

imagine99··on Amazon competitor got our belt listing taken down by saying it contains drugs
That's actually very interesting. One problem I have started to run into recently however, is that you can't mention the word "blockchain" any more without being laughed out of the room (in some circles), and in many cases rightly so. The word has just been to much vaporware-ified and misused because VCs and other decision-makers were eating it up like crazy.

However, it seems like blockchain-based technologies are to be an integral part of web3, or are there alternatives to it? Is there a way to talk about the concept without mentioning blockchain?

imagine99··on Amazon competitor got our belt listing taken down by saying it contains drugs
No, you're missing the point completely. His competitors were using the same data source. The problem here is not ads appearing next to "bad" words, or what and who gets to decide what "bad" words even are, that's a whole other discussion.

The issue here is that Google, Amazon or $bigcorp allows its "blocking" algorithm to be misused, to be weaponized by competitors and that it allows no possibility of human review, that you can't get any human via phone or email to review a completely arbitrary (and often enough plain wrong) decision a random algo has committed (through human instigation or on its own rampage, as it happens often enough). That nobody has to account for and take responsibility for algorithmic decisions ("Sorry, computer says no. Good bye).

I have become so frustrated with this issue (we seem to discuss it every other day on HN) that I've come to think that you should not be allowed to offer services using automation without a clear and working process of escalation to a human in case of trouble. If we allow this behavior to continue and to spread (and look, I get it, doing business this way is very attractive and scales beautifully), things will only get worse.

We'll get to the point where it's "sorry, your car was deactivated because $passenger reported that you used a bad word in his presence. Do not contact us again". Maybe this will wake people up and show them that this way of offering services is broken.

Or "sorry, our algorithm decided you get the death penalty based on 100 reports of people that you did $badthing. chops head off Sorry, don't contact us again." Too much hyperbole? We'll see. Algorithmic determination of prison sentences already exists.

imagine99··on Amazon competitor got our belt listing taken down by saying it contains drugs
The question is: How do you enforce that or even complain about it? Say your Amazon account gets locked for whatever reason due to an automated decision (probably all of these decisions are automated). There is no way to contact Amazon without an account. It's not like they have a link on their website that says "Request human appeal under GDPR" (I haven't checkt tbh, but I'm 99.9% sure they haven't).

I wonder what happens if you file e.g. in small claims court against a company like Amazon? They'd probably never get the message, and even if you win due to them not showing up and making their case, good luck enforcing the judgement.

Short of hiring a major law firm whose letterhead might get someone's attention and/or making major waves, I don't see how Joe Sixpack can force a human appeal without major monetary outlay.

I think their strategy of burying their head in the sand and just ghosting you works probably pretty well for the large majority of cases where people simply won't bother (or be able to bother). The cost for the one or two cases that have the energy and commitment to fight is comparably minor and quickly resolved once it hits the front pages somewhere.

imagine99··on Terraria on Stadia cancelled after developer's Google account gets locked
Sounds like I'll have to check out Fastmail :-) However, please bear in mind that if you've got to switch over a whole organisation, you'll have to keep UI friction to a minimum. Users who have used Gmail for almost a decade (our Outlook, for that matter) will be extremely hesitant to be dragged over on to a new service. I guess, a fully featured mail server doing all the work in the background while offering you a front and that looks like OWA, Gmail or $UI would be ideal (pipe-dream, I know, but wouldn't it be great?). Still, I get what you're saying and I'll look into it. Do you have any experience with Fastmail for business? Can it be branded and used with different domains and aliases without paying through the nose?
imagine99··on Terraria on Stadia cancelled after developer's Google account gets locked
I will look into it. Thanks.
imagine99··on Terraria on Stadia cancelled after developer's Google account gets locked
You have to understand that this is SINO (service in name only), an offering that is there on paper to satisfy procurement requirements of businesses ("Does this product offer this service with that SLA? If yes, you can buy it. If not, you can't"). That doesn't say anything about the efficacy of this service. In fact you will find that it isn't very useful (I've only had to use it once, but still, useless and frustrating, not much different from talking with GPT3). Many if not most enterprise software vendors have SINO offerings, Microsoft and VMware are just two I experienced personally that provide you with certain 24/7 telephone support lines which will not do anything but waste time until the next morning (if you're lucky) where you might be able to get an escalation. So if you're buying ESXi hoping that VMware might help you fix a pink screen at 2 in the morning, you are mistaken. But management will be able to tell everybody "yes, we have a 30 minute SLA on this with the vendor". Sure.

Lastly, you might also find that you will not be able to access the support options anymore if you have real problems or once your account has been locked for whatever reason. There are several services like this out there and I have seen it happen once at an old company: Provider locked a whole group of users out of the platform because of "suspicious login activity" on the admin account (admin was overseas). To access the support page you had to login first. Which you couldn't. Because it was locked. Took three weeks and snail mail (!) to get access to the platform back. Cancelled right after.

I would be extremely surprised if paying $6/month meant that your experience was different. Not that it shouldn't be, mind you, of course it should. I'm just saying it likely won't, so don't bet on it...

imagine99··on Terraria on Stadia cancelled after developer's Google account gets locked
Sorry, how does paying for Google Workspace prevent you from getting your account locked and not being able to do something about it? I do believe that to login to the admin back-end and to contact support in the first place, you need to log in with your Google account.

Also, their support is... not exactly useful. I had to use it once a couple years ago (a feature wasn't working, I forgot which one) and all they could offer where excuses and "we take XY very seriously" and "thanks for bringing this to our attention". They never fixed it, of course.

Google has excellent engineers who crank out amazing stuff with a passion. Google is however shockingly bad in converting these things into something of lasting value, supporting and improving the excellent seeds they have/had (just look at the famous Google graveyard). As money is no object for Google, you can only come to the conclusion that all this is done on purpose and even purposely sinister. They focus on their ad business as that has a ROI that blows literally any other product in existence out of the water. And they just don't bother with anything else anymore. I mean, why would you spend your days toiling, building and maintaining stuff earning a decent (but not an obscene) wage if you had an ATM, nay a dozen, that just shoot free money at you all day like crazy. I can understand it, but it's still sad, from a societal perspective ("make the world a better place" etc. etc.).

imagine99··on Terraria on Stadia cancelled after developer's Google account gets locked
There is no other service with feature parity on the UI alone out there. I've searched one for ages and would switch the whole org over in a New York minute if there was an (ideally open-source) "copy" of the Gmail UI available as front-end for one of the other mail servers. Features we can't do without nowadays are tagging; advanced filter and forwarding rules; split inbox with tabs for ads, newsletters, social media; support for multiple domains (10+) and dozens of aliases per user which you can easily switch between; 30 sec undo after sending an email; send later function; snappy UI that's not from the 90s.

Also, unfortunately Gmail/Gsuite is very cost-effective for us. We've looked at ProtonMail which seemed nice and potentially worth supporting but they would have cost us probably ten times or more what Gsuite costs (for email service only!) thanks to having to buy a ton of add-ons to get feature parity (they actually do charge extra for pretty much each custom domain and alias you want to use). And buying 100 GB of storage costs an eye-watering $120/month ($1.99 on Gsuite). I really don't know why their pricing is so weird. I know they can't probably scale as well on storage but adding aliases does not cause any measurable additional cost for them...

Anyway, if anyone decides to make a Gmail UI clone with a reasonable spam filter and pricing that's at most 2x what Google charges: Please let me know, I will migrate 120 new users to you within a couple weeks (not much on a grand scale but it's what I can offer...) :-)

imagine99··on Super-expressive – Write regex in natural language
I’ve often wondered why there isn't a tool that generates regex for you automatically when you feed it a number of similar strings. Is this too complicated mathematically (even for machine-learning), or does such a thing actually exist (and I just don’t know about it)?

Imagine you want to write a regex that captures hex values such as 0xC0D3. You enter a few sample values (the more you enter, the more concise the regex which the generator will spit out) and the generator should easily discover that all your values start with 0x followed by exactly four digits 0-9 or a-f and give you a (albeit maybe not the best, or several) expression it can. Bonus points if it indeed explains in natural language each part of the regex it generated...

I’d imagine this would also be a great tool for learning regex, a sort-of “learning by reverse-engineering” if you will.

I seem to need regex only once every two years or so, which is not enough to learn it properly or, if I did, to retain it. So such a tool would be awesome.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →