HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

indoclay

28 karma · joined July 20, 2022

submissionscomments
indoclay··on Oregon law rolling back drug decriminalization set to take effect
Being forced anywhere starts to sound like jail, except it would be a free for all in there. How would the policy force anyone into a camp without guards? Why would this work great?
indoclay··on China orders telcos to rip out American chips by 2027
US imports from China is ~2% of US GDP and largely in electronics [0], which are actively being targeted for sanctions. It will be painful but not catastrophic for the US to "de-risk".

China has to import both energy and food to sustain it's economy and population[1, 2]. There is very little domestic consumption to absorb their own production capacity and western countries are actively blocking their markets, like the EV situation in Europe or electronics with the US.

They have a very bleak demographic picture with a massively aging population along with some of the lowest fertility rates in the world[3]. It is odd to think of China as running out of people[4], but there will be two elder dependents for every working age person very soon.

There is an expectation of a full on collapse coming and local governments there are already $100TN+ in debt collectively[5]. If there was a pivot possible, would anyone provide that capital with what is happening with the Evergrande liquidation where foreign capital is the first to get wiped out?

Any company that hasn't pivoted to India or some other SEA country for manufacturing will simply be left behind.

[0] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/visualized-ranking-the-good...

[1] https://www.cfr.org/article/china-increasingly-relies-import...

[2] https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61843

[3] https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/china-demographic...

[4] https://jonathanrileywriter.medium.com/chinese-demographic-d...

[5] https://www.wsj.com/world/china/chinas-colossal-hidden-debt-...

indoclay··on Boeing whistleblower found dead in US
I think we could agree generally that "the hostile work environment at Boeing ... led to his death." It is appalling that they could apply this kind of pressure to one of their own .

I'm not familiar with the process here, but does anyone know if the officer makes the determination that this is a "self-inflicted gunshot wound"? I thought that kind of assessment was for the coroner to determine over the course of the investigation.

indoclay··on FCC Authorizes over $18B to Expand Rural Broadband
I take it you did this yourself but that is definitely not the cost of paying someone to do it for you. There is no way you can purchase the fiber and pay someone to trench and lay it for you for under $1.50/ft.

I would have preferred a program where in rural counties the up front cost of acquiring the $599 kit can be claimed as a tax credit.

In the FCC press release above,

> Collectively, these companies are committing to deploy broadband service of at least 100/20 Mbps service to over 700,000 locations and to maintain or improve existing 100/20 Mbps service to approximately 2 million locations in 44 states across the United States.

That is Starlink bandwidth and that 18B would pay for 30M install kits instead of just 2.7M homes.

indoclay··on FCC Authorizes over $18B to Expand Rural Broadband
Why does it matter if they are getting government funding when the article is discussing government subsidy to the tune of $18B?

It might be more cost effective to service rural customers using Starlink. I know of many people working remotely using it. Some of which have fiber at the road in front of them, running it up to their rural home from the road would still cost tens of thousands out of pocket and opted for Starlink.

If we are all helping pay to deliver internet access to every part of this country, which I wholeheartedly agree with, could we do so in a way that maybe also helps R&D space travel instead of whatever Comcast or Verizon is doing?

indoclay··on YouTube blocks Russell Brand from making money through its platform
What evidence has been provided to meet this preponderance of evidence standard you are putting forward for moral evaluation?

You have one party making an allegation claiming they have documents to back it up and the other party denying innocence with claims of their own exculpatory evidence. Nothing has been shared to the public by either party for me evaluate who has the preponderance of evidence.

I do believe YouTube (or any other private platform) can and should be able to set it's own rules for participation so I see no issue with what they did here. If it's a right for someone to be on that platform then we should not be relying on a private party to guarantee that and make the necessary legislative changes.

I would just love to understand why I should be outraged at this individual before anything has been presented before me so that I can evaluate for myself.

indoclay··on YouTube blocks Russell Brand from making money through its platform
> If people find these allegations credible—and most should

Why should most people find these allegations credible? I do not believe there is a police report, arrest, and let alone a trial. These are currently just allegations, their credibility has not been adjudicated.

indoclay··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
That is by design and I consider it a feature rather than a bug. We have options to live at a local or state level closer to our own values rather than being forced to conform at a national level.

Our national institutions are very accepting of LGBTQ as well as the federal government. Looking at LGBTQ equality by state, https://www.lgbtmap.org/equality-maps the majority of the country, 29 states are fair or pro LGBTQ vs 21 that have negative policy or low equality.

Additionally, 71% of people support same-sexy marriages https://news.gallup.com/poll/393197/same-sex-marriage-suppor...

Is it still counterculture when it is accepted and embraced by the overwhelming majority of citizens, education and cultural institutions, and protected by laws in the majority of the country?

indoclay··on How Twitter moderated the Covid debate
Looking at the results disparity for "noble lie" and +covid both in the news and search tabs in Google is really eye opening given everything that has been released with twitter's moderation tooling with regards to deboosting and view filtering.

It seems only conservative and libertarian sources are covering the recent deposition in which he confessed that he knowingly made false public health statements in the early days of the pandemic. Both moderation and policy decisions were based on these statements.

indoclay··on How Twitter moderated the Covid debate
My bad, that's on me, I am having trouble parsing out sarcasm with some of the comments on this topic.
indoclay··on How Twitter moderated the Covid debate
What makes it noble and who gets to decide when the interest of the public good is sufficient to suspend the rights of the citizenry? If it is to be believed that most people lack the intelligence to behave in ways that are in their own and society’s best interest then what is the point of democracy? What other rights are we willing to suspend for the interest of the public? Even if it is justified in this instance, what else could the precedent be used for?

This subversion of rights and erosion of trust with government actors directly pushing for censorship, no matter what the intentions, will cast doubt on the system as a whole and any purpose it might have in the short term is far outweighed by the damage it causes in the long term.

I highly recommend reading the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, specifically articles 51 through 55.

indoclay··on The Twitter Files Part 2: Twitter's Secret Blacklists
> misrepresented the case for limiting the Dr’s reach

Could you help me understand what the argument is that this person should have been put on any form of blacklist?

indoclay··on The Twitter Files
For this specific example with the laptop, Twitter censored the the White House press secretary by suspending her account.

https://twitter.com/mtaibbi/status/1598831758207696896