HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

induscreep

84 karma · joined April 26, 2012

submissionscomments
induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
> Changing employers after 180 days have elapsed should not affect the underlying approved I-140.

Employers can actually withdraw the I-140 if you switch jobs BEFORE filing I-485 and letting 6 months elapse - and then you have to start all over again.

http://www.murthy.com/2008/01/18/ac21-frequently-asked-quest...

The green card has become the new "leash" for H1Bs.

induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
> management prefers a pliant, docile, easily controlled workforce

I am trying to understand why, and what the incentive is. If the overall cost balloons up, what is it about a docile workforce that is so lucrative to these companies? Ability to pay lower wages? Not having to search for replacement employees every now and then?

induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
> if they have an I-485 application pending for six months and an approved I-140

That is related to a green card. And yes, employers typically try to file your I-140 under EB-3. This means that you need to wait 10+ years before your priority date becomes current. Once the PD is current, you can file your I-485. After another 6 months elapse, ONLY THEN can you invoke AC21. In effect, the employee is tied to the employer for 10+ years since companies only file for your green card after you spend ~6 years on H1B. The decision of EB-3 vs EB-2 (about 5 years shorter) lies with the employer. These two categories of green card cannot be self petitioned, only an employer can do it.

EDIT: So to summarize, the employee usually is first locked in during the 6 years on H1B, with the hope that the employer will apply for a green card (i.e. file the I-140).

Then, the employee is locked in for another 10 years, waiting for the PD to become current. And then, after 6 more months, the employee is finally free to change employers.

I don't understand how this isn't indentured servitude.

induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
H1B portability is a misnomer. All that happens is that the new employer applies for a new H1B for you, which is not subject to the cap. So you are just tied to the new employer. Portability here just means that you can choose which employer to be tied to.

http://www.immihelp.com/visas/h1b/h1-transfer.html

induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
Penalizing early exit with loss of immigration status could be illegal...penalizing with money is probably not.
induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
So there's a high initial cost involved, but then the company can wage suppress the employee over the next 5-6 years, and in the end turn a profit? Wow.
induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
EDIT: AC21 is for those who are applying for a green card (I-485 pending). How the heck is AC21 even connected to H1B? Source/link please?

EDIT2: H1B transfer does not seem to involve AC21. All that happens is that the new employer will need to apply for a H1B petition all over again. So you are simply tied to the new employer, instead of your old employer.

http://www.immihelp.com/visas/h1b/h1-transfer.html

AC21 is not free, there are legal fees and processing times involved. There is a non-zero cost involved. If this cost did not exist, if an employee could just switch jobs WITHOUT needing the receiving company to do anything, then obviously there would be no wage suppression. Employee can ask for a raise, and simply leave if refused.

induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
Does anyone know if this situation is specific to IT/tech/computer science related companies? Does it happen to, say, petroleum engineers?
induscreep··on Job brokers steal wages and entrap Indian tech workers in US
Isn't the "something else" just money? The employer gets an employee who is afraid to ask for a raise, since that might mean losing immigration status and returning to a (not as comfortable) life in their home country. With the green card process taking a few good years, the employer has an indentured servant. Indian born CEO or American born, money is money to them.

Immigration reform is essential. If someone on a temporary visa asks "for more" like you did, they might just get fired and replaced with another temporary visa worker. So, they don't end up asking for raises, which means that the labor rate is artificially depressed. If H1Bs were not tied to employers, then this would not happen. BUT this is not in the employer's interest, so I don't think this has a chance of changing.

induscreep··on Calories in, calories out
Hmm but you can still lose weight by eating low satiety index foods, as long as a calorie deficit is present. This means eating smaller portions of these foods. It just takes more self control because the body "feels hungry" when in fact it isn't.
induscreep··on Calories in, calories out
Have you tried high protein-low carb instead of high fat-low carb?
induscreep··on Calories in, calories out
There was some research that showed that the brain goes into hunting mode _for protein_, and it gets satiated when enough protein is had.

But, today's sugary foods contain less protein than before, so we keep eating these foods until the quota of protein has been met. This is why probably the keto diet reduces appetite.

induscreep··on Calories in, calories out
Diets are more about getting people to not feel hungry. This is done by reducing carbs, and increasing fat/protein. So, people won't "feel hungry" on a low carb diet, and thus, they are less likely to binge or gorge on some snack.
induscreep··on Calories in, calories out
Anyone have insight on how "my thyroid" affects weight gain/loss? As in, does TDEE decrease when something is wrong with the thyroid? If a typical TDEE is 2200 calories, then with thyroid problems, will it go down to 1500, or is 2100 a more likely figure?
induscreep··on Workers paid $1.21 an hour to install Fremont tech company's computers
One of the most sensible questions in this thread...
induscreep··on CBS Offers Web Service as TV Unbundles Itself
ultra basic cable is free. Over the air broadcasts.
induscreep··on Hacker News API
Finally, an AlienBlue caliber app for HN is now possible. Soon.
induscreep··on CDC confirms first Ebola case diagnosed in US
Also, there were patients with Lhasa fever and Marburg in the USA before - and nothing happened. Ebola is hyped up because there's an outbreak in Africa.
induscreep··on ISRO Mars Orbiter Mission: Spacecraft successfully enters Martian Orbit
Er yes I can. I want to know what is new since the 1971 orbiter success, and why India cannot put a rover on Mars.
induscreep··on ISRO Mars Orbiter Mission: Spacecraft successfully enters Martian Orbit
Maybe I should rephrase. Is this mission a scientific achievement? It could be a economics/accounting/marketing/HR/logistics achievement, but what is new scientifically?
induscreep··on ISRO Mars Orbiter Mission: Spacecraft successfully enters Martian Orbit
Is this really an achievement when someone else could do it in 1965? Is it an achievement when other countries can land rovers on mars? India should be a leader, not follow others' footsteps.

EDIT: 1971, not 1965

induscreep··on The Cost of My Mother’s Cardiac Care in the United States and India
But India is 24 hrs away by flight. If there was a list of countries with the flight duration and cost of medical care, what countries would lie on the Pareto front? What if you sorted by a "$-hr" metric?
induscreep··on Show HN: International Development Jargon Detector
I tried uploading a computer science research paper from IEEE - detects "capacity" as jargon haha.
induscreep··on How the global banana industry is killing the world’s favorite fruit
Doesn't Big Banana invest in GMO stuff to make them resistant to a well known disease?
induscreep··on Stripe and Apple Pay
Even BofA in the USA issued tags that could be attached to the back of a phone (or anywhere else).

That's what I don't understand...why does a NFC transaction have to involve smartphones? What is it that needs the processing power of a smartphone? Is it so that Goog Wallet/Apple Pay can access your transaction data?

induscreep··on Stripe and Apple Pay
Yup exactly. What is the incentive here for the banks to allow Apple to tokenize CC numbers, AND pay Apple for it? Some kind of risk/liability reduction?
induscreep··on Stripe and Apple Pay
Interesting. Does this mean that transaction data (what I bought, when I bought) is visible to Google, unlike Apple Pay (claimed)?
induscreep··on iPhone Barometer, Eat My Weather Dongles
Maybe it's about existing dongles communicating with the iPhone.

On that note, is the communication protocol over 3.5mm audio standardized in any way?

induscreep··on iPhone Barometer, Eat My Weather Dongles
What is the point of this article? New iphone has barometer, some android phone dropped thermo/hygrometer support, some other folks made dongles which communicate via 3.5mm...so what.
induscreep··on Stripe and Apple Pay
What I meant to ask was, "what did people do before Stripe came into existence"?
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →