HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

infamouscow

476 karma · joined April 13, 2009

I am not a lawyer. Nothing here is legal advice or creates an attorney-client relationship. Laws vary by jurisdiction. Consult a licensed attorney in your state for advice about your specific situation.
submissionscomments
infamouscow··on C++ Safety, in Context
Virtually everyone wants to improve software and make it more secure. We're approaching it from different angles and it's being confused for disagreement on the topic.

There's a lot of value in having good faith discussion from each perspective so we can mitigate downside risk while enhancing the upside goal. I'm eager to hear your thoughts on the undeniable problems restated in my previous replies.

Google is not a good example -- they're technically competent and were already doing work in Rust. It seems like focusing on small software shops still writing C++89 code would be better thing to focus mental energy on. Are there any examples of those kind of businesses using this WH report to steer their roadmaps or technology directions?

infamouscow··on C++ Safety, in Context
What exactly do you think this report accomplishes?

It's not legally binding like Congressional legislation or an executive order.

Nobody has been prevented from using memory safe languages prior to the report being published. I'm sure there are plenty of instances where consultants and contractors have been required to use C or C++ because it's written into hundreds of thousands of pages of antiquated government contracts, but this report isn't a magic wand that's going to change those contracts. You have to convince the most stuffy lawyers imaginable to change them, which is an expensive endeavor that no reasonable business is going undertake unless it affects their bottom line, and that only happens after Congress passes a law. And prior to a law, there's going to be an army of lobbyists ready to carve out a waiver system, render any hope of improving software quality moot.

I'm of the opinion it's merely a clarion call for D.C. parasites to invent ever-more creative ways to waste tax dollars. Without clear objective success criterion defined by the government, the problem will persist indefinitely. And if you're a bureaucrat with friends and family making millions consulting on this problem, you're disincentivized to solve anything. Why cut off the hand that feeds you.

I'm eager to hear your thoughts about these undeniable problems.

infamouscow··on C++ Safety, in Context
This is a gross mischaracterization. I would encourage you to re-read both of my replies so as to best respond to the points about how government involvement does not actually solve problems, but instead perpetuates problems because of institutional corruption.

Ad hominem attacks are not a counterargument to these inescapable facts, they're also against the community guidelines and do very little to persuade anyone to your position: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

infamouscow··on C++ Safety, in Context
Because there is no clear objective success criterion.

Further, once consultants are being paid, they're disincentivized to actually accomplish this incredibly broad and nebulous goal. It allows politicians to campaign on more secure computing, but never actually accomplishing anything except profiting from their spouse being one of these consultants. And by never solving the problem, it continues, which only further justifies spending more money to "fix" the problem.

You might call this cynical, it's not, it's realistic. I challenge you to find an example where this level of corruption isn't taking place, and explain what makes you so confident that will be the case for this specific issue, drawing specifically on areas of contrast.

If you can overcome the government corruption, you still have to overcome the lobbyists. You can't do both except in situations where the corporations are in cahoots with the government.

infamouscow··on C++ Safety, in Context
The Whitehouse report should scare the shit out of anyone invested in better software. People think the report is a step in the right direction, it's not.

You do not want the blob of D.C. putting their eyes on anything that looks like a bottomless money pit for consultants and self-proclaimed experts. Once that happens and is codified to some degree in law, it's very difficult to change or remove.

This potentially affects every government system in existence, and those systems are already some of the most legacy systems today. The US Navy still pays Microsoft to maintain support for Windows XP, so the idea this will happen in any less than a 25 year horizon is absurd. And even then, the dates can be extended. Why put a stop to the gravy train when it can keep going -- it's not like the public is even aware of just how enormous the federal government really is. Once you understand this an opportunity to extract billions of dollars from large organizations, you then have to ask what their lobbyists will do to change the laws in their favor to completely neuter the legislation codified into law.

I haven't see anyone even consider this highly likely, if not almost certain outcome.

infamouscow··on Deadspin Sold by G/O Media, Entire Staff Laid Off by Email
The reason these are layoffs is because there's no openings for liars, manipulators, and propagandists in the reorg.

Corporate journalists are the enemy of the people. They deserve maximum contempt.

infamouscow··on Fedora Workstation 41 to No Longer Install Gnome X.org Session by Default
I'm sorry, but the users really only have themselves to blame.

The Xorg maintainers have been abundantly clear about this transition for longer than most on this board have been writing code.

Virtually every single program that doesn't work on Wayland is a result of the collective laziness of the userbase for a decade, deciding to fallback to X11 rather than fix problems or be a forcing function to pressure companies to fix software.

You're not entitled to the free labor of open source project maintainers. I don't understand why this is so difficult for some people to grasp.

infamouscow··on Differential: Type safe RPC that feels like local functions
A ZIRP phenomena.
infamouscow··on Fedora Workstation 41 to No Longer Install Gnome X.org Session by Default
Since nobody wants to maintain Xorg anymore, every new CVE puts pressure on distros to also drop support.
infamouscow··on Fedora Workstation 41 to No Longer Install Gnome X.org Session by Default
The Wayland maintainers also maintained X and have been saying they need help for over a decade. Nobody stepped up.
infamouscow··on Journalist casualties in the Israel-Gaza war
The word has been diminished by deranged activists in the US, but in international law it is clearly defined.

The problem Israel has is it has either satisfied all of the criterion for a genocide, or it has satisfied all of the criterion for being apartheid state. There is no inbetween or alternative at this point, so which is it.

You can pick both if you like because it is both.

infamouscow··on Apple terminates Epic Games developer account, calling it a 'threat' to iOS
When this question is asked, it's always with an implicit bias that executives are all morally bankrupt demons that would be beaten to death by the public if not for police.

My response to that is: we should change the laws.

Nobody ever asks this question thinking about multi-generation family businesses where the executive is the head of household and if everything works out, the business will be passed down to their progeny.

Of course, it also begs the question why do we accept this?

infamouscow··on Global Economy Approaches Soft Landing, but Risks Remain
I think what's happened is compensation packages have normalized or converged.

If you live in an HCoL area, you're probably not very happy about this, but if you live in a LCoL area these compensation packages are excellent.

infamouscow··on Global Economy Approaches Soft Landing, but Risks Remain
Does the bay area role also come with equity? I doubt that's true for the restaurant manager.
infamouscow··on Global Economy Approaches Soft Landing, but Risks Remain
In practice, this sounds no different than most engineering manager roles outside of very tech-savvy organizations.
infamouscow··on Rust for Embedded Systems: Current state, challenges and open problems
That's great it works well for AMD64 Linux ELF files. I would be surprised if it didn't given the toolchain seems to have been designed around that triple specifically.

But the majority of embedded platforms are not booting or running AMD64 Linux, they're running ARMv{6,7,8}, MIPS, or 32-bit RISC-V chips.

infamouscow··on French court issues damages award for violation of GPL
This is true until a Judge decides otherwise under penalty of permanent imprisonment.

As for the AGPL, the AGPL is regarded as the most deadly toxic irradiated poison ever concocted to big tech. You'll be in a very serious meeting with your supervisor, HR, and lawyers if you use AGPL code in big tech. But they'll more likely just outright terminate you. If you maintain a prominent AGPL project, they will not hire you and put you on a blacklist when they find out.

The virality of the AGPL is something no lawyer wants to test in court. They're scared shitless of it.

infamouscow··on Florida defies CDC in measles outbreak, it's fine to send unvaccinated kids
The point is there's no legitimate reason to accept this as okay.

You seem to think that's fine, and you're entitled to your opinion regardless of how distant from reality it is, it's just no reasonable person with an IQ over 75 wants to deal with entirely preventable communicable disease.

infamouscow··on Rust for Embedded Systems: Current state, challenges and open problems
It's a show stopper when size matters and you can't fit the binaries into flash.

I'm sure "sorry for getting everyone to switch to this unestablished language" will go over very well with your boss and upper management. At least in C and C++ you can blame your tools.

If you've stupidly convinced management the existing tooling is shit, then you've got a problem. And I don't mean a technical one, I mean a problem with paying rent, because you're not going to be employed much longer.

infamouscow··on Rust for Embedded Systems: Current state, challenges and open problems
What about all of the projects where your assumptions are false?
infamouscow··on Rust for Embedded Systems: Current state, challenges and open problems
First, 100% of HFT are businesses trying to make money above all else. Security and correctness are secondary to the business requirement of making money, especially when you are uniquely situated to have financially quantified their risk when things go wrong to remain within controlled error bands.

Second, HFT developers are using very expensive FGPAs to do trading with network packets. People are quick to reach to some example where their favorite toy is used at some organization, but that's besides the point. The tools for getting code on those FPGAs is horrible and unless Xilinx adopts Rust internally I doubt much will change. Rust can be adopted elsewhere, but that's not what's making the organization money. HFT folks are not persuaded even slightly by these arguments about security and correctness. Jane Street is not a HFT firm and they will gladly tell you that.

It helps immensely to understand ones concerns, constraints, and values before assuming they're identical and them swiftly demonizing anyone that dissents. The Rust community really has done itself a massive disservice in alienating everyone that doesn't conform to its monoculture composed mostly of amateurs and unemployable extremists.

Of course, this will simply be downvoted by the pathetic and unimpressive. Nobody views this as an opportunity to even try disputing the argument or use it as a legitimate data point that Rust should strive for. They simply want obedience and mindlessness in the monoculture because they lack the tools needed to handle conflict of any kind. It's also why so many features are perpetually stuck as nightly rather than stable. The project does nothing but stultify talent into leaving for genuine innovation.

infamouscow··on Rust for Embedded Systems: Current state, challenges and open problems
I work on systems that don't run on Linux, and those systems also have reasonable business requirements for graceful failure on OOM. This is unhelpful.
infamouscow··on Google Founder Sergey Brin: Gemini issue due to lack of "thorough testing"
I'm pretty sure these problems were noticed, but reporting it risks your job and getting branded a racist. Nobody needs the hassle.
infamouscow··on Amazon lobbyists banned from EU Parliament
It would be better if they were banned from the EU, but this is a start.
infamouscow··on Ask HN: How do I report a SF startup that doesn't share salary in job postings?
How about just shame them publicly here -- that is the most effective way to effect change.

They will have plenty more mistakes along the way if they ever become successful, so don't feel bad.

infamouscow··on Florida defies CDC in measles outbreak, it's fine to send unvaccinated kids
The CDC doesn't seem to mind all of the migrants lacking vaccine paperwork.

I can see why states disregard the CDC. Any perception of credibility they once had was flushed down the toilet with their blatant cronyism the last few years.

infamouscow··on Vice Staffers Brace for Worst After Tip Warns Site Will Be Deleted
I'm surprised Vice managed to stay in business as long as it did considering their only competition were outlets reporting the truth.
infamouscow··on Biden administration cancels student loans of more than 150k borrowers
I look forward to whatever US states decide to interpret the Sixteenth Amendment like D.C., California, and New York interpret the Second Amendment.
infamouscow··on Amazon Joins SpaceX in Mission to Destroy NLRB
This kind of thinking is exactly why they rule over you.

Rather than do anything to improve the situation, it's easier to point fingers and argue against a false choice between being a career politician and nothing else.

A television game show host won the presidency against a career politician in 2016 and spent about half as much on their campaign. This flies in the face of the all the idiotic rhetoric that money buys elections i.e., Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, and that the media can assassinate the character of a candidate. If you're a conspiracy theorist thinking the boogieman got him elected in 2016, the same boogieman certainly didn't help in 2020 when he had four years to prepare and the advantage of already being POTUS.

A few years ago the NYT reported about 20% of Congress were outsiders -- double the success rate of startups. And despite the obstacles in front of them, people start businesses and take massive pay cuts every day. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez run a campaign and get elected while waiting tables and tending bar at a taqueria in NYC.

These events should inspire readers to start getting involved. It's the only way to change things.

infamouscow··on Amazon Joins SpaceX in Mission to Destroy NLRB
One of the penalties for refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors. - Plato
← PreviousPage 13 of 34Next →