HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

interesting_att

374 karma · joined November 5, 2014

submissionscomments
interesting_att··on Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata has died [pdf]
Such sad news. Iwata's influence has been enormous on my childhood as well as many others. Gaming is becoming a legitimate hobby, in no small part to people like him. He truly cared about the company, the products, and the consumer. RIP
interesting_att··on Thomas Piketty: “Germany has never repaid.”
Everyone here seems to be criticizing Piketty for weird reasons. He is not saying post-war Germany's debt is the exact same thing as the current Greek crisis. Pointing out parallels isn't same thing as saying two situations are equivalent.

His point is that this isn't a "moral" decision between two peoples. It's an economic decision between nations.

interesting_att··on Why Don’t the Poor Rise Up?
Most people would agree living today would be better than the 1950s. We have 60 years of social progress and 60 years of technological advancement.

Economic inequality isn't inherently bad, per se. But in America, it is usually a signifier for two things: the effects of poverty and corruption.

Yes, the rich and poor both drink Coca-Cola. But the poor get put into worse prisons, have access to worse lawyers, have juries that tend to be more biased against them, have worse schools, live in neighborhoods with higher crime rates and more corrupt police forces, have less access to healthcare, etc.

The rich, on the other the other hand, have access to lobbyists to use the government to their whim. Remember the poorly constructed bailout?

interesting_att··on Ask HN: Why So Stressed?
One of the best answers I have seen in a long time. Start ups are brutal.
interesting_att··on Ask HN: Has YC or other VCs invested in gaming startups?
Ha, I am a TinyCo alum who started his own gaming company. Let me know if you want to get coffee one of these days.

Would highly recommend you have a finished game + some revenue before you hit up institutional investors. In the mean time, find angels who respect you. Believe you are an engineer, so people won't often doubt your ability to produce.

interesting_att··on Ask HN: My lawyer has asked for 5% equity. Is that fair?
These terms seem absurd to me. 1k/month retainer for a startup alone seems awfully high. 5% equity is absurd. Get a new lawyer. If in SF, there are some great tech lawyers who won't rip you off.
interesting_att··on Kongregate: the science behind the massive profits of F2P games
Actual F2P developer here. I've spent countless hours interviewing payers. Vast majority of people are normal, hardworking people who just genuinely enjoy games.

You're focused on a problem that doesn't affect 99.964% of people playing the game (Math: Avg 3% of people are payers, 4% of those payers are whales, and a small fraction of those big payers could be recognized as people with issues).

Moreover, even if this problem existed, that doesn't make these games inherently bad. People can develop addictions to whole gamut of things: alcohol, drugs, sex, gambling, porn, Facebook, relationships, food, etc. But none of those things are inherently ban. Why is gaming any different? Yes, F2P games optimize for retention/monetization, but how is this any different from any other product in the market?

interesting_att··on Why I faked being black for med school
This is such a weak argument. It's misleading to include white people in the discussion of affirmative action, because, almost paradoxically, the program only strengthens the white-power hierarchy.

There are millions of things we can do to reduce racial inequality that don't involve discrimination against Asians: ending the drug war and funding rehabilitation programs, reducing police brutality and discrimination, ending for-profit prisons, voting rights for previously convicted, quality hospitals and healthcare access for the poor, funding mental health programs in urban neighborhoods, monitoring and reducing discrimination against colored people in the court systems, actually investing in poorer neighborhoods, funding quality public transportation, seriously funding low-income schools, enacting regulations against companies that take advantage of the poor (payday loans, for-profit colleges). The list goes on and on and on.

Affirmative action has effectively increased the white power structure in this country by reducing the power of Asians, while simultaneously used a delaying tactic for real justice for poor African Americans.

interesting_att··on Ask HN: Do you avoid reading articles on sites with paywalls?
Of course I avoid these articles.

First, most material behind paywalls aren't that great. The NY Times hardly has the monopoly on quality reporting. In fact, most money-driven publications tend to be low quality in many respects, especially when facing people with power and money, because the paywall isn't their only revenue stream. The Intercept, which is a non-profit, routinely beats out the NYT on national security reporting.

Second, these paywalls can be easily bypassed. Again, why pay for this? These notions that these words are their property and hence need to be paid for it have no moral weight to me, especially when some of these publications got us into the Iraq War.

interesting_att··on Spotify raises $526M at a $8.5B valuation
At a $120/year for 6 years, you've basically spent $720. That is amazing. I, on the other, have spent $0 on all music in my entire life (excluding concerts).
interesting_att··on Snapchat's Evan Spiegel: ‘We Need to IPO’
Am I the only one here who is impressed with Evan Spiegel + optimistic for Snapchat?

Everyone keeps citing the fact that the company is pre-revenue and pre-profits, but FB was too for a while. Snapchat can easily turn on the revenue and profit hose if they so choose to.

1.5 ads a day x $20 CPM x 100m DAU x 365 days/year = 1.095B in revenue a year from advertising alone! With Snapchat's explosive growth, we can assume it will eventually hit 200m DAU. That means 2.2b in annual revenue, just from advertising! Add in monetizing things like the discover feature, Snapchat, to even things like local event promotion, and that company can hit in 2.5b

The kicker here is that Snapchat can be instantly profitable. 1000 employees will cost at max 100M, and infrastructure costs will only cost a few hundred million. On 2B in revenue, that's insanely profitable.

The big question mark is if ads reduce user growth and engagement metrics. However, it seems like Snapchat is a platform uniquely similar to TV, hence I personally don't care when I see a high quality ad or two. Moreover, they are putting a lot of attention to this issue, which is awesome.

Just for a comparison, Twitter made 1.4b in annual revenue and has never posted a profit, and is worth 24 billion. If Snapchat makes 2.2b in annual revenue, and got the same P/S ratio, it would be worth 36bn. Not bad to get in at a 15bn valuation if you ask me.

interesting_att··on Ask HN: Am I missing out by not being in sillicon valley?
If your goals are to make a good bit of money and retire by solely doing your consulting business, then you definitely aren't missing out on much. Save that dough up for when the bubble bursts.

That said, if you are interested in a new living scene, weigh the pros and cons. SF has amazing weather and average person is pretty intelligent. However they are passive aggressive as hell and dating scene for men is absolutely terrible.

I don't know if you're seriously interested in it, but I also think you are reducing your chance of building a huge startup, in large part because:

a) SF-tech is a positive signal for funding

b) easier access to funds from VCs + angels

c) easier access to tech clients (nothing beats face to face)

d) easier access to business information (want to find out how Zenpayroll makes money? Find some employees and get coffee with them. Try doing that in St. Louis).

e) A lot of great tech talent has moved here, so you can find some awesome employees relative to other American cities

interesting_att··on Engineers of addiction
A lot of people in this thread have moral qualms with slot machines. I know I did. However, I have since been heavily involved in the industry (not of my choosing), and have been able to better understand it. The slot industry is not the epitome of evil.

1) Slots can be fun- Most people think slots are bad because they are "addicting". They conclude that these machines are addicting in large part because they themselves can't wrap their heads why ANYONE would spend so much money on a game without some serious mental disorder. But that completely ignores the actual voices of the users (who slot designers actually talk to). Players actually enjoy the thrills of winning AND losing. We have to come to grips that what others consider fun is sometimes beyond our realm of imagination. And just because we don't understand the thrill of their experience, doesn't mean the machine is tricking them. I don't see most people confused when their 75 year old grandmother doesn't like Call of Duty.

2) Spending lots of money on slots isn't necessarily a symptom of addiction- I have met so many people (Completely normal, wealthy people) who have a limit of spending $30/day on slots in their spare time. That is, they spend around 10k/year on slots. Anyone seeing 10k/year would think that this person was addicted, but they don't measure his/her background. Slot players tend to be older, they tend to spend on little else (they don't go out to bars!), tend to have a good amount of free time, and tend to have a good bit of savings. They - of all people- should be allowed to play slots if they so choose to. Obviously the money society spends on slots would be better used to feed some starving child or build some fancy new lifesaving technology. But that's more of a critique of capitalism, not just slots.

3) Casinos don't target gambling addicts- Of course slot makers do basic A/B testing of their games. But it's not like casinos put ads outside of Gambling Addicts Anonymous meetings. They target people in general, and gambling addicts will always find a way too them. When do we start placing the responsibility on the end user?

4) Is the rate of problem gamblers (gamblers who spend a lot of money and can't) who use slot machines higher than the rate of alcoholics? Shopping addicts? Drug addicts? Do you suggest banning alcohol because some people can't handle it?

5) Casinos and slots are heavily regulated by what they can and cannot do. Moreover, taxes on casinos do go to fund problem gambling help, schools, and a lot of great other things.

In the end, unless you actually take an effort to learn how to enjoy slots, you won't understand why people like it. And because of that, you will just vilify the industry. Eerily similar to the war on drugs.

interesting_att··on Harvard Accused of Bias Against Asian-Americans
I see some strength in your analogy, but two main differences:

1) Tax money spent on sending kids to college helps everyone, even the non-parents, since more educated people = better world. Affirmative action doesn't help Asians in any conceivable way. Does it even help society at large? No one arguing for it shows reliable data that it creates significant community benefit.

2) You can always have a child in the future if you choose to. You can't become non-Asian if you were born Asian.

interesting_att··on Harvard Accused of Bias Against Asian-Americans
If we posted stipulations on all the grant money we give universities, every elite university would quickly follow through with it. It's too much money to throw away, even for Harvard.
interesting_att··on Harvard Accused of Bias Against Asian-Americans
A private school can use whatever criteria it wants if it believes it enhances the experience. But why should Asian American tax dollars go to a university that clearly discriminates against them? Harvard shouldn't be able to get public funds and engage in systemic racism.
interesting_att··on Zenefits Series C at $4.5b Evaluation
Anyone else blown away by Zenefits' valuation? It is 45x the company's projected 2015 revenue. Even more surprising, the company is no where near profitable, has a number of regulatory challenges ahead, and is only 2 years old.

This reeks of a bubble. I guess funding consumer-focused apps is old news, and it's all about funding enterprise startups (i.e. Slack).

interesting_att··on Talking About Money
There has been a recent trend in tech discussions to have greater transparency in compensation, and more importantly, removing negotiation from employment procedure (see recent changes at Reddit). I fear that this move would dramatically hurt startups, who need all the flexibility they can get. Moreover, this move could dramatically kill any form of cohesiveness in startups. Lastly, this move would de-emphasize the importance the skill of negotiation, which would be a detriment to the company.

To those who don't know, most large companies already have a structured pay table. Try working at AT&T or McDonalds, and you can probably predict where your salary will be in the next 5-10 years. Real negotiation for most people in most positions mainly happens in small firms and startups.

Lack of salary negotiation will only scare away well qualified candidates who don't fit some arbitrarily made rubric (which will almost always back out to years worked, which is a terrible standard). Imagine if by paying 20k extra, you can get one of those mythical "10x rockstar" engineers. Would you remove your ability to hire him?

By opening up everyone's salaries, it will only hurt the startup culture, as it will only make people dislike each other. I often found engineers and business development people devalue each others work, in large part because neither party can understand the work of the other. Imagine them knowing each others salaries! Each side can find a justification on why they are being under-compensated while the other over-compensated. Startups need cohesiveness to survive.

Lastly negotiation is a valuable skill in the workplace. Interviews reward people who can handle stress and negotiate. Imagine a shipping date is imposed upon you, and not all the features can be included. You're going to want a leader on the engineering team to negotiate with the strategy makers to find an equitable solution. De-emphasizing negotiation is de-emphasizing a critical human skill.

interesting_att··on Twitter Reports Weak Earnings and the Stock Is Crashing
Did anyone expect any different from Twitter? Their main platform needs significant improvement.

Biggest disadvantages for Twitter:

1) People are flocking to other social messaging apps, especially the mobile variants (Snapchat, Instagram, etc). I suspect because its coolness factor is waring off, because of rampant trolling, and poor discovery.

2) Most of Twitter advertising is useless, in large part due to poor data collection. I have yet to see any performance campaigns really kill it on the platform. Brands only advertise because they are easily misled by agencies.

Can anyone offer realistic suggestions to help improve the company's outlook? Here are some random thoughts:

1) Trying to take a piece of the mobile ecosystem seems like a smart move, as they show genuine expertise. I liked their acquisition of MoPub and every developer seems to use Crashlytics. People seem to use Periscope and Vine often, as well. This could lead to a lucrative formula: Making apps easier to build with their tools, nudge developers to monetize through MoPub, and then take the plethora of learnings from the latest mobile craze and build an awesome new app.

2) They need to better monetize news, not just social interaction. How much content is written today because "Person said X offensive statement on twitter"? Twitter gets $0, despite the fact most news comes from them. Maybe try to attempt to be the Bloomberg Terminal for all news going forward? How about trying to beat Nielsen (16bn market cap) in actually monitoring sentiment? This obviously would take some ingenuity, but could be very rewarding. They seem to be trying this strategy, with some of their recent acquisitions.

3) Find out what other countries want. There is still a huge untapped marked in the 3rd world. Twitter could expand there by offering new services.

4) Somehow disincentivize blowhards from going on Twitter too often.

interesting_att··on “Transgender Surgery Isn't the Solution” (2014)
Thanks for posting the article here.

Some of McHugh's stats/arguments are misleading:

1) "Most of the surgically treated patients described themselves as "satisfied" by the results, but their subsequent psycho-social adjustments were no better than those who didn't have the surgery."-- This could be a valuable piece of data, but you're potentially comparing two different groups of people. The ones that elected to have surgery obviously had stronger feelings than the ones that didn't. If they were denied surgery and joined the latter group, it could potentially lower the average psychological health of the latter group.

2) "Most shockingly, their suicide mortality rose almost 20-fold above the comparable non-transgender population." -- The only stat that would be worthwhile would be comparing transgender who had surgery vs the ones that didn't. Comparing transgender populations who had surgery vs normal population only would show that transgender populations need more help, acceptance, and support.

3) "Facing long sentences and the rigors of a men's prison, they have an obvious motive for wanting to change their sex and hence their prison." -- This is absurd. No one would want to remove their genitalia just so they can be in a different-sex prison.

Despite all this, I do think he makes some interesting points when it comes to the nature of children. Altering a child's body dramatically before he/she hits puberty based on some beliefs that we know often change does seem absurd to me. Adults should make decisions for themselves, not anyone else.

As with all medically invasive surgery, data and research are key. We should not stop based on some pre-conceived beliefs.

interesting_att··on College for the masses
The research cited controls for economic status.
interesting_att··on College for the masses
You make a great point. A lot of this "ticket to the middle class" sounds like delaying the issue of wealth inequality. One of the biggest predictor of financial success is who you are born to, something you have no control over.

When we drive millions more poor people to college, the average value of a college degree will go down. Then we will come up with some new institution that is the "ticket to the middle class," like getting a masters degree. Back in the 1970s, you could get a job with a high school diploma. Now, you have to go to college, work a few unpaid internships, hope you can get an OK job.

interesting_att··on College for the masses
One quote really struck out to me:

"College graduates are also healthier, happier, more likely to remain married, more likely to be engaged parents and more likely to vote, research has found."

Much of discourse surrounding college has been the economics. Arguably, it is hard to justify the cost of $200k price tag + $200k opportunity cost for a top-tier university, and come out with a $40-60k/year job. But college isn't just about crafting yourself to a job market. You get to truly explore who you are with a diverse group of people (race, genders, sexualities, culture, political leanings, economic backgrounds, drug habits) near your age, all while having access to all the knowledge of the world (be it religion, history, art, economics, etc).

Is the SJW culture of thought police hurting what makes college awesome? Yes. Is there a huge bloat of administrators that drives up the cost of college education? Yes. Are certain humanities departments misleading students into thinking that they can get a job with their degree? Yes. Do less-social students get less out of college? Yes.

But is college completely worthless? Of course not.

interesting_att··on Venture-capital infusions shrank Box founders’ stakes, ignited strife
1) "Did the founders' risk --and their contributions-- equal the total of everyone else in the company, combined?"

It depends on how you define the founders' risk as well as their contributions. Both are highly subjective. In Box's case, they could've failed due to an infinite number of potential causes, leaving Levie penniless. We don't consider them because Box is now a huge company. As for a founder's contribution, a prescient business strategy and the ability to handle stress is worth its weight in gold. Who would have thought of starting a cloud storage company in 2005? Who could have raised funds for a tech company in 2005, especially someone as inexperienced as Levie? Additionally, founders have to deal with way more stress than an employee. Founders end up thinking about their startups 24/7, because that is their future. An employee can walk away at any time and just get another job.

2) "I'm arguing the numbers in today's equity distributions are wildly out of proportion."

This assumes there is some ideal proportion, one that leads to some optimal social outcome. High equity payouts for founders mean there will be more founders, as average long-term compensation will go up. High equity payouts for first-employees will mean there be more people who want to join semi-stable startups as employees #1 and #2. Which leads to a better social outcome? I don't really know. I would guess we would be better off trying to encourage people to become founders rather than employees. What I do know is that if you don't think equity is good enough for you, you can always try to start a negotiation or start your own company.

interesting_att··on Yahoo in Talks to Buy Foursquare
People forget that Mayer acquired 56 companies (57 if Foursquare deal goes through). That is, 41% of all of Yahoo's acquisitions over the past 20 years happened in the last 3 years. Think it is important to analyze this Foursquare deal the context of this yet-to-be-proven strategy.

Back to this deal: Interesting possibility, for sure. Will it work out? Who knows with Yahoo.

Foursquare assets:

     1) Brand name with both consumers and businesses

     2) 45m daily active users

     3) Valuable data- Can improve Yahoo Search, Yahoo ads, etc

     4) Large group of domain experts

Yahoo's value add:

     1) Yahoo does have a strong ad sales department, so it can bring lots of brand names to Foursquare

     2) Can heavily integrate Foursquare into its search features- so Foursquare's DAU can stabilize/grow.

Seems like Mayer's strategy is:

1) Buy her way out of changing Yahoo's employees + culture. This is a longer term play.

2) Try to create some constellation of a platform. Ideal world for Mayer would be:

     a) Get your homepage to be Yahoo

     b) Read the latest trending headlines via Yahoo media 

     c) Yahoo stories pump up Yahoo-owned Tumblr blogs, Yahoo-owned Flickr photo sharing, etc

     d) After that, you search for things on Yahoo. The search would ideally share information coming from Foursquare.
The big thing is on execution and that's why people constantly criticize Yahoo. If they do actually make a sensible platform, expect Mayer to be viewed very positively.
interesting_att··on Mark Pincus, Zynga’s Founder, Returns as C.E.O
Exactly. If I were Pincus and was a rational self-interested agent, I would've gotten rid of Mattrick at this time, and then reap the benefits of Mattrick's game end of the year. If they succeed? Pincus is a genius. If they fail? Mattrick was an idiot. Can't lose.
interesting_att··on Mark Pincus, Zynga’s Founder, Returns as C.E.O
I am surprised Don Mattrick would be let go, especially since most of the projects he oversaw have not been released yet. But given that we're dealing with Mark Pincus, the founder famous for wanting control, I guess this was expected.

To those who are unaware, Mattrick was primarily let go for his failure with Zynga Poker. The updated version killed user engagement so badly, the game may never recover. Zynga Poker is one of the company's most interesting assets, given that online gambling will be legalized in the next few years.

Mattrick represented a shift in Zynga: instead of low-brow clones of competitors, Zynga would focus on high-polish triple AAA games. It was a daring strategy, since Zynga's reputation single handedly scared away many amazing game designers. You can copy a farming game easily and get decent results if you have a team of data analysts. It is quite difficult to copy a great hardcore RTS and get good results. Zynga spent 500 million USD to buy NaturalMotion, an excellent game developer in this space. They spent a ton of money on their slots game, acquiring valuable IP licenses + great slot designers. They spent a ton of money getting the Tiger Woods license. Etc etc.

Pincus has never shown the ability to manage high quality game designers. He has only showed the ability to manage MBA-types, who aren't considered the most creative of the bunch. Mattrick would have been a better leader in this vertical. Any midcore/hardcore gamer would rather want the XBOX CEO over Pincus.

What does this signal for Zynga's future?

1) All of Mattrick's high-polish products are now under the leadership of someone who isn't as geared towards this vertical.

2) Increased importance for social casino and real money gambling for the company- The fact that this is the main reason why Mattrick got fired highlights Pincus' goal of dominating real money gambling.

#1 is a negative signal, #2 is a positive signal. I'd agree with the rest of the market and say this is a net-loss for Zynga.

interesting_att··on EA Shuts Down ‘SimCity’ and ‘The Sims’ Developer Maxis
EA survive off of Madden and FIFA licenses. They don't have to spend that much money on improving the game year after year, but millions of people purchase them almost religiously.
interesting_att··on EA Shuts Down ‘SimCity’ and ‘The Sims’ Developer Maxis
It is very difficult to get financing for a AAA game company since the industry is so hit-driven. Moreover, it'd be rather difficult to find investors just after the studio you worked for just shut down due to poor performance.
interesting_att··on Ask HN: Does anyone actually hire from 'developer bootcamps'?
I know some people who went to App Academy and did really well for themselves. My guess is that a bootcamp is the same hours equivalent of a person a bare-basics CS degree without the internships.

Here is my reasoning:

* 2 years of college is just to finish core curriculum/elective stuff (history, foreign language, writing, philosophy, etc)

* 2 years of college is used to finish computer science major

* Each year, students study for 40 weeks. So in total he studies for 80 weeks.

* Each week, he takes an avg around 3.5 courses a week.

* Each course takes him an avg 4 hours a course (remember college kids waste a lot of time...a lot of time).

Total= 2 years * 40 weeks/year * 3.5 courses/week *4 hrs/course = 1120 hours

Conclusion: If you put in bootcamp hours, which is 80-100 hours a week, it's only 11-14 weeks. That's the avg length of a bootcamp. Bootcamp = college degree in CS (from a mediocre program) minus the core curriculum and minus the 2-3 internships you would do in college.

Many people here are saying that bootcamp alums aren't as good as college grads. I don't have enough data, but I would agree with that statement. While bootcamp grads aren't as good as CS grads, I wouldn't say the bootcamp education is worse than a poor/mediocre CS program, because of some unaccounted for variables:

1) Internships are still vitally important! 2-3 internships is basically a full year of programming on a very diverse set of problems!

2) Selection bias: Better programmers tend to start earlier in their career, hence they don't have to go to bootcamps.

3) Confidence issues: It takes years for people to be comfortable with engineering. I would not be surprised if people don't have confidence issues going into interviews + work after a 12 week bootcamp.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →