HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

irq11

404 karma · joined January 27, 2009

submissionscomments
irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
> Take a look at Japan

OK: ” A record 7,841 new coronavirus cases were reported in Japan as of 8 p.m. on Friday. The nationwide daily tally has set a record for a fourth day in a row.”

https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/news/20210108_40/

That’s some fantastic evidence that masks don’t work.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
I “cherry picked“ no other studies for this thread.

The DAMASK study is literally the only RCT ever run for masks and Covid. You may not like it or what it says, but its much higher quality than any of these uncontrolled, correlative, pro-mask “papers” that have been rushed out since March.

> It did not attempt to measure the effect on transmission from the mask wearer to others at all.

Because you can’t. Short of locking a group of people in a room with infected people and seeing who gets it, thats an unfalsifiable hypothesis.

Fortunately, we know that masks are not magically effective in one direction only, and if they don’t work in one direction....

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
It’s a “synthetic control” because they didn’t actually have a control group. So they tried to pretend their was such a group by taking data from elsewhere.

Yes, I read the paper.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
Yes, we agree on that. Which is, again, why we don’t do “science“ by length of signature list.
irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
Literally everyone thinks their favorite pseudoscientific theory is a parachute.

Calling something a parachute is not science. It’s just a pseudo-intellectual defense of superstition.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
So let me summarize:

Cases go down after mask mandate: proof that masks work!

Cases go up after mask mandate: masks still work!

This isn’t science.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
You’re right, the Danish mask study showed that masks are consistent with every outcome ranging from an increase in infection to a reduction.

You spins the wheel, you takes your chances, I guess...

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
> A later increase in infections does not invalidate statistical significance for earlier studies. It’s just math, not “an excuse”.

So your theory is that masks worked then, but stopped working now?

Convenient!

> You’ll never see the data for how many cases would have been recorded without the measures in place.

Well, yes, exactly...these are uncontrolled studies. Which is why they’re such garbage.

You can see that in the title of the paper you posted: “a synthetic control study”. That means they didn’t have a control. Which means all they can do is squint at correlations and try to claim they prove cause.

(oh also: the WaPo “data” is from a phone survey...so yeah: people who say they wear masks a lot claim they have fewer “symptoms”. Whatever that means.)

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
I have “cherry picked“ nothing. That’s the data from the study. The researchers picked the start date, arbitrarily, to produce the outcome they liked. It’s obvious.

By the way: there was a randomized controlled trial for masks and covid published just recently. They were able to detect no statistically significant protective effect:

https://www.medpagetoday.com/blogs/vinay-prasad/89778

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
It is not. Science is “built on” evidence.

I am a professional scientist. Nobody has ever given me a pass on publication simply because they want to believe me.

That said, science is a human institution, and all humans have cognitive biases that can be exploited - particularly in large groups.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
You should look more deeply into that Kansas study. They cherry-picked their data in a way that is extremely dubious:

https://mobile.twitter.com/ianmsc/status/1332407421151576064...

Turns out that if you pick slightly different start and end dates, you can get dramatically different results.

Even if you think there’s a justification for it, plotting the counties’ data next to each other shows that they’re torturing the data. That is a perfect example of the horrible, flawed methodology that has been getting published all year.

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
There’s always an excuse, but there’s never any data backing your claims.

Provide even a single shred of evidence that masks affect the R0 of the virus in the real world.

Modeling studies and correlations observed in April don’t count: most of the papers published this year looked at areas where case counts subsequently skyrocketed in the fall. My personal favorite is the mask study from Jena, Germany in the spring, which only made it into a journal right as cases were reaching an all-time high in the same area:

https://www.pnas.org/content/early/2020/12/02/2015954117

https://gesundheit.jena.de/en/coronavirus

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
> Mask use is nowhere near what it should have been

All available evidence shows that you’re wrong.

Self-reported mask usage rates are over 90%, nationwide. Moreover, many of the places with the highest compliance rates (e.g. Los Angeles) have the fastest-growing case counts:

https://delphi.cmu.edu/covidcast/?date=20201018&signalType=v...

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/business...

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6943e4.htm

irq11··on Over 100 Scientists and Doctors Call for Increased Vitamin D to Combat Covid-19
The open letter for face masks is a great example for why this kind of thing is dubious.

All prior high-quality evidence disputed the claim:

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/covid-19/podcasts-webinars/specia...

The subsequent evidence of real-world effectiveness isn’t great: cases are skyrocketing around the northern hemisphere, and mask mandates aren’t making a difference. The only randomized controlled trial ever conducted for masks and covid was not able to detect any protective effect, yet was rejected from multiple journals because of “consensus”:

https://www.medpagetoday.com/blogs/vinay-prasad/89778

Science by signature count isn’t science; it’s a popularity contest. It’s perfectly fine to advocate for a belief, but nobody should pretend that they have the “scientific” argument simply because their signature list is longer.

irq11··on The Plague Year
It isn’t free. Among other things, “making people feel safer” can easily have the consequence that they stop doing the things that actually matter. It’s called “risk compensation”.

Arguing that this isn’t a significant risk just begs the question: without positive data for effectiveness, nobody has any idea.

irq11··on California reports 585 coronavirus deaths, new single-day record in state
And on the 27th there were 64, and on the 25th, 77. There’s a fairly obvious dip in the 7-day trendline around Christmas:

https://covid-19.direct/state/CA

It’s likely that some of this is due to reporting delay over the holidays.

irq11··on Covid-19 Changes Our Sleep
Everything you wrote is your opinion, whereas it’s been extensively documented that lockdowns are leading to a huge surge in depression and suicidal ideation. Just one example:

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6932a1-H.pdf

Here’s a longitudinal study, showing that lockdowns were directly associated with increased depression in children:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33298552/

Rates of depression in Wuhan decreased after the lockdown ended:

https://www.healio.com/news/psychiatry/20201112/anxiety-depr...

A study showing that rates of depression tripled during lockdown in the UK:

https://www.newswise.com/coronavirus/depression-and-anxiety-...

At some point, facts have to matter.

irq11··on How a British Covid-19 vaccine went from pole position to troubled start
We did not “eradicate SARS”. It disappeared from hospitals on its own, and we simply stopped looking.
irq11··on How a British Covid-19 vaccine went from pole position to troubled start
Yes. I have a doctorate in the field. Regardless, you don’t have to take my word for it - I linked directly to the source, and you can read it yourself.

It is deeply, deeply ironic that other users on this thread are eager to downvote and dismiss me, based on nothing other than their opinions, when I give citations backing up nearly everything I write. Consider their biases.

irq11··on How a British Covid-19 vaccine went from pole position to troubled start
Yes, I’ve read the original report upon which that claim is based. They make it utterly clear that the evidence is weak, and that genetic variants can achieve high frequency even if selectively neutral:

https://khub.net/documents/135939561/338928724/New+SARS-COV-...

This slide deck puts it in perspective: there’s a specific mutation that is increasing in prevalence in a certain surveillance network, there’s a hypothesis about why it might lead to increased spread, and it requires more investigation. That’s it. Any claim of knowledge about impact on Rt is simply wild exaggeration of the data.

This is a case where if you don’t understand the field, you have no ability to judge the quality of the claim being made. People are irresponsibly reading second-hand sources, and quoting numbers out of context. Other people quote those sources, and before long, the snake is eating its own tail.

I would wager that the author of that BMJ piece never even read the presentation I quoted above (even though it’s the cited source by NERVTAG for the “genetic evidence” claim in the brief whitepaper that the authors do cite).

This stuff is almost 100% speculation.

irq11··on How a British Covid-19 vaccine went from pole position to troubled start
And nobody has any idea if that variant actually affects the transmission rate, let alone what impact it might have on “Rt”.

Speculation about this is irresponsible, at the very least. Moreover, we have eradicated exactly one human disease in all of history, and it took a couple hundred years of effort. Eradication is not the goal.

Immunize the most vulnerable people in the population (those over 65 and/or with certain co-morbidities), and the death rate for this virus will be dramatically reduced long before any herd immunity threshold is achieved.

irq11··on Mutated Covid-19 strain confirmed in Japan as case tally hits record high
“all-time high“ meaning “all-time high“...and continuing to accelerate.

I love the way you keep shifting the goalposts. When you’re shown that they haven’t controlled the virus, you pretend that it matters what the absolute magnitude of the case count is today. To wit: “You just don’t understand exponential growth!”

By the way, Korea has tested about 2M people, total, or about the same number of tests that the US did yesterday. So yeah...they’re probably finding a few less cases:

http://ncov.mohw.go.kr/en

irq11··on Mutated Covid-19 strain confirmed in Japan as case tally hits record high
> How about South Korea? It isn’t an island, and it’s doing pretty well.

Cases are at all-time highs, and have pretty much escalated out of control:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2020...

irq11··on Mutated Covid-19 strain confirmed in Japan as case tally hits record high
“Hypothesis with a small prior” is a fancy way of saying “speculation”.

There are literally dozens of strains on nextstrain that have rapidly grown to be the predominant strain in a region. That alone is not a strong indication of anything other than founder effect.

irq11··on Mutated Covid-19 strain confirmed in Japan as case tally hits record high
It’s not remotely clear that this strain is easier to transmit. It’s entirely hypothesis and speculation.

We have seen strains quickly accelerate because of founder effect several times in 2020, and particular strains dominate in particular regions. The experimental studies that are needed to confirm a claim of evolutionary advantage have not been done, and the observational evidence is weak.

Those who would panic about this should be just as circumspect in their their claims as those who would dismiss it.

irq11··on London put in emergency lockdown as U.K. fights new strain
I spent a week in a small apartment with someone who had symptomatic Covid. Close contact the whole time. Neither of us wore masks.

I never got it.

An anecdote means very little, and certainly is not evidence that masks work without controls for every other thing that might have prevented you from getting infected.

irq11··on Almost one in five Americans may have been infected with Covid-19
The comment I was replying to was doing exactly what you’re doing: responding to cited facts with pettiness. Any information that contradicts your opinions is met with mockery and moralizing judgment.
irq11··on Almost one in five Americans may have been infected with Covid-19
what an intellectually compelling rebuttal. when you have no counterargument, you resort to insults and mockery.
irq11··on Almost one in five Americans may have been infected with Covid-19
Well, I just showed you, per the CDC’s own numbers, that a third of those had nothing to do with Covid.

A reasonable person might then ask your question, but look for answers that involve something a little more intellectually rigorous than morally scolding strangers. For example: it’s seeming quite likely that our extreme, panicked reaction to this illness has killed a huge number of people.

How many more will die due to postponed cancer screenings, surgeries, and so on? How many children will be set back in their education, permanently? How many minority and low-income families will be carelessly tossed into generational poverty? How does that number weigh against the people who have died from this virus? Have you even given it a second thought?

But sure, go be “sad” about people sharing documented facts, instead. It’s much easier than critical thought, and it lets you feel morally superior. I can see why you prefer it.

irq11··on Almost one in five Americans may have been infected with Covid-19
I’m not arguing that there’s not a “case surge”. If you test everyone who walks in a hospital door (which we are), you’re going to find “cases”. If you did this with influenza, you’d find the same thing.

People go in to the ER for a broken leg, have a positive covid test, and get counted as a covid admission. This isn’t fiction: multiple state health departments have admitted it is happening. It’s too difficult to try to determine if Covid is “the reason” for an admission, so nobody tries.

Therefore, the only important question is: how are hospitals faring relative to any other year? And so far, the answer is that it looks like a moderately bad flu season. To hype the narrative that “hospitals are overwhelmed”, the news media routinely cherry-picks one or two hospitals, fixates on them for a week, then moves on to the next.

https://mobile.twitter.com/justin_hart/status/13277409970783...

← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →