HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

isaachinman

92 karma · joined July 22, 2018

Me: https://isaachinman.com

Currently building: https://marcoapp.io

submissionscomments
isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
Sorry, I don't quite get the point you're trying to make...

With an app password you have full IMAP access.

isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
Use regular old IMAP with an app password.

Don't jump through their hoops.

isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
Agreed! One of the reasons we started working on Marco.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
Because _it is_ specific to Gmail. It's using OAuth and presumable API access.

IMAP is much harder, and much slower, and is bound by Google's bandwidth limits.

isaachinman··on Ask HN: Best email solution for personal domain
Yes, we've dealt with those issues, and that was actually one of the hardest problems to solve. Most email providers use mailboxes, while Gmail uses labels to "emulate" mailboxes (sort of).

We have spent quite a lot of time and thought creating a label abstraction that makes _all_ email accounts play together nicely. There is currently no other product like this on the market.

isaachinman··on Ever wondered why Gmail search fails to find text you're sure is present?
We're building Marco, which is essentially a cross-platform, modern Thunderbird.

Full-text search and indexing is done client-side via Orama, and search is on the order of single digit ms.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Google has most of my email because it has all of yours (2014)
We're building what you're looking for!

Had the same problems myself so decided to build a product I actually needed.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Ask HN: Best email solution for personal domain
I'm in the same boat as you – happy with iCloud as a host for personal domain, but absolutely hate the client.

That's part of why we're building Marco:

https://marcoapp.io

I'm building it for myself, but sounds like it could be a good fit for you too.

isaachinman··on Offline-First with CouchDB and PouchDB in 2025
WatermelonDB and Replicache both follow this model.
isaachinman··on Office is too slow, so Microsoft is making it load at Windows startup
Strong agree. Wrote a blog post about it here:

https://marcoapp.io/blog/marco-an-introduction

We're building an IMAP-primitive, cross-platform, multi-account email client that is single-digit-ms fast in terms of search.

isaachinman··on Show HN: Talanoa – The email client I always dreamed of (people-first, Kanban)
If what you mean is that Google-only is a non-starter for yourself personally, check out what we're working on at Marco. It's IMAP-primitive:

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on The One-Person Framework in Practice
What made you choose Hotwire over Capacitor?
isaachinman··on Show HN: Bhvr, a Bun and Hono and Vite and React Starter
No idea, but shout out to Tanstack Router. It's fantastic.
isaachinman··on Show HN: Talanoa – The email client I always dreamed of (people-first, Kanban)
Excellent work!

We're building something similar at Marco:

https://marcoapp.io

If you're up for a chat sometime I'd be keen! Very impressed with your work.

We've taken longer to get to market, but will be launching with full IMAP support and web/desktop/mobile apps.

I like your pricing – hit the nail on the head.

isaachinman··on Show HN: Open-Source AI-Native Email Client for Gmail and Outlook
Do you have a public roadmap anywhere?

We've built IMAP support and Marco and always interested to see others' implementations.

IMAP when talking "cross provider"/"unified inbox" is really hard.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on AI Horseless Carriages
For anyone fed up with AI-email-slop, we're building something new:

https://marcoapp.io

At the moment, there's no AI stuff at all, it's just a rock-solid cross-platform IMAP client. Maybe in the future we'll tack on AI stuff like everyone else, but as opt-in-only.

Gmail itself seems untrustworthy now, with all the forced Gemini creep.

isaachinman··on Supabase raises $200M Series D at $2B valuation
Not until/unless it has proper offline-first support. Check out InstantDB and Triplit.
isaachinman··on Ask HN: How do you ensure you don't get locked from your email?
What email client(s) do you use?
isaachinman··on Ask HN: How do you ensure you don't get locked from your email?
What email client(s) do you use? Do you mind me asking who the "reliable company" is?
isaachinman··on Notion Mail is out
Good questions!

> But is this one of those "let's build everything in rust since it's super-fast"? (I HOPE so actually).

No. It's not written in Rust. Language choice would have literally nothing to do with making IMAP/the email experience any faster. I don't want to make any firm claims as we've yet to do serious benchmarking, but what we've built is _much_ faster than Mail.app, let alone Gmail.

The tech we've chosen, and the actual app itself, essentially _feels_ like Linear for email.

> I feel there might be a market for a fully native MODERN and OS-native looking mail client (alternative to at least Mac Mail, but actually fast with search that is actually useful).

Yes, this is what we're building, but a bit beyond that. It's completely cross-platform: web, Mac, Windows, iOS, Android, Linux. Any N number of clients a user might have running will seamlessly and instantly sync, given network availability. That said, each client is also fully offline-first.

There _is_ a market for this. It's been a nasty problem to solve, but we have a massive waitlist.

Superhuman has achieved great success (although being an over-valued VC org) but only support Google + Microsoft _via_ API access.

Notion launching their product is further validation that there's a lot of space in this market.

But Marco is quite different. We're building a cross-platform IMAP-primitive email client that gets the basics right. It'll work with any email provider that supports IMAP (basically all). We're not pushing or even _building_ any "AI" stuff yet.

I wrote a blog post detailed our motivations here:

https://marcoapp.io/blog/marco-an-introduction

Let me know if you have any follow-up questions.

isaachinman··on Notion Mail Is Out
https://marcoapp.io
isaachinman··on Notion Mail is out
Have a look at Marco. It's IMAP primitive and will work with any email provider. I'm a co-founder.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Notion Mail Is Out
I strongly suspect that is their goal. They acquired Skiff.
isaachinman··on Notion Mail is out
Have a look at Marco. It's IMAP primitive and will work with any email provider. I'm a co-founder and we're bootstrapped.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Notion Mail is out
IMAP is indeed nightmare fuel.

We're building https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on What is Local first development
Not at all true. One good solution exists.
isaachinman··on Mozilla launching “Thundermail” email service to take on Gmail, Microsoft 365
Genuinely had to look that up. Not familiar with Microsoft speak.

From a quick look, it indeed looks similar. Although I imagine Microsoft's implementation is filled with cruft.

We use Replicache + Orama. _All_ data is fully offline on the client and synced to the BE when network is available. Orama handles indexing and full text search, filtering, sorting, etc, all in single-digit ms.

Let me know if you have any follow-up questions!

isaachinman··on Mozilla launching “Thundermail” email service to take on Gmail, Microsoft 365
Yes, we've started from scratch. A detailed explanation for our reasoning can be found here:

https://marcoapp.io/blog/marco-an-introduction

TLDR: There are _no_ IMAP-primitive truly cross-platform email clients in existence, except for Missive, which is built for team collaboration. We are building something net new.

The content on the website is indeed a minimal representation and the actual alpha product has matured quite a bit beyond what you see there.

The kanban suggestion is brilliant, I have made a note of that.

isaachinman··on Mozilla launching “Thundermail” email service to take on Gmail, Microsoft 365
Apple Mail was actually the straw that broke the camel's back for me.

I wrote a blog post about our reasoning here:

https://marcoapp.io/blog/marco-an-introduction

isaachinman··on Mozilla launching “Thundermail” email service to take on Gmail, Microsoft 365
Great questions.

1. It is _both_ local and hosted. The client itself is fully offline-capable, including proper full-text search (single digit ms), writing drafts – anything you would expect an email client to do. The "hosted" bit is to ensure rapid synchronisation across multiple clients (ie your desktop and mobile).

2. Some metadata is hosted in pg to facilitate cross-platform synchronisation, as mentioned. This is encrypted at rest on a provider with SOC 2 Type I certification. Further symmetric encryption (AES-256) of sensitive columns is also done. We're well aware that security is the most important aspect of this product and is our primary focus.

3. We've not forked Thunderbird. Marco has been built from the ground up, both on the FE and BE, and has been a monumental task.

4. We have no immediate plans to add SMS/WhatsApp/RSS. If those interest you, you might have a look at Missive.

We understand that storing email metadata is potentially a turn-off to some, but is actually the key driver to an entirely new email experience. It means that a Marco client itself is virtually stateless (save for some lightweight metadata) and syncs instantly across N number of clients – it runs on web/OSX/Windows/Android/etc, and changes propagate between them instantly. New client setup happens via Marco in a proprietary way on the order of seconds and doesn't take hours to sync via IMAP.

We're building this for ourselves. Thunderbird is "alright". Apple Mail is "alright". Superhuman is decent, but ridiculously expensive and Google/Microsoft only. Missive is fairly decent (and also stores metadata), but is built for team collaboration, not individual use.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →