HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

istorical

1,894 karma · joined May 20, 2013

submissionscomments
istorical··on Facebook is researching AI systems that see, hear, remember everything you do
I find it absolutely painful that our recommender ML based content discovery streams like YouTube and Tiktok and Instagram don't have multiple 'hats' you can put on and take off, in the sense of saying 'hey TikTok, I'm feeling frisky, feel free to send me those thirst trap videos now', but then 30 minutes later you can say 'OK TikTok, I know I watched a bunch of those dancing videos, but can you send me the educational stuff now'. Ditto IG, YouTube etc. Like 'hey YouTube, engage education mode', 'hey YouTube, engage self-improvement mode', 'hey YouTube, I just wanna relax and laugh'.

I know that there are categories, even auto-generated categories on YouTube, but they aren't that great or all encompassing. My biggest critique of present personalized ML content streams is that there's no two-way communication. I can't tell IG that yes I wanna see big booties right now, but no I don't want to see them five hours from now. Or I want to see aquaponics right now since I'm on a learning binge, but later tonight I don't need more technology and science, I just need to laugh and unwind.

Our actions, our content consumption, is not allowed to be one and done. Every move you make is seen as a signal to the algorithm that you want more of that all the time. The closest thing we have is incognito mode, or maintaining multiple accounts for different purposes. But why can't you look at an ex on instagram one time without them showing you that person everytime you open the app for 5 years. It's really toxic and unsustainable that all of your actions are seen as 'yes, please more of this all the time'.

istorical··on Meat and mental health: Meat eaters suffer less depression, anxiety
Causal link or no causal link, this definitely lines up with what I've observed among people I've met. A lot of depressed and anxious folks that are vegan or vegetarian compared to the 'go to church twice a week and watch football' crowd.

But it very well may be an "I'm depressed / anxious, and somehow that is linked with me wanting to become vegetarian/vegan" rather than the other direction.

Either way, if I was very depressed or anxious and vegetarian or vegan, and I'd tried a lot of other interventions, I'd definitely consider the option of returning to meat like trying nutrient dense meats like organ meat (heart and liver are great) that are often thrown away or discarded because they are less marketable, or meats that are going to be trashed whether I ate them or not (expiring, or leftovers from someone else's meal? or some grocery store food donation program), and see if it gave me any respite.

istorical··on Meat and mental health: Meat eaters suffer less depression, anxiety
It seems as if you responded to someone saying "are you confident you know what components are needed and that all components have been identified?" with "one component we've identified is vitamin b12, it's possible to get it via blah blah blah".

Feels like sort of a non-sequitur?

istorical··on Best part of Windows 11 is a revamped Windows Subsystem for Linux
Have things changed / improved with regards to file system related bugs and config hell that was sometimes popping up in WSL2 on Windows 10 in the recent past? Or is it a small improvement over WSL2 on Win10?
istorical··on Statement from Mark Zuckerberg
Seems like you more than anyone would see that solving the types of problems FB is trying to solve eg: freedom of speech vs user safety / harm reduction is not some super simple problem, no? I wouldn't call Reddit evil despite the fact that many powermods are both amazing contributors doing free labor and curating great communities while also simultaneously abusing their power every day to silence people they disagree with, shaping narratives in human culture, automating blanket unappealable bans on users for participating in unrelated subreddits (even if you were participating in that subreddit in order to combat its views), making snap judgments on content moderation that might ruin someone's day when they make a bad call on a ban or delete, or unilaterally self appointing themselves as mouthpieces for their broader communities via subreddit blackouts or preachy pinned posts.

It's unfortunate that when you build a product so close to the ground of human communication and human nature you're never going to be able to get everything right, and you're no longer solving technology problems alone but trying to basically combat basic human moral failing itself. We don't ask that of the telephone company.

^ That being said, we can only excuse some of their failures with the above line of thinking. Others we can blame on greed or recklessness, or ignoring the social costs of something like ML recommenders optimizing for engagement. Not sure if those things deserve to be called evil, but I'd still hold back personally. Misguided, overcome by greed, or reckless, perhaps.

istorical··on Statement from Mark Zuckerberg
Zuckerberg IS facebook. He controls it. Who's to say even if the main FB app and IG app and WhatsApp apps all lost their entire userbases and revenues went to 0.05% of what they are now, that he wouldn't just run the 500 person skeleton of what they currently are and just focus on his latest pet project, whether it be VR or something else. Honestly that's what I'd do if I was a billionaire with a passion for technology and a failing company but with millions in cash reserves.
istorical··on How to Live in Airbnbs for the Price of an Apartment Lease
I did this for a year but with countries, before ultimately deciding that for me and my given circumstances, my starting country was my choice to put down roots. But then after flying back to my home country, did a mini version of the same strategy of my home country but didn't wanna leave the second place after I was there and ended the tour early (which might have been largely motivated by the fact that I'd spent a year moving between airbnbs and was sick of relocating).

The one thing that's difficult is that when you are already living out of a checked luggage + carry-on, its easy to do this. But once you've put down some roots once and accumulated any significant furniture or larger possessions, it's so hard to do it again. Unless you are truly motivated or you have nearby family with storage space to keep your most prized larger possessions. That and Airbnb prices in the markets I've looked at have gone way up in the past 5 years relative to longterm apartment rental prices in the same markets.

5 years ago you could move to NYC and find a room for rent for the same price a similar room would cost if you subleased from someone, with maybe a few hundred dollar premium extra for the convenience of Airbnb. Today it seems like the 'Airbnb' price for a month is $500-1000 more than the same room would have cost if you'd found it the old fashioned way.

One funny thing was that in 2016 when I did this (and I will admit I was fairly price-unconscious and more excited about adventure than about finance) it seemed like there was remarkable consistency of prices regardless of country. I kept paying right around $1000 USD a month to live in fairly nice to extremely nice rentals (they were all studio apartments) whether that was in gayfield square in Edinburgh or near Mariatorget in Sodermalm Stockholm (I think I got truly lucky on that one) or staying in city centers of second tier cities in Poland or at a beach hotel on the Black Sea or even staying in Mapo in Seoul or Chapinero in Bogota. I kept paying around $1000 a month at the time it felt like no matter the 'on paper' cost of living of the country. I think I was definitely paying a tourist tax in many of the lower cost of living place (whether I was paying 50% more or double what I would have if I'd booked locally or triple or what I don't know), but at the same time it's surprising I was able to stay in such nice places in higher COL places like Stockholm and Edinburgh without a higher tourist premium. I would guess though that the same accommodations on Airbnb would cost double today.

Airbnb seems both more hated and less useful today for longer-term stays than it used to. Still better for tourism than a hotel in most places though. Still waiting for something similar to Airbnb that was designed (from both product perspective but also legal/regulatory/compliance perspective) for long term month minimum to year long stays so that the antiquated apartment rental system was more instant and not so shady.

I wouldn't advise anyone to follow the '1-3 months in each city/country for a year' strategy after living it out myself unless you are doing it with a friend or loved one. I do think it broadened my perspective but went from the most exciting adventure at the beginning to a bit soul-crushing by the end in terms of how impermanent all of my friendships and relationships felt. First country I went to I invested in language learning to interact with shopkeepers, I made a decent network of couchsurfing/international meetup/language exchange friends, and had some youthful encounters with love and lust, but 10 months and several countries later it was like 'why should I try going out tonight to befriend that dude, I'll never see him again next month anyway' or 'I shouldn't text that girl, I'll probably just end up breaking her heart since I know I'm leaving in a few weeks' (which while not something inevitable with all of my prior experiences hooking up or dating while traveling, is a painful enough experience that at that time I couldn't easily brush off when it did in fact happen). By the end I was going to far fewer social events / mixers and far more sort of cerebral, maybe sentimental people watching walks through cities alone.

If I knew what I knew now and wanted to do a 'life geography reconnaissance mission', I would do much faster and shorter hops to far more places initially (even if it cost a lot more for transportation and cause of not getting long-stay discounts), and then after visiting 4-10 places quickly (maybe 5-7 days in each country/city to just get the initial/basic feel/vibe?) I would pick my top 1-3 and visit for longer. 6-12 months at my favorite one or two places from that year or travel would have been much more fulfilling (although maybe the goodbye would be even more painful?), but then again if I hadn't visited so many places I wouldn't have known which resonated most with me.

istorical··on Visualize 3D hyperbolic honeycombs and sphere packings
wish there was a modern day equivalent of medieval patronage (one rich patron you had to convince, rather than pleasing and amassing hundreds of small patrons with online astroturfing and self-aggrandizing spam marketing), I would love to spend my life creating virtual worlds you could travel through as beautiful as those fractals but with interesting things to do and discover inside.

was scratching my artistic itch and self-funding exploring such things but ran out of money and had to go back to the real world: https://cmadams.itch.io/preydrivr

istorical··on I Got a 'Mild' Breakthrough Case
The last two times you had flu with severity great enough to alert you that you had flu.
istorical··on How did the plain green lawn become the central landscaping feature in America?
this is a really interesting take that I surprisingly have never seen anywhere, thank you for sharing. would love to learn more about this perspective and body of knowledge, thought not sure where or what to google or what resources might exist. for example, what mitigation can or should be done if one did want wild grass and flowers but wanted to prevent erosion, and what happens if you don't prevent that erosion. is this still a concern on a completely flat piece of land?
istorical··on Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month?
Yes, yes they are.
istorical··on Vulnerability in Bumble dating app reveals any user's exact location
Crime is not difficult. Every woman is already in danger. As is every human. Every animal. The world is dangerous.

If level of danger caused by a company was proportional to punishment, then every gun or tobacco (secondhand smoke) or fossil fuel company would have to have everyone in the org resign effective immediately.

istorical··on Show HN: Hypergraph, a data structure library to generate directed hypergraphs
I can't be the only person who has wanted to try bringing the wolfram physics project style hypergraph generation rules into some 3D game engine like unity or unreal but was too intimidated to start.

I've done some cool stuff with generating fractals like these ones made by Softology

https://www.flickr.com/photos/39445835@N05/albums/7215769136...

https://www.flickr.com/photos/39445835@N05/albums/7215768121... using visons of chaos to create .obj files and then importing them as voxels in unreal engine using voxel plugin, but hit some limits quite quickly in terms of data size / memory usage and how large of a fractal structure I could visualize (example: megastructure in this demo of a vr game I was working on https://photos.app.goo.gl/V7NrtG4bCbU3EEwy8)

but would love to try to create some way to visualize and interact with large hypergraph structures in 3d space like the wolfram ones: https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/data/uploads/2020/04/041... https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/data/uploads/2020/04/041...

Wonder if this library could be a good place to start to look into this. you obviously need some language / format to store info about hypergraphs and build them up (what this seems like it could help with?) and then some way to render them or create procedural meshes (which in and of itself will be difficult, although I've seen some people have success with stuff like fractal procedural meshes (https://forums.unrealengine.com/t/wip-procedural-fractal-mes...).

The standard noise generation algorithms (perlin, simplex, iq noise, value, voronoi, etc) and rendering algorithms like marching cubes capture all the procedural 'terrain' / structure attention/hype in games and media, but I think cinematic sets or game environments built of hypergraphs or fractals are an unmined/overloocked resource.

if I could get a team of 2-5 and enough to pay them for a few years, I feel like you could combine hypergraphs and fractals 'terrain' with ue5 nanite to make the memory requirements of the huge / high fidelity meshes lower and make some really cool stuff.

istorical··on Google's payments team is seeing an exodus of executives and employees
That's essentially what university is. Learning and research for its own sake or for the sake of self-improvement without worrying about applications or real world value.
istorical··on Fructose in diet expands the surface of the gut and promotes nutrient absorption
The food pyramid used in the western world misled people to believe fruit is a necessary component of a diet. It absolutely isn't. Vegetables give you all the dietary components without the high amounts of sugar. And if you eliminate all simple sugars / obvious bad carbs from your diet, then eventually stuff like sauteed carrots / corn, beets, etc. starts to taste 'sweet' to your reset tastebuds.
istorical··on ‘Horizon Workrooms’: remote collaboration reimagined
I would say that for most meetings, the current state of VR is not worth it. So no to your question.

But I would also disagree with "quite a lot of people can get quite a lot done with just audio or audio+video meetings" at least to the extent that I would say people who will enjoy this work culture long-term are in the minority. I truly don't believe most people are meant to work in a room alone for hours everyday (even though some thrive on it!).

istorical··on ‘Horizon Workrooms’: remote collaboration reimagined
Reading these comments is like the "640k ought to be enough [memory] for anybody" quote by Bill Gates or the "Remote shopping, while entirely feasible, will flop." Time Magazine quote.

Social presence is the best killer app of VR so far besides porn.

edit: will admit to understanding the hate for the fb 'stench' altho at this point people are falling into a bit of a sports-team level of blind love and hate towards particular FAANG members, but people utterly failing to see the potential of virtual 3d/physical environments for communication/collaboration? c'mon, it's ok to hate oculus/fb but have some sense of the bigger picture as far as what this could turn into in 20 years.

istorical··on Tinder will introduce voluntary ID verification to reduce catfishing incidents
It does if you follow rules #1 and #2.
istorical··on New York City adds 629,000 people, defying predictions of its decline
"The subway-cars can become a place to forni- and deficate for the homeless for weeks, making it unusable for citizens. But critique cannot make a dent, becaue it is guilty by association."

this is the type of stuff people who don't live in NYC say. guess what, I use the subway all the time and things go perfectly well! it's definitely got its problems and there's a real homelessness crisis in NYC (although nothing like the west coast tent cities exists here), but to say it's 'not usable'? you're out of touch.

istorical··on The rise of the one-person unicorn
which part of northern europe? my experience was that it was cool but not particularly different in that respect
istorical··on Ask HN: Should I even bother competing for React jobs?
If you've been programming for years and can't get an entry level job, it might be that your presentation skills / communication skills are the weak link. Might be worth doing a mock interview with a professional whose job it is to help you get a job (you may have to pay them for their time) to make sure there's nothing obviously wrong with the way you are presenting yourself. As far as react goes, have you done work on front-end only or back-end as well? Do you have experience with databases and writing SQL? Getting a full-stack engineer role often requires less 'know this exact framework/language' if you can do some simple technical screens online where you can select from multiple languages or in-person via pseudocode.

When you say you can't get a job doing it, how many positions did you apply to? Even for a competitive candidate with a degree, you might have to send out 50 applications to get in pipeline with 10-15, ultimately end up with 2-3 offers.

Last, what country are you from?

istorical··on July 2021 was the warmest July on record for the globe
The long term trend in planetary sea ice still shows a decrease though, for more information on Arctic vs Antarctic ice:

https://www.carbonbrief.org/guest-post-deciphering-the-rise-...

istorical··on What if a deadly heatwave hit India?
People have been incredibly more ignorant in the past, it's the power brokers and influencers (wealth, media, political class, etc) that guided the unwashed masses to at least somewhat expedient futures previously, but who now seem to have either vacated their responsibility / succumbed to greed or short-term thinking or alternatively some breakdown of systems of power and democracy because of technology or legal changes and their effect on media, fragmentation of public knowledge, erosion of institutions, etc.

On a very real level, we have better technology, more people learning greater chunks of knowledge, higher literacy rates, etc. than we did in the 1700s or 1800s or 1900s, so you can't blame widespread ignorance alone.

istorical··on 2020 U.S. Migration Map
that's a strange takeaway to make without evidence.

alternate hypotheses:

remote work enabled more people to earn a high salary typically found in a large city or coastal area while moving to lower cost of living areas.

also, people who lost their work in industries heavily impacted by quarantine (hospitality, food, restaurant, retail) moved back home or in with family to save money.

istorical··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
You seem to be drawing no distinction between the following two possible outcomes:

1. Slow carbon emissions now despite the incredible amount we've already added and hope that the damage we've done is not enough to completely ruin the planet.

2. Do nothing and let emissions accelerate even further, create an even bigger problem than we've already created. Gamble to an even greater extent with our future.

Where in your incredibly long essay have you provided any reason to believe option 2 is better than option 1?

As far as I can tell, all you've done is prove we can't get back to pre-industrial levels quickly just by stopping emissions today. So what?

Who ever said the goal was to get back to pre-industrial levels? I think all climate science believers aim to do is reduce the extent of this incredible gamble and unintended experiment humanity has undertaken. Instead of gambling on a 1% odds of survival slot machine, climate scientists want to slow down and gamble on a 10% odds of survival slot machine. No one ever said we could move that probability back to 100% odds of survival slot machine.

To me your post comes across like someone on the Titanic saying 'Hey guys, we've looked at the data and situation, stop thinking these 20 lifeboats will be able to rescue us. Just give up.' when there are some people arguing that the ship isn't sinking at all, and others trying to quickly come up with ways to create more impromptu lifeboats, trying to figure out how to stop the ship from sinking, or trying to urge those that they can to get in the lifeboats, despite the fact some will still die. At the end of the day your post just encourages those who don't think the ship is sinking or those that think there's no point to try getting in a lifeboat or creating a new one out of furniture to just go back down below deck and listen to the violinists for another hour before drowning.

istorical··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
American democracy is just as capable, see Japanese internment, Guantanamo Bay, the Tuskegee experiment, warrantless wiretapping, etc.
istorical··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
Quite frankly, that is why democracy will fail us. Most Americans will do just about anything to avoid their income falling for 10-20 years but do just about nothing to avoid the global climate from torpedoing the world's biomes, food production systems, weather patterns, coastlines and coastal cities, decimating species diversity, etc. over 10-100 years.

We could be saved by technological or business breakthrough from an individual, or we could be saved by authoritarianism, but the preference you just described is why we're probably fucked if we hope for a political solution in western democracies (at least the US).

istorical··on ST Sees AR Glasses Replacing Smartphones
One commonality between mouse+keyboard and smartphone is that small movements mostly in fingers and wrists are all that's needed for input. Contrast with Xbox Kinect - hype then disappeared, Nintendo Wii - hype then disappeared, and now some VR input...in all of these systems many of the experiences are designed around large body movements that go against the ingrained human instinct to be lazy. See "gorilla arms".

AR/VR needs micro-gesture input. Logitech K830 keyboard is tracked in VR with Oculus Quest 2 which is a step in the right direction. FB acquired CTRL-Labs whose CTRL-kit allows for some elementary BCI and Valve is investing heavily in BCI, Gabe Newell can't stop talking about how excited he is about it. And I'm sure Google and MS are trying as well.

But AR will need low-effort input before it replaces smartphones (unless it focuses only on high read / low write use case as its killer apps). Hopefully Apple has an input system for its AR product that doesn't require gorilla arms. AR + smartphone where the smartphone touchscreen acts as a trackpad or controller would likely be a better system than any hand wave-y / hand tracking.

istorical··on Google co-founder Larry Page is a New Zealand resident, government says
A lot of people in these comments will likely miss a lot of the relative value in NZ as a bunker-of-last-resort:

Factors:

1. Radioactive fallout patterns in a hot nuclear war between any of US, China, Russia, Europe. NZ has low target priority and wind driven fallout spread may be lower.

2. Spillover effects from climate-change driven mass human refugee migration (water and distance are an effective barrier from hundreds of millions of displaced people from Africa, South Asia, or Latin America who may be forced to flee areas that cannot grow food or which reach the wet bulb mark in temp+humidity).

3. Low population density relative to natural resources / nature / arable land.

4. Relatively high amounts of freshwater resources relative to population (and possible population post-refugee/migrants in an adverse war/climate scenario).

In the event that the proletariat rose up and demanded support from those in bunkers, the number of 'normies'/refugees that 'robber barons fled to NZ' would have to support is much lower than the number of revolutionary poor that could storm the Bastille in most other continents. The amount of 'bread and circuses' you need to supply to avoid ending like Versaille is cheaper. If you decide mercilessly to just kill any refugees / migrants in a post-apocalyptic scenario, you can do so while they are still in the water / on improvised rafts rather than defending an area on land.

Of course I may be wrong and am happy to be corrected on any of these points.

istorical··on The STEM Crisis Is a Myth (2013)
do you think your productivity or output or skill level increased 60% alongside the 60% raise or do you think your skill level increase / change in 'worth' was less?

Or in other words once you got in, did things get way more difficult / stressful?

← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →