HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

itistoday2

628 karma · joined June 18, 2011

I upset the powers that be through my support of Bradley Manning, and now have this new account.

    Previous Karma  : 2231
    Previous Avg    : 7.47
    Previous account: http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itistoday
I've got https://lobste.rs invites! (HN "like the good ol' days".) Happy to invite folks I feel will contribute positively to the community.

On Lobsters: moderation is public info, and so is who invited who. Downvotes require reasons, and they are undoable.

Send me an email (itistoday at gmail) with your HN profile and temporarily place your email info in your HN profile so that I can verify you.

submissionscomments
itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
The point is that torture:

1. Is not helpful or useful even if, by chance, accurate information is given [1,2].

2. Hurts our national security [2].

3. Is unnecessary. Given that torture is one of the most harmful options to pick from, it's likely there are other, less harmful options available, and if so, the logical and ethical action is to pursue those instead.

On that third point I challenge you to prove me wrong. You won't be able to, however, because we have no meaningful oversight of these practices.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9867266 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9868400

itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
Well, we can all chip in to help move it forward.

Behavior like his should be rewarded, and the behavior of those he outed should be punished.

How else are we going to stop torture?

To send Kiriakou $USD is to take real, meaningful action against torture.

There is something to be said for doing good for goodness sake, but wouldn't it be great if people knew that honorable behavior could also be rewarding in both senses of the word?

itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
> It would be nice to know why they're so intransigent about it. Do they believe the evidence is wrong? Or perhaps they only use intelligence gathering as a pretext, and they really use it for punishment. Despicable, either way, but I'm curious to know.

Some people really are sadists and derive pleasure from the suffering of others. Others are fools or are too apathetic or cowardly to do anything about it. This may very well be the reality of our government. Signs seem to point in that direction.

itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
Well, they've done trials of torture (as the article points out).

Maybe he should survey those who were tortured?

"I know from personal experience that the abuse of prisoners will produce more bad than good intelligence. I know that victims of torture will offer intentionally misleading information if they think their captors will believe it. I know they will say whatever they think their torturers want them to say if they believe it will stop their suffering."

— John McCain

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/12/John-Mcc...

itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
It's one thing to rationalize "live donor transplants", quite another to make excuses for torture.
itistoday2··on Psychologists Shielded U.S. Torture Program, Report Finds
I would like to take this moment to point out that John Kiriakou is doing an Indiegogo campaign:

https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-whistleblower-who-won...

It's because of people like him that we know about this at all.

He put his life on the line for us. Only he was imprisoned. The torturers [1,2] are still free.

Until there are consequences to torture it will continue to happen, and Kiriakou's sacrifice will be in vain.

Think about what the pizza delivery man has done for you, and compare that to what Kiriakou did for us all.

Consider sending him a monetary thank you for his service to you, to our country, and to humanity. I did.

[1] http://www.ibtimes.com/who-cia-torture-report-george-tenet-h...

[2] http://www.publicintegrity.org/2014/12/12/15221/whos-respons...

itistoday2··on Office of Personnel Management Says Hackers Got Data of Millions of Individuals
Well, "But, ISIS!" is not a real argument, that should be clear.

Backdoors make the situation worse, not better. We'll still have ISIS, we'll be even less secure, and we'll have lost whatever is left of our right to privacy.

Pretty much a lose-lose for everyone involved (except maybe ISIS).

The answer to "But, ISIS!" is not backdoors, it's foreign policy.

itistoday2··on OpenSSL Security Advisory
> If you think you can write a better implementation then put your hands where your keyboard is. Show us the code.

Here you go!

https://github.com/mirleft/ocaml-tls

itistoday2··on Are killer whales persons?
Here's an example of a grizzly expressing non-consent to being caged up:

http://www.startribune.com/minnesota-zoo-bear-slams-rock-int...

That is sufficient for me and it should be sufficient for any decent human being.

If you require a grizzly or an orca to "sign on the dotted line for informed legal consent", you are a monster, and you are the one who should be caged up.

itistoday2··on Mailpile Chooses AGPL v3
Happy to see the community chose AGPL.

I'd be more OK with the Apache license if it did not contain very dangerous language in it for contributors:

https://www.taoeffect.com/blog/2013/09/the-apache-contributo...

For those looking for an Apache-like license without such language, consider the MPL 2.0.

itistoday2··on Are killer whales persons?
> because an orca will neither grow up to be able to give consent

Conjecture that I do not agree with. Orcas can definitely give consent, it depends on the situation.

> nor could they reach that capacity as a species (within human timeframes).

More conjecture with which I disagree. Orcas can talk and they can indicate consent already.

> there isn't any selection pressure guiding them in that direction.

Conjecture. Strongly disagree.

> Personally I think Sea World is criminally abusive because it is necessarily incapable of holding large water mammals like orcas in captivity in a way that minimizes suffering for them

Finally, something we agree on.

itistoday2··on Own-Mailbox, the first 100% confidential mailbox
Anything relying on HTTPS is not "100% confidential".
itistoday2··on Are killer whales persons?
Nice exception to Betteridge's law of headlines, IMO.
itistoday2··on Are killer whales persons?
Under United States law companies are persons as well, so these definitions are a bit out of date.

It's perfectly reasonable to expand the term "person" to apply to non humans, companies and orcas alike.

itistoday2··on JScreenFix – Repair stuck pixels
I had read that, and it didn't really answer my question.
itistoday2··on JScreenFix – Repair stuck pixels
How do pixels become "stuck" in the first place? What is the mechanism by which this happens, and how does this technique fix it?
itistoday2··on China’s Troubling Robot Revolution
HN discussion on this article from two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9697058
itistoday2··on Do Binaural Beats Really Affect Brainwaves?
What is "conscious auditory processing", and what is "an effective side-channel attack on the synaptic substrate"?
itistoday2··on Do Binaural Beats Really Affect Brainwaves?
Um, brainwaves != subjective cognitive effects.

Even plain old, ordinary, non-binaural music has significant, meaningful cognitive effects (and is often used in gyms and therapy for that purpose).

Most know from first-hand experience that sound can affect the brain (and body) in significant ways. Sound affects neurotransmitters and hormones in the body. If it didn't, we probably wouldn't have ears. The purpose of ears is to make it possible for sound to affect us.

If your conclusion is "no effect", you're probably not listening hard enough, or for the right thing. That "Not much difference" could make all the difference.

itistoday2··on Asciinema
> Would this be better if the pasted command included some checksum which was checked before piping into the `sh`?

hashpipe does exactly that:

https://github.com/jbenet/hashpipe

itistoday2··on Being Sneaky in C
I am aware of that.
itistoday2··on Being Sneaky in C
Looking at the source, this is where the alarm bells should go off in a reviewer's head:

    memcpy(filter->buffer, output->piu_text_utf8, sizeof(output->piu_text_utf8));
1. memcpy is less safe than memmove and strncpy. strncpy should be used.

2. The two character arrays should use the same constant in defining their length, and that constant should be used both in the struct definitions and here in the copy operation.

3. The code is written in C in spite of it being 2014 at the time.

itistoday2··on China’s Troubling Robot Revolution
> I'm curious about this. Any references?

Yes, see my post above for links about one possible cryptocurrency approach called Group Currency (disclaimer: I am one of the contributors to that idea).

Group currencies can be thought of as "company-tribes" where relationships are familial instead of exchange-based. We'll post a simplified version of this scheme to https://blog.okturtles.com soon.

The TLDR of the simple method is: (1) members of the company-tribe all accept payment for their products and services to the group's account. (2) Funds are divided evenly until a basic income has been reached for each member (say, for the month), after which all additional funds go to the member who is generating them.

> The problem I see is that you already have this huge taxation burden which soaks up surplus wealth that might power such things. Implementing basic income at the government level would redirect this firehose, but I don't see how decentralized voluntarist approaches would achieve that.

This is a great point, and one that needs to be considered and discussed.

It is possible for a group to both pay taxes and provide its members with a basic income (and campaign for an end to mandatory income taxes ;).

itistoday2··on China’s Troubling Robot Revolution
> I'm a fan of the idea of eliminating coercive taxation but I do not see it as something politically achievable in the foreseeable future.

It is also questionable whether basic income itself is politically achievable.

The beauty of the non-coercive voluntary approaches to basic income is that it can be implemented right now by any group without requiring or waiting on any political gesticulation.

itistoday2··on China’s Troubling Robot Revolution
> Guaranteed basic income. It's the only way... at least if we want a future that is actually good for more than ~10% of the human race.

Basic income is one of two ways of realizing a future that is good for everyone (and those ~10% won't be happy without it because the zombies will be at their door). The other way is to make everything free (either forcefully, or through price reductions via technology and automation).

Basic income is known to work [1]. "Making everything free" forcefully is a no-go because it disrespects the realities of market dynamics (as we've learned from Communism).

It is important also to realize that there are many ways of implementing BI, and some of them are better than others. This is a debate and discussion we should be all having.

The primary ethical decision I see is whether BI is implemented in a coercive manner (i.e. taxation) or a voluntary manner. Both approaches are possible and each can be done in various different ways. I worked on something called http://groupcurrency.org [2], a voluntary cryptocurrency approach to basic income, and there are many other approaches as well, the simplest of which is simply for a "company-tribe" to guarantee its members a minimum income (backed by the fruits of their collective labor).

For those interested in Basic Income, I strongly recommend perusing the subreddit r/basicincome and related subreddits (r/CryptoUBI, etc.).

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index#wiki_that.27...

[2] HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9501059

itistoday2··on Arguments in the Bitcoin Block Size Debate
Relevant: coverage of various perspectives and positions by Ethan Heilman along with counterarguments to each:

https://github.com/EthanHeilman/BlockSizeDebate/blob/master/...

I like that it also includes discussion of the Lightning Network's role, and the idea of making the block size dynamic. These are less heard of perspectives that nevertheless seem significant.

itistoday2··on HTML is done
He's not saying "HTML is done" as in "over" or "not to be used". He seems to mean something along the lines of "feature complete" and suggests further efforts focus on parts of the web that are lacking (JavaScript, DOM, CSS).
itistoday2··on HTML is done
This is the problem with reading only the title of an article...
itistoday2··on Ross Ulbricht Sentenced to Life in Prison
I think you meant to reply to mpyne, but that is a very amusing observation. :)
itistoday2··on Ross Ulbricht Sentenced to Life in Prison
> There's a difference in degree and in kind. Water does not create addiction that forces you to consume it in amounts that are seriously harmful to your health.

Neither do most drugs, especially most illegal drugs.

Many legal drugs do (the most addictive of all being nicotine), but that also doesn't matter and is besides the point.

These are health issues, not criminal issues.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →