HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

j-wags

285 karma · joined February 13, 2019

Jeff Wagner, Open Force Field Consortium
submissionscomments
j-wags··on We try out the first legal level 3 automated driving system in the US
As a pedestrian in an urban area, my main purpose for communicating with drivers is to figure out whether they're going to actually give me the right of way that I (by law) have at stop signs. This is necessary because ~30% of human drivers choose to break the law and go first anyway. I'm optimistic about autonomous vehicles because (I assume) they're programmed to give pedestrians right of way 100% of the time.
j-wags··on 2024 Nissan Kicks Is the Kind of Car We Need More Of: Affordable
I strongly suspect that we could make equally protective, lighter weight crumple zones if we were designing for collisions with lighter weight cars. Excessive cabin protection is largely needed because bumpers on light trucks are at head level for passengers in normal cars. Weight is a safety factor independent of crumple zones and cabin protection because in a crash m1a1=m2a2, and you don't want to get caught with the smaller m.

I'm concerned that we're currently cranking out a generation of uniquely heavy and dangerous vehicles which future vehicles will have to share the road with for decades, perpetuating these dangerous design factors.

If we designed a new 5-seat sedan that could easily reach 90 mph, but which only needed to share the road with other copies of itself, I bet we could do it in 1000 pounds and it would be far safer.

j-wags··on College football in the US is awash with money
A slight tangent - I played small college football as a lineman and every once in a while we'd be in a televised game. Those games were almost a different sport because they'd stop play during commercial breaks, so it was as if 10+ random time-outs were sprinkled through the game.

While not an exact comparison, playing line during a possession is like having a series of 5 to 10-second intervals where you're either sumo wrestling or sprinting, with 10-40 seconds to recover between each. So during the off-season, linemen are trying to reach a balance of strength, speed, and cardio to meet their team's play style. Because most of our games were non-televised (and therefore we didn't get the additional breaks) our linemen conditioned more heavily for cardio/recovery. So when we'd play a televised game we'd basically feel like our cardio was "underutilized". I'd love to see an analysis of whether our team ran more line-intensive plays during these games because we had the additional recovery time.

It's weird for me to see these huge guys in D1 college and the NFL playing line, because I'm pretty sure they'd cramp up/get gassed during a drive in a non-televised game.

j-wags··on Thousands of octopuses gather off California to brood eggs at a warm spot
I learned recently that the pluralization of "octopus" is a linguistics rabbit hole. While most people would reach for "octopuses" or "octopi", the strictly correctest pluralization would be "octopodes" (last syllable rhyming with "these"), since the word is from ancient greek. [1]

I first heard this on a linguistics podcast called "Talk the Talk"[2] (now superseded by "Because Language"[3]). The hosts go on to clarify that language evolves over time and is most importantly defined by what people actually use, so there's nothing wrong with modern English deviating from the ancient greek pluralization.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Etymology_and_pluralis... [2] https://talkthetalkpodcast.com/ [3] https://becauselanguage.com/

j-wags··on Putin’s Forever War
In this vein, I recommend the 1420 channel on YouTube [1]. It has videos of random Russians being interviewed with provocative questions, mostly in the major cities but sometimes also in small towns/villages. It is admittedly anecdata, but folks often candidly share their thoughts, and it paints an interesting picture of modern Russian society.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/@1420channel

j-wags··on My resignation letter as R7RS-large chair
I upvoted because I'm involved in a growing OSS project that's tangling with similar questions of scope and governance. Simultaneously being responsible for everything from software deployment and PR reviews to project scoping and interpersonal conflict de-escalation is absolutely exhausting. I'm fantasizing/extrapolating that many of the people writing "so sorry to see you go" messages were the ones being quarrelsome and refusing compromise, and now they're getting the defect-defect outcome.
j-wags··on Wind and solar will be 25% of U.S. generating capacity within three years
This article [1] on pumped hydro tempered my expectations a lot - It calculates that a nation-scale pumped hydro battery for the USA would need to be about the size of Lake Superior and have a 300 m height drop

https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2011/11/pump-up-the-storage/

j-wags··on Grad student unions strike deal with University of California
Narrowly speaking, $100/hour is probably true. However my arrangement as a chemistry phd student at UCSD included the following conditions:

To be eligible to earn $100/hour, you must be a grad student who:

* only earns at that rate for 20 hours per week

* is forbidden to work any other job for pay

* pays $20k/year in "tuition" despite the fact that you don't take classes after the first year or two of your 5+ year program

* also works at least 30 hours per week for $0/hour in your research lab (otherwise your advisor will drop you)

So, when you include those conditions, the situation is really "work 50-80 hours per week for $30-35k/year in an expensive california city". Which people were fine to do until phd student stipends started falling behind the cost of living in these cities for the past 10 years.

j-wags··on Grad student unions strike deal with University of California
Your comment could be read in two ways. Could you clarify?

1) The UC professor offered a remote postdoc because they did not have enough funding to pay the minimum UC postdoc salary, but could pay less to out of state employees

2) The UC professor offered a remote postdoc because the allowed UC postdoc salary was not sufficient to attract candidates given the area's cost of living

j-wags··on The hacking of Starlink terminals has begun
Ah, you're right - I'd vaguely remembered seeing this before and pasted the wikipedia section without reading it thoroughly. My mistake!
j-wags··on Too many Americans live in places built for cars – not for human connection
> They also are miserable with homeless people, drug addicts, and crime.

What aspect of urban development caused these people to be homeless, drug-addicted, or criminal? Did the frequency of bus service get them addicted to drugs? Did the taller building height take their job?

We make this unconscious logical leap that there's some justification for human misery to be concentrated in urban cores. I live in a dense urban core right now, and I see human misery when I go outside. I think "boy, it'd be nice to move to an area where this miserable person isn't". But... it'd be ridiculous to be happy by pretending misery doesn't exist because it's not in eyeshot. If that were the case, we should just ship miserable people to the suburbs where I don't have to see them (that would be cheaper and more convenient for me!). The wealth density of an urban neighborhood is huge, there's easily enough money to relocate miserable people into even rich suburbs.

The better thing to do is to make choices that cause there to be fewer miserable people. I'm optimistic that the current debate around the urban-suburban-rural divide and the role of cars will make us recognize that there's huge mutual interest in the idea that _public spaces should be nice_, and that seeing the misery that results from our policy choices is a feature and not a bug.

j-wags··on Too many Americans live in places built for cars – not for human connection
The Netherlands seems to pull off having a high fertility rate [1] and high population density [2]. Anecdotally, my friend who was born there in the late 1980s described being allowed to travel alone starting from a young age. I had one American friend born in the same generation who was allowed to bike around LA in his mid-teens, and my parents almost called CPS on him.

[1] https://i.redd.it/k03mlnruuro61.jpg [2] https://www.stockingblue.com/article/126/european-union-stat...

j-wags··on The hacking of Starlink terminals has begun
Hackers damaged/destroyed the ROSAT satellite in the late 90s

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ROSAT#End_of_operations

j-wags··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
There were a few scenarios in the RTS Cossacks that had this - Two armies would be facing off, and the general (you) would just be a single horseman. You were surrounded by messengers that you could dispatch to various units, but you had to take into account that they wouldn't get there immediately, and that sometimes the messengers would get shot en route to delivering their commands.
j-wags··on Antiviral compound blocks SARS-CoV-2 from entering cells
I initially skipped over this post because it appeared to be written in bad faith [1]. But I gave it another shot and read the linked paper, and I agree with the summary. Thanks for pointing this out -- your post has changed my understanding of the vaccine's effectiveness.

For skeptical readers - The linked paper is a medrxiv preprint, with authors from several locations. Many of the authors list affiliations with Pfizer, and the last author is an MD at Pfizer. This seems to be a required report from the ~6-month point of a clinical trial. There really are 14 and 15 all-cause deaths reported in the placebo and treatment groups, respectively. The causes of death for each group are in table S4 [2]. The incidence of COVID in the treatment group is much lower than in the placebo group.

I'm surprised by these results because I would have expected to see significantly lower mortality in the vaccine group.

One possible reason for this surprising result is that only a small fraction of people - even in the placebo group - caught COVID at all. I'm not sure how to account for possible missed infections but Figure 2 of the main text indicates that 0.08% of the placebo group became CASES (which I think means something like "person felt bad enough to see a medical professional, who then diagnosed them with COVID"), and the table in Figure 2 indicates that there were 1034 "occurrences" out of ~22,000 people in the placebo group (which I read as "~5% confirmed infections").

So, it's possible that the beneficial effect of the vaccine is still hidden in the statistical noise since there have been so few infections in the placebo group. It's also possible that some people _were_ harmed by receiving the vaccine (see table S4 [2]), so there's a fixed harm upfront to the vaccine group, which may eventually be surpassed once more of the placebo group gets infected.

Thanks for posting this!

[1] I really do appreciate you making this post, and it helped me learn something. I would have been more willing to read it initially if it had excluded the phrases "such a joke", "since people like to be binary thinkers", "crappy associative arguments", "to quote the great...". It seems like there's a silent majority of HN lurkers that are interested in all perspectives, and really are open to quality arguments like this, but might dismiss this post before reading it because of the choice of phrases.

[2] Link to supp material PDF is on this page: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.07.28.21261159v...

j-wags··on Chemical space is really big (2014)
If you'd like to check out what current chemical database files look like, "Enamine REAL" is a fairly widely-known one.[1] My understanding is that this file is a mix of their ACTUAL in-stock inventory, as well as the product of running a small number of high-reliability reactions on each compound in that inventory. So it serves as a "vendor catalog" file, where everything in here can be ordered from Enamine and synthesized+delivered to your door in a few weeks.

Another approach I've heard of for iterating through every molecule in a large region of chemical space is to START with a large molecule dataset, then for each molecule, predict the result of performing simple reactions on it. For each reaction product, do your full analysis, and only store the result if the analysis indicates it is noteworthy. This, in effect, lets you scan over a larger region of chemical space than you can fit in memory.

[1] https://enamine.net/compound-collections/real-compounds/real...

j-wags··on 0 A.D A free, open-source game of ancient warfare
Some of my friends started a weekly gaming group when lockdown began. We initially played 0 AD as a joke. One year in, we've had stints of Starcraft 2, CS:GO, and Among Us. But at this point we've settled into something of a rotation of 0 AD and Overwatch.

It's a good game to play with friends and the jankiness is actually pretty charming. Just stay away from naval combat.

j-wags··on Electricity over $900/MWh in most of Western US now
The fridge should be a very efficient heat pump, moreso than an resistive electric heater. Can you get its waste heat to the fish tank?
j-wags··on Setup Anaconda, Jupyter, and Rust
> Once Miniconda is installed, we need to create and configure our environment. If you added Miniconda to your PATH environment during the installation process, then you can run these commands directly from Terminal, Powershell, or CMD.

AFAIK, the PATH modification route is no longer recommended. Instead one should use, eg `. miniconda3/etc/profile.d/conda.sh` to add a particular miniconda installaiton to the environment.

j-wags··on Gmail having issues
Over the past 24 hours, I've had GitHub request that I re-verify my gmail three times (roughly 22 hours ago, 2 hours ago, and now), each time resetting my primary email's status to "Undeliverable" and "Unverified"

The triggering event may be an email bounce. I get a lot of github notifications sent to my email, and the failure of just one/a few may trigger the reverification.

j-wags··on Trolls break into meetings on Zoom
I attended a PhD defense yesterday that got zoom bombed. They quickly moved it to an actively managed call and the presenter did a fine job of keeping their composure and getting back on track. Now we're circulating guides about how to set up secure rooms and webinars, so I don't anticipate this will happen again.

Normally I'd wave this off as a childish prank, but both the URL and loading screen prominently indicated the name of a major medical school, and the contents of the presentation were proteins and chemical structures. Bombing this meeting in particular seems to be in especially bad taste during a pandemic.

j-wags··on Aussie firefighters save world's only groves of prehistoric Wollemi pines
From a purely monetary standpoint, genetic diversity has growing commercial uses [1]. Isolated ecosystems often contain genes and enzymes that let us access new areas of chemical space (this is big in drug discovery ATM). We recognize that sequencing methods at a given time may not capture all of the relevant info about a gene (ex. methylation, weird folds, expression), so having living samples as new technology becomes available is critical in this research.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_product

j-wags··on ‘Virtual Pharmacology’ Advance Tackles Universe of Unknown Drugs
Hey Oleg, I just wanted to say thanks for doing some really great work. AutoDock Vina made a huge impact on the field, and its results are still on-par with commercial docking codes. Academic software development is a combination of some of the worst parts of open-source software development and the worst parts of academia, but projects like Vina motivated me to be a better coder and scientist in grad school.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2