HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

j_wtf_all_taken

147 karma · joined July 5, 2019

submissionscomments
j_wtf_all_taken··on Don't Feed the Thought Leaders
> He found that experts could be split into two broad categories, the first of which he called Hedgehogs. A Hedgehog had one big idea like free-market capitalism (or nordic model capitalism or demand-side economics), which they used as a lens to look at many issues. They applied this big idea to every situation, which resulted in noncontingent and straightforward advice. You always need more freedom, nutmeg, and unit tests. Hedgehogs are “Confident forecasters”.

> When all the predictions were added up and scored, hedgehogs lost out to his second category: Foxes. Foxes were the opposite of hedgehogs. They had complicated advice and were skeptical of even their own predictions. Tetlock also found that foxes were less likely to be famous because contingent advice is harder to explain in a sound bite.

This explains so much - unfortunately, because there's no fingers to point and no quick solution. Its just all of us and our stupid brains that always fall for the hedgehogs.

j_wtf_all_taken··on Solar assets ‘underperforming’, modules degrading faster than expected: research
Only if grandma works as an insurance agent.
j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
> I hear this argument a lot but maybe that's just me but I don't forget much. I don't have perfect memory, far from it, but remembering my thought process when faced with my old code, even decades old is not really a problem for me

That might be true for you. But I have met too many people that say this about themselves, but then I see them "understanding" their old code (i.e. looking around and not having a clue). In their cases, its just self-deception.

Its the same people that say they don't need comments, but then they look around their own files with confused faces.

But yeah there are definitely also people with good memory. Those are also the people that happen to, for example, put more thought in structuring their code.

> Boring, repetitive tasks are for the computer, not the developer.

Unfortunately we have to do a lot of boring, repetitive tasks when developing that could be done by the computer ;-(

j_wtf_all_taken··on Solar assets ‘underperforming’, modules degrading faster than expected: research
It depends. One, two, three or four wheels?
j_wtf_all_taken··on Third member of FDA panel resigns over approval of Biogen Alzheimer's drug
That, and with respect to:

> Alzheimer’s sounds like a good candidate, or near-fatal diseases (6-month-to-live cancer) - you literally have nothing to lose!

But others have a lot to lose. No matter how experimental the application and how much consent and oversight - if the drug is being used on people before finishing all testing and without taking all necessary precautions, you increase the risk of side or adverse effects. That in turn will likely delay the approval of the drug for all patients.

So in the end, a couple of people get experimental treatment but might delay the treatment for a large group of people. That's no easy trade-off, and is certainly not a sign for a broken system.

j_wtf_all_taken··on Solar assets ‘underperforming’, modules degrading faster than expected: research
It can work in a well regulated market with healthy competition.
j_wtf_all_taken··on Privacy Analysis of FLoC
Yeah the difference between the things we know we should want, and the things we actually want in the moment. Its incredible in how many ways the brain can be annoying ;-)
j_wtf_all_taken··on Privacy Analysis of FLoC
I strongly believe that gaping holes did exist in peoples souls waaaay before ads were invented.

Don't know, though ... when I asked the all-knowing internet if "gaping holes did exist in people's souls before ads were invented", the first search result is a link to the Harry Potter Fandom-Wiki article about Dementors:

"Dementors are among the foulest creatures that walk this earth. They infest the darkest, filthiest places, they glory in decay and despair, they drain peace, hope, and happiness out of the air around them... Get too near a Dementor and every good feeling, every happy memory will be sucked out of you. If it can, the Dementor will feed on you long enough to reduce you to something like itself... soulless and evil. You will be left with nothing but the worst experiences of your life."

j_wtf_all_taken··on Privacy Analysis of FLoC
It'd just be nice to have a little more control, for starters. So advertisers try to figure out what we want by what websites we visit and are not too good at it. They could also just ... ask? I'd like to have an ad service that I can tell what I'm actually interested in these days, and that forces the companies to provide lots of information about the product they are advertising for (documentation and stuff). So if I see an interesting ad, I can easily find out if its actually something I want. And money only flows if I actually buy something, affiliate-link style.
j_wtf_all_taken··on Privacy Analysis of FLoC
But then it seems the problem is not ads, but the gaping holes in peoples souls?
j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
We'll never get those things right at first. That's why - specifically the more complex code you talk about - stuff should be isolated with clearly defined interfaces, known or no side-effects etc. Only then its possible to reorganize and refactor the code when you figure out how it actually should be.

For example, the car driving example: what about the drivers license you need? All the traffic regulations you have to follow? Also gotta buy or rent a car to be able to drive one. What do you do if your car breaks down? Maintenance?

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
Newbie can also be yourself looking at your own code a year later. You will have forgotten a lot and will have made it harder for yourself to re-understand what you were doing.

There's a difference between learning stuff and applying stuff.

Its about not making the code more complicated and obscure than necessary. Using generic language constructs like switch/case - sure. I don't think that falls in the category of "clever".

j_wtf_all_taken··on A martian’s review of The Martian (2015)
> So you end up with lots of scenes where one character has to come across as clueless so that the other character can explain things to them (and to the reader). This is not how normal conversations between people at mission control would go. Realistic conversations would be nearly incomprehensible to someone who is not an expert, thanks to all the shorthand. People wouldn’t be explaining things in great detail, instead other people would be cutting them off mid-thought, already seeing where they are going and jumping to the next logical conclusion.

Sounds a little like "everyone at NASA is a genius". Well, probably not. Routine stuff in mission control - ok. But when there's off-nominal stuff, there will definitely be people that have no idea what's going on and need extra explanations. People at mission control are highly specialized, I guess, so why should someone doing X instantly know what's going wrong with Y?

Also, there's administration, and some of those scenes are about convincing administrative people. They surely have technical understanding, but there would still be some explaining going on.

> In reality, upon being stranded, an astronaut would probably sit down and figure out in a few hours and a few pages of calculations what it takes Watney weeks, and lots of trial and error, to sort out.

No. Also astronauts are no all-knowing geniuses. They specifically are not looking for people that are incredibly awesome in certain areas and know everything about that topic, they are looking for people that do not underperform in any field. They don't need geniuses, they need workers who do a job that is pretty much pre-determined. And yes they need to be quick thinkers and stuff, need to be able to draw logical conclusions etc. But they definitely do not need to have all knowledge about any probably relevant topic in their head (as far as I remember Watney didn't have a dump of Wikipedia with him. Why the f ever they wouldn't send a copy with them. That'd be the first thing I'd put on a rocket to Mars).

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
I really hate that saying "its simple until you make it complicated".

No! I really like the distinction between "simple" and "easy".

Writing a little script that does some job is easy. Then you add lots of extra conditions and edge cases and exceptions because damn, its not as easy as you thought, so the script becomes complicated. After a while you figure out what the problem domain is, think of some smarter rules making the thing complex. Then you dumb down those rules, throw out unnecessary stuff, streamline things, realize that multiple specifically covered edge cases can actually be covered by changing some structure in your code etc - and finally, finally that all makes the thing simple.

Simple isn't dumb. Simple is so elegant and smart that it looks dumb.

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
> Software developers spend years training (or self-training) to use their brains to solve complex problems, which involves continuous learning, constantly making "tactical" decisions, and quickly gaining understanding of the big picture.

I'm just not sure that applies to all people working in software engineering (or any job). I know too many that have no desire to actually understand the/a problem or make tactical decisions but just try out ten code snippets from SO until something works, use any plugin that kinda fits their need (without looking at the size of its code base, if its maintained, how flexible its configuration is etc) or are happy to use any framework as long as it tells them exactly what to do (and not because they actually came to the conclusion that's the way to go, but because they are not responsible for anything but the framework is).

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
> Now suppose we could have an alternative version of that tool, written by a skilled developer using a more performance-oriented language, and placing greater emphasis on runtime performance even if it means sacrificing some readability in the source code.

I'm just not sure that's a decision that we often have to make. Is more performant code most of the time also less readable? What about still using JavaScript, still having readable code and getting the execution time to 1-2s?

Also, using another language is probably never the issue except its some weird rarely used language.

But given your scenario: what if changing to the other language and the less readable code keeps other developers from extending the tool, writing plugins and stuff? So what if you have to give up all those contributions from other people?

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
The examples you gave are exactly the ones I mean with generic solutions. Stuff you can apply to many things, like lambdas. Such things exist in many programming languages. Yes, that's stuff people should learn and keep up with.

But using some weird quirk or very uncommon language construct just to save a couple of lines of code (and show how well you know the language) - tempting, but just don't.

And use long, understandable variable names! Don't be a mathematician, you're an engineer! (totally unrelated but its just really annoying)

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
> But what if the junior member can't understand OOP, functional programming, has no idea of abstraction and can only produce duplication and duplication of code

... then this person obviously did not pay attention in class and should probably not have been hired.

j_wtf_all_taken··on Clever vs. Insightful Code
> it's self-inflicted dumbing-down. I really don't understand where this rampant support for antiintellectualism comes from

I don't think it is about dumbing-down or antiintellectualism. It is about knowledge. No matter how clever or smart you are, you do not know everything. So any special knowledge (about the OS, the language, etc) you have to be aware of to understand code is a barrier.

I specifically don't mean domain knowledge. You got to know stuff about the problem you're trying to solve, sure. I mean knowledge about the tool you use to solve the problem. Its just a tool. Nothing else. A tool should be practical, the less you need to know to use it, the better. If you want to write a manual for a machine, you wouldn't use poetry, right?

Of course some stuff is worth it. If there's a language construct that makes lots of things "better" (whatever that means) - cool, we should use that. But it should be some generic thing that can be applied to many problems (so its worth learning about it), not some specific thing that solves specific problems more clever.

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> Assuming you get a political majority to approve it. If you do, the costs will indeed be transferred to others, but I don't think it's politically feasible.

> Current society is fixated around short-term profits, and has little regard for the good of humanity.

Kind of sad. We could do it in a fair way, we just don't care enough. But was there ever a time when that was actually different? I assume not, and even though lots of things are crappy right now, we're probably still better off than ever (speaking for Europe, at least ...)

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
Well, the EU is pretty heterogeneous, so I would expect different politicians saying and wanting different things. Still seems like its worth it, though, on an economical level at least.

England, for example, did only join the EU back then for economical reasons. Them leaving the EU now doesn't seem like an economical win (and it was probably not an decision made based on economics, I guess).

So I agree that

> Germany is a very likely benefactor from all of this.

but I would argue that all countries in the EU are.

> Because let's call it what it is - it's a redistribution of wealth into the power centers of EU obscured by lies (...)

Which lies do you mean, for example?

> (...) and insane amounts of bureaucracy.

Well yeah. But if the EU would not manage these things, each country would have to manage them with each of the other countries, leading to much much more bureaucracy.

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> Problem is that those changes will be prohibitly expensive for a lot of people.

There's this idea that we introduce a carbon tax, and pay out the money to people. Seems like this could be designed in a way those people don't suffer.

> If rents go up due to climate-saving efforts, they will have to give those up. Because landlords won't give up their profits.

That's why we can implement laws forcing them to. If they add insulation to the house, the cost for heating will go down. So we just got to make sure that the one makes up for the other.

> Change incurs costs. Costs means someone is paying.

But its an investment, isn't it? Its not like we're throwing the money out of the window. We're investing, we are building things that will have a positive net return in the long run. For example, solar and wind are so cheap now and don't require constant imports (or digging up of) fuel. So in the long run, we'll have a more robust and cheaper energy production. Or from above - insulating a house will cost money now, but we'll save money in the long run.

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> Most of our so-called leaders come from a completely different class than the rest of us, or were inducted into that class through their networks.

Yes. And some are not, and we could vote for them to give them more influence. I bet once that happens, even more of such people would come into politics.

> Unfortunately, you don't just have people voting for leaders; you have leaders pushing propaganda to influence thought patterns to make people vote for whomever has the most resources, and alternative voices are pushed off the stage before most people have a chance to change their minds.

Speaking for Germany (and I believe it is the same in many European countries), I don't see that. I don't see manipulation and propaganda on that level, and I do, for example, see quite a lot of good journalism providing good information.

Of course there's wild theories going around on social media and influencing people in really bad ways, but that's just people telling lies to other people, not a lot of the classic elite/leaders there.

> those with the most power aren't absolved just because the voters give them their value

I absolutely agree. That's why its so depressing that we do not vote such people out.

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> we (as in Europe as a whole) took too many immigrants without any consideration of how to manage them

So in Germany, we are actually quite successful in managing the million that came in 2015. Most got a job and pay taxes. Actually quite awesome, fiveteen years ago everyone in Germany was afraid we'll run out of young workers.

> it should be stated that this is a failure born from rigid top-down management structure of the EU

As far as I remember, the problem was that it was actually not possible to do a top-down decision, because each national government did whatever they wanted to do? I guess the only thing we did end up doing on a EU-wide level was border protection. Not sure though.

> Same reason why the joint debt mechanism being forced on the excuse of COVID is a horrible idea and will end in tears for many.

Funny, I strongly believe its the reason the EU will not just survive but strive. Finally, the excuse of "all the money we have to give to the EU" is gone. Soon, the EU will have some taxes that only make sense on the EU level (financial transactions, or a tax on digital goods) and we're good. Besides, no national government would get the low interest rates when taking up debt that the EU combined will get, right?

j_wtf_all_taken··on The Sad Truth About Traditional Environmentalism
Except when Söder closes the border (again) g Oh wait, he doesn't do the immigrant thing any more, and for a while he and his politics were actually making sense. Seems like that's over now, but had some (two? three?) good years.

In the end it doesn't matter where the panels are installed, as electricity is distributed throughout Europe, I guess?

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> "giving my children a better future, so that their lives aren't as hard as mine"

Although they'll have a pretty hard live if we don't do something against climate change. And yes, many people do not have the resources to do these tings.

> Because people have neither time nor money for any of this.

Many people do not have that, yes. But many others do, and they could start doing it and as they are probably the ones better off, their over-proportional influence as consumers would make a huge difference. Its a complete failure of the "middle class".

> Systemic incentives are what's needed to save us.

Well yeah, I agree that politics/elections are a better way. Its just that ... we do neither. We do not take our individual responsibilities serious, neither when voting, nor when consuming.

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> It's the ordinary masses that will lose the ability to travel abroad (and probably be limited in their ability to travel within their own country), who won't be able to see their friends and family so much anymore, who will lose a lot of the daily comforts of life.

Pretty dark view of the future. Its not that we have to lose all those things, we just got to change a little bit in how we produce things and electricity and how we travel. And got to insulate houses a little. We don't have to give up any of the comforts of modern life.

That's actually the worst part of it all: its not even that we would have to give up something in order to prevent climate change. We'd just have to CHANGE something, but even that seems to be too much to ask. That really makes me mad. So incredibly unnecessary :(

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
They're not more expensive. And of course it changes something when enough people change providers, as those providers then have more money to invest in renewables, just as you said. If enough people switch, coal power plants would have to shut down as no one would buy their elecricity.
j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> If we had a proper carbon tax

That would be awesome :)

> Your entire argument relies on the false premise that the will of the people is translated into policy.

I can only speak for Germany, where it does. Right now, the Green party has the least seats of all parties in the national parliament. Why should the parliament then do something about climate change? However, when they were in the government between '98 and '05, the put the "EEG"[1] into effect (basically just implementing subsidies for renewables), and now 50% of our electricity is produced by renewables (not including nuclear). And that happened even though the following government tried to slow the transition.

There's national elections in September in Germany. With some luck, the green party will be in the new government, right now they are 2nd in the polls. That will, undoubtedly, change national politics with respect to climate change policy.

As for the US ... not sure what your problem currently is. Does the two party/winner takes it all system lead to these problems? Or is it because the republicans basically stopped caring about the truth in the 90s to win elections, spoiling the whole political process? No idea ... however, still, under the last three democratic presidents, more was done for the middle class (and probably less wars were started) then under republican presidents, right? So it does definitely matter what party wins, right, making voting not completely irrelevant even in the US?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Renewable_Energy_Source...

j_wtf_all_taken··on G7 nations committing billions more to fossil fuel than green energy
> So in theory you could get (50+epsilon)% of the votes in each of 51 seats, and 0 votes in any of the other 49 seats and hold power, despite only getting ~25% of the overall vote

Ah ok, got it. However, probably an unlikely scenario even in a "segregated" (republicans vs democrats) country as the US. But yeah - the reality right now that 40, 45% of the votes are enough for - in the case of the US - the republicans to win is pretty bad already.

> Depending on the electoral system you might not need to win a majority of the votes in any constituency,

In Germany we have two ways to get into the Bundestag (national parliament) - the one is a "Direktmandat" (the candidate with the most votes in one county county gets the seat), the other is via the party ticket. The parties have lists of candidates, and depending on their percentage of the total vote, the first X candidates get a seat.

That system tries to balance between each county getting the representative in they favor, but also representing the relative votes via the party ticket.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →