HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jacobgold

1,149 karma · joined October 17, 2021

Building AI infra @ https://clor.com in SF Bay Area.

Helped launch and scale Vibecode and Bluesky. Prev: Nuro, Docker, Google, founder. Addicted to history, computers, and open systems.

Unconditional love for all conscious life.

Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/jacob.gold

Blog: https://jacob.gold

submissionscomments
jacobgold··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
No, it rests on the idea that almost all of the money, most of the people, and the GPUs are here.

Any country would be able to take the open weights and keep going in private. But countries like China can already do that today, since the weights are almost certainly already in foreign hands due to espionage.

What they can't do is fund the next frontier run at today's pace without selling into the US market, and selling into the US market can require opening the weights.

jacobgold··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
Laws don't extend to the whole world, but markets do. The law should apply to anyone selling model access to Americans, the same way GDPR applies to US companies selling to Europeans.

Frontier development won't simply move offshore because the GPUs, most of the people, and almost all of the funding is here.

Our European and Asian allies would probably go along with this idea, because it costs us far more than it costs them.

jacobgold··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
> Forcing the weights to be opened to the world accomplishes the opposite of all of that. The argument is incoherent. Or this author doesn’t understand the topic at all?

Or maybe you understand less than you think?

Frontier progress is limited by compute, and compute is bought with investor money. Investors fund labs at hundreds of billions because they expect exclusive ownership of the model weights.

If the weights are public the day a model ships, the valuations drop, the funding rounds shrink, and the next training run is smaller or later. Make sense?

jacobgold··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
I explained this in the post. He seems like a genuinely good person who might actually do something this great.
jacobgold··on An open letter to Dario: if you mean it, open the weights
Author here.

It's a law, so nobody has to agree to anything. If want to sell access to a model, you have to open the weights.

It's Dario's plan that depends on every lab in the world agreeing.

Step #2 of his essay is "democratic coordination" among frontier labs and step three is coordination with China. I'm suggesting a single law Congress could pass that every US model company would have to follow on the same day, whether they like it or not.

Frontier progress is compute bound. Compute is bought with investor money. Investors put up tens of billions because they expect to sell the proprietary model that is created.

You're welcome to think the effect would be smaller than I do. But "it requires everyone to agree" is backwards.

jacobgold··on Tell HN: OpenAI keeps re-enabling the 'allow training' setting
If you have more than one account, you should suspect this was your own confusion. Users constantly report errors like this that are really just them being confused by something, perhaps a bad UI that really is to blame.
jacobgold··on GLM-5.3 (open-weight) beat Anthropic/OpenAI models – for 1/5 the cost
The entirety of the coding evals are just 7 trivial coding tasks in Python? This is a joke.
jacobgold··on OpenRouter is joining Stripe
You create an account. Pay money. Get API key. Use APIs.
jacobgold··on Anthropic's 'watermark' text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
Watermarking will be one more nail in the coffin of proprietary models if the world is so fortunate.

Reminds me of printer tracking dots.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printer_tracking_dots

jacobgold··on John C. Lilly on solid state intelligence and the elimination of man (1978)
> "By means not understood by Man..."

Man will likely be Man 2.0 by this point, whatever that ends up looking like.

jacobgold··on Water system controllers don't belong on the internet, says ex-NSA chief
NSA's job is SIGINT, so it's at least partly their responsibility when the threat is foreign.

For example, the NSA should be successfully infiltrating every major foreign hacking team in the world and monitoring and/or disrupting their activities.

jacobgold··on Water system controllers don't belong on the internet, says ex-NSA chief
With coding agents now being used for hacking, there's a decent chance we'll see a 9/11-scale hacking incident as a result of NSA/DHS negligence in securing American internet-connected services. Similar to how the CIA's negligence allowed 9/11 itself.

The USG should be deploying thousands of security engineers armed with the latest coding models and agents, in attempt to secure systems before they're hacked. A few billion dollars spent here could save us trillions.

jacobgold··on GitHub Actions and Pages are experiencing degraded availability
It's just silly to guess at how a system works, or should work, without digging into the details. Because you simply don't know what you don't know.
jacobgold··on In Memory of My Wife, Elise Cawley, with Thanks for 36 Wonderful Years
Sounds like Elise Cawley had a great life. Stephen Wolfram has an incredible mind and this post is a great example.
jacobgold··on The Silicon Valley Founder Meat Grinder
There are different kinds of founders in Silicon Valley now. Some are more like founders from the previous generation, like Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak. Others are more like Elizabeth Holmes and Adam Neumann.

There are lots of earnest, sincere, and interesting founders. There are also lots who probably would've been happier on Wall Street.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
Our government condemns and even demolishes people's houses when they're dangerous or become a public nuisances because their owners fail to maintain them.

Most Americans agree with this policy and don't see it as infringing on their freedom at all. Our choice is to enforce basic standards or allow our cities to become horrible places to live, and the same is true of the internet.

So yeah, it seems pretty reasonable to give people repeated warnings, then slow or pause their internet until they take basic steps to stop their connection from being used to abuse others.

jacobgold··on Show HN: Echo – Fable-level results at 1/3 the cost using open-weight models
> Fable-level results at 1/3 the cost using open-weight models

But we get ~$2500/mo worth of Fable credits for $200/mo on Anthropic pan? I'm still confused why people (who don't have to use API billing) are chasing open weight models based on cost.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
What I'm calling for is exactly how things are already supposed to work.

The US government should already be infiltrating hacker groups and identifying infected American computers. Internet providers should be informing customers that hackers have compromised their devices.

Characterizing this as "mutilating the internet" is ridiculous.

jacobgold··on OpenAI and Anthropic unite against open-weight AI risks to their bottom line
Humanity discovered a technique for compressing the world's information into a few files that fit on a USB drive. It's just insane that some people thought they'd get to be the only ones who get to possess them.
jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
- Actual data and identity loss of American citizens.

- Malware that can record video and audio from infected devices.

- Infrastructure for foreign covert influence campaigns.

- Botnets used in hacking and DoS attacks.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
Because this is exactly like file sharing...
jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
> Ok but these proxies almost certainly reverse-tunnel. How do you prove a customer is hosting one?

Why do you think that? These are proxies, so they're making huge numbers of outbound connections to websites on behalf of the people operating them. They are the "exit nodes" in this setup.

You could probably just count the number of unique destination IPs they connect to each day. If the average residential user connects to 5,000, an infected machine is probably connecting to 50,000+.

But the simplest approach is to buy access to these illicit proxy services and use them to make requests to web servers you control. If you see your own unique request arrive from a residential IP, you've proven that connection is being used as a proxy.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
Voluntarily, maybe not, but we can make it a legal requirement.
jacobgold··on John C. Dvorak has died
He was our Andy Rooney. RIP.
jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
Not sure how it would? Because the bad actors are remotely instructing infected computers/devices to make HTTP/TLS requests for them, so they appear totally normal to the other side.
jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
> These are not open proxies.

Okay, I was being imprecise. These residential proxies aren't "open proxies" in the traditional sense, but they're usually "open" to anyone willing to pay a small amount of money to use them.

> Most ISP abuse reports are routinely ignored. They might as well be a dead letter box.

This is where regulation might play a role, or at least a change in attitude. Companies shouldn't be allowed to pollute the internet in this way when they can easily prevent it.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
In terms of law enforcement, sure. But what we really need is competent white hat hackers doing battle with the black hats.

Even if no one goes to jail, the NSA could make residential proxies much harder to operate in the US simply by detecting them and reporting them to ISPs. It would be good for ISPs to then validate the reports properly, give warnings, etc.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
It may actually be costing them money through higher peak usage (requiring more capacity). I'm not sure but either way the government should have a role if market incentives aren't sufficient.
jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
There's no spying required. The NSA and ISPs can find open proxies through infiltration and report them to (e.g. abuse@comcast.com), then Comcast simply has to act on it robustly.

ISPs already deal with abuse reports like this, the system just isn't being operated comptently.

jacobgold··on LG to ban residential proxies from smart TV apps
US residential proxies are the bane of the internet. They're the major source of social media manipulation and spam.

Services can dramatically reduce abuse by blocking entire IP ranges based on country of origin, organization, or type (hosting providers). But a company can't block US residential IPs if it would also cut off many of their real customers.

The US government (probably the NSA) should be cracking down hard on US residential proxy networks. They're a genuine national security threat, actual data/identity loss of American citizens, act as infra for foreign covert influence campaigns, botnets used in hacking/DoS attacks, etc.

Major US ISPs (Comcast, AT&T) should detect clearly suspicious activity coming from customer IPs and warn them to scan their computers, check their TV apps, and find whatever is turning their internet into a proxy. It's very bad for the customers too (slows things down, gets their IP banned, etc)

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →