HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jacobsheehy

855 karma · joined October 9, 2010

https://allclearweather.com
submissionscomments
jacobsheehy··on SpaceX's rise can be traced to a critical launch from a Pacific isle
That is the broken window fallacy. You cannot support growth by destroying things and using that as a reason to buy more.
jacobsheehy··on SpaceX's rise can be traced to a critical launch from a Pacific isle
> What would these companies be getting sued for exactly in your mind?

I was responding to a comment, sorry if this message got lost. Companies who do not spend their money according to stockholder wishes get sued, correct? For misuse of funds?

My post was attempting to explain that I consider it a gross misuse of corporate funds to not spend excess cash-on-hand on projects to reduce the effects of climate change on humanity. To me, it is clear that a corporation wishing to maximize profit must address climate change or risk being sued for misuse of their funds.

> Do you own any stocks? Even holding a broad exchange fund makes you a stockholder.

No I do not own any stocks.

> Have you led the charge in any lawsuits or is this just lip service outrage?

There's no need to be rude. I stand by my words. I have no resources or funds or stocks to give me the standing to approach this topic with a corporation or lawyers. I just get by every month. There's no need to insult my opinions and call my description and opinions 'lip service'. I'm being serious, no need to belittle me.

jacobsheehy··on SpaceX's rise can be traced to a critical launch from a Pacific isle
This is what gets me though and it's so confusing. If I were a stockholder of a big megacorp and they weren't spending their money on looking climate change solutions - especially the corps causing the most damage (due to future lawsuit concerns I would expect these companies to be most on board; if they don't get on board then the future will consider them mass-murders and their money-making opportunities will shrink further than I outline in this post) - then I would be leading the charge to sue for poor use of money.

The companies are leaving trillions on the table right now by not spending their money wisely. The future economy is going to be based around climate change cleanup at the rate we're going right now and most companies are trying to lose customers by accelerating global climate change to make their customers pay more money to relocate, fix environmental issues, instead of buying their products.

Our society is going to be so financially strained in the future and it is a Direct result of the megacorps not spending their money in sustainable, responsible ways.

They should all be facing constant lawsuits from their stockholders for not doing better to protect the environment. Since their high-payed lawyers are presumably the ones that lobbied congress in the first place to make sure environmental care was not going to be part of taxes, and in fact that they should pay nearly no taxes at all, suggests to me that they think that the public good is best taken care of by corporations. It seems the only logical conclusion of this line of thinking: if the corps don't want to pay big taxes because they think it is a waste of money, then they have to be in charge of clean air for us, bu they don't actually care about that and so we're all going to suffer and pay less for their products because we have to pay more to fix the air.

I just don't get it.

Edit: For example, how many people in North Carolina will be buying new consumer electronics this Christmas? Will it be fewer than normal, because they have to spend a lot of their own money cleaning up from a storm that was exasperating via climate change and had to deal with a government that made planning for climate change illegal? I think so. I think fewer people there will buy iPhones this winter and fewer people there will buy TVs are even new fancy cars too. But really why are these corporations losing these sales already? It's because an area hit by a climate-change-fueled storm was unprepared by not taxing companies correctly and by the corporations themselves trying not to be taxed; so we end up with the population themselves trying to fix the errors of their government and this process takes expected money out of the corporation's hands.

But the storms will come, and come, and come, and there will be fewer opportunities to make money from people affected by climate change.

I. just. don't. get. it.

jacobsheehy··on Ask HN: Why did your startup fail and what did you learn?
- Poor leadership (me). Inability to align team on a common goal (!), inability to communicate clearly about plans, etc.

I learned that I'm not the leader I thought I was.

- Canadian business. Means US B2B enterprise checks get stopped at the border for 3 weeks while they 'investigate'. Makes your last mile enterprise sale that much harder. Investors are conservative. Wanted $5-10k MRR before considering angel-level investment, no go until then. Harder to compete against Valley companies.

I learned get the revenue first anyway, the days of bootstrap a free service until funding are harder and harder to come by. Revenue first.

- Problem we were solving was harder than expected (barometer data to weather forecasts). Main product was going to be a weather model but we never made it that far. Data quantity, quality control and user retention were bigger problems preventing us from executing to success. This leads to running out of money.

I learned that hard problems are hard. Your startup doesn't have as many advantages as it thinks it does if the incumbents can copy/do better than you with your "hard problem" solution or if you take too long to build your real MVP.

- Team skills were not right to solve our problems. After company founding and initial pivots we were not left with founders and staff that could solve the problems we now had to solve.

I learned to be careful starting a company with your friends. And that pivoting can have risks like a lack of skill required to complete the pivot.

- Probably the final item would be despair. When things get bad there is almost no way to come back because you've lost the trust of the people who were holding up your fragile startup to begin with.

I learned to know when to quit before driving things into the ground and taking your team with you.

- One more item: If you can catch it before you start a startup, it's a good idea to really make sure your hobby project shouldn't just stay a hobby project. Maybe it has some organic growth and media attention - but that doesn't mean it should be a startup.

I learned to keep my job and my hobby separate. I'm employed with a day job now and I can do phone weather experiments in my free time with a hobby [1], not trying to shoehorn some idea of a startup into an otherwise neat and successful hobby.

[1] Labelling photos of the sky as a training dataset into machine learning classifiers for auto-labelling of weather data in photos is a hobby - not a startup: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.allclearwe...

jacobsheehy··on Show HN: Weather data created by phones for machine learning classifier training
I'm building 'virtual weather stations' out of disparate, unused data sources.

This effort is to create new data sources that describe our atmosphere. I don't know if any of it will be useful but I cannot find much else out there that is working towards this kind of effort. So here we are.

The main experiments I'm working on are 1) sky photos, 2) sensor data like barometers in phones, and 3) user-submitted current weather.

1) Sky photos. I think that we can use a machine learning classifier that is built from user-submitted labelled photos of the sky. We should be able to them auto-tag weather data in the photos and get (numerically?) useful historical weather data from all outdoor sky photos. Additionally live photos could used to gain real-time information as well. Smartphone cameras are getting really good and can detect significant detail.

2) Most phones have a barometer now, other sensors as well like hygrometers etc. This data needs major QC and protection for user privacy and for preparation for integration and assimilation into models like WRF. This is a ways off but research has been done already here and there can be significant progress with good quality data. Here is what data from a single phone in Colorado looks like spanning a day or so: https://imgur.com/a/45lTZ6j. The sensor code for Android is open source to encourage other apps and make the process of collecting atmosphere data from smartphones much easier. [2]

3) Current conditions reporting. I found that MADIS stations don't update frequently enough to keep track of rapidly changing weather events. Users can submit current conditions and an algorithm picks which to show based on recency, trust, and other metrics. So far it can create a more accurate current conditions experience for the user.

I have taken significant effort to show the weather data from NOAA in a clear and readable way. The large graphics and animations have significant logic code behind them to attempt to most appropriately display the conditions described by MADIS stations. For example, even when most APIs will return a thunderstorm icon for a 30% chance (I find that misleading) All Clear takes an approach of showing a faded flashing bolt with a clear indication that it is 'chance'.

Other efforts are made to improve weather data communication, such as automatically converting text forecasts to units set by the user. It's not simple! But it is a useful thing for users. (See this forecast API result:https://api.weather.gov/gridpoints/OKX/33,37/forecast/ for example). It has text forecast only in US units and I don't see any options to change it otherwise.

Thanks!

[2] https://github.com/JacobSheehy/AllClearSensorLibrary

jacobsheehy··on Earth at risk of becoming 'hothouse' if tipping point reached, report warns
This is absolutely not true. People don't know that. Ask 2000 people on the street in a southern red state what their contribution to climate change is. I bet you get 0s back. "Taht fake thing isn't real" - "My car doesn't pollute you schmuck" - "the Earth is here for us to pollute it, that's what god said", etc.

People do not know that their largest personal impact is cars and meat. They just don't know that at all because 1) they don't know that climate change is real thanks to Fox and Exxon, and 2) they don't think that their habits matter. Your assumption that they do is dangerous and wrong.

Remember that Exxon Mobil has spent 40 years knowing about the dangers of climate change, but "educating" Americans through TV that it isn't a real threat. The primary education Americans get about this topic is from the megacorporations and mega rich people who are selling us polluting products with no alternatives, and is not a real education at all.

jacobsheehy··on Why We Disagree with The New York Times
I was banned from HN some time after I made that post (for something else) and should not be posting any more (sorry mods, I'll stop). This will be my final post.

Here's a news article about it (probably).

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/oct/02/facebook-...

jacobsheehy··on Why We Disagree with The New York Times
It reads like a long defensive argument, "how else did you expect us to make huge sums of money"? It is exactly as tone-deaf and legalese as you would expect. There is no new information here; Facebook says legal contracts actually protect your data so it can't go anywhere, "just trust us", etc.

> These partners signed agreements that prevented people’s Facebook information from being used for any other purpose than to recreate Facebook-like experiences.

That sentence does not make any sense. Signed agreements do not prevent your information from being used in other ways. That's insane, literally.

> Contrary to claims by the New York Times, friends’ information, like photos, was only accessible on devices when people made a decision to share their information with those friends.

In the past, Facebook Legal has stated that once a Facebook user has signed up, they consent to having psychological experiments performed on them with no further notice or direct consent. Facebook has acted on this and intentionally made hundreds of thousands of people fall into a depression, just to see if they could, and then they bragged about it. The sentence quoted above actually means "friends’ information, like photos, was only accessible [whenever and however we wanted to]" as Facebook considers those people to have already "made a decision to share their information with those friends" when they signed up.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> Being at the forefront of science and technology is what helps to maintain our position as a/the global financial leader. This is what Republicans understand and care about and why science is funded.

Your post here specifically states that Republicans care about being #1 in the world financially, and you imply here it is not about helping their constituents live good lives or anything like that. The Republican apparatus here is specifically an attempt at a short-term money-making one, not one that improves lives or even makes money in the long run.

If you are right and Republicans are funding science because they want the US to be the global financial leader, that is massively fucked up and massively wrong. It will also backfire, because funding things for the reason of being a leader is like making a startup to try to become a billionaire. It will fail. You must work on the core things like basic science, quality of life, etc, to improve the country's stability and economics across the board.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
Is it the Democratic Party's position that GMOs are bad and so are vaccinations? I hadn't heard this before and I think it's completely untrue.

You took my quote out of context. I was saying that it is mostly Republicans and not Democrats who tend to be anti-science "when the science in question contradicts their party line."

There is no party line to speak of with the Democrats and vaccinations and GMOs. Yes there are crazy people everywhere. It is not that these people are told by Democrat politicians to hate GMOs! That does not happen like it does with Republican politicians encouraging their constituents to think that high school education leading to further education is a bad thing.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> People of any party tend to be anti-scientific when the science in question contradicts their party line.

[citation needed]. That's just not true.

> Democrats are as guilty as Republicans.

More false words have never been spoken. You are incorrect. The current political situation should show that clearly. No Democrat has ever lied about so many things as the current Republicans in power: even simple, verifiable facts like crowd size are made into lies and distributed as propaganda by the current group of Republicans in power in the US House/Senate/Executive/etc.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> You've never heard Barack Obama speak on TV?

Nope. Not about this anyway.

> http://www.nbcnews.com/id/35209628/ns/technology_and_science.

What's that supposed to mean? It does not show anything like Obama not supporting NASA, or being a Democrat who thinks space isn't a priority, or anything like that. Not sure what point that link is trying to make in this discussion.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> So... they only fund science because they care about how investment in science improves our lives?

I'm not sure how you arrived at that conclusion from what I wrote. I wrote the opposite. Many Republicans are seemingly interested in funding NASA only because of misunderstood economics and logical fallacies.

Perhaps you arrived at the conclusion you did by thinking that by default, job creation and decisions based on expected economic outcome are things that "improve our lives"? But that simply isn't true. Jobs for the sake of jobs makes no sense and creates massive waste and inefficiencies in the world.

Republicans chanting "jobs jobs jobs!" are hurting their constituents, not helping them. This is especially true of the current batch of Republican politicians in power, who chanted about bring back the dying and polluting coal jobs for years and years. Those jobs and policies are not helping the people they claim to be.

Back to NASA. Sure, if someone gets a job that helps them out. But the policies in place are not meant to help that person. The policies in place are meant to entrench the Republican in power, for better or worse, and are not made while considering the actual well being of the people who live there.

This is evidenced more clearly in other policies, that keep the poor poor and the uneducated uneducated. The policies implemented by Republican politicians in the name of "jobs" are rarely good for the people who live there.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> Before attacking huge swathes of the population especially about their ignorance

Wait, what? I never did that! The closest thing to an 'attack' I can imagine anyone reading from my post would have to have been about

> Republican politicians

which is surely a few thousand people at the most, it has got to be like 0.001% of the population that I said something negative about.

> But to say that people are anti-intellectual is just wrong.

Some people are. Some very important, prominent and influential people are in fact anti-intellectual and that is not wrong to say. Many Republican politicians are proudly anti-intellectual. They even say that. The GOP in some states like Texas specifically call out education as a problem in their party platform documents. They are, as a group, overall an anti-intellectual group. That is not a false statement, that is composed of their own words.

> it probably reflects people's misunderstanding about the good government does

Yes, that's my point. People have been brainwashed over decades to assume that the government does no good.

> (that is, they think it does more good than in reality).

I'm not sure I follow - I've never met a person in my life who thinks the government does good overall, certainly not more good than bad.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
Okay, but you're still missing my point. It's not about the specific amount of money that is spent. Ever.

It's about what the money is spent on and where it goes. I very much suspect that the Republicans who are in favour of increasing NASA's budget are doing it to secure 'jobs' in their own districts and are not doing out of the goodness in their hearts or their desire for more knowledge in the USA about science or space.

They often say as much in their speeches. "We will bring jobs!" etc. NASA is a means to an end for a lot of Republicans specifically, as they focus on economy and jobs from the spending bills, not the resources developed or the knowledge learned or the science experiments done or the kids they have inspired to become engineers or anything like that at all.

Republicans rarely support basic research, even at NASA.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
> There are many Democrats who feel that space exploration is a waste of money that would be better spent on social programs.

That may be so, but I've never met one or heard from one. They would seem to me to be such a small minority I did not even know of their existence until today despite being both a democrat and a fan of space and science research.

> And many Republicans that are very pro-NASA for bragging rights and national security implications if not other reasons.

"For bragging rights?" But I'm talking about support for basic research and science in general. If they show support for NASA publicly for "bragging rights" but then vote party-line items on bills that hurt science research then they are not actually Pro-NASA or pro-science at all. I would even say that's true if they are not extremely vocal every single day about how bad most Republican policies are for science in general.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
I'm unable to watch the video right now, I'll check it out in a bit. But I can say right away that you are not responding at all to what I said. I'm aware that Republicans love to fund science, but usually that only happens when it aligns specifically with industry, economics, business, revenue, etc. I very specifically wrote in my post about 'basic science' - that is, science research that is done for the purpose of science research and has no likely vision or anything to be commercialized. That research is extremely important, and is the kind that NASA does a lot (especially stuff like JWST) and is the kind of science that Republicans specifically do not like to fund.

I'll watch the video in a bit.

jacobsheehy··on NASA reveals delay for Hubble successor
In the 1990's, a survey was done and found that something like 60% of Americans thought that the NASA budget was 25% of the entire federal budget (it's like 0.4% today). This is done very specifically by propaganda just like you mention to make Americans think that science, space, research is stupid and expensive and we shouldn't do it. Republican politicians especially will use logical fallacies to try to justify reducing our understanding of the world and to justify falling economically behind other countries and powers.

It is a case of anti-intellectualism and a strong desire for guns, war, etc and to shun science and basic research. It is born from greed and selfishness and probably also fear of the unknown.

NASA is and has always been really really cheap for what it does. But there has been a multiple-decades-long battle to convince Americans otherwise.

Edit: Here's a citation on that survey I think: http://www.thespacereview.com/article/1000/1

jacobsheehy··on Countries with more gender equality have fewer female STEM grads
> You miss the point that a satisfied person has little incentive for activism.

This is interesting - what do you mean by this? I'm not sure what you mean in this context, but in an overall, general sense I strongly disagree.

Certainly there is significant incentive for activism from a satisfied person. A person may be satisfied but that does not mean that there is not room for improvement or change. Satisfaction is something that is static, stagnant, and doesn't last forever. One day you may be satisfied with a product or political situation, and the next day you might not be even if it remains unchanged itself.

Activism is a method of creating change. Everyone is incentivized by it because everyone can benefit immensely from change, even the ultra-rich.

> Also, most conservative opinions tend to be met with anything from disgust to derision online, further disincentivizing counter-protest.

I have found the opposite to be true, actually. Depending on the online community, sometimes it is the conservative opinions that are the only ones deemed acceptable by the community (as is often the case here on HN), and in others perhaps the liberal comments.

But I have been a liberal commenter on the internet for nearly 20 years and I have found, time and time again, that the internet has little room for acceptance of left-wing opinions.

jacobsheehy··on Countries with more gender equality have fewer female STEM grads
I think you may have misread the article. It does not present the data you think it does.

> In countries with the highest levels of gender equality, where women are least likely to experience any of these negative forces

That is absolutely not what a high level of gender equality means. Countries that have "higher levels of gender equality" do not guarantee or even suggest any likelihood of not having these negative forces in a girl or woman's life. (I would privately posit that it may be the opposite, in fact - that perhaps those countries would find that in private home lives, those forces are as strong or stronger than elsewhere. But I don't know this, I'm speculating on that point.)

Often the forces in a person's life are from close friends or their family - these are not measured in this article and certainly have an impact on how people choose their careers and interests in life.

You also made up the idea that they are "self-selecting" to not be a part of the system. The article does not make that claim - you did, out of thin air.

jacobsheehy··on Rent Control Needs Retirement, Not a Comeback
The author thinks low-income people's incomes are rising and that is false. The rest of the article is fallacious because of this.
jacobsheehy··on Extreme event attribution is an expanding subfield of climate science
dang, usually I would agree, but why capitulate like this? The title was absolutely correct. Climate change articles are always full of hate on HN, with people saying climate change is fake, etc. See the top comment in this thread: the theme is strong on HN, to hate climate scientists, to flag the articles as fake, and to get the real content removed from HN. In this one, there is a chorus to say the headline is false. But it is the chorus that is false, not the headline. You have censored the headline for no reason.

Also, my main account, cryptoz, is now temporarily? banned from posting on HN due to me defending the correctness of this headline. I wish it had not been changed. I have lost this battle.

jacobsheehy··on SpaceX Launch Livestream: CRS-8 Dragon Hosted Webcast
Yes, I think 2008 was a very hard year for Elon. The issue with Tesla was that something like 200 Roadsters were manufactured incorrectly and all had to be fixed at immense cost and time delay. He was also going through a divorce at the time. And all SpaceX launches had exploded off the Pacific island that they were forced to use since their competitors successfully lobbied for it to be illegal for SpaceX to launch from the USA. Rough year.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2