HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jakubp

803 karma · joined September 25, 2011

submissionscomments
jakubp··on ‘I believed I didn't have the right kind of brain for science’
Not sure what culture you are from, but in Poland at least I have almost never heard girls (or anyone!) say anything particularly bad of that sort to boys, but I sure have heard said a lot to girls.

There's definitely still a strong 'boyish' culture where boys can say almost anything they like and it's OK, but girls (for whatever reason) won't. It's not about who's better - it's about what we let people get away with.

Also it's not about thinking. Thinking is the ultimate change you want, but we can't see and know what people around us think, but we can still try to enact standards of reasonable, gentle (non-violent if you will) communication.

jakubp··on ‘I believed I didn't have the right kind of brain for science’
The point is we've identified gender is used to knock people down a lot, that this particular angle seems to have little basis in fact, and so are trying to make people aware to stop this particular angle.

If we find more systematic ways in which people are getting knocked down, we should probably work on those, too.

jakubp··on Car Owners Should Control Data Collected by Cars
(X) owners should control data collected by (X)

I'd add: at least possess this data, maybe also control (but not necessarily 100% e.g. I would want to be able to say, as the nation-state, that some data must be made available to others, e.g. safety related, accident related, energy efficency related)

Sounds like a fairly obvious rule. Doesn't make it easy for the business to sell the value added services things or to make moat vs competition...

jakubp··on Protections Against Fingerprinting and Crypto Mining in Firefox Nightly and Beta
You are happier to have your resources stolen and not be aware of it (it's invisible, you can't see what's happening and react - right?) than to be shown an annoying thing which is very much in your awareness? I don't know, I'd rather know someone is harming me silently and have the means to stop it by default. The things that are shown in front of me, I can handle them...
jakubp··on The Terrible Secret (2011)
Bombadil was the name of a doll in Tolkien's home. That's why he was the "oldest", because the name predates the book itself. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Bombadil
jakubp··on Google launches AMP for email
It's an obvious generalization. Everybody else gets what he meant, don't you?
jakubp··on Google may rank sites for queries that don't appear on the page at all
If users want equivalencies then they shouldn't use quotes, which are for exact match. Let's not play semantics here. Search syntax is clear - put things in quotes, get 'exact match' in return. Equivalent words are not exact match. Get smart with me, decrease usability for me. This is what is happening.

We can argue whether there is place for more operators, or whether it's better on average for an average user to still be "outsmarted" by the engine, but it's clear what's going on - these aren't exact match results and the results often have zero relevance with what user is looking for precisely because the user knows the specific word WILL appear on the page they need and a page without that word WON'T be what they need. I don't know how much clearer we can be :) It used to work (or seemed to). Now it doesn't. It frustrates some people. That's it.

jakubp··on Google may rank sites for queries that don't appear on the page at all
On Google, at least a few years ago and back, when you put a query "X" you were guaranteed to see X in the HTML contents of the page. Or at least I can't remember getting a result that didn't satisfy that condition. Now it's common to not find X there.
jakubp··on Google may rank sites for queries that don't appear on the page at all
I don't know about links, but the phenomenon of getting results for a query like: A "B" with no B on the page has been particularly disturbing for some time. At least months, maybe longer, I can't say. I have no idea why they made a change this drastic (it is drastic when someone makes a deliberate effort to say "I need "B" in the page, it's not a whim or a random query" and the search engine shows results which violate the query _syntax_).
jakubp··on Daydreaming about the future instead of doing work today
Maybe you missed the point of the article. The author is describing a common issue where people have lots of ideas, plan them out in their heads and get the reward in form of pleasure (anticipation of success, power, beauty, anything). They don't imagine or plan actually doing the work, they plan for wonderful outcomes. They never do what's necessary and become quite frustrated, not knowing why. There was even psychological research into this phenomenon if I recall correctly , and it yielded the somewhat surprising result that this is a strong habitual behavior and thus fairly hard to change.
jakubp··on In Estonian parliamentary election, 44% of the votes were cast online
As if democracies aren't buying votes already en masse?! Lobbying is just that, on a scale that actually matters more (directly at policy decision making point).
jakubp··on Ask HN: Why are browser authors allowing notification spam?
I would rather the browser protect me from all popups, and only enable such a "feature" by specific request.

I did set what you mention now, but my point is, why isn't it the default, and why is it so hidden (e.g. there are multiple settings you need to do to block those popups).

It's not like standard JS popup is worse than this - standard JS popup does not permanently enable website to know a location of a user, or to bug him with notifications outside the browser, i.e. standard popups are less intrusive!

jakubp··on Why are glasses so expensive? The eyewear industry prefers to keep that blurry
Fielmann is a German brand available in several European countries, but I'm not sure if they make their own eyewear.

Still, I can't imagine paying 1000 USD for a pair of glasses. In Poland 100 EUR gives you a decent pair, 200 EUR is already a bit much.

jakubp··on Study Identifies Effective Mental Strategies for Aversive Challenges
Yes!

You could also focus on emotions and thoughts i e Just notice wgat you feel or think without trying to change it.

jakubp··on Study Identifies Effective Mental Strategies for Aversive Challenges
Hm. I interpreted it as being aware of where i am in activity, how I do parts of it, kind of trying to do it well and recognizing where i am in the process.

Mindfulness to me would be just To continually bring awareness to whatever I feel, sense, think, without connection to a process.

If there are averse conditions, running away from what we feel is the opposite of mindfulness and any directed way of distracting/framing the situation would be going away from mindful appreciation of the very aversive situation.

jakubp··on Study Identifies Effective Mental Strategies for Aversive Challenges
This is an excellent list of strategies, really good breakdown that maybe be useful in facilitating behavioral change.

What I find surprising is the lack of mindfulness on the list, i.e. employing mindful awareness to an activity as a way to deal with it.

jakubp··on Train Your Brain Like a Memory Champion
There's a bigger story hidden behind the achievements of memory champions. The groundbreaking result from the past few decades is not that there is a way for a human to memorize a thousand numbers, or that a particular method of memorization (say, memory palace) is the way to do it. It's nice, but not that relevant for everyday life and not applicable to most life problems.

The true achievement is recognition and verification, across many disciplines, that: 1) there are better and worse ways to improve skill 2) anyone can improve any skill [if they do it the right way] 3) mental representations are key to high performance. Some are better than others. 4) one should study how to learn a given skill, or get someone who knows that to teach, e.g. to study people who are best at something - to find out their training regimen, their way of structuring the information/skill/work/memory/... - this is likely to work everywhere 5) If that doesn't help, i.e. little progress is made, one can still figure out, discover, create their own ways of practice to advance. 6) the upper limit of skill is way way higher thank we think 7) Many fields don't have clear criteria for success, so little feedback is available on low-level performance details, which limits the progress of training methods.

If you're interested in all that, I recommend reading the book of a renowned scientist who actually discovered a lot of this stuff and who worked with early memory champions, provoking them to push the boundaries of what was thought possible -- Anders Ericsson, "Peak: Secrets from New Science of Expertise".

jakubp··on Threema – Seriously secure messaging
Thanks :)
jakubp··on Threema – Seriously secure messaging
I can't follow this, it's too technical for me. Are you saying anyone here on HN who watches the talk (and is technical enough) could just read text messages of the people who are in the area around their BTS? How is that NOT done en masse then?
jakubp··on Threema – Seriously secure messaging
I don't fully follow the prefix thing. So a scammer makes a call from a number that's a prefix of my number? That doesn't affect 2FA, that won't show up as "me" on my friends' phone screens when they call, etc... how is that an issue?
jakubp··on Threema – Seriously secure messaging
Right. So if you need physical access to my phone to be able to copy my keycard, I'm not too worried. I'll find out very quickly I don't have it, within minutes typically (hours at most). If someone is an incredibly smart adversary, steals my phone, gets the SIM card, copies it, and gives it back without me noticing, I'm f*ed anyway.

Or is there a way to copy SIM card remotely???

As for state-level adversary, I get it. I'm even less concerned here :)

jakubp··on Threema – Seriously secure messaging
This is interesting, how exactly can a phone number be "stolen"? I mean a practical reality. I'm in Poland, have had the same number for >10 years with several carriers in a row, contract-based. How can anyone "steal" it / take it over?
jakubp··on EventStorming: Continuous discovery beyond software modelling
Interesting point about trying to minimize the proxy expert game. I myself don't have full clarity on which level of proxy is OK. Should it be a dedicated person (typically an analyst)? Should it be the team? Part of the team? Someone mixing roles e.g. dev who talks to the client(s), or PM who also manages the backlog, etc.

There are many tradeoffs to consider here. If technical team has to talk to clients, well, we will lose some clients, period. Many types of clients and many types of engagements (for a software house) are simply unavailable, because we will lose out in competition with companies who will be given very good support by great client-facing specialists who will woo them, and actually give high quality consulting and value on the early stage of the project.

However, if we put those good business guys in front of the team (or as part of it), they start to lead the process, and our less developers who are usually much less ready to talk to clients etc. and have tech-related biases, suddently lose the best chance to learn. Because when someone takes away the difficult part of managing the client and trying to figure out what they need, you stop thinking about it on your own and you don't develop those mental models as fast (if at all).

There is maybe a middle ground where there's a mix of comms coming from technical and non-technical folks, who knows. In my experience this typically morphs into either model though.

jakubp··on EventStorming: Continuous discovery beyond software modelling
Oh boy...

"But I do think this is revolutionary. The typical processes people use for understanding a novel business domain take weeks to months."

You must be aware that there is a large group of people who have largely solved the problem of learning about a domain when client is in the room. It includes Business Analysts, System Analysts, some portion of people who call themselves Solution Architects, some portion of people who call themselves [software] consultants, and probably other roles, too.

There is nothing significantly new to ES. It's a specific method to run a workshop, with a client, live. It's one of many, many well known methods used in IT design/analysis. Not under this name though.

It's the same as half of Agile Industrial Complex (to quote on of Agile Manifesto's authors) -- people take a good technique and give it a name to market themselves or to promote the technique in the industry.

Don't fall for it.

"Traditional processes for understanding the domain also tend to focus on nouns."

I don't know where you get this from. What processes do you mean specifically? If you look at BABOK (Business Analyst body of knowledge, a good reference point), you will notice a huge section of _dozens_ of tools used to map and understand a domain and then to model a system for that domain... ES is just one item out of many, many methods.

Many of those methods have nothing to do with nouns, they are far more generic.

Sorry about the rant, but I was just sharing the same thoughts with a colleague who's learning some basic aspects of business/system analysis, so here goes...

The actual, real problems with running _any_ kind of joint work on requirements with clients are the REAL challenge of software dev teams in most models, and here's just a taste of what they can be:

1) client won't come to see us. Yes, seriously. 2) client will agree to a VC, but VC quality is so poor we have to go to them 3) we can go to the client, but we will never get 2-3 key stakeholders in the same room before project deadline. So we must do separate workshops, which complicates things. 4) Getting a team of people to another country for several workshops gets expensive fast. 5) Some members of the team don't want to or can't go

And now for the actual work...

6) Facilitation of a workshop such as this is generally a difficult job, one needs specialized skills to make it effective. ES proposes a format, which can be helpful, but to get value from a workshop you need good facilitators on the team AND a format, not just a good format. If you can have only one, pay for a facilitator, and let him pick any format, it's generally more useful. Formats are easy to get, and won't cover all the needs of a particular client-team relationship anyway. 7) Facilitation of a workshop is generally far beyond what a typical 25-30 year old software developer can handle given their typical focus (this specifically targets the myth spread by one optimistic ES promoter in my country who tells developers "just do ES workshop!" but fails to recognize the high level of soft skills required to make it effective, esp. with clients who don't have much time). 8) wrong people from the client have come, but you only realize it halfway through the workshop. Time wasted, potential misinformation spread 9) time required to collect all the necessary information this way is larger than total time you have to deliver something to the client to prove to them you are a good supplier of software. So you need results much sooner than this before they even let you work with them.

And finally...

10) People take time to ingest and process information. Lots of new information + many people = long time. It's not 1 day and we're done.

Summary: Just hire an analyst and your team will thank you. If your team is already good enough in terms of facilitation skills to run Event Storming, you don't need Event Storming.

jakubp··on Chess World Championship: Stockfish live-analyzing game 7
https://lichess.org/ has a great live commentary of every game.
jakubp··on Jack Dorsey runs two multibillion-dollar companies without using a computer
Have you thought of writing? Or reading? Or watching large enough images?
jakubp··on Software disenchantment
It's an awesome collection you have there, thank you. (And yeah, also a bit depressing...)
jakubp··on We designed Canada's cities for cars, not people – and the people are dying
Yes. In my view, the governments are simply unwilling to devise _actually_ meaningful way to remove bad actors from the roads (bad drivers, i.e. drivers that are reckless, drive too close to cars in front of them, use mobile phone too much, do dangerous maneuvers, etc.) , so they claim "speed kills". Which is like saying "life kills".

There are a myriad reasons why people have accidents, and "speed" is not one of those reasons. Driving faster than one's skill, and car capability, on a given type of road surface, in given air visibility conditions, with given traffic, pedestrians and other people around, buildings/architecture blocking vision, and other factors, not to mention the whole huge range of actual distrations for the drivers such as ads, using mobile phone, talking with passengers, being tired, etc. .. those things actually cause accidents (and near accidents). Speed in general is almost never the issue. High speed is also almost never the key issue. Where one driver has an accident at 60kph due to being distracted / ignoring safe distance (relative to all the conditions above), etc., another can safely and confidently drive 100kph.

jakubp··on Google: Security Keys Neutralized Employee Phishing
FWIW, in Poland some banks started using 2FA (many different types) several years before Google or any other site I know of.
jakubp··on Just How Much Money Do “Influencers” Make?
I'm not right here? Where is that? Why do you restrict this conversation to one imagined location as if the same thing wasn't happening in multiple countries simultaneously?

I am right here in Poland and I tell you, the things you show, and the things described in the article and in the first comment in this thread, they are all consumed en masse by young and mid-age adults (especially women). Lifestyle, sports, fashion, diet, craft, yoga, coaching, ikebana, it's all on Insta and Facebook and other platforms and when you see who's commenting, it's not JUST kids. And there's way more people 20+ than the kids. I never said kids do not have influence (sic) of that kind, they do. But when someone says "if you see something odd or stupid, it's the kids", it's just completely wrong. Kids have serious purchasing and decision making power now, but still it's just a fraction.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →