HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jameshart

22,635 karma · joined March 31, 2011

submissionscomments
jameshart··on Tesla Roadster
Mach diamonds in a compressed air jet aren’t surprising. You can get them from a canned compressed air duster: https://hackaday.com/2024/02/18/canned-air-is-unexpectedly-s...
jameshart··on eBay Restricts Listings of Radio Equipment, but Exempts Ham-Band-Only Gear
Yes that would never happen to the internet
jameshart··on David Rudnick on "borderline impossible" process of designing Arsenal typeface
It’s more that both the club and the area are independently named after the site of the stadium where the club used to play. The club would still be called Crystal Palace even if the name had died out for the area of town.
jameshart··on OpenCode 2.0
Anthropic and OpenAI models are available via a number of different channels eg AWS, GitHub copilot, Google Cloud… using those kinds of platforms behind a vendor-neutral tool gives you the ability to swap models out while maintaining the same workflow.
jameshart··on David Rudnick on "borderline impossible" process of designing Arsenal typeface
Crystal Palace is also a bit weird - named after a building that was moved, then burnt down, which also gave its name to an ill defined area of London that straddles three boroughs, which is not where the club plays any more…
jameshart··on Show HN: Unfenced – Land for sale that borders public land
If you want similar benefits in more urban environments, consider property next to a cemetery. The neighbors are quiet and the lot is very unlikely to be turned into a strip mall.
jameshart··on OpenCode 2.0
Codex and Claude should not be seen as ‘the standard’

They are vendor offerings but you don’t have to take them.

jameshart··on The road we were told not to take
Whole piece has that Claudish sense of a complete absence of theory of mind. The LLM has all this background knowledge in context - it’s just read all the historical facts about what happened and who said what when - so it jumps around trying to thread a narrative among those facts but it has no sense of what the reader is likely to be familiar with or what is novel; there’s no storytelling.

It could just be bad writing by someone who knows the subject well and is done explaining all the background needed to understand their thesis. Or it could be extracted from chapter 10 of a book where the prior 9 chapters laid all the groundwork so you can start weaving together a thesis like this from the pieces you’ve already planted.

But it reads a lot like Claude.

jameshart··on Gemini 4 Argon
Why? Don’t you think the steady improvement in pelican bicycling SVG art is itself a worthy field of endeavor for LLMs to be optimized for?

Yes, Simon has made pelicans a benchmark and now models have grown very good at rendering them. Is there a reason to believe that this isn’t manifesting as useful skill in general in SVG generation?

jameshart··on Gemini 4 Argon
Is it me or is there maybe some carryover happening where the pelicans are portrayed as expending different degrees of effort too? Like, the high effort pelican has a determined look on his face.

Is the prompt context telling the models what their effort level is, and the ambient presence of that concept of ‘high effort’ in the context window is leaking through and affecting the portrayal?

jameshart··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
I’m just saying we don’t yet know what works best long term for LLM managed code. Not suggesting that what LLMs produce today is optimized for that, and ‘human-readable’ is for sure a good default place to start.
jameshart··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
Most store doors are open much of the day
jameshart··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
If someone walks in and unplugs your refrigerator and causes you to lose all the stock in it, your insurance is going to cover you. You don’t need to show you locked the power sockets.
jameshart··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
This is true, but we also don’t know the long term architectural tradeoffs that are right for an LLM-maintained codebase.

For human-maintained code you manage duplication and locality of changes in the codebase because you want concepts to fit inside a human’s working memory. Keeping method bodies short is so they fit in one code window on the screen.

LLMs’ working memory works in very different ways; they see codebases not as windows of code but as blips of grep results. It might be that it’s easier for an LLM to just ensure five pieces of code are all modified in sync with one another than to safely implement a DRY refactoring.

jameshart··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
People have gotten very used to breaking down tasks into separate things they know how to do on a computer. Asking an LLM to do each of those individual tasks is easy but feels both lazy and also ‘so what?’ - I knew how to do that task.

The thing people are slow in realizing is that you don’t need to break the task down, and you don’t need to know how to do the task. You don’t even need to have the software installed on your computer to do the task, or even know that software to do the task exists - a sufficiently motivated LLM can pull down the needed open source tools and use them, or even build its own.

jameshart··on Yandex Takes a Second Data Center Hit in 48 Hours
You are perhaps mistaken here. The FAA allows passengers to take guns on planes provided they are documented and secured and checked into the hold. What the FAA is concerned about is people being personally armed on planes and there are obvious reasons for that.

They are largely unrelated to the reasons countries might have for being nervous about merchant vessels packing anti aircraft weaponry.

You are I think getting lost in your analogy and in the process conflating two different things:

- the reasons countries might want to prevent people from entering with weapons

Vs

- the reasons countries might have for being nervous about armed merchant vessels in their navigational waters

jameshart··on Computers Cannot Make Decisions
Precisely. It seems reasonable to say that ‘a triangle can only have one obtuse angle’ - but in some strict senses it is incorrect - one obtuse angle is not the only thing a triangle can have; it can also have none.
jameshart··on Computers Cannot Make Decisions
It gets used more often to express prohibition not impossibility (“you can’t be in here” spoken to someone who manifestly is for example). Also disbelief (“this can’t be happening” about something that is happening). It’s just not clear which sense people mean it in, so it can’t be used when you want to be sure you can’t be misunderstood.

For another example of ambiguity, consider the sentence “A triangle can not have any obtuse angles”.

Is this 1) true, because there exist triangles with only acute angles, or 2) false, because triangles can have obtuse angles?

jameshart··on Computers Cannot Make Decisions
The original article feeds precisely this misreading. It quotes the old IBM adage ‘a computer MUST never make management decisions’ (my emphasis) but describes it in its headline as ‘a computer CAN not make decisions’ (my emphasis)

These are not the same, and this misinterpretation of the author’s intent inevitably follows.

CAN NOT is horribly ambiguous in English which is why RFCs use MUST and MAY.

In casual speech someone might say “you can’t park there” but that’s not true. They might mean “you must not park there” or “you should not park there” but the only reason they are telling you is because you CAN park there.

jameshart··on My personal AI agent posted my bank details on company Slack
Also somewhat reckless with mixing access to his personal finances with access to his work communications systems.

Even without agents being involved that’s a recipe for trouble.

jameshart··on Apple/macOS silently removed from official Unix registry
Well… that’s handy.
jameshart··on Apple/macOS removed from official Unix registry
Microsoft just shipped a full-fledged first class Linux container runtime as part of Windows[1]. I don’t think it even made front page of HN, which shows how far windows has fallen as a developer environment, but it is absolutely something Apple should be offering as a first class capability on OS X. The compatibility of the host OS file system with being mounted into docker images makes it a better environment for running such things.

[1] https://blogs.windows.com/windowsdeveloper/2026/09/29/wsl-co...

jameshart··on Triple-A Minesweeper
That will be coming in the first DLC in a few months, delayed because it is being developed by a new team after the original development studio was bought by Activision, retasked to making a mobile solitaire game, then laid off.
jameshart··on Triple-A Minesweeper
Failed certification because it didn’t warn you not to turn off when the save icon is spinning.
jameshart··on Triple-A Minesweeper
No pets credited either.
jameshart··on Yandex Takes a Second Data Center Hit in 48 Hours
Replacing the RAM is going to be expensive
jameshart··on Yandex Takes a Second Data Center Hit in 48 Hours
Oil tankers..
jameshart··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
Passing a constitutionally valid law through congress and then having the executive branch enforce it would not meet any judicial resistance.

I suspect the courts would welcome it.

jameshart··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
Which leads to more water parks existing.
jameshart··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
This is a lump of labor fallacy.

By finding a ready source of people willing to staff the water park at a lower price, more ‘water park amenity’ is available at a lower price.

This frees up the labor of local teenagers who can now be employed in other roles, producing other useful things for society, like… I don’t know what teenagers do nowadays. Provide market-clearing services on Kalshi by placing bad bets? Upload short form video to TikTok to enable ad buyers to find customers?

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →