HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jannotti

695 karma · joined February 11, 2011

Verifying my Blockstack ID is secured with the address 1914xedLWW7ENJjNf899eXeip4yeNNCbN5 https://explorer.blockstack.org/address/1914xedLWW7ENJjNf899eXeip4yeNNCbN5
submissionscomments
jannotti··on Moving Forward on Basic Income
That's certainly an issue, but your demand stifles any effort to learn more by saying that you have to study "generational effects" (what, maybe a 50 year study before you can learn anything). Which will just be followed up by the equally valid criticism that you can only study this if everyone has BI (to see if it's the relative effect that matters).

Reasonable seeming concerns, but you have to start somewhere to learn anything.

jannotti··on Shebang Quine
That's not the issue, really. The issue is whether the program has access to itself as input. This one does, so it's not a quine. But it's cool.
jannotti··on Rainbow Color Map Still Considered Harmful (2007) [pdf]
Nice clear presentation. I'm convinced.
jannotti··on My Passion Was My Weak Spot
Beware, asking for stock instead of options can be worse. If you are granted stock, you are being given something of value, and you must pay taxes as if it was income on the "fair value" (which, admittedly, may be low).

If you are given options, as long as the strike price is current value, you are not on the hook for any taxes until/unless you exercise them at a higher price. (ISO vs Non-qualified affects the details on that, but the point about stock grants remains.)

jannotti··on Amazon Echo Dot
I'd love to see a nicely curated "voice recognition benchmark" to assess claims like this. Do you know of one?
jannotti··on A 19 basis point portfolio beats the average of most college endowments
I don't care about the label, I care for a fair comparison of the question, "Would Universities be better off with a simple mix of index funds or using their current approach?" To answer that question, you'd like to figure out what the performance would have been if universities used that simpler approach, and that might include saving a lot of money on the university employees who select managers or make investment decisions at the university. I hope it didn't seem like I thought you should subtract out the costs of random university employees.

(Rereading my words, I can certainly understand that interpretation. Sorry.)

jannotti··on A 19 basis point portfolio beats the average of most college endowments
I wonder if the returns quoted for endowments properly subtract out the salaries, build space, etc for the employees of the institution with the endowment, or just the explicit costs from outside management?

(See my clarification below. I'm talking about the costs only for the employees making investment decisions.)

jannotti··on We Must Repeal Our Segregation Laws
His point is precisely that segregation laws and zoning laws do the same thing, so he's trying to use language that makes that obvious. It's not a leap really, right? To "segregate" things is almost synonymous with putting things into their proper "zones" isn't it?
jannotti··on The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High
It's important that drivers be reasonably competent too, and so we have a licensing program. But it is cheap and quick. (Where "quick" might mean a long line at the DMV, but not an apprenticeship.)
jannotti··on Half a year later, the Apple Watch feels like a stalled platform
Are you contending that Android Wear watching can't keep time? I'm willing to listen if you have any evidence, but that sounds like an extraordinary claim.
jannotti··on Blowing the Whistle on the UC Berkeley Mathematics Department
Right. I was skeptical in first few paragraphs, since students' teaching assessments do have their flaws. But if there was a statistically significant improvement in his students performance in later classes, then the man's doing his job.

Yes, there could still be confounding factors. He is seen as an enjoyable lecturer, and students who care about their classes enough to select the better lecturer might be better students. But still.

If you want to continue the analogy to software engineering, the modules he's producing are students, and they are meeting their specifications (later performance) quite well.

jannotti··on CLU: Reference Manual (1979) [pdf]
We used CLU when I took MIT's Software Engineering class. I think we used pclu ("Portable CLU", which translated to C.
jannotti··on I am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator – AMA
If your application came across at all like your post, it's pretty clear why it wasn't strongly considered.
jannotti··on Meet Model X
"no-brainer people will start carpooling more" ?

I don't think people buying Teslas will start carpooling any time soon.

jannotti··on Meet Model X
Inside? I watched the presentation, and it didn't seem like the seats folded forward. Do they?

Now that I think about it, I haven't even seen the back open. Why can't I find pictures from the back, with the gate open?

jannotti··on Meet Model X
It might, since I think moving heavy objects is pure drag on a ICE vehicle, but if you have regenerative braking, you get some of the extra effort you put in, back out.

That's an advantage many subways have by using electrical power.

jannotti··on Arbitraging credit cards while traveling abroad
I think, but I'm not sure, that you're overstating the complication. Looking at your four steps: 1. Everyone should have two credit cards. You don't want a single point of failure (mistaken fraud freeze, for example.) 2. You only check every day, not every transaction. 3. Again, I argue you should have two (Visa + Mastercard) 4. Again. You're just trying to make things sound hard by repeating the same thing.

So. Have two cards. Make sure they autopay themselves. The only new work is checking the exchange rates once a day.

jannotti··on The Electric Car
Cars can drive autonomously, but they can't sense a spill?
jannotti··on The Electric Car
I agree there's a problem here, but the trend you point out is probably breakeven with respect to gas/electric. Many people how move into a dense city have no car at all.

(Those who do have more money and often garage their car, so they'll add charging to long term garages as demand increases.)

jannotti··on To Apple, Love Taylor
I think it could be either way, but many object to the fact that it is both. In other words, corporate tax is seen as double taxation, since the earnings (after taxes) are then passed on to shareholders, who pay tax on it again.

I could see a coherent tax code that taxes corporations, but not individuals, or one that taxed individuals, but not corporations (Of course with either of these there would no doubt be all sorts of new loopholes to deal with). But taxing both seems odd to me.

jannotti··on Android’s 10 Millisecond Problem explained
Then assembly is more flexible than your favorite high-level language? It's true that you can, by definition, do more with low-level access. And I suppose that's one definition of "flexibility". But I think most developers would use the word to mean that various pieces of functionality can be put together easily. So they might say, for example, that Unix pipes are "flexible". I think I'd usually agree with that meaning.
jannotti··on The Last Man to Beat Floyd Mayweather Jr. Still Regrets It
Agreed. The reality is that the offer was probably still on the table in roughly the same form. After the Olympics, he could had the offer examined, weighed his options, and had pretty much the same starting point as Mayweather.

I won't bother to speculate whether he would have had the same success from that starting point. But he did NOT lose all opportunities in the instant he turned that deal down.

jannotti··on Who decided indenting with spaces was a good idea?
Because sometimes you must use spaces, because you are indenting a continuation line that should be indented to an exact spot with respect to the previous line (you're in the middle of an expression, you want to be at the start of an open parenthesis, etc).

Surely the suggestion in that case is not to carefully insert tab characters to the same indentation of the previous line, and then spaces for the rest, so that you have some tabs and some spaces on the continued line? Anything else fails if the tabs are set as "developer preference" on display, but that tabs + spaces on one line is incredibly fiddly.

jannotti··on New Tesla product line – not a car – will be unveiled on Thurs 8pm, April 30
There are several electric motorcycles that look pretty good. Google around. I forget which I thought were best (and I'm not knowledgable enough about "normal" bikes to be a great resource anyway).
jannotti··on How Many Mutual Funds Routinely Rout the Market? Zero
With the caveat that if your job does any 401k matching, you should take advantage of it. Automatic 100% return is hard to beat.

(And then if you switch jobs, roll it over into a Vanguard IRA.)

jannotti··on On the Pricing of Apple Watch
That all sounds reasonable. But I have to believe it's completely wrong. Because it's the same sort of "reasonable" that says every level of technology is pretty much all you need. That is finally (decades later) pretty much true of desktop computers (but not displays). And it's getting there for laptops (excepting their displays and batteries). It's still years away for phones. And to think that the very first generation of of Apple watch is somehow going to get everything right to last for even one decade? I think that's preposterous.

The only way I can see them getting around this is by saying that for, say $500, we'll be able to take your watch in and swap out its guts entirely. It feels like that has to be true. (Yet, it also seems "chincy" to talk about popping things in and out. I guess we'll see.)

jannotti··on Gmail just broke every Chrome extension. Here’s how we fixed ours
"every Chrome extension" That's some serious hyperbole you've got there. You should have it checked out.
jannotti··on That Time Buffett Smashed the Efficient Market Hypothesis
Not sure where I side in the larger debate, but on this point it's perfectly plausible that Buffett (correctly) guessed that the banks were safer than they might appear. He may have believed a bailout would be inevitable if things went badly for them.
jannotti··on Show HN: TripBright – activities and tours for your Airbnb guests
Right. Consider partnering with rental car sites. If you can get a commission from several different ones, then let me add the closest one to my guide book, everybody wins.
jannotti··on Show HN: TripBright – activities and tours for your Airbnb guests
I think you need this feature quickly. Let me add restaurants and other places easily by finding them on yelp, and let me add generic boxes with a url, and let me add my own notes on them AND on the tours you provide. Until then, I can't use it, it would come off as crass.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →