HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jariel

749 karma · joined May 28, 2019

submissionscomments
jariel··on Apple Approves Parler to Return to App Store
"Hang Mike Pence” is calling for assassination.

"Arrest Mike Pence" is not.

"Put Mike Pence to Trial and then Hang Him" isn't either.

You have to qualify 'Kill That Guy' with something more in order for it not to be calling for someone's murder.

This activity was out in the open, uncontrolled on Parler which is why it was a problem, even if technically it might be legal, Apple doesn't want to deal with that.

I think their response was on point, though Amazon's cancellation has more material effect their responsible response should have been 'you can't go live with that while on our servers you have 3 months to change policy or move out'. Granted, they may have been warned.

jariel··on Huawei ‘may have eavesdropped on Dutch mobile network’s calls’
There's some debate about the degree to which the authorization could have been abused, but it today's world it's just hard to imagine how such rights and authorization could be granted in the first place.
jariel··on Apple Approves Parler to Return to App Store
There's nothing really comparable between calling for someone's assassination, and on the other hand, someone to be arrested and brought to justice for a crime.

And there's also the fact that there's no basis in reality for the claims to be begin with.

In all of this confusion, it is true that Parler was essentially (Edit: not! obviously 'not' moderated)moderated - and - there was a lot of really terrible stuff happening there. Like 'kill these people'. The cover that Twitter can use is that they actual do moderate people and try to get rid of them. Mostly.

Parler must have had a huge leadership failure to play that game and think they were going to get away with it. There is zero chance that hosting people directly calling for violence, unmoderated, is going to last when associated with other people's brands.

I believe the CEO actually wanted to do something but his backers didn't.

jariel··on Apple Approves Parler to Return to App Store
"Oh please. Laws exist, platforms must ensure their customers follow the laws, and when a customer refuses to remove illegal content"

Don't make this about 'laws' - this was definitely not about 'laws' or the 'law' would have stepped in - and it's definitely not Amazon's job to enforce the law.

Amazon knowingly sells fake goods and suppresses unions so let's not give them the moral high ground.

Apple's concern I don't think was arbitrary: there was a lot of 'really bad discourse' on Parler, and it was not moderated at all (or community moderated which had no effect).

I don't like Apple's App Store 'monopoly' however they were within reason to not want Parler in the store.

If Apple allowed non-AppStore downloads, then I think it would have sat much better.

Amazon however, I think did something a few steps more inappropriate and more nakedly political.

Amazon has a zillion customers that do arguably more nefarious things, in the 'big picture' they look hypocritical, though they are surely within legal rights as well.

I do feel however, that Amazon shouldn't be allowed to drop customers without a 3 month notice unless said customers have done something actually illegal, and by that I mean 'illegal as designated by an actual Judge'.

jariel··on Immigration Policies an Ongoing Concern to AI Researchers
Yes, the US has a byzantine migration bureaucracy, as do other nations, but that's a separate issue from notions of 'welcoming' or 'integration' or 'opportunities' etc..

It's also weird how the US has all the best talent in the world and some of the more ill-equipped bureaucracies.

jariel··on Immigration Policies an Ongoing Concern to AI Researchers
There's a citation there, and I think people are smart enough to understand what the term 'welcoming' might mean.

The data is very consistent - whatever words you want to use, the US and UK come out pretty well in terms of their respect and openness to migrants. [1][2]

The issues I have mostly is with the false narrative created in the press, particularly around Brexit although using Trump's words as evidence is not entirely unfair, it's still a little misrepresented.

[1] https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/uk...

[2] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/19/british-att...

jariel··on Immigration Policies an Ongoing Concern to AI Researchers
I have been an immigrant / temporary resident in both countries. Ad-hominem is not helping.
jariel··on Immigration Policies an Ongoing Concern to AI Researchers
Whatever the net rate of migration in IT workers, it's not something an individual is going to notice in terms of offers.
jariel··on Immigration Policies an Ongoing Concern to AI Researchers
The US and the UK have the most open policies and are overwhelmingly the most welcoming to migrants.

Both in practice and in culture.

The hints of Trumpism and Brexit 'nationalism' are essentially bigotry on the part of the author.

The paradox is if you have quite a lot of newcomers, that's going to make some people upset, or at least the policy will get attention. If you have few newcomers, it means there's little discussion but that doesn't mean the place is welcoming.

And some of it is just a matter of regular cultural barriers: Germany is a tough nut to crack even linguistically, let alone the culture. In America, it's 'English' and beyond that, there's little to worry about.

While Brexit has certainly caused some degree of unknowns because a former policy with the EU has changed, I think it will be sorted out.

Since there has been some policy change, the premise of the article I think is fair, but the wording was a little bit snide.

The data concerning attitudes towards immigrants consistently denies the narrative in the press regarding US/UK migrant populism. Have a look [1].

Survey after survey from generally the most respected institutions tend to reveal the same thing and that is the Anglosphere is considerably more open than other places. I don't consider that any kind of moral basis, however, it is a reality.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2019/03/14/around-the-wor...

Edit: I should add that the US/UK are not only the #1 destination for migrants, they also accept considerably more migrants per capita than most places, though not as much as Canada/Australia, notably, Anglosphere countries.

The evidence is overwhelming and undeniable that those places are generally good for migrants, almost all of the data supports it (number accepted, destination, openness, views of migrants etc). As noted below - the US system is rather bureaucratic, but it in the end it does extend status to mangy millions of people a year, a higher number (and per capita than most places so it's not that bad).

If you want to contend this, this you'll have to provide evidence other than the rather indirect notion of 'Trump said something mean'.

jariel··on Where’s the evidence that grit predicts success?
"doesn't change my point that grit seems to be a strict subset of the actual definition conscientiousness w"

Yes, I think it quite clearly does.

By definition (chose your own source, that's fine) and example, they are different things.

jariel··on How Developers Choose Names
Yes, convention is more important that the quality of the convention. The convention abnegates the need to think about things, and for a developer, thoughts are precious.
jariel··on How Developers Choose Names
"s almost like never having to think about logic. "

Not really, because naming is 98% convention when it's done right.

The challenge is establishing all the conventions for a project, and then sticking to them.

If there are really good conventions in place, well known, then naming is considerably easier.

In fact, even if the conventions are not super good - they can be powerful when they are very well adhered to.

Example: recently broke a rule and decided to use a known naming anti-pattern by suffixing variable names with the system type. This is normally not good. But within this module, the meta typing was ambiguous - by adding the suffix, the code was magically more clear. That little convention, very easy to apply, solved a clarity problem far more so than any issues around what functions should be called. So we used it for the module and that module only.

Apple has some pretty hardcore naming conventions that I don't really like, but what's more important then whether they are good or not, is that they are very consistently applied - in other words - a lot less to think about.

jariel··on How Developers Choose Names
This is one of the most interesting artifacts of programming, and it's probably impossible to explain to people outside the field. How at the same time it's trivial and important, and a constant cause of neuroticism.

It takes up far too much tought-space to the point I would gladly follow some ugly set of conventions merely to have to just never think about it.

jariel··on Ask HN: What was the biggest leadership challenge of your career?
"the guy who sponsored the fellow who did get promoted managed to get my ranking knocked down so I wasn't competing with his fellow for ED."

You're working at a toxic place and putting your own self worth up to them for measurement - this is not healthy.

People out of school until age 35 sometimes have a hard time truly separating their work from their professional identities, something we could all work on.

So sorry for your losses, I wish you well.

jariel··on Ask HN: What was the biggest leadership challenge of your career?
The thing to realize: this is normal.

People are weird - all of us.

We get into our own head-space, and we interpret the world differently than others, sometimes objectivity falls by the wayside.

Sometimes someone is truly working is rear off advancing the mission, but but that nobody really noticed, or if they did, that it didn't matter because 'hard work' isn't necessarily the only management requirement. They get upset because they didn't get the promotion.

Lashing out at 'management' is the easiest, most common thing for any worker to do, often there's a basis for concern, but just as often people don't recognize how inherently chaotic it is the higher one treads.

The moment you're in a leadership position, you will constantly be challenged by at least one 'hard case' of some kind or another.

Once simple rule to help differentiate: if they are making a fuss about the product, or something that will help the company/team, then there's probably good faith there. If the fuss is always about themselves or their career, that's not good.

jariel··on Ask HN: What was the biggest leadership challenge of your career?
This is a really good point, the social dynamics change so much in a power position it's really hard to relate.

Keep the 'bad puns' though, that's more of an expression of humility than anything and it gives them an excuse to groan.

Everyone 'hates/resents their manager' just a tiny bit, and a little opportunity to groan but not get too serious about it is a nice valve.

And yes - the greater the power, the greater every little thing gets parsed and possibly taken out of context, I loathe that because it's the thing that stops us from being candid, and why even in the long-form podcast world, people are not truly forthcoming.

jariel··on Ask HN: What was the biggest leadership challenge of your career?
This is highly subjective though.

Personally, if I'm sick, the last think I want to do is communicate with my manager - it means you have to be careful, you never know if they're digging, or 'professional but not exactly sincere empathy' etc..

'Adult Professionals' shouldn't need to be coddled. If you're sick you're sick and that's that.

If you have something that's a 'big deal' then you have that in a conversation in which the managers emotional response one would expect is empathy but beyond that it's a matter of 'how to work around it'.

'Trust' is a multifaceted thing, I generally do not trust that people will do their jobs well at the outset, until I've seen evidence of that, but as far as those kinds of workplace issues I definitely 'trust by default'. People get sick and that's that.

And then have a lot of tolerance because we are all a little odd in our own ways and it's just easier not to get caught up in stuff.

jariel··on Ask HN: What was the biggest leadership challenge of your career?
This is good advice for many but it's not nearly as universal as it's implied.

There are people who don't live up to the mark in terms of quality and that's that, and in those scenarios it would have little to do with trust.

jariel··on Where’s the evidence that grit predicts success?
I've literally just explained the difference to you.

From Google:

"Grit is the perseverance and passion to achieve long–term goals. Sometimes you will hear grit referred to as mental toughness."

"Conscientiousness is the personality trait of being careful, or diligent. Conscientiousness implies a desire to do a task well, and to take obligations to others seriously. Conscientious people tend to be efficient and organized as opposed to easy-going and disorderly."

They are not the same thing, though obviously the characteristics overlap.

People in creative disciplines can have 'high grit' but often very low conscientiousness and be successful.

As someone exposed a little bit to the music industry, I'm amazed by the level of determination people have in the face of rejection, and and at the same time, a lot of careless, inconsistent and risky behaviours in their life. Hard drug use, unstable relationships etc. - those are all 'low conscientious' things. But grit off the scale.

Tons of people are 'highly conscientious' and have little grit. Your bus driver, 12 year vet, never missed work? Probably highly conscientious, and likely low on grit. In fact, most working class people doing thoughtful and diligent, consistent work, but who have no greater goals or ambitions and avoid risk are probably low in grit.

jariel··on SPAC Wipeout Is Punishing Followers of Chamath Palihapitiya
I'm really hoping for the Kumail Nanjiani spin-off of Pied Piper where he plays Chamath.

The new era of RobinHood traders has brought an incredible degree of financial populism, youtube is crowded with people giving their opnion.

Some of it is really great, often more insightful and detailed than what a lot of banks dare publish - but a lot of it is rubbish.

jariel··on Where’s the evidence that grit predicts success?
'Conscientiousness' and 'Grit' I think are different attributes.

Conscientious people are like your 'nice Grandparents': they are consistent, orderly, pay their bills, are pleasant, predictable, file their taxes, recycle, don't steal.

Gritty people are those who mount the psychological effort necessary to take on a challenging problem, and have the wherewithal to keep going when things get rough.

To me the bit of confusion might arise between: 'Grit' and 'stubbornness' i.e. continue down an actually bad path and 'Grit' and 'Lack of Self Awareness' i.e. people utterly underestimating their ability, or the complexity of a domain. 'Fake it tell you make it' is actually a helpful characteristic in some areas, but in others it's not.

I do believe that 'grit' and 'conscientiousness' are both positive attributes in people who start companies, but that 'conscientiousness' is probably a more important attributes in most of the employees.

From the article: "Conscientiousness was twice as useful at predicting success as grit was." I have no doubt it's a better predictor for general life outcomes and especially academic outcomes. Doing a degree is mostly a grind.

jariel··on Bitcoin miners are buying power plants
"Anything can be valued at anything" is not an argument.

It's just some weird rhetoric you're using to somehow show a parallel between BTC and Stocks.

The material issue here is that stocks can be rationally valued by determining the underlying value of the implied asset ownership - and mostly are - whereas BTC cannot.

That someone can pay $1 Trillion for a pair of shoes, a BTC, or an Amazon shares is not relevant.

jariel··on 55% of all Tether, $25B, were created in 2021
This is the closest thing to correct, more specifically USD is backed by some real-estate and mostly TBill which is the government's ability to pay it's debt.

There's some sketchiness there, but generally it works, and of course, there are externalities like petrodollar but generally it's a sound currency.

It's not a super store of value, but it's not meant to be, there are other assets for that.

BTC is about as financially relevant as a GameStop mob, so if we're going to understand it, its' for the populist psychology, not for anything else.

Here is the 'backing':

USD [1]

Canadian Dollar [2]

Euro [3]

Bitcoin -> nothing.

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL [2] https://www.bankofcanada.ca/research/ [3] https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/annual/balance/html/index.en.h...

jariel··on Nassim Taleb: Bitcoin failed as a currency and became a speculative ponzi scheme
"It's the perfect settlement layer for large actors."

Wow, all the 'large actors' seemed to have not figured that out?

If it's the 'perfect settlement' process, then why are literally zero large actors using it for settlement?

Nobody uses it as a currency.

jariel··on Nassim Taleb: Bitcoin failed as a currency and became a speculative ponzi scheme
No, we cannot 'do it'.

1) a) There can only be 1 currency for an economic area - this is because we need price stability. The 'second currency' with the promise of 'less dilution' wouldn't be useful for transactions - people are not going to accept it widely, therefore it becomes more of a potential 'store of value' (but most cryptos are not good at that either).

b) A currency or any store of value is as good as the entity backing it. There is no avoiding that. You cannot have magic numbers represent value. Currency is a contract between you, and the people that use that currency.

2) Stable/Reliable for contracts. Contracts are agreements that are only valid in a legal regime. They are completely pointless without a legal framework to judge them in - and where there is enforcement. They always require interpretation. An 'independent document' doe nothing to help.

3) 'Storage' - you can't 'store' value in a bunch of numbers. You can buy land, commodities, stocks, bonds, commodities with some underlying value. We could feasibly use Gold as a kind of 'historical agreement' about what we value and do not (which has incumbency) - but the volatility of crypto makes it poor for 'store of value'.

4) Rapid transactions. We already have those.

Finally - we lose monetary policy and hand it over to an algorithm. No thanks.

The crypto world fail to understand what currency is, why it is used, and why we do the things we do but most fundamentally that money is a contract ultimately.

When China stores $1T in USD as excess reserves, surely, it would like to not have to depend on the US Government but there is no other way.

A USD is a contractual IOU from the economy of America - there is no way around that, no way to just magically extract the value of those trade surpluses into something that has intrinsic value.

A kind of Crypto that is backed by real assets, to replace VISA - merely to make transactions easier, might work. But any crypto backed by assets has centralized trust (fine for most people) and it would be hard to promote because it would need price stability and with price stability means you don't have millions of GenZ on their iPhone buying in.

Crypto might have a legit future but nothing on the horizon seems to fit just yet.

jariel··on 55% of all Tether, $25B, were created in 2021
"far from having shed the problems of government-issued currency,"

Government currency is backed by assets, or the governments ability to pay debt.

BTC is backed by nothing and they issue currency on the basis the ability to do fancy math problems.

So which currency has a 'problem' now?

jariel··on 55% of all Tether, $25B, were created in 2021
BTC has nothing backing it whatsoever. The crypto space doesn't seem to mind.

The minds managing the crypto space have never depended on reason or financial integrity, just a means to excite the masses onto their scheme.

jariel··on Bitcoin miners are buying power plants
Saying 'people can or cannot use it means that it's not a fundamental property' -> is not an argument.

Nobody has to use anything to value a stock - including current profits. Therefore even current profits would not be 'a fundamental property'.

And of course, nobody has to use any data or logic when valuing absolutely any financial asset anywhere, ergo - the statement is completely pointless.

Again: we value stock based on it's estimated book value, future earnings and other assessments. We can argue a little bit about all of that, fine, that's why we let the market decide.

BTC is just a fantasy speculation.

jariel··on Bitcoin miners are buying power plants
The problem is the young financially illiterate people BTC hypers who believe that BTC is an issue of tech, when really it's an issue of money and finance.

BTC a number who's ownership can be legitimized by some degree of public scrutiny.

It has utterly no value, no benefit, it's not a currency or store of value.

It's like a pair of Nike shoes, baseball card or comic book, except that it ownership can be transmitted digitally, hence the 'baseball cards'. It has utterly no value other than novelty and speculation.

It's not worth dealing with the BTC crowd, they're the same kind of people who think the Earth is Flat, that Trump won the election or that COVID is not real, following Elon Musk Pied Piper 'to the moon' because of a Tweet.

jariel··on Bitcoin miners are buying power plants
" The fact that we can agree that bitcoin gives us a source"

'Sources of Truth' are a commodity.

There are any number of ways to do that.

There's no reason to have a $50B source of truth.

And FYI there is no value merely in a 'source of truth' it has to be put to use in some way, and BTC has zero uses.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →