HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jasondclinton

883 karma · joined August 20, 2017

dCISO at Anthropic. Former staff software engineer at Google leading the Chrome Infrastructure Security team defending against APTs. Before that: payments security engineer (Android Pay), ChromeOS engineer, beowulf cluster engineer, GNOME Games module maintainer, and author of Ruby Phrasebook.

Signal: @jasondclinton.11

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jasondclinton; my proof: https://keybase.io/jasondclinton/sigs/DL7kLNV4-17_G3NlqgNDOzGigaqZ72Z8MDwwBybZT9k ]

submissionscomments
jasondclinton··on The Return of the 90s Web
The "Player of Games" by Ian M Banks takes place in a far-future society in which the abundance is so high that many people do pass the time playing games or whatever else enriches their lives. The question is: since we long since passed the point at which most people could work one day a week and maintain the level of abundance that existed in the 1960s, is that the society that we want to live in?
jasondclinton··on The Return of the 90s Web
Yes, the joke is that unemployment benefits are the real Endowment for the Arts. One wonders if we would have a healthier society if those who are capable of creating great art could do so by being freed up from financial constraints.
jasondclinton··on The Next Step for Generics
This should be the top comment: constructive criticism with a working example of how a simple sum-type-Rust-like-thing would be implemented.
jasondclinton··on Netgear 0-day vulnerability analysis and exploit
That's not a workable solution for the vast majority of the population.
jasondclinton··on Shadertoy Path Tracing: Fresnel, Rough Refraction and Absorption, Orbit Camera
Amazing and made to look so accessible. I love posts like these.

FWIW, this ShaderToy doesn't seem to work in either Firefox or Chrome for Android. Had to view it on a Linux machine.

jasondclinton··on The Curious Case of Swift's Adoption of Smalltalk Keyword Syntax
It's really weird to me that this is (currently) the top-voted comment on this article. This little quip is not what the article is about nor does it represent the author's views.

Do you have any feedback on that article's thesis that the closure syntax could have been handled better?

jasondclinton··on Microsoft: Rust Is the Industry’s ‘Best Chance’ at Safe Systems Programming
> I heard the Rust API changes between versions such that it’s a bit of a pain upgrading systems. Is this true?

No, this isn't true. https://blog.rust-lang.org/2018/07/27/what-is-rust-2018.html... was the last change and it was optional and automated migration.

jasondclinton··on Microsoft: Rust Is the Industry’s ‘Best Chance’ at Safe Systems Programming
I'm really confused by your comment because the experience that I have had and in surveys of my coworkers in the Rust community has been uniformly amazing: 1) the technical discussions are always respectful, 2) the in-person conferences have clear code of conducts and the speaker panels represent the best of the engineering and human community, and 3) the community actively encourages people asking newbie questions and goes out of its way to be supportive and non-judgemental when replying.

The only counter example that I can think of is the way that the actix unsafe maintainer's behaviour was handled (brigadiering bands of Reddit evangelists flaming him for his own flaming). However, I chock that up to an anomaly caused by Reddit's toxic community and not representative of the Rust community.

jasondclinton··on Avoiding the Global Lobotomy
I was on Mastodon for more than a year and loved it: great conversation that reminded me of the hope and promise of the Internet in the late 90's. Then my instance admin went AWOL, the site crashed, and all of my data and social graph were lost. I still can't get the admin to respond to emails. I could host my own server but who really has the technical know-how and time to do that kind of work? Mastodon has got to solve the reliability and/or portability problem. If I could have recovered my social graph on another instance, I would still be on the network.

Edit: I donated to the admin's Patreon account in excess of his hosting fees. But, that didn't cover his time, apparently. The admin is still active on GitHub after the server crashed; I guess he just lost interest.

jasondclinton··on Bye, Amazon
You said:

> Employees at this level are astoundingly uninterested in performing well, or, in other words, there is a reason they are working entry-level positions. This makes management yet more difficult because managers may have to become near micro-managers of cat herds trying to get the company to produce whatever it is supposed to produce.

which very much sounds like an indictment of all low skill workers. If you didn't mean that, perhaps you could reword that paragraph.

I haven't managed a business employing low-skilled workers because--and the reason that I grew up on food stamps--my father owned his own small business employing two to three such workers digging ditches or running electrical and construction type work. And the margins were incredibly thin and he paid them almost nothing and we still didn't have enough to eat. At various times throughout my childhood, those workers would inevitably have a heated argument with my father or otherwise steal from or slight him in some way. I think about that time a lot. Part of the reason that I think he continually failed as a manager/owner was that he had worked for medium sized companies when he was younger and went about replicating their management style in his own business. I often wonder if he would have done better if he made and treated these employees more as co-founders in a venture and allowed them have a sense of ownership and self-direction. I'll never know.

jasondclinton··on Bye, Amazon
I downvoted your GP and I will tell you why: it wasn't the observations of the way that businesses are run. It was this: "there is a reason they are working entry-level positions". This is Just World Hypothesis or "people are miserable because they deserve it". I flatly reject any hypothesis that the world we are living in is fair. You can consider any number of anthropological examples of societies that are not organized like capitalism in the West to see that the portion of the population that are "freeloaders" is not as high as the number of people who are stuck in "low skill" jobs. Just to take an example, the Amish do not experience this high level of stratification and wage slavery misery. They have their own problems, for sure, but humans are not en masse lazy. Most of us want to contribute to society and our system is exploitative.

And before you accuse me of being upper class, I grew up on food stamps, didn't complete college because I was working full-time to pay my way through it and it just didn't work out, and I worked plenty of terrible, low-skill jobs before I landed a job in tech.

jasondclinton··on Lyft lays off 17% of workforce, furloughs hundreds more
> I love many aspects of technology but am really growing to hate industry practices to the point of looking at career changes.

Agree with your post (and upvoted) but wanted to point out that these labor practices common to capitalism and so you're likely to find it just as bad outside of tech. In some industries, worse than others, for sure. But this is the Faustian bargain that we signed up.

(Personally, having worked some really terrible jobs outside of tech, I wouldn't leave it.)

jasondclinton··on The electric scooter Bird startup with big workplace problems
How do these tech "leaders" watch Silicon Valley and then behave exactly like the maligned characters and not see themselves as part of the problem?
jasondclinton··on Rust Survey 2019 Results
Just answering the question, not saying that it's true: it's seen as describing someone who has opinions about how to develop software or design systems without having the engineering expertise to back up those opinions.
jasondclinton··on Rust Survey 2019 Results
Yea, the survey says that IDE support is the third-highest item for increasing adoption (https://blog.rust-lang.org/2020/04/17/Rust-survey-2019.html#...). Rust users would benefit greatly from the Analyzer work that is in flight. Really looking forward to this becoming stable. The tooling it offers is great.
jasondclinton··on Rust Survey 2019 Results
I think that its a reflection of where much of the market's jobs are: "backend web app" might as just well be replaced with "thing moving data around with RPCs" which is what so much of the value software provides in the economy is tied up, these days. Also, for startups who live-or-die by their cloud hosting costs, reducing CPU utilization by 2x and MEM utilization by 5x versus GC'd languages, the value proposition is real.
jasondclinton··on Rust Survey 2019 Results
I was surprised to see the title "System Architect" was the second most-common job title among respondents. Use of that phrase is culturally taboo within Google. Are there regions in the world where its common to use that title? I see that the respondents were from all over the world in 14 languages.
jasondclinton··on Emacs: The most successful malleable system
That's also built into VSCode. The feature is called "Remote".
jasondclinton··on Flour mills working 'round the clock' to meet demand
Baking is such a wonderful way to relieve stress and there's so much chemistry involved that it's great for geeks, too. A good book (available in ebook) is The Bread Makers Apprentice: https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/39910
jasondclinton··on Gadgets That Refuse to Die
Another product with a much longer time horizon is those electronic dial pads on apartment buildings and entry gates: https://www.google.com/search?q=apartment+door+dial+pad&tbm=...

These things are running on technology from the late 90's virtually unchanged. Even the most advanced ones are low end silicon with terrible thermal designs and horrible user interfaces (scrolling through pages of residents on a bad monochrome display one line at a time). Nothing competes with them. They have no high-failure parts and can last for decades. (And some have.)

jasondclinton··on T-Mobile officially completes merger with Sprint, CEO John Legere steps down
I think that the first-class Google Fi devices have shown a path where CDMA and UMTS networks like Sprint and T-Mobiles can coexist on the same phone. Basically, the phone uses geolocation and a database of signal strength to determine which network to prefer in a particular location. It hangs up the baseband on one network and switches to the other. (Disclaimer: work for Google but not on the Android or Fi teams. Know nothing that isn't public.)
jasondclinton··on Honda bucks industry trend by removing touchscreen controls
All Tesla climate is non-physical. All newer Volvos are except for the defrost controls, as well.
jasondclinton··on What is the engineering hiring bar?
I was agreeing with you until you used the phrase "diversity hire" in your comment. I think that you could have made the same point without inferring that the hiring bar has been lowered for employees in underrepresented groups. That's a pretty terrible thing to say to anyone who is in one of those groups.
jasondclinton··on What is the engineering hiring bar?
I agree with a few things you said but you're also wrong about a few things.

FAANG compensation is much higher than you think. $200k/year (including stock) in the Bay Area for new grads is common. Yes, the prep for these interviews is insane but what has effectively happened (and this is supported by the article) is that companies have offloaded the selection work to the interviewee: they will only be able to pass if they are willing to do the ridiculous prep work. And yes, the interview questions have nothing to do with the job; that's not the point. Sadly, the process is often selecting for intelligent, compliant worker bees and not, what I would prefer, more creatively-inclined people. I agree with you: depending on what team you end up on, you could be asked to clock-in, crank out code, and clock-out without much creativity or input into anything.

BTW, Google doesn't use brain teasers since 15+ years ago. But, there is the occasional interviewer who asks questions about trivia that only they know about. This is supposed to be banned but there's no consequences for interviewers who do this. Hiring committees (who make the decision) usually throw out these questions when they see them in the list of interview feedback that they are using to make a decision.

Re: age. I worked on a team at FAANG that has tried very hard to hire folks with industry experience and we haven't found any resistance from interviewers to that. However, when talking to potential interviewees, we have found that very few are willing to subject themselves to the interviewing process for the reasons that you've outlined above. I don't blame them.

jasondclinton··on Honda bucks industry trend by removing touchscreen controls
This comment is off-topic: the article is about physical buttons for non-safety-critical systems. E.g. the article explicitly mentions climate control.
jasondclinton··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
Thanks for sharing your perspective. As it happens, I also grew up poor. I found the book extremely interesting so I wouldn't discount it just because you had that experience.
jasondclinton··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
Poverty does two things to us: limits our degrees of freedom (available choices) and diminishes our decision-making capacity (a famine/crisis response[1]). In extreme cases, poverty leads to sleep deprivation in which we cannot make even basic rational decisions.

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/20518805-scarcity

jasondclinton··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
I appreciate that you brought your own perspective to the problem with your comment. I would have liked to have seen more clarity on how victims could be helped to choose to escape.
jasondclinton··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
This thread is not the appropriate place to propose a policy solution because the parent article is about a sad topic with lots of terrible suffering. To make policy proposals here would be insensitive. And, no, I'm not a libertarian. I think that dysfunctional organizations are a moral problem that we must strive to solve, collectively. The free market will not.
jasondclinton··on For people with an abusive partner, lockdown means captivity
This is the most HN comment I've seen in a week. You tried not to blame the victim and acknowledge poverty is the trap but then came off as doing that in the context of personal responsibility shaming. Poverty or the fear of poverty is the real decision maker here; the math is as unforgiving as orbital mechanics.

And please don't reply, "But there are programs!" Governments and NGOs convince voters and donors that they are doing something by creating programs for domestic violence and then make those programs so difficult to enroll in that they spend half of their funding creating labrythine beurocracy. Anyone already at their mental capacity with abuse struggles even starting these processes.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →