HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jcahill

137 karma · joined November 24, 2016

submissionscomments
jcahill··on No, of that I'm innocent
I challenge "one of the MOST influential people" as vigorously as is posthumanly possible.

Off the top, how many people here who are both under 30 and hack on something (hardware, wetware, anything) know who scoble is? I only vaguely remembered his name with effort, and even that may have been by analogy to somebody else.

In fact: the more I look into him, the more the expression "never-was" (as a more extreme form of "has-been") comes to mind. Just step through his wikipedia entry⁽¹⁾ and it'll be hard to disagree with the assessment:

    > 4 Appearances
    >
    > In November, 2013, Scoble was co-keynote speaker with
    > Shel Israel at the 2013 Telstra Australian Digital
    > Summit. Scoble and Israel talked to their book titled
    > "Age of Context: Mobile, Sensors, Data and the Future of
    > Privacy".

read: noise.

    > On April 1, 2008, The Register ran an April fool’s spoof
    > claiming Robert Scoble was actually an IBM bot.

read: a stumbling, college newspaper-esque exercise⁽²⁾ in retrofitting a disposable assignment (april 1) to trash-talk scoble openly. unambiguously dripping with disdain, really.

    > On November 14, 2007, he was a contestant on a game show
    > at NewTeeVee Live […]

at what now?

    > [f]eaturing other internet celebrities such as Veronica
    > Belmont, Casey McKinnon, Cali Lewis, Kevin Rose, Justin
    > Kan, and others.

who? there are two tech names here, and zero celebrities.

    > On November 6, 2006, Scoble appeared as a panelist on a
    > Chinese Software Professionals Association event called
    > "The New Age of Influence: The Impact of Social Computing
    > on Media and Marketing".

read: noise.

    > 5 Milliscoble
    >
    > In September 2008, Follow cost, a website which
    > calculated how annoying it would be to follow anyone on
    > Twitter, invented the milliscoble unit of measurement
    > defined as: "1/1000 of the average daily Twitter status
    > updates by Robert Scoble as of 10:09 CST September 25,
    > 2008." At that time, Scoble was averaging 21.21 tweets
    > per day, so a milliscoble is 0.02121 tweets per day. A
    > person with a milliscoble rating of 1000 will be as
    > annoying to follow as Scoble.

read: further open contempt of scoble as shitposter incarnate.

So what do we have? A guy who had some kind of readership as a microsoft evangelist 13+ years ago, then circled the drain of ~web tv~ for a decade, then landed an Entrepreneur in Residence gig — read: unpaid internship⁽³⁾ — ultimately just circling a slightly newer, slightly shinier drain (VR).

One who, along the way, consciously uncoupled⁽⁴⁾ from all the content streams and personal branding whose maintenance constitute the entirety of an independent writing career. The blogger's own site, at .blog no less, is a contentless placeholder now.

We're left with some sorta phantasm of a now-defunct, still-not-tech personality: a never-was.

If the Ghostblogger of Milliscobles Past can kill your startup, your startup almost certainly didn't need to exist.

____________________

¹ http://enwp.org/Robert_Scoble

² https://theregister.co.uk/2008/04/01/ibm_scoble_nano

³ https://scobleizer.blog/2016/05/17/mental-blocks-resource-co...

⁴ https://scobleizer.blog/2012/07/02/scalable-livin

jcahill··on Fact Checks
"Progressive" and "Conservative" are sometimes used in extra-political contexts this way, e.g. in linguistics when characterizing dialects.
jcahill··on Keybase launches encrypted Git
Fortunately, Trello's free plan limits are so low that very little of substance will be lost.
jcahill··on Giving you more characters
Nothing valiant about telling users not to use a standard feature. Double-plus anti-valiant to suggest prioritizing mobile over desktop.
jcahill··on Hack – A typeface designed for source code
Hack isn't all that great. Here are tons of alternatives:

https://github.com/chrissimpkins/codeface

(Use Input)

jcahill··on Unpopular ideas about social norms
That wouldn't work like you're hoping. You're assuming a (representative) respondent pool that's all of these:

1. capable of switching off preference falsification for a survey

2. introspectively active (and accurately so) over a long enough period to notice that they behave differentially in public and private contexts

3. interested in exposing this degree of candor for a survey, i.e. motivated to "show the researchers" (show themselves, really) their belly after collapsing across all the reasons they'd rather not.

Humans are primitive. Questionnaires have to be designed around that.

jcahill··on The Rising Return to Non-Cognitive Skill [pdf]
(but really, the term "cognitive" used in this context boils down to g-loading, so "non-kernel processing" is as apt as anything else — an improvement over "non-cognitive" at the very least.)
jcahill··on The Rising Return to Non-Cognitive Skill [pdf]
Usually refers to precognition in the psychic sense, in english.
jcahill··on The Rising Return to Non-Cognitive Skill [pdf]
GNU/cognitive skills
jcahill··on What Nassim Taleb can teach us
Trouble there is simple: academically, he hasn't really innovated anything substantial enough to bother discussing in isolation. I mean that in a purely descriptive sense.

Just take a look at his google scholar⁽¹⁾ or crossref search⁽²⁾ hits and gloss over the books, republications of books, translations of books. What remains are miscellaneous vagaries about tail risk etc. In particular, lots of reviews / position papers that amount to him just setting up strawmen to tear down.

That contrarian browbeating is what drove him to prominence. And in sole-author article form, the attendant research laziness manifests itself as junk like this⁽³⁾ thing that's lower quality discussion of the subject matter than a lot of replication forum posts.

____________________

¹ https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&user=64BtMdsAAAAJ

² https://search.crossref.org/?q=%2BNassim+%2BTaleb&type=Journ...

³ Taleb, N.N., 2016. The Meta-Distribution of Standard P-Values. SSRN. http://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2834266

jcahill··on What Nassim Taleb can teach us
the poetics of successful sophistry is a potential research topic in its own right, so sure
jcahill··on What Nassim Taleb can teach us
Thing is that he picks an organizing principle⁽¹⁾ and rides it into the ground, through the center of the earth, and back out the other side until eventually de-emphasizing it in favor of some new organizing principle more attractive to current audiences.

That is: there are geological layers of taleb based entirely in reader-response. He can't make his subject matter audience-invariant, because how it plays determines its significance to him: it's a feedback loop of bullshit by design. Right now all his acolytes can manage to sputter forth is acronymized slogans like SITG (skin in the game), so that's what he plays up. Formerly it was stuff like antifragility, etc. It just keeps devolving.

____________________

¹ http://enwp.org/organizing_principle

jcahill··on What Nassim Taleb can teach us
if you start from a position of disdain instead, you'll be able to move past thinking his works have enough value to suffer the bullshit antics and be well on your way to never thinking about him again except in passing social context.

taleb is ultimately just another LARPer. people get the impression that he's something more for ~4 basic reasons:

1. he's more verbal than them.

2. they don't know stats too good.

so, given a crisis of confidence in all statistical orthodoxy plus a guy who really really seems to talk like he knows about stats a lot, and whom others — who also don't know stats, but want social proof of reading & shit — say knows about stats, they have no choice but to remain agnostic or go along with taleb's dogmatic-sophist-monkey-dance.

3. they fail to appreciate that his depth of extended expertise is never more than ankle-deep, and breadth very agonizingly chosen so as to min-max in terms of knowledge required to signal learnedness to the unlearned.

he'll say some poncy shit like « flâneur » out of context just because his readers are unfamiliar with it. he'll go on seeming deep-dives about language evolution and community segregation in the spinning of statistical fables — and it'll be utter horseshit, but nobody reading him will suspect that, and anyone with the requisite expertise to debunk it line by line doesn't give a shit about him and has no incentive to do so: why debunk a LARPer whose entire shtick is being a cleverer obscurant than most with an institutionally-enabled gish gallop lifestyle?

4. academic culture is so actively pathetic and conflict-avoidant that it's trivial to come across as some sort of masculine breaker-of-chains figure merely by not sucking in the majority mould — sucking differently is sometimes sufficient, at this point.

just look at jordan peterson. i don't intend to imply that he sucks, but look at him, presentation-wise. dude's basically a couple slices of ham held up by suspenders wrapped in a blazer, mouth-hole cut out so wind can blow through, and he's hailed as some kind of triumphant anti-establishment figure simply because culture wars shit has gotten so farcical.

wonks are thrown off by taleb's eagerness to be crass in the middle of otherwise frou-frou discourse, and that's the only thing that gives it any influence — because he discards all epistemic norms in the process. he won't circle back for them if they wait it out, or otherwise re-engage like a good lad. he doesn't choose to be vulgar for shits and giggles while nevertheless maintaining soundness of argumentation, he does it simply as a short-circuiting mechanism.

the posturing is slumming to him: he's aping a working class affectation without the life experience of having an epistemic peer+ interrupt the ritual to physically dickslap him and then resume reasoned discussion.

you see it with the powerlifting posturing as well.

i mean, nobody gives a shit what some physically unremarkable old man lifts. not young girls who don't wanna fuck unremarkable old men, nor young powerlifting guys who don't wanna have their sets interrupted by some old poseur pretending to do a 2016 election exit poll so he can inevitably find that

  HIGH T ⇒ TRUMP VOTER
  LOW T ⇒ HILLURRY
  
  LUK, A BUNCHA MATHEMATICA BULLSHIT
  BUNCHA MATHEMATICA BULLSHIT ⇒ IMRITE
  AND IT'S A PICTURE SOOOOO…
  YOU CAN'T USE IT W/O TRANSCRIBING IT
  DESPITE ALREADY KNOWING IT'S BULLSHIT
  HEE HAW AREN'T I SUCH TROLE
  
  GLOBALIST CUCKS BTFO BY #BLACKSWAN
(yeah, this refers to an actual thing⁽¹⁾ he did on twitter)

in fact, the only possible audience for such effete anti-intellectual snobbery is Young Male Scholars™, pencilneck NYU Stern dandies who can project aspirations onto such a transparently less-than-nothing caricature as taleb in the same way that lots of young guys get really into BEING LIBERTARIAN as a social posture & gender identity.

so taleb, then: a brand for dullwits, a statistician who squandered nigh-unsquanderably fortuitous career timing to shitpost about things he just read a single wikipedia entry on, a guy who needed to be spanked a lot more as a kid, gist him however you like.

it doesn't really matter how you do it, because he doesn't matter

____________________

¹ https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/814560759577513984

jcahill··on Software is narrative
https://archive.is/1CJpA
jcahill··on Manuscript Was Due 30 Years Ago, University Press Still Wants It
Knuth is not going to "become the rise of scientific publishing" on the basis of your HN comment.
jcahill··on Staedtler and Faber-Castell's productive pencil rivalry (2011)
> Let that sink in.

This is the sort of rhetorical affectation that will have you ridiculed straight out of any room I'm in. Please discontinue.

jcahill··on Ask HN: Protect loved ones from online scams?
There's always reducing the circle you consider "loved" ones, and CRISPR…
jcahill··on Psychology of Intelligence Analysis (1999)
For anyone else stuck in a captcha redirect loop:

https://doi.org/10.1109/AERO.2015.7118968

jcahill··on Bitcoin Fork Monitor
Different audiences. Most friends & acquaintances asking me for explanations about august 1

⒈ get repeatedly caught up on basic blockchain concepts (i.e. go in circles w/ terminology)

⒉ know absolutely nothing about the politics of the decision-making up to now

⒊ yet have already been exposed to somebody's propaganda and half-internalized the wrongthink

So i'm not sure that a flowchart of just the proposals w/o entities serves much purpose. Its audience is essentially limited to devs who just need to be caught up on current events.

Coin Dance already has this information available, but across two dashboard-style pages⁽¹⁾⁽²⁾ — not quite arranged efficiently enough for an interactive infographic.

Starting from "know your hardforks" and adding the missing bits from the flowchart as tooltip or on-hover information could work.

____________________

¹ https://coin.dance/blocks

² https://coin.dance/poli

jcahill··on Bitcoin Fork Monitor
try this infographic: https://i.imgur.com/RjTkcdQ.png
jcahill··on Linkarchiver, a new bot to back up tweeted links
> It also required that I figure out how to “daemonize” the script[.] I found this aspect surprisingly difficult; it seems like a really basic need, but the documentation for how to do this was not especially easy to find. I host my bots on a Digital Ocean box running Ubuntu, so this script is running as a systemd service.

Agreed on the relative dearth of well-gisted tutorial content re: routine sysadmin tasks.

Outlets that pump out tons of marginally-differentiable content on <today's unnecessary stack element that'll have you terraforming the noosphere 333% more, free> tend to prevail by sheer numbers.

That being said, systemd is its own problem in need of abstracting away from. Supervisor⁽¹⁾⁽²⁾ might be the layer you're looking for.

____________________

¹ http://supervisord.org/index.html

² https://digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/how-to-install-...

jcahill··on As Workouts Intensify, a Harmful Side Effect Grows More Common
rhabdomyolysis.

https://archive.fo/KqM4u

jcahill··on Maps reveal the structures of ‘Choose Your Own Adventure’ books
Notable exception: Meanwhile… (2001).

Web blurb, slightly different from print⁽¹⁾

____________________

Meanwhile began as a series of seven increasingly complex flowcharts. Once the outline of the story was structured, a computer algorithm determined the most efficient way to transfer it to book form, using a system of tabs to interlink the panels and pages. The problem proved to be NP-complete; it was finally cracked in spring of 2000, with the aid of a V-opt heuristic algorithm which ran for twelve hours on an SGI machine.

____________________

¹ http://zarfhome.com/meanwhile

jcahill··on A blockchain in 200 lines of code
Commits aren't automated and their contributions aren't commensurate. It's a distributed system, but not one solving the same problem.

We can always torture the concrete into extended metaphor. It just doesn't add any value here.

jcahill··on The Distribution of Users’ Computer Skills: Worse Than You Think
Not mentioned yet: separation of concerns.

http://enwp.org/separation_of_presentation_and_content

jcahill··on Statistical Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
> find me a published scientific paper with only Bayesian results in it

Trivial¹, surely?

> [B]ut I don't think anyone does it. It would be seen as a stunt.

What did you mean by "scientific"?

You'd have to hunt for a narrow reading s.t. the above holds — extant counterexamples aren't limited to any one branch.

Check it out² for yourself.

Further: cogsci's bayesian adoption is rapidly accelerating.

The replication crisis is brutalizing huge swathes of psych:

• loss of confidence in NHST is becoming near-total for many

• journals are purging in turn — e.g. BASP's p-value ban³⁴

• others are overhauling stats-in-psych entirely

J Math Psych alone has two recent special issues⁵⁶ on this.

I mean:

> no frequentist stats at all

isn't even a strawman lately, let alone an absurdity.

In some fields, it's a battle-cry.

All that being said… re:

> Argue for its superiority all you want

I wouldn't even go that far. Don't give em that.

Probability interpretation fundies

• are all wrong,

• narrow minds and waste lifespans with the cultism, and

• should at least learn of the other interpretations.

Pitching probability as a 1v1 isn't merely wrong-prime⁷ — it's doublepluswrong″⁸.

It's pseudofundamentalism: fundies uphold foundations.

Flamewars predicated on ignorance of the same gotta go, no matter how fashionable they may be.

____________________________________________________________

[1] http://enwp.org/bayesian_game

[2] http://google.com/scholar?q=fully+bayesian

[3] http://doi.org/4z8 | BASP 37

[4] http://doi.org/34p | Nature re: BASP

[5] http://doi.org/btqx | J Math Psych 72

[6] http://doi.org/btqz | J Math Psych 74

[7] http://enwp.org/all_models_are_wrong

[8] http://enwp.org/not_even_wrong

jcahill··on Statistical Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
All models are wrong. That much is entailed by 'models'.

There is no Zuul.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4