HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jegoodwin3

102 karma · joined November 2, 2012

bitcoin
submissionscomments
jegoodwin3··on The world in 1975 (2007)
Mostly on base -- but no mention of the exit from Saigon? 1975 was the year the '60s ended.

Also, in 1975, one heard a lot more about 'the coming ice age' than global warming. The concept had a brief reprise in the 80s with 'the Cold and the Dark' (Nuclear Winter).

jegoodwin3··on The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment
So this is a political problem -- here's my prediction of what will happen (given that we live in the real, political, world).

A political entity -- not necessary a sovereign government, but perhaps a bank or financial institution -- will offer a currency swap to existing blockchain holders to adopt their crypto currency. The inducement will be a limited time window to put in your claim, with all unclaimed but mined numbers going to the financial entity to reward their followers or stakeholders.

In the real world, this is called escheat and it is a power of the crown. Bitcoin is essentially a system for recording deeds to digital land. They aren't making more numbers, so the problem is the political resolution of competing claims to the same resource. This sort of claim comes, in the end, to a network consensus of who is the sovereign.

jegoodwin3··on Paribus (YC S15) saves you money when items you purchased online drop in price
You should take it a step further and help the retailers add this as a feature to their own apps -- having a store app should include a promise that if the store lowers prices, it will refund the difference for purchases in the last week (or whatever time frame) to loyal customers, perhaps through a store credit. It's a dandy reason to drive adoption of the app.

One thing you should listen to is the number of people who want a reserve price (transaction threshold). This price setting is pure economic gold as information goes -- it tells you their risk aversion (probably) and the shape of their utility curve for extra income. I'm sure it correlates with income, and gives independent verification of income, statistically.

If you have 5 big retailers using your app feature internally, offer to build them a network they can join, to make their rebate offer even more attractive to participants.

With the stores' aid, you can circumvent the problems with email permissions, which frankly are going to limit your adoption. You are far better off working with the stores in a partnership I think, and helping them to understand their own customers' reserve price (and hence propensity for returns and chargebacks, which they surely care about), than being a 'gotcha' adversary.

Added link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expected_utility_hypothesis

jegoodwin3··on Paribus (YC S15) saves you money when items you purchased online drop in price
Is it like a kid screaming and paying people to shake down restaurants? Not really. The essence of the problem solved is information asymmetry. To see this, break the app into two apps -- one that simply informs you that you missed out on a deal and makes you feel bad, and one that compensates you and makes you feel better by giving you a savings.

This is a side-payment, as in Coase's theorem. You are outraged at the side-payment, but that just hides the information asymmetry under a cloak of disgust. There is no valid reason that the purchaser should not learn the price subsequently dropped -- but the nature of homo economicus being what it is no one will use the first app without the second.

This app is an application of Coase's theorem, and takes an externality (uninformed consumers are like a clean river to dump bad pricing into at a profit) and internalizes that cost by making companies pay it -- it is always better for the market if costs are internalized, assuming markets work at all.

It doesn't matter whether the company or the consumer pays, according to Coase's theorem. The result will be the same. We might invent reasons to be outraged that the company pays, but really all that has happened is a market inefficiency -- information asymmetry -- has been eliminated. Prices are less sticky and more flexible. This is good.

jegoodwin3··on Why I Carry a Newton
This was very helpful. Thanks. The second link made it sound very smalltalkish to me -- it sounded like an OODBMS that real world users could relate to. So I followed the link at the Wikipedia article and was surprised to learn that NewtonScript was a prototype-based inheritance language modelled on Self.

If the secret sauce is a user-accessible OODBMS written in a prototype-based scripting language, would it not be possible to build a Data Soup system in JavaScript? No need to bring the device back -- just replicate what people liked about it.

jegoodwin3··on How Will Consumers Use Faster Internet Speeds?
Obligatory educational link on bufferbloat

http://www.bufferbloat.net/projects/bloat/wiki/Introduction

'One of the most insidious things about bufferbloat is that it easily masquerades as something else: underprovisioning of the network. But buying fatter pipes doesn't fix the bufferbloat cascades, and buying larger buffers actually makes them worse!'

jegoodwin3··on One Clause in the Net Neutrality Regs Would Be a Fiasco for the Internet
Readers might want to acquaint themselves with the performance issues around buffer bloat:

http://www.bufferbloat.net/projects/bloat/wiki/Introduction

jegoodwin3··on Firefox’s adoption of closed-source DRM breaks my heart (2014)
'market position' is a red herring -- it's a proxy for Developer Will. Developers care about the market share of what platform they write for, and they care about it more than principle.

You might as well say, if the developer community got its act together and stood on principle, no company could caputure 'market share' without their consent.

The problem is not the Mozilla non-profit knuckling under -- it is developers failing to have an institution similar to other professions, such as the Bar or AMA, giving them principles.

jegoodwin3··on Why I can't have conversations using Twitter
If only he'd called it 'the 1%' instead of the 99th percentile, he could have founded the 'Occupy EC2 movement'. #lostopportunity
jegoodwin3··on Snowden Documents Indicate NSA Has Breached Deutsche Telekom
Representing Germany as a US client state made sense a generation ago, when it was an occupied nation not least because of its aggressive actions towards European Jewry, and because of the Cold War. Now it is home to a large Muslim population, many of whom are the targets of this surveillance, and the US is allied with Israel. Also, we have been fighting wars in the Middle East for over a decade.

I would suggest that the Germans are more than either a client state or allies. They are a leading state in the EU if not its defacto leader, and the EU is not your grandfather's EU.

Whatever metapolitical order establishes itself in cyberspace will certainly respect the real world politics, which is that relations between the US and EU are tense, and Germany's relationship with its own Muslim population is ambiguous as regards the concepts being thrown around here -- 'treason' and 'duties of a citizen' and 'sovereignty'.

Technical persons would do well to think through what they really want out of the world political order, and to pursue policies with good will that are conducive to peace. Perpetuating the political order of the last century will be both futile and counterproductive.

jegoodwin3··on NoSQL databases benchmark: Cassandra, HBase, MongoDB, Riak
Not sure I buy the paper's analysis. They don't seem to know much about load testing -- they speak as though throughput is 'load' (rather than the multiprogramming level) and don't computer Bandwidth - Delay products.

Also, rather than using M/M/1 or some reasonable analytic model, they deliberately trottled their request rates to hold throughput constant (thereby guaranteeing different loadings for different 'benchmarks')

Just reading the first graph, for example, and applying Little's Law, it's pretty evident that Cassandra was loaded more heavily than than the two MySQL systems, with HBASE and Riak trailing.

Looks like HBASE and Cassandra lead the pack to me, with different characterists for different purposes.

Advice to authors: buy a book by Neil Gunther.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2