HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jenwkejnwjkef

38 karma · joined January 11, 2021

submissionscomments
jenwkejnwjkef··on That XOR Trick (2020)
Nobody wants to see the XOR solutions. These questions are really basic and only filter out the non-programmers. Any decent programmer should be able to solve all of these without a problem.
jenwkejnwjkef··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
Yes but every extension that does anything remotely interesting needs access to "your entire browsing history," which is a comment much scarier than it usually is. The truth is that it is impossible for a computer to distinguish malicious javascript from useful javascript, meaning all trust and verification needs to come from the user.
jenwkejnwjkef··on Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the extensions?
Yeah. The $99/year is big enough to pretty much block out all hobby devs and open-source projects, so what's left are generally commercial and closed-source. Apple says that they do their own vetting of extensions, but I don't trust Apple to prevent extensions from reading my browsing history, especially considering spyware extensions like Honey are served on the App Store without warning.
jenwkejnwjkef··on Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
Sci-hub is not breaking any laws. They are accused of breaking laws. Who gave Twitter, in your eyes, the power to act as a judge?
jenwkejnwjkef··on Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub
Intellectual "property" is not property.
jenwkejnwjkef··on Sci-Hub Is Now on the ‘Uncensorable Web’
Yeah, it's pretty weird how he uses him to further left-libertarianism. How do you know Aaron Swartz stood for anarchism? He seems like anti-intellectual property to me, but you know right-libertarians oppose intellectual property too. I find it despicable to use someone to further an ideology without giving them the chance to actually state their own political beliefs.
jenwkejnwjkef··on Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar (2018)
> they actually review and actively publish the information

They do it to save their own ass. Since they publish it, they are responsible. Facebook should either review the all content they publish, or they should stop being a publisher.

> Do we honestly believe that between ML and a real person Facebook is validating and approving every comment on Facebook?

I never said that; here's my point: if, say, the New Yorker replaced their human editors with AI ones, then the outcome is the same and they are still publishers. Alternatively, say they made human-run personal curations---each subscriber gets an individually-tailored set of articles which are suggested---then they are obviously still publishers. So if they replace these human curators with AI, are they still publishers? Because that would be what Facebook is today.

And on your Gmail point, Google is not a publisher, it acts like a phone service. You send your email, the recipient receives it, unconditionally, without modification. Facebook actively shadow-bans, time-delays and puts fact-check warnings on posts. Since that show they disapprove of some posts, it kind of implies that they approve of all the others.

jenwkejnwjkef··on Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar (2018)
It doesn't matter who makes the content. Take for example, the New Yorker, which curates short stories and poetry not written by their own authors/editors. If they were to publish something inciting violence or otherwise illegal/immoral, they can't just throw their hands in the air and say "it wasn't me!", legally nor socially.

Besides, I'm talking mostly on a social aspect rather than a legal one. I'm not a lawyer. But too often do we give Facebook a pass since it doesn't make the content, it only curates it. The curation is automated at a massive scale by AIs, and is done for each user, every day, but it is still undeniably curation.

An example of a platform is if the user does their own curation. E.g. old Instagram. You got everything posted by everyone you follow, in chronological order. Now Instagram will change the feed order and time-delay/shadowban posts, making it, in my view, a publisher. Your SMS example is a platform since you chose to have your SMS's sorted by time.

jenwkejnwjkef··on Facebook Admits It Was Used to Incite Violence in Myanmar (2018)
I'm not sure why anybody falls for the frankly absurd idea that social media sites are platforms and not publishers. They choose what to show you, just like the NYT or any other traditional publisher. The only difference is who does the choosing---algorithms or humans. But that, to me, is just a logistical detail and shouldn't have an effect on the distinction between publisher and platform. To think that Facebook and other companies act as merely connectors between viewpoints and are really just platforms for free speech is ridiculous.

From the article, no, Facebook did not "fail to prevent its platform from being used to foment division and incite offline violence;" they published content which foments division and incites offline violence. The distinction is important.