HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jeremysmyth

1,146 karma · joined February 15, 2012

submissionscomments
jeremysmyth··on Zika Is Coming
it's a world which is changing, and generally for the worse

Ah, but this is objectively wrong, by almost every metric (crime, security, murder, health, longevity, happiness, poverty). What is getting worse is the general level of fear, and this comes from the fact that we can hear bad news faster and more generally than ever before, combined with our evolved nature to implicitly feel that everything that we hear about might personally affect us (see Dunbar's number), and clickbait tactics of news editors and the need to fill the 24 hour news cycle with sensationalism. Fear causes stress, and both fear and stress cause physically and socially damaging effects.

To wit: I never met anyone affected (directly or indirectly) by the recent Ebola outbreak in any social environment (online or offline) to which I belong, but almost everyone I spoke to about it was afraid of it. That's not to diminish the effect on the (globally) few people it impacts, which is horrible and terrifying, so the imbalance is not at all universal. However, it's a fair assumption that fear of Zika is considerably more dangerous to the average person (globally) than the risk of the virus itself. Multiply this across all the other things that people are afraid of but that are actually less dangerous now than at any time in our recorded past, and you end up with fear being the most damaging change for the worse.

jeremysmyth··on Design better databases
and if the order is not important. Reordering large numbers of rows can be a very expensive operation.
jeremysmyth··on Non-obvious indicators that a transaction might be fraudulent
Aside from the probabilistic harm mentioned by sibling posts, there are also issues of self-fulfilling prophecies coming from fishing expeditions.

Assume:

- LEOs use profiling (based on statistical models) to target individuals who are not the subject of investigation but rather subjected to random stop/search/frisk.

- They catch some "bad guys" by following this model.

These assumptions are not dissimilar from the premise outlined in the grandparent post.

Now, let's say the statistical model throws up "20-25 year old preppie white guy with glasses, called Peter" either through error or some odd outlier stat. If LEOs start to check out every 20-25 year old matching that description, sooner or later they're going to find drugs or a gun or a lot of cash or something. Their statistical model gets updated with these stats, and before long it becomes a truism that a disproportionate number of preppie Peters are criminals.

If you shine a spotlight somewhere, that's where you'll find what you're looking for.

jeremysmyth··on Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it illegal (2014)
Overall, over time it's much easier to take out the hammer and create one-size-fits-all answers to every catastrophe that occurs. Repeat and rinse this process over several years, and you've got a software shop that's running ten times slower than everybody else.

...and not killing anyone.

"People have to channel their creativity into changing the process," says Keller, "not changing the software."

"Most people choose to spend their money at the wrong end of the process," says Munson. "In the modern software environment, 80% of the cost of the software is spent after the software is written the first time — they don't get it right the first time, so they spend time flogging it. In shuttle, they do it right the first time."

"The most important things the shuttle group does — carefully planning the software in advance, writing no code until the design is complete, making no changes without supporting blueprints, keeping a completely accurate record of the code — are not expensive. The process isn't even rocket science. Its standard practice in almost every engineering discipline except software engineering."

http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff

jeremysmyth··on Powerful Political Forces Are Aligning Behind Minimum Income
Right, but that administration already exists for social payments, except the majority of the administration is in the gatekeeping side: Making sure that the people who are claiming are entitled to it. Remove that administration and you make large savings.
jeremysmyth··on 10 years later, Twitter still isn't making money
Wrong question. This is like asking "As a carpenter, how would you use this shoe to hammer in a nail?"

Twitter, as it has evolved (or been driven depending how much you trust the vision of its management) is not a lucrative platform. It needs either to change how it connects payers, payees, and audiences drastically (and not just be pitched differently), or it needs the industry to change underneath it. The latter option is not actually that unlikely at the moment.

jeremysmyth··on Explosions in Brussels Kill at Least 13
"Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

jeremysmyth··on Ask HN: What books do you wish your manager would read?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peopleware:_Productive_Project...

That page doesn't do it justice, sadly. This book just gets it about working in teams and larger organizations.

jeremysmyth··on Toddlers Kill More People in the USA (with guns) Than Terrorists Do
The ultimate worry is that in 100 years our countries will be split into separate warring tribes.

The ultimate worry is that there won't be a 100 years. Some demagogues and dogmas attract ruthless followers. It only takes one well-supplied psychopath (with access) to cause a huge amount of damage. It might be an idiot with a bomb in his underwear, or it might be a North Korean nuclear submarine captain.

jeremysmyth··on How People Used to Download Games from the Radio
I did this exactly once for a ZX Spectrum game, and it didn't work. It turns out the slightest hash or fizzle or cracking on the station messed up the reception enough to corrupt the download.

Something the article mentions but I'd like to re-emphasise: The amount of time it took to record from the radio and subsequently load (or attempt to load) is quite significant. We had to set up the recording, get ready for the announcer to call it, and press record. Then go away for five to ten minutes, hoping (and that's a long time to be on edge), and then rewind, move the tape over, and press play having typed the appropriate LOAD command, only for it to fail. Rotten way to spend an evening that I'd planned for over a week.

jeremysmyth··on Political Correctness Devours yet Another College, Fighting Over Mini-Sombreros
Like being white straight and male makes you automatically rich, powerful, racist and a misogynist

No, but being white, straight, and male means you don't have to navigate barriers formed by even slightly racist, homophobic, or sexist people. And there are lots of slightly racist, homophobic, or sexist people to navigate[1].

In motor racing, even a tiny advantage lets you win disproportionately more races than your competition. If someone is going to get rich and powerful, it's going to be the person with the most advantages and least disadvantages. Not having to deal with discrimination is such an advantage, particularly when you accept that racism, homophobia, and sexism are things that affect real people.

[1] https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/takeatest.html

jeremysmyth··on Why Did Ancient Europeans Just Disappear 14,500 Years Ago?
Time at war isn't the only measure of peace, social stability and contentment in a country.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_the_Uni...

jeremysmyth··on Kuhn's Paradox
SO subscriber content (e.g. answers) are CC BY-SA[0] which "is often compared to “copyleft” free and open source software licenses"[1]

[0] "all Subscriber Content that You contribute to the Network is perpetually and irrevocably licensed to Stack Exchange under the Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike license" http://stackexchange.com/legal

[1] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/

jeremysmyth··on ECB votes to ban 500 euro note
Title is incorrect, should be "ECB considers scrapping 500 euro note"

Nobody is voting for anything yet: European finance ministers have asked the ECB to look at ways to tighten cash security.

jeremysmyth··on The radical plan to destroy time zones
WV: So, the Universal Time Zone system. What lead you to argue so strongly for that option?

HH: Because from a physics point of view, there IS only one time!

Um... this would've been a more convincing argument if there was an attempt to use physics, any physics here. "Relative to the centre of the Earth... relative to ..." well, anything, really. The fact that some of our most interesting time sources--GPS satellites--have the difference in their relative time baked into how they operate is a score against the whole "only one time" idea.

jeremysmyth··on People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads
Same effect, but different mechanism (and causal route):

http://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comics_en/rat-park/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park

jeremysmyth··on Internet Access Is Finally Permanently Tax Free in the U.S.
Permanently? That suggests a law that can't be repealed, amended, or otherwise modified, when in fact it's just had its expiration date removed.

This law is no different to any other tax law, and is therefore subject to the usual whimsy of Congress. Just this time it doesn't expire automatically.

jeremysmyth··on India launches 'lightest gun' weighing 250g
What change in attitude is going to stop sex-deprived men from acquiring what they are programmed to want more than anything else?

This statement is profoundly insulting to the billions of men who have enough self-control every day not to destroy another person's bodily integrity and dignity to fulfil a temporary need. Just because some people cannot control themselves to obey the law and common respect does not suggest that their attitude is normal or cannot be changed.

There's a similar argument used in certain conversations about rape to the effect that you wouldn't dangle a tasty slice of bacon in front of a dog and expect him not to jump for it. While that might be true of feral dogs, I've known many domesticated dogs who are capable of even that degree of self control, and I absolutely would not apply the same metaphor to humans, or otherwise suggest that we are incapable of distinguishing ourselves from feral animals in the face of certain desires. We're better than that, and for you to suggest otherwise is abhorrent.

jeremysmyth··on Foregone conclusions – the Kruskal count
Obligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/903/

Ah, but unlike any other obligatory XKCD you tend to see on HN, the relevance here isn't in the comic but in the alt-text you get when you hover over the image.

jeremysmyth··on Friction Between Programming Professionals and Beginners
and frowns on those that might involve discussion

No, it explicitly forbids questions that involve discussion.

The point of Stack Overflow is (and to a large extent always was) to be the place for definitive answers (and their alternatives) to well-asked questions. It is not a place for discussions, ranked opinions, interesting conversations, or anything else that does not have a "right" or "best-guess" answer.

It so happens that many questions are interesting to the community of people who visit Stack Overflow, but that doesn't mean they are contextually appropriate. If you want a discussion, go elsewhere. This isn't just a "if you don't like it, leave" judgement: it's explicit in the design and mission of the site[1]. There are better places to discuss things, just not on Stack Overflow.

[1] "This site is all about getting answers. It's not a discussion forum. There's no chit-chat...Avoid questions that are primarily opinion-based, or that are likely to generate discussion rather than answers.", from http://stackoverflow.com/tour

jeremysmyth··on Sweet Spot: New Study Shows Optimal Group Size for Baboons
50-70, to avoid the clickbaity title.

For a humorous look at the same idea for humans (150 fwiw), see here: http://www.cracked.com/article_14990_what-monkeysphere.html

jeremysmyth··on Tell HN: Don't post if you're not actually hiring
I'm curious what OP thinks they should do if "the position is filled or they are hiring a stronger match". There aren't that many alternatives.
jeremysmyth··on This is actually what America would look like without gerrymandering
It also has some emergent complexity that might not be immediately apparent without having seen how it works in practice:

- Success (i.e. being voted in) is considerably easier when you depend on a proportion of the population than a majority, and this diminishes the power of party political vehicles.

- PR therefore encourages (or rather, discourages less) the formation of splinter groups, "forked" parties, and independent candidates

- It results in legislative bodies with no clear majority, which in turn leads to coalitions of convenience (great for mapping to population majority on single issues) but tends to destabilize governments that do not dance the dance of diplomacy very well (because tyrannical "we have a clear mandate" decisions don't work without a clear majority).

These are not necessarily bad features, because cooperation becomes regularly necessary rather than an occasionally inconvenient task. It does mean, however, that politicians have to be good at politicking to ensure they continue to be important in a world where loyalty to the party is only a piece of the whole pie.

If you add in STV (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_transferable_vote) it gets even more interesting, because the transferable vote means each winner has to have the approval of a majority of the electorate. This means that, while in FPTP or simple PR, someone might get elected with (e.g. from parent comment) 17% of the vote (meaning that up to 83% of the population voted against them), in PR with STV, at least 50% + 1 has to approve of the candidate, to some extent.

Neither system removes the problem of gerrymandering however, because it's still possible to draw a constituency that is statistically going to maximize e.g. working class candidates, thereby reducing the impact of that electorate on neighbouring middle-class constituencies.

jeremysmyth··on 216 postive words not in the English language
Mistitled. It's not words that aren't in English, but words categorized by language, many of which are (naturally) not English.

There is, however, a category for English language, and other languages have words that have migrated to English, like "Tao" and "wanderlust".

jeremysmyth··on Your Life Is Tetris. Stop Playing It Like Chess
Neither Tetris nor Chess, but Dwarf Fortress.

http://www.pcgamer.com/into-the-deep-its-time-to-learn-how-t...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/24/magazine/the-brilliance-of...

jeremysmyth··on Request For Research: Basic Income
...given a guaranteed, fixed reward no matter how much or how little you work for it, disincentivizes work...I just think that socialism and communism (which basic income basically is...)

Wrong. Basic income lifts the floor. It does not concern itself with the ceiling. Calling it communism is utterly wrong and completely missing the point.

jeremysmyth··on The height limit of a siphon
No, unless the water had to rise 10m from your bathtub before descending. If it only had to rise enough to climb through a window before descending to your yard, then that is not enough to produce the problem in the article.

The problem described is that water cannot be lifted up more than 10m (due to air pressure pushing on the bath side not exceeding the weight of 10m of water in the hosepipe), not pulled down on the far side.

jeremysmyth··on The clock is ticking for Dropbox, valued at $10B more than a year ago
That's a different article from 8 months ago.
jeremysmyth··on The clock is ticking for Dropbox, valued at $10B more than a year ago
The title as I write this is "The clock is ticking for Dropbox, valued at $10B more than a year ago". This title is not that used in the article, nor is it a meaning I can grasp from the article.

Nowhere is it suggested that Dropbox will fail, merely that it is overvalued for its current (and expected) business model, and that the price demonstrates "declining investor confidence".

jeremysmyth··on What subversive thing will be mainstream tomorrow?
I think the premise is mistaken, and the so is the meaning taken from David Bowie's comment (that if he'd started in 2000 he'd not have entered the music business because it was no longer subversive).

David Bowie started making music in the early-mid 60s, which was the era of doo-wop, sha-la-la, Louie Louie, and other popular but mainstream (and not even slightly subversive) music. It so happens that the 60s also gave us the Rolling Stones, Jimi Hendrix, the Beatles, Yes, Genesis, and so on, but it's so easy to take what we like from that era and remember only that.

The era of the 2000s that Bowie says is not subversive also gave us innovation in music and other art. The same thing can be said even of this year. Music might have been a dominant means of novel creative expression in the 60s (although television was in a massive ascendancy, and the Beat poets and investigative journalism were also hugely influential in other areas), but it was no more subversive then than it is today when you consider NiN, Skrillex, and the constant innovation in indie rock and EDM.

The reason the Internet might have been considered "subversive" by this article in the 2000s (and music less so) is that it was on the boundary between innovation and mainstream, as was Bowie's brand of music in the 60s and 70s. It's nothing to do with authority and everything to do with a new generation creating something without heeding the status quo, without sticking within the established norms.

This, if anything, is what the article describes. Not subversion, but innovation beyond the established norms. When someone in their late teens or early twenties starts creating, they often do so by solving problems in new ways that are not based on existing solutions or patterns, and sometimes that act of creation from relative ignorance creates entirely new norms.

Applying that thought to now: The Internet is now mainstream, but the innovation that has not yet become mainstream is that which is controversial, that which laws and regulations have not yet caught up with. Social media and social content platforms (Instagram, Youtube, Facebook, Twitter) started in an era where they didn't have to deal with trolls until they arrived, which meant they could do the fun stuff first and then raise the bar as the bad parts of society (griefers, regulations, nannying) caught up. A new platform in the same space has to reach that bar to get started. Topics that are currently in that space between innovation and mainstream acceptance (hence regulation and nannying) might include privacy/encryption, P2P, geographical presence sharing and decoupling, piracy, gender/sexuality issues, drug taking and distribution, or any of a number of other things that create tension due to being innovated faster than the status quo can keep up.

Some of those things look "subversive" in the classical sense, but in reality it's technology moving at the leading edge of society and society catching up, rather than anything to do with authority.

← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →