HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jernfrost

3,726 karma · joined July 23, 2012

submissionscomments
jernfrost··on Ikea founder leaves fortune to no one, structures it to ensure it lasts forever
As a Norwegian I keep getting surprised by things I learn about Sweden. Sweden seems to have been a lot more socialist than Norway. In some respect might still be.

The housing system in Sweden sound more socialist than what we got in Norway today, judging from how a Swedish friend has explained it to me.

However welfare benefits seems more generous in Norway. How sick people are dealt with in Sweden seems harsher. No pay the first days out of work, and maximum days sick decided by the government for different ailments etc.

jernfrost··on Ask HN: What's the most underrated programming language?
Probably not underrated but not very well known. I’d say Julia as it easily one of the best script languages.

But I’ve also wondered why D is not more widely used as it is a much nicer version of C++ and integrates fairly well with it.

Also a bit odd that OCaml and SML isn’t more widely used

jernfrost··on Why Create a New Unix Shell?
Interesting seeing so many fish fans. I absolutely love fish. It makes my everyday shell usage so much nicer. But it seems like a totally unknown shell to most people. I never see anybody else use it at any job I've had.

I did use fish a bit as a script language, but I decided for anything of any size I much prefer Julia. For typical file system navigation, fish is better, but Julia is actually pretty decent as a shell, despite being a real language. So writing shell scripts in it is pretty nice.

In the beginning I wrote separate programs executed from fish shell. But now I just fire up Julia as a shell and run functions directly there interactively.

jernfrost··on Why Create a New Unix Shell?
I essentially solved these problems with fish shell and Julia programming language.

For all sorts of interactive stuff I use fish, because it works the way you want for the most common tasks. I can use it to really quickly match and get back previous statements or do a completion.

Also much easier to configure and grok than bash, because it has saner syntax and is a simpler shell language.

However when writing shell scripts I use a real language like Julia. It integrates very well with the shell world so I don't find it problematic to do this. It is very easy to read output from processes and pipe stuff. Much nicer than say Python or Ruby.

You got built in syntax to deal with shell stuff, but then didn't make it crazy so you end up with a mess like perl. Julia is actually a very clean and nice language. Which also happens to blistering fast and have LISP style macros.

jernfrost··on Plunging costs make solar, wind and battery storage cheaper than coal
Good point about regulation. I am from Norway but have lived in the US. My impression is that regulation and bureachracy tends to be overly complicated in the US, while usually much simpler in Norway.

This happens despite Norwegians generally being positive to government and regulations while Americans seem knee-jerk anti anything government.

To get simple and good regulation I think you need an effective government and a belief in government. In Norway you can enact large and broad reforms and regulations, while in the US everything seems peacemeal.

Take welfare or healthcare. The US has a huge patchwork of small programs and minor regulations. This is due in part because of a reluctance towards broad but simple government programs like single payer.

A government can set standards for data exchange and bills e.g. which is why prescription can be sent from my doctor electronically to all pharmacies in Norway.

jernfrost··on Elon Musk Is Selling Flamethrowers
Refreshing with a CEO that doesn't take himself too serious. I can imagine most CEOs would be terrified of doing something this silly, and promoting it in such a nerdy and silly way.

I like how his marketing is basically about appealing to the inner geek or man, who is really just a big boy who want bigger and more expensive toys.

Too many ads are essentially focused on fashionistas, people who want to be trendy or whatever. Flamethrowers in contrasts isn't trendy in any meaningful way. It is just a fun thing.

In a way everything that Musk does is really about making the stuff geeks dreamed of when they were kids. I spent considerable time marveling at space-stations and spacecraft in illustrated science magazines as a child. Beyond 2000 I fancied myself as a space tourist.

Of course none of that ever came to past, but now Musk is bringing back the childhood dreams.

In many ways it makes me realize how important literature and dreaming is. Science fiction literature might seem like time waste, but it is the kind of stuff that has helped inspire people like Elon Musk as a child and make him dream of a brighter future. Without dreaming we can't start to push the envelope.

For a long time I sort of imagined that dreamers and doers could not be the same person. But Elon Musk demonstrates you can both dream and be a talented guy who gets stuff done.

jernfrost··on American Illusions and Korean Realities: Preventing Conflict on Korean Peninsula
Mirrors my sentiment except written more elegantly. Although I spelled it out more clearly that a nuclearly armed north korea is something we simple have to learn to live with.

https://medium.com/p/ebf86a16ebee?source=linkShare-c2fa2c34f...

jernfrost··on SpaceX can't test fire its Falcon Heavy rocket due to the government shutdown
Clanan, to my knowledge this is ALL Trump and the republican's fault. Until 3 weeks ago they could have passed anything they wanted. It is just because they wasted time and Trump sabotaged everything the republicans came up with that so much time passed that they reached a stage where a 60 senate vote was needed.

You can't blame this on democrats when republicans could have handled this exclusively themselves and had ample time to do so.

This is simply a reflection of the chaos that is the Trump administration.

It is ironic to think of how I told Trump voters before the election, that if you vote on that man you will get noting but grid lock politics, because he is not a uniter. He is not a man who seeks cooperation and common ground.

I got laughed at for this, with Trump supporters telling me they didn't need democrats for anything because they controlled both houses.

I guess it is my turn to laugh then. I great irony that they manage to get themselves into this mess. The democrats didn't even have to lift a finger.

jernfrost··on SpaceX can't test fire its Falcon Heavy rocket due to the government shutdown
In my native Norway, we let the public sector and private sector compete to perform public services. I can't say that I've ever seen that the private sector has a clear advantage, otherwise they would already have taken over running everything.

In fact I think I know of far more cases of private companies doing considerably worse job than what the public sector did.

My city recently switched to a private company for garbage collection e.g. It was an absolutely horrible mess. My home town had a care home for mentally ill people, that got taken over by a private company. They promised to run it cheaper than the government. Except they totally messed up everything. They lost a lot of talented people, who quit due to their poor management. Then they demanded to be paid more than the public solution had charged to do the same job.

So not only were they worse, they were also more expensive. Sure these are just anecdotes. But it puts a hole in the claim that the private sector is ALWAYS better. To disprove the notion of always you only need a single counter example.

I am not against private companies. Just let them compete on equal terms and prove that they can do the job better. Unfortunately our conservative government is often so ideologically tied to the idea of private always being better than they push for private sector solutions even when a company is not able to demonstrate that they do a better job.

In fact almost every case I've seen where a private company does the job cheaper, it is because they give their employees worse conditions and salaries, not because of smarter organization and management.

jernfrost··on SpaceX can't test fire its Falcon Heavy rocket due to the government shutdown
chisleu I've contemplated this as well. I don't really believe in big political unions. However there are major practical problems dissolving a union which needs to be addressed, which people who favor dissolving a union seldom address.

It is very hard to have open borders between states if there is no federal authority. It is also hard for a state to run their own economic policy without their own currency and central bank.

Already American states struggle with running different welfare policies. You see how red states e.g. a freeloading on blue state welfare programs, by dumping their poor people in blue states and enticing companies created in innovative states like Calefornia by luring them with low taxes.

I personally think it would be nice if we could have a wide selection of countries and states following completely different policies. It is good with experimentation and trying new things. In practice however this is difficult, as somebody can just freeload on everybody elses work by creating a tax paradise.

jernfrost··on 2017 Homicide Rates in Latin America and the Carribean
It is like that in almost all countries though. Most countries have towns or cities with much higher than average rate. That is natural. Except e.g. the most violent city in Sweden has the same rate as the average in the US
jernfrost··on 2017 Homicide Rates in Latin America and the Carribean
5 in the US, in my home country Norway it is 0.5 elsewhere in Europe it is around 1 I think.
jernfrost··on What It Felt Like in Hawaii When Warning of an In-Bound Missile Arrived
Must be a terrible thing, if anything good can come out of this I hope it alerts people to the horrors of nuclear war. I am puzzled by why we speak so much about global warming but almost nobody talks about nuclear war.

Global warming is not remotely as dangerous as nuclear war. Sure it will make crops fails some places, cause water shortage for some millions, force people to move off the coast etc. But it will not kill billions of people. Nuclear war could do that.

As long as the US and Russia stockpile huge quantities of nuclear weapons the whole world is in jeopardy. The number of times nuclear war has almost gotten triggered due to mistakes like this one in Hawaii is scary to think of.

How many human errors or hardware/software failures need to happen before one day, an actual launch of nuclear missiles happen by default?

These weapons are far too dangerous to stockpile in such huge quantities. There should be a push to reduce the stockpile to something like 20-30 missiles.

It isn't hard to imagine a president in the style of Donald Trump, acting irrational and making a rash and stupid mistake which puts the world on fire.

jernfrost··on Red Dawn in Lapland
I got to agree with brabel. The Ukranian invasion did not come out of the blue. If you think that, then you simply have not paid attention to politics and history.

Crimea was Russian originally not Ukrainian. Of course they stole it from somebody else before that.

The Ukraine has a long history with Russia, and when the Soviet Union split up the west agreed to not try to get the Ukraine into NATO, EU or other western organizations. Russia sees the Ukraine as a buffer state and don't want the west on their doorstep.

The west broke all those promises it had given Russia. Naturally they are pissed from feeling ignored. Russia is a bit childish, but it is simple. They just want to feel respected. That is all we got to give them. When they don't feel respected. They start acting like dicks. Sure it is not fair or warranted, but we could totally avoided this if we had been smarter.

jernfrost··on Red Dawn in Lapland
I think you overestimate the Russians grossly. They screwed up in countless wars since then against small nations. They couldn't take out Czeczenia. They failed in Afghanistan. Why should they succeed in Finland.

Russia is capable of dealing with long drawn out battles on home turf. They have not displayed that great ability to invade. To be real, neither has really the US either.

You can't underestimate an opponent fighting on home turf for their own independence against an opponent, where the soldiers don't really see the reason why they are invading in the first place.

Also remember for whatever tech or equipment the Russians have. They have really shitty democratic traditions. They don't let their men work independently. History has shown again and again that top heavy armies are ineffective.

It is how Israel beat 3x bigger Arab armies, even when the Arabs had better tech.

jernfrost··on Red Dawn in Lapland
I would have done the same if it was about national survival. Nobody was coming to Finland's aid. They had run out of options. Nazi Germany was the last option.

Not exactly first or last time this has happened. Vietnam had been promised independence from the US after WWII, and tried to align with the US. When they US, renegaded on their promise and let France take Vietnam back, those fighting for Vietnamese independence ran out of options, and eventually allied with their last option, the Soviets.

Same with the founding of Israel. the UK and the US refused to take in jewish refugees from Nazi Germany. It left jews with the shitty option of declaring the state of Israel for their own survival.

People want to survive so they pick the options they have even if they aren't great. Then they get to listen to people from big countries moralize and criticize for the rest of their existence.

Okay, that last part was kind of exaggerated ;-)

jernfrost··on Why the U.S. Spends So Much More Than Other Nations on Health Care
They are more regulated. More use of max prices, more standarization. US hospitals can charge whatever they want and hide it.
jernfrost··on Why the U.S. Spends So Much More Than Other Nations on Health Care
Part of the reason it is more expensive in the US is because medical school is very costly in the US. This increases the financial risk of those aquiring a medical degree. Higher risks usually demands higher profits in the market.

Hence free university education could be a factor in reducing US health care costs.

Fundamentally you see how the free market approach to everything drives up costs everywhere.

Or more specifically drives up costs in industries/services which don’t naturally have functioning markets.

Free market approaches to health care found in Europe or Asia that works tend to be strongly regulated. E.g. max prices for procedures

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
Actually I forgot the perhaps most crucial point. Very few people are in unions who work as software developers. So it doesn't really make logical sense to make conclusions about software developer salaries based on unionization rate in the rest of the country.

Engineers and software developers are if anything members of what could be more called trade groups. These groups don't negotiate or push for salaries on behalf of members, nor do they do things like organize strikes.

To test you hypothesis I think you have to look at several countries in Europe at similar GDP number and compare salaries. Then you'd have to compare between those of different GDP numbers and see whether GDP or unionization rate correlates most with salaries.

I got to point out however that such a task is momentously difficult, because differences in how things are recorded and rated. As an example I just remembered several other factors in addition to the previous mention that I forgot.

1) The salary quoted in Norway, is the money workers get after special income tax is deducted by the employer. This is about 14%. So a 65k salary is more like 75k if you consider this tax.

2) High living expenses in Norway is heavily influenced by a very high VAT tax of 25%.

Sure that doesn't mean the money is suddenly in your pocket but it means it doesn't just disappear. It goes to cover extensive welfare services, which e.g. Americans would have to pay for out of pocket.

In essence it is hard to compare very high tax regimes with extensive welfare benefits to one with low taxes and few benefits.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
The real cost of housing is distorted though when house prices keep going up. In many cases, if you take into account the value increase of housing, it is actually opposite of what you claim. People don't spend anything on housing, because they get back whatever they put pay for the house in terms of value increase of the property.

I think it would be more fair to look at, how much does it cost to build a house, and divide that cost on the time it may be used. We should not really add the price of property to the equation.

If one does this I will bet that consumer goods make up a much bigger part of the economy than you think.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
Agree there is this illusion that the market is there to figure out what you want and deliver your needs efficiently at a low price and high quality.

Instead it is more like the producers create their own demand by emotional manipulation of the consumers.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
I liked a lot your analogy with altruism. Wish I had thought of that one myself ;-)

I probably disagree with the notion that people actively seek to create bullshit work for themselves, initially. I think a lot of bullshit jobs is something people realize they are doing after the fact when it is hard to change careers or find another job. They then engage in a sort of cover up operation to avoid losing that bullshit job.

Of course there are a lot of bullshit jobs which exist due to regulations and red tape. People might seek a lot of bullshit jobs simply because they have high status and pay. E.g. it is well paid to be a lawyer and high status, despite the fact that a lot of lawyer work, is just bullshit.

I also think everybody could have been employed despite removing bullshit jobs, it is just that people would simply need to work a lot fewer hours. This assumes of course a gradual change. If we removed all bullshit jobs tomorrow, there would for structural reasons be a lot of people who can't change to other activities easily.

I also think that a lot of bullshit work, isn't 100% bullshit. There are perhaps 10 hours worth of work to be done each week. However workers have no incentive to expose that, because otherwise they could not excuse the pay they get. Also people are proud and don't want to look like they are lazy or working less than others. So in a sense people end up doing bullshit to simply not look worse.

So part of the solution is also to stop valuing work so dam high. We have a tendency to glorify work. I personally think people would end up doing useful things for the most part if given the choice. People are unnecessarily concerned with others being lazy.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
Agree, I just didn't want to put all the blame on American workers for the low unionization rate. I think they have much harder job than their peers in Norway and Germany.

Forming a union is never easy, even in Norway.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
I think it is a bit hard to compare the salaries, because Norwegian currency is presently at a historical low. When I compared at earlier years salary of me and my friends in the software industry was more similar to the US.

Also I am in doubt about how many Norwegians report to these web pages. It would be more accurate to look at statistics gathered by NITO among its members.

One aspect you have to consider with respect to the US and Europe in general is that Europeans work a lot fewer hours. A lot of difference between US and European software developer salaries could simply be down to difference in hours worked.

I make about $97 000 at current exchange as a software developer in Norway. But I work only 37.5 hours per week. I got 5 weeks vacation per year. In addition to a lot more public holidays than in the US. I haven't worked overtime in over 10 years. While judging from accounts from Europeans working in the US, it is quite normal with very long work weeks and overtime.

Oslo living expenses will look extra high because we are most likely at at the top of a property bubble. We never had a downturn in 2008 for the housing market.

Also living expenses in Norway is usually hard to compare with other countries since food prices and recently housing costs are quite high. However health care, education, child care etc is quite cheap. Many consumer goods are also relatively cheap. E.g. food is much cheaper in Spain than in Norway but buying a TV is cheaper in Norway.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
Thans for the suggestions. I have contemplated this as well. It always puzzled me at work as a software developer how we had more sales people than developers. It just seems wrong that we have more people hired to sell the software than make it. Then you got all the guys doing marketing in addition and the ones managing all these people. You end up with a lot of stuff surrounding the core value creation.

A lot of this is really just need because we live in a free market economy where we need to sell stuff to people. We can't just give it to them if they need it. OTOH how would be allocated resources effectively if we did not have the market.

The soviet approach seems to have been a big failure. Although I suppose wit the internet, computer, crypto currencies etc, there might be other ways of organizing labour and allocating resources.

At least I wish people would acknowledge something is fundamentally wrong with how we organize society today. Unless we do it is hard to pour resources into finding alternative ways of doing things.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
You have to consider the wealth of respective countries and cities. E.g. my native Norway which is more similar to the US in GDP per capita has developer salaries closer to the US.

Not only is Germany poorer than the US, but Berlin is among the poorer cities in Germany. Hence I don't think it says much about the results of unions.

Norway has equally strong unions as Germany and close to 80% of Norwegian workers are unionized.

I am pretty sure that if you compared to developer salaries in a richer country such as Switzerland you would also find much higher software developer salaries.

And then there are national peculiarities. E.g. more developers in Germany than in many other European countries might be associated with manufacturing industry which doesn't necessarily value software developers as high as a more startup like scene.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
My native Norway is much like Germany with respect to unions and speaking with my American side of the family, and following American news I get the strong impression that laws protecting people's right to unionize are VERY WEAK in the US.

They are also designed in ways which makes people end up resenting unions. I register a lot of union hatred in the US which simply doesn't exist in Norway. Part of the reason seems to be from how unions function in the US.

You are either a union shop or you are not. People are forced to join the union or they are forced to not join it. People don't like being made to do things. In Norway it has always been free choice to join a union. There is no such thing as a "union shop".

Unions in the US also don't seem to hold much power except in its ability to sabotage the company, and so that seems to be what they do. In Germany and Norway unions are more like partners with management. They are on the company boards. They can't be ignored as easily as in the US. To be heard in the US, it seems like unions have to cause trouble. I think this creates a very unhealthy union environment and creates a bad reputation for unions.

Unions in Norway form hierarchies so that you huge national unions which together with representatives for employers negotiate work life in Norway on regular basis.

The other part I think is that Norway and Germany has quite extensive welfare systems, so unions are not as actively protecting particular jobs as they are trying to protect people. Losing your job in Norway or Germany is not the same catastrophe as in the US. So people are more accepting towards it. Instead what people want to see is things like job training and aid to help you get a new job.

jernfrost··on Why hasn't economic progress lowered work hours more? (2016) [video]
Anthropologists David Graeber, has addressed this and offered the explanation with the observation that we as a society produce what he calls bullshit jobs. Almost 40% of Brits in a surveyed acknowledged that their job wasn't needed.

People believing in effective markets would of course protest and claim such enormous inefficiency can't possibly exist. Somebody will simply start a company without bullshit jobs.

However I think there is a good explanation why this doesn't happen: https://medium.com/@Jernfrost/why-do-bullshit-jobs-exist-4f5...

In short, in any complex organization bullshit work will start accruing and there is no good mechanism to week out such jobs, because the people doing those jobs will have zero incentive to tell their managers that their job in pointless and not needed.

I've tried researching this on reddit and seen that a lot of work people do could have been automated. The people doing those jobs also frequently see this. However they have no economic incentive to do so.

This has lead me to contemplate that guaranteed minimum income has merits, because it would remove the disincentive to make yourself redundant, to some extent. Of course not in the case where your bullshit jobs is very highly paid, which is frequently the case.

jernfrost··on Groups funded by the Koch brothers are campaigning against municipal broadband
No, the most sucessful train company in Europe, the swiss doesn’t. And those who have go e for separate companies have just bad experience with it. This separation is mostly ideologially driven with no proven benefits. Right wing parties will push through anything their economic text books say is smart regardless of pracrical results and experiences.
jernfrost··on Groups funded by the Koch brothers are campaigning against municipal broadband
I am all for municapal internet in the US, but really it is a bandaid. The fundamental problem is how competition is regulated in the US. Most European countries I know of did not achieve high speed internet by making it municpal. Rather we did it by forcing competition. Cell phone and broadband infrastructure owners in Europe typicall have to let competition offer services on their hardware. Same with power. Here in Norway companies owning the power cables going into my house are not allowed to exclude competitors from using their lines to send power to me.

You, need struct regulation of natural monpolies and that is what the US lacks. That is why Americans ironically end up with government solutions.

See the same with so many things. Government mandated minimum eages because unions are so weak. In Nordic countries, Germany etc there has never been a need for go ernment to provide this as unions have solved the problem with exploitative wages.

Ironically by fighting government regulation you just end up with more government.

← PreviousPage 7 of 24Next →