HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jewbacca

1,431 karma · joined May 18, 2010

submissionscomments
jewbacca··on Flexbox Froggy: A game for learning CSS flexbox
Doesn't that redundancy kinda suggest that there are two orthogonal things going on here?

ie,

    block | inline
      ---------
    flex  | inline-flex
What could you label the axes here? Or is this not a valid way to frame the relationship between these things?
jewbacca··on Montana Standard newspaper plans to retroactively unmask anonymous commenters
In the first 2 pages of your HN commenting history, I can find half a dozen comments that, tied to your real identity, and given a sufficient amount of the right flavor of public attention, could be blown up to ruin your life.

Not that I necessarily think these comments are so wrong that you would remotely deserve such an outcome for thinking or saying them, but that's the point: if it came down to it, that wouldn't be my judgement to make. And would you have unreservedly said all the things you have, if they were going to be permanently and publicly tied to your real identity?

In fact, after a few more pages of your history, applied to some leet cyberstalking skills, I know your real identity and where you work and live. How would you feel about being outed, even over such nominally innocuous things?

I would never do that, because it would be wrong.

You commented with the assumption of a certain degree of anonymity. So did the people you're saying there would be nothing wrong with stripping a similar anonymity from.

jewbacca··on Paris Shootings and Explosions Kill Over 100, Police Say
I know this is a piddlingly minor thing, but I'm seeing it propagated everywhere, and in the spirit of having an informative HN thread:

'Eagles of Death Metal' is not a death metal band.

What they do play is eclectic and hard to label as anything more specific than "rock", but doesn't fit even a very inclusive definition of metal. See: https://www.youtube.com/user/EaglesDeathMetalVEVO/videos

jewbacca··on State of emergency declared across France after Paris shootings and explosions
Top comments in the primary Reddit thread at the time of this post (using 'top' sorting): https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/3sphue/shootings...

1. Updated chronology of news with source links

2. Practically important publicization of #porteouverte effort

3. Updated chronology of news as experienced by Parisian local

4. First-person account of person who was present at theatre shooting

5. ... content-light junk starts. More than halfway down the page.

There's interesting commentary in this HN thread that I'm not seeing upvoted to visibility on Reddit, so it is valuable. But there is a ton of uniquely valuable stuff on the Reddit thread, and that is consistently the case in these live serious news situations.

----

And 10 minutes after I posted this, the top comment on this very HN thread and all its replies are all empty sentiment. "vive la france", "hearts go out", "be safe", etc.

jewbacca··on Resigning from the Haskell Platform
Withholding a tl;dr until I've read enough to understand it myself, here is where I'll be looking to generate a quick impression:

https://www.reddit.com/r/haskell/search?q=foldable+traversab...

https://wiki.haskell.org/Foldable_Traversable_In_Prelude

jewbacca··on Nuclear Forensics Shows Nazis Were Nowhere Near Making Atomic Bomb
My favourite account of the German nuclear programs (note: using the plural here is deliberate, and significant) is "Hitler's Uranium Club: The Secret Recordings at Farm Hall" (http://www.amazon.com/Hitlers-Uranium-Club-Secret-Recordings...), by physicist Jeremy Bernstein.

The centrepiece is a curated set of transcripts from secret recordings of the candid conversations of a group of German scientists detained together for months after the war (specifically for the purpose of surveilling such conversations).

Some vaguely YC-ish lessons on how their failure to produce could be attributed in many ways to seemingly mundane organizational structures that were debatably inherent to Nazi German society and internal politics.

Also some borderline pornographic payoff when they find out about Hiroshima. At the time, they were convinced they were 10 years ahead of anyone else, and were being detained as a prelude to being showered with honours and put in place to bring American and British science into the modern age. Then they set about convincing themselves they failed on purpose for moral reasons.

jewbacca··on Google Nexus 5x and 6P
1. The Nexus line is supposed to be something like Google's Android reference device, and implements the minimum common set of features -- up-to-date computing hardware and screen, reasonable-resolution cameras, standard set of sensors (GPS, acceleration, etc.). An SD card slot doesn't really add any technical possibilities.

2. Google probably wants to push the idea that any storage beyond local apps should be to the cloud.

(which is comically unviable in Canada, where you're paying $25-50 per 1 GB of mobile data)

---

A year ago, I got a Nexus 5 after a long search for a replacement for my stalwart iPhone 3GS. The lack of SD card was the primary sticking point, and caused me days of choice-agony. In the end, price and "cleanliness" (stock android, lack of shitware, doesn't fight software customization very hard) won out.

jewbacca··on Apple TV Markup Language
The "About TVML" page is far less compelling. Barely better than noise, in the context of a link on the HN front page, without a specific and pre-existing interest in the topic. If OP had linked to that, I personally wouldn't have read any further.

The (arbitrary) template page linked to has visualizations and code samples. Much better.

jewbacca··on Tesla unveils new car-charging robo-snake
Not strictly on-topic or generally interesting, but for any of us who've read Neal Stephenson's new novel 'Seveneves', this reveal has a thin extra layer of interestingness:

In that book, a character who is an obvious analogue for Elon Musk sponsors the development of a variety of asteroid mining robots, including a type that superficially resembles this thing. 'Siwis' are, unlike this real thing, modular, semi-autonomous, self-propelling, and meant for operating in zero-gravity.

But still... snake robot sponsored by Elon Musk, out of nowhere.

jewbacca··on [dead]
On Android:

You can install ABP at a system level (https://adblockplus.org/android-install) or uBlock as a Firefox extension (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/android/addon/ublock-origin),

You can install Ghostery as a standalone browser (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ghostery.a...) or as a Firefox extension (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/android/addon/ghostery/)

----

Embedded videos:

You can usually get them working with some whitelisting (which can be temporary or permanent). Though I personally often welcome the video blocking as a feature and impulse control tool (anecdotally, it seems to mostly break social media click-farming bullshit).

jewbacca··on Economic projections inadvertently posted to the public
Looks like something called EViews:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EViews

http://www.eviews.com/online_help/helpintro.html#page/EViews...

ftp://ftp.rau.am/EViews%20Enterprise%20Edition%207.0.0.1/Example%20Files/Sample%20Programs/model/taylor1.prg

jewbacca··on Why I am pro-GPL
Free as in Freedom: Richard Stallman's Crusade for Free Software

Chapter 1

For Want of a Printer

http://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch01.html

jewbacca··on Tolkien and the Fairy Story (1963)
This seems to be missing large sections of text, beginning immediately. The full text does not seem to be available for free to the public on the surface web. Bummer.
jewbacca··on Let's talk content. AMA
Here is a similarly-aligned sentiment from the OP thread here, beautifully-stated by somebody with potentially more credibility on the subject (let's be honest here) than me (though do note that she rightly does not claim to be speaking for anybody but herself):

----

> I have been a redditor for a very long time, and I've been part of a range of kinds of communities that vary fairly significantly.

> I am also a female who was raped, and this is something I have been opened about talking fairly frequently on reddit.

> I disagree with the ban of the aforementioned sub, because I feel that it sets a precedent depending on what the society deems appropriate to think about, and what it does not.

> Please note, that I can not and do not pretend to speak for any woman who was raped besides myself.

> What I am concerned with is this distinct drawing of a line between the people who own the site, and the people who create the content on the site. Reddit appealed to me because it was the closest thing to a speaking democracy I could find in my entire existence, utilizing technology in a way that is almost impossible to recreate across large populations of people otherwise.

> This sequence of events marks this as a departure from that construct. From today onwards, I know that I am not seeing clusters of people with every aspect of their humanity shown, as ugly as it may be sometimes. I feel that it is not the subreddit that causes subs like /r/rapingwomen to exist, but this stems from a larger cultural problem. Hiding it or sweeping it under a rug from the masses is not what solves the problem; I have already lived under those rules and I have seen them to be ineffective at best and traumatizing / mentally warping at worst.

> People's minds should not be ruled over by the minds of other people, and that is what I feel this has become. Internet content is thought content, idea content. It is not the act of violence - these are two very separate things. You can construct a society that appears to value and cherish women's rights in the highest regard, and yet the truth can be the furthest thing from it.

> I really would hope that you would reconsider your position. To take away the right of being able to know with certainty that one can speak freely without fear, I don't have many words to offer that fully express my sadness at that.

> The problem is not the banning of specifics. The problem is how it affects how people reason afterwards about their expectations of the site and their interactions with others. It sets up new social constructs and new social rules, and will alter things significantly, even fractions of things you would not expect. It is like a butterfly effect across the mind, to believe you can speak freely, and to have that taken away.

-- /u/abcabcdeabc, responding directly to Steve Huffman

https://np.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/3djjxw/lets_t...

jewbacca··on Let's talk content. AMA
For very many habitual users of Reddit, the way in which it is probably most valuable is as the canonical general discussion forum of the web. An important part of the infrastructure of their perception and interpretation of the world around them, for pretty much any domain beyond the most incommunicably personal.

To read Reddit can be, in a surprisingly real way, like participating in a collective consciousness -- with all the addictive dependence [I say that in a non-judgemental way, not being able to come up with a less negative way to characterize it at the moment] that the type of speculative fiction which imagines such living arrangements usually predicts.

The practical side of this is that, for any given news event, cultural phenomenon, popularly-circulating idea, whatever: for these users it is instinctive to consult the reddit threads on the topic, as a deeply-ingrained part of their process for digesting and interpreting it. That those reddit threads will exist and have an active discussion on any given topic is a given. Even if the local source of a news piece has a forum/thread of its own, it is fundamentally not the same thing.

It's been, in a hazy golden age that may have never actually existed, something close a total function for processing the events of the world, big and small.

One day, there was an event, a dumb internet drama event, but one for which the primary Reddit discussion thread was displaying a count of 20 thousand comments -- but on inspection, every single last one of those was showing up as [deleted]. That was the start of it for most users. Many have fixated on the specific topic of that initial drama as the source of the problem with Reddit, and many others have fixated on this fixation as the source of the problem with Reddit.

But there is a general sense that this is growing, spreading, and mutating, and seems to be cropping up in places that are not strictly predictable.

For example, there are persistent rumours that several of the more popular subreddits for which the news would be directly and explicitly on-topic, are systematically removing discussions about various global trade agreements currently being negotiated. Is it true? Maybe, maybe not, but the trust is broken.

----

The main thing is (the perception that):

Now there is a partial function where before there was a total function. That is disastrous damage in an information processing system.

----

To these users, this is a very profound and frightening piece of damage, having extended a part of their cognition into this machinery that now seems to be failing. Panic sets in, which obviously means wild flailing at anything that pops its head up and can be in any way seen as responsible for the damage.

Hence, the reaction to Ellen Pao (and what would have been the reaction to Steve Huffman here, had he unilaterally taken a more extreme stance than he has here). Especially after she made public statements of purpose that were easily interpretable by these users to the effect of "whatever else might be the source of the damage to your extended cognition, we intend to start deliberately doing some more damage to areas we don't consider important".

----

----

Also important to understanding this:

To the users I'm talking about, the "cognitive value" of Reddit is not entirely about directly being fed opinions to take up as one's own.

Many of these users find great value to being exposed to, they deliberately seek out for their own enrichment: idiocy, malice, counterfactuals, cognitive dissonance, debate (honest and otherwise), the whole range of perceptions and opinions. To them, being exposed to these things is just as much of the value of Reddit as the "good stuff". And that seems to be the aspect of Reddit most strongly and immediately under threat.

Anyone who does not value this kind of experience (which seems to be a very large proportion of the people participating in this conversation at the most visible levels) is going to see any attempt to frame this type of content as valuable in any way as totally incomprehensible, evil, and malicious itself. So this part of things is pretty close to an impossible conversation to have in public.

----

----

(reposting a comment that I've made before, in a thread that was apparently soft-killed on HN)

jewbacca··on Details Emerge About Victoria Taylor’s Dismissal at Reddit
Also important to understanding this:

To the users I'm talking about, the "cognitive value" of Reddit is not entirely about directly being fed opinions to take up as one's own.

Many of these users find great value to being exposed to, they deliberately seek out for their own enrichment: idiocy, malice, counterfactuals, cognitive dissonance, debate (honest and otherwise), the whole range of perceptions and opinions.

To them, being exposed to these things is just as much of the value of Reddit as the "good stuff". And that seems to be the aspect of Reddit most strongly and immediately under threat.

Anyone who does not value this kind of experience (which seems to be a very large proportion of the people participating in this conversation at the most visible levels) is going to see any attempt to frame this type of content as valuable in any way as totally incomprehensible, evil, and malicious itself. So this part of things is pretty close to an impossible conversation to have in public.

jewbacca··on Details Emerge About Victoria Taylor’s Dismissal at Reddit
Fair enough, I appreciate your perspective. Here is an attempt to communicate my own, as someone "closer" to Reddit:

For very many habitual users of Reddit, the way in which it is probably most valuable is as the canonical general discussion forum of the web. An important part of the infrastructure of their perception and interpretation of the world around them, for pretty much any domain beyond the most incommunicably personal.

To read Reddit can be, in a surprisingly real way, like participating in a collective consciousness -- with all the addictive dependence [I say that in a non-judgemental way, not being able to come up with a less negative way to characterize it at the moment] that the type of speculative fiction which imagines such living arrangements usually predicts.

The practical side of this is that, for any given news event, cultural phenomenon, popularly-circulating idea, whatever: for these users it is instinctive to consult the reddit threads on the topic, as a deeply-ingrained part of their process for digesting and interpreting it. That those reddit threads will exist and have an active discussion on any given topic is a given. Even if the local source of a news piece has a forum/thread of its own, it is fundamentally not the same thing.

It's been, in a hazy golden age that may have never actually existed, something close a total function for processing the events of the world, big and small.

One day, there was an event, a dumb internet drama event, but one for which the primary Reddit discussion thread was displaying a count of 20 thousand comments -- but on inspection, every single last one of those was showing up as [deleted]. That was the start of it for most users. Many have fixated on the specific topic of that initial drama as the source of the problem with Reddit, and many others have fixated on this fixation as the source of the problem with Reddit.

But there is a general sense that this is growing, spreading, and mutating, and seems to be cropping up in places that are not strictly predictable.

For example, there are persistent rumours that several of the more popular subreddits for which the news would be directly and explicitly on-topic, are systematically removing discussions about various global trade agreements currently being negotiated. Is it true? Maybe, maybe not, but the trust is broken.

----

The main thing is (the perception that):

Now there is a partial function where before there was a total function. That is disastrous damage in an information processing system.

----

To these users, this is a very profound and frightening piece of damage, having extended a part of their cognition into this machinery that now seems to be failing. Panic sets in, which obviously means wild flailing at anything that pops its head up and can be in any way seen as responsible for the damage.

Hence, the reaction to Ellen Pao. Especially after she made public statements of purpose that were easily interpretable by these users to the effect of "whatever else might be the source of the damage to your extended cognition, we intent to start deliberately doing some more damage to areas we don't consider important".

In the end, I very strongly suspect that the problem is much deeper and probably well beyond any control of the central management. If there were a way to, I would put money down on the prediction that the Reddit crisis, a direct continuation of the exact same crisis that's currently associated with Ellen Pao, will continue.

jewbacca··on Details Emerge About Victoria Taylor’s Dismissal at Reddit
Question: How comfortable are you with well-upvoted and -participated-in discussion threads -- like the one we are participating in here -- suddenly dropping out of visibility on a community you contribute to in a matter of minutes, without explicit explanation and behaving other than how you might expect from the published details of the local ranking algorithm and official moderation policies, as this one has?

Your answer to this question might relate to the "popular" perception of the leader of reddit in the past ~year, whether honestly and solely earned by them or not.

jewbacca··on Yishan Wong comments on "What's the best long con you ever pulled?"
For posterity:

--------

> Here's one.

> In 2006, reddit was sold to Conde Nast. It was soon obvious to many that the sale had been premature, the site was unmanaged and under-resourced under the old-media giant who simply didn't understand it and could never realize its full potential, so the founders and their allies in Y-Combinator (where reddit had been born) hatched an audacious plan to re-extract reddit from the clutches of the 100-year-old media conglomerate.

> Together with Sam Altman, they recruited a young up-and-coming technology manager with social media credentials. Alexis, who was on the interview panel for the new reddit CEO, would reject all other candidates except this one. The manager was to insist as a condition of taking the job that Conde Nast would have to give up significant ownership of the company, first to employees by justifying the need for equity to be able to hire top talent, bringing in Silicon Valley insiders to help run the company. After continuing to grow the company, he would then further dilute Conde Nast's ownership by raising money from a syndicate of Silicon Valley investors led by Sam Altman, now the President of Y-Combinator itself, who in the process would take a seat on the board.

> Once this was done, he and his team would manufacture a series of otherwise-improbable leadership crises, forcing the new board to scramble to find a new CEO, allowing Altman to use his position on the board to advocate for the re-introduction of the old founders, installing them on the board and as CEO, thus returning the company to their control and relegating Conde Nast to a position as minority shareholder.

> JUST KIDDING. There's no way that could happen.

/u/yishan (Yishan Wong, former Reddit CEO)

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the...

--------

> We all had our roles to play.

/u/spez (Steve Huffman, new Reddit CEO)

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the...

--------

> Cool story bro.

> Except I could never have predicted the part where you resigned on the spot :)

> Other than that, child's play for me.

> Thanks for the help. I mean, thanks for your service as CEO.

/u/samaltman (Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator)

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the...

jewbacca··on First Abortion Drone flight a success
Was this story removed? It has more points than several older stories currently visible on the HN front page (and, for that matter, the next 5 pages after that), which, as far as I know [0], means it should be listed on one of those pages. But it's not.

----

[0] http://amix.dk/blog/post/19574

jewbacca··on Atom 1.0
> https://goo.gl/tF6M4C – this goo.gl shortlink has been disabled. It was found to be violating our Terms of Service.

----

For what an isolated anecdote is worth, I originally switched from Textmate to Sublime because I preferred Sublime's default colour scheme. Not for any trivial reason like features or "being in active development".

jewbacca··on Reddit Bans Five Communities In New Anti-Harassment Campaign
> he was never dumb enough to try to police 4chan

This is not true, there was a massive controversy and subsequent schism less than a year ago.

A "folk history" (if you're feeling generous enough to call it that) of the episode here: https://encyclopediadramatica.se/M00t%27s_GamerGate_Sellout

jewbacca··on The Restful CookBook
Ah, I think I understand what you're getting at now, that's a really interesting question.

I can't entirely back this up without probably days of reading RFCs, but my initial gut feeling is that making this distinction, which is not really possible in a truly general way (provided the URI is a syntactically correct HTTP URI), would be exposing internal implementation details in a way that would be conceptually inconsistent with other HTTP response statuses.

eg, how to usefully and consistently make the distinction:

    GET /asfd
    200 OK

    GET /qwer
    4XX We don't have that right now

    GET /zxcv
    4XX That is not even a thing
Keep in mind that the RESTful URI style is not part of the HTTP standard in any way. In HTTP, URIs can be random gibberish, even if they refer to "sibling" resources semantically. "You're on the right path" vs "What are you even talking about" is not an inherent concept in HTTP.

It might make sense in certain circumstances of RESTfully-modelled resource URIs layered on top of HTTP:

    GET /users/asfd
    200 OK

    GET /users/qwer
    4XX We don't have that right now

    GET /blarghs/asdf
    4XX That is not even a thing
But to describe this situation in an HTTP response status would be "mixing layers" and making assumptions in a way that opens a conceptually messy can of worms.

----

Disclaimer: I have no idea what I'm talking about and am not entirely convinced by my own argument. I'm always skeptical of "that's just not how it's done right now"-flavoured arguments, which this doesn't stop smelling like as I attempt to reason about it.

----

As practical matter, the body of the 404 response can describe the situation within the context of the application. And if your application is smart enough (though to do this in the general case is impossible or would require something like strong AI), you can use any of several more specific responses (Gone, Found, etc; depending on the context) if you're willing and capable of inferring a specific intent from the otherwise bad request.

jewbacca··on The Restful CookBook
> 404 should be reserved for URL/route errors.

What dichotomy are you working off of here? It is absolutely a 404. How is this any less applicable to a DELETE request than it would be to a GET request for the same resource? What extra information would this new status status code carry?

----

> 10.4.5 404 Not Found

> The server has not found anything matching the Request-URI. No indication is given of whether the condition is temporary or permanent. The 410 (Gone) status code SHOULD be used if the server knows, through some internally configurable mechanism, that an old resource is permanently unavailable and has no forwarding address. This status code is commonly used when the server does not wish to reveal exactly why the request has been refused, or when no other response is applicable.

http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec10.html#sec10...

jewbacca··on Memes are a myth
It's hard to argue about this without some idea about what the original author considers "real"/"not a myth".

If he considers genes to be "real" in comparison (which I cannot totally infer from this piece of writing; but he does seem to put a lot of stock in the identification of a physical mechanism for projecting the idea of genetics onto, in DNA), there's a pretty straightforward map-vs-territory argument to reduce that (and pretty much everything else) to equivalence.

All of thought and semantics are imperfect metaphors. The question "are memes real" is exactly equivalent to "are genes real" is exactly equivalent to "is math real" is exactly equivalent to "are trees real" is exactly equivalent to "is anything in our understanding of reality real".

Short of a physical "theory of everything", the only description of physical reality that is "real" is the total enumeration of all of physical reality.

jewbacca··on BrowserHack: NetHack ported to the web
This is fucking nuts!

All of the game code is Nethack's original C: https://github.com/coolwanglu/BrowserHack/tree/master/src

Porting is mainly accomplished by defining a windowing system for 'web' (mostly in C), right next to the definitions for 'X11', 'Qt', etc: https://github.com/coolwanglu/BrowserHack/tree/master/win

And compiling through LLVM via Emscripten, resulting in a browser-runnable JS target: https://github.com/coolwanglu/BrowserHack/tree/gh-pages.

Absolutely incredible work all around.

----

That said, fuck tilesets. ASCII graphics master race.

jewbacca··on A Brief History of Graphics [video]
Highly recommended related video by the same person (XboxAhoy / Stuart Brown):

"Doomed: The Embers of Amiga FPS"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv6aJRGpz_A

jewbacca··on China's Man-On-the-Side Attack on GitHub
https://github.com/cn-nytimes/ and https://github.com/greatfire/ host information about and software for circumventing the Chinese government's internet censorship systems -- which, among many other things, blocks access to, eg, Google, and The New York Times.

Apparently they (the Chinese government) are not willing to entirely block Github traffic in the same way (presumably as an important tool for their software industry as well). This DDoS is an attempt to punish Github for not removing this block-circumventing information, and force the inaccessibility of those 2 repos specifically. It is being conducted in such a way that this is readily obvious but plausibly deniable.

jewbacca··on The Rise of the Cryptopticon
Note:

"Cryptopticon" (cf. "Panopticon")

not

"Cryptonomicon" (Neal Stephenson novel)

----

Not that this isn't a valuable and fascinating article (and extremely relevant to anyone who connected with that novel), but noted for other inattentive readers who potentially started into it expecting something else.

jewbacca··on Development of Doom
"Doom and Metal/Rock: A Comprehensive Comparison"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4H3BB2gKKeY

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →