HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jfkebwjsbx

1,123 karma · joined February 12, 2020

submissionscomments
jfkebwjsbx··on Fighter pilot breaks down every button in an F-15 cockpit [video]
You are taking design decisions made in a wildly different context and assuming they were made that way because it fits your UI vision.
jfkebwjsbx··on Fighter pilot breaks down every button in an F-15 cockpit [video]
> Whether it is hidden in 4 level deep menu in a touchscreen or immediately accessible with a toggle switch makes no difference IMO

That is wrong. It makes a huge difference for the overwhelming majority of users.

In addition, you are trying to extrapolate the design choices of

  + an extremely specialized UI,
  + for trained experts,
  + intended to never break,
  + designed decades ago,
  + to be used while in combat,
  + etc.
...just to support your preferences and beliefs in UI design.

You may be right or not, but comparing web pages with cockpits does not make any sense at all.

jfkebwjsbx··on Fighter pilot breaks down every button in an F-15 cockpit [video]
That is such a bad analogy. 104 buttons but it is mostly a single input.

It is like saying a touchscreen is thousands of switches just because it has that many sensor points.

jfkebwjsbx··on Kongregate closed to new games, shutting down forums and chat
Is this an ad? Not only you mention a single engine, you also sell it as super easy.

The reality is that making good games is extremely hard, and has always been.

Unity is not the first game framework, there have been many along the years. Flash being one of them (while not even designed for that originally!).

Some of them are easier, some are more featureful, some have better graphics, some are specialized into a genre etc.

While some genres need almost no code, others are full of pages of tricky game logic. And that is without counting into account the engine code.

Further, Unity had nothing to do with Steam being flooded. The actual reason is that

  1- Valve pivoted into being a distribution platform,
  2- they stopped curating what goes in,
  3- gaming exploded and became way more mainstream (along with streaming, e-sports and programming, all which helped a lot), and
  4- people started making money selling courses, degrees and content on how to make games.
jfkebwjsbx··on How Did Vim Become So Popular?
Sorry but as someone that has done both C# in Visual Studio and embedded development in vim/gdb/UNIX, your claims do not hold up...

> have no comparable analogue in traditional text-focused, non-IDE editors.

The same features have been there in TUI editors for many, many years. There is nothing visual about the backend that handles those queries.

Whether the interface is easier to use or not is a different matter, but the features have been there for decades.

> Not to mention visual debuggers

Well, yes, visual debuggers are better with a GUI, that is obvious.

> not to mention remote debugging!

Remote debugging is very common. What you are thinking of is visual ones.

> However, objective tests show that even highly skilled users aren't as fast at completing high-level tasks as mouse-users.

Citation needed.

Blender, for instance, is praised by artists for its hard modeling productivity thanks to all the shortcuts.

A few years ago when I worked in VS, I used all kinds of shortcuts. It does not matter that the tool has a GUI or not to make the keyboard useful. It is orthogonal.

> took days or weeks to solve the same problem! Days!

That is just nonsense. There is no way one takes days/weeks to "debug" something that takes 30 minutes in another general purpose language.

Either the task could be trivially solved using the .NET standard library and not the others (which makes it incomparable), or they picked up participants with no clue in the other languages.

The debugger or the GUI/TUI distinctions have nothing to do with that. A visual debugger is most useful when dealing with very big code bases that you did not write yourself. For a programming puzzle that fits in 100 lines, a visual debugger is irrelevant unless you are new to programming.

jfkebwjsbx··on How Did Vim Become So Popular?
An IT degree is not about writing code. Perhaps you are referring to CS.
jfkebwjsbx··on The x86 Advanced Matrix Extension
> apparently, for certain Intel processors

Not certain Intel processors: all of them. The CPU will reduce its clocks, reducing its overall performance.

Using AVX256 or AVX512 is easily a net negative on performance, depending on the software, input data and other processes running in the system.

Unless you are certain you have enough data to offset the downclock, don't use them.

jfkebwjsbx··on Ampere’s Product List: 80 Cores, up to 3.3 GHz at 250 W; 128 Core in Q4
The context of the discussion is literally ARM scaling up to desktop performance.

The person you replied to said:

> There is no proof that these outperform traditional CPUs at all.

To which you replied talking about embedded market share and supercomputer which have nothing to do with that.

Since now you mention Apple and MacBooks, which haven't been even mentioned, I think you are answering to the wrong thread/post.

jfkebwjsbx··on The x86 Advanced Matrix Extension
You are 100% right, it is AVX1 I was thinking about (which nowadays I am not sure if that has downclock or not either).
jfkebwjsbx··on Ampere’s Product List: 80 Cores, up to 3.3 GHz at 250 W; 128 Core in Q4
I always frame it this way: if there were a 40% price/perf improvement, why is not everyone (including AWS!) using ARM clouds?
jfkebwjsbx··on Firefox 78
I don't like the constant UI changes, the ugly configuration menus, the new bar and the bundling of stuff nobody asked for like Pocket.
jfkebwjsbx··on Ampere’s Product List: 80 Cores, up to 3.3 GHz at 250 W; 128 Core in Q4
Yes, you are missing something.

Two threads reading and writing to the same memory area do not necessarily give problems. In fact, many software is built to exploit several facts about how memory accesses work with respect each other.

ARM processors give very few guarantees, so code has to workaround that.

jfkebwjsbx··on Ampere’s Product List: 80 Cores, up to 3.3 GHz at 250 W; 128 Core in Q4
Amazon marketing claims are not something you should trust.
jfkebwjsbx··on Ampere’s Product List: 80 Cores, up to 3.3 GHz at 250 W; 128 Core in Q4
Phones are not built for performance, which is what was asked about.

As for supercomputers, >90% of them are Intel/AMD.

jfkebwjsbx··on The End of the Redis Adventure
It started as a memcached with persistence to disk for fast startup.
jfkebwjsbx··on The KDE community is moving to GitLab
OpenID etc. do not avoid having to switch tabs into another site.
jfkebwjsbx··on The x86 Advanced Matrix Extension
I am not talking about ease of use, but about the downclock.

The other extensions do not trigger it, not even AVX256.

With AVX512 is not always a win, and you don't even know until you try in particular hardware.

jfkebwjsbx··on The x86 Advanced Matrix Extension
Only in a subset of cases, which is the problem: you cannot simply always use it like the previous extensions.
jfkebwjsbx··on A Few More Reasons Rust Compiles Slowly
Of course compile times increase with code size, that is not what people are talking about when they say "X language compiles slowly". They are talking about time per code size.

Messing with the type system is using it for things you really should not in any reasonable project. For instance, some of the Boost libs with their overgeneralizations that 99% of users do not need.

jfkebwjsbx··on The KDE community is moving to GitLab
This is a good answer, but the feature you mention sounds to me like it is useful because it is a productivity feature (avoiding time creating accounts and switching tabs in a browser), not really used for socialization.

Like when telephone lines were introduced, they were a massive boost to productivity. Even if they could be used as a social feature within companies, it was not why they were useful there.

jfkebwjsbx··on A Few More Reasons Rust Compiles Slowly
What is "staying in the flow"?

Recompiling fast helps the most when learning to program, but not for actual applications with some complexity.

Many applications do not even have meaningful output by just running it, for instance they may take a long time to compute something meaningful.

jfkebwjsbx··on The KDE community is moving to GitLab
It is not about being social or not (I am a quite social individual), but about the context that I am wondering.

When I am working, I am not trying to be social but to be professional.

jfkebwjsbx··on The KDE community is moving to GitLab
When those projects started, not much. They offered Git storage and an issue list, pretty much.

Then they started to grow, specially GitLab in the beginning, and now try to be a single centralized solution for all software development needs like Atlassian, IBM and others had always been selling.

jfkebwjsbx··on The KDE community is moving to GitLab
I genuinely ask: why is "a sense of community" important in a productivity tool?

I have never cared about all the "social features" that work tools seem to always end up introducing...

jfkebwjsbx··on A Few More Reasons Rust Compiles Slowly
C++ build times get high only if you start messing with the type system and ask for it to be recompiled every single time again and again.

Rust is slower overall, which is why people tend to complain. And if you start messing around like in C++, then you get even crazier times.

But in neither case it is a dealbreaker compared to other languages. Go proponents claim compilation speed is everything, which is suspicious. I do not need to run my code immediately if I am programming in C++ or Rust. And if I am really doing something that requires interactivity, I should be doing it another way, not recompiling every time...

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
Yeah, but that is a monopoly for the publishers dealing with Steam, not for gamers which don't care as long as it is not broken.

Like Walmart or Amazon, the problem is for devs, not customers.

jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
Except gamers do not care about Steam being a monopoly (they are just a distributor and does not set prices), but would really be hurt if Epic and exclusivity of titles starts to take hold.
jfkebwjsbx··on Godot 4.0 gets SDF based real-time global illumination
The statement is from the perspective of the studios, not customers (studios want to sell in every store they can, customers only buy the game once).
jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
> Free native apps abound.

Yes? I haven't claimed there aren't free native apps.

> Web apps tied to subscriptions are also plentiful.

Fair, but most of the ones I know are usually technical apps or they offer something else that is not about software (for instance, storage more than the app).

> the web is unique in allowing you to actually inspect the source that is running on your machine

That is not unique, nor true.

Uniqueness: you have apps made in scripting languages everywhere. Even for compiled languages it is a decision not to give you the code, not a technical one.

Truthness: many webs are obfuscated on purpose like native apps are.

> you have no way of verifying that the code in an open source repo is what actually runs inside your iOS app.

False, you can definitely verify that a binary matches the source code in deterministic builds and even provide debugging symbols etc. The fact that many projects don't care about that does not mean there is "no way", it just means the overwhelming majority of users do not care.

jfkebwjsbx··on Apple declined to implement 16 Web APIs in Safari due to privacy concerns
The average customer is not paying 1000$ for getting "protection from those risks", and it is that customer that drives the price, not the average user in HN.

And that is assuming they are trying to "protect you", but that is a different discussion.

← PreviousPage 6 of 29Next →