HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jforman

1,398 karma · joined February 18, 2010

Director of Product Management at Wayfair. Previously: Faculty MIT Sloan; Founder, Inkling (backed by Sequoia). Erstwhile quantitative biologist.
submissionscomments
jforman··on Show HN: Jeff Atwood's "Effective Programming" on Hyperink's new Crowd Reader
This reading app has wonderful UX — my feedback is somewhat biased, admittedly, because it's ripped straight off from us (Inkling):

http://tinyurl.com/inkling-frommers-france

(yes, you have to create an account to view content, but it only takes a second)

jforman··on So Pythonistas, you want to get rid of the GIL...
Why would the inability to write multi-threaded programs that are worth a damn be a troll talking point? It meaningfully lowers the appropriateness of using python for server code.
jforman··on A conversation with Bill Gates on the future of education
I don't think your characterization is fair. Read this:

http://www.gatesfoundation.org/highschools/Documents/met-fra...

It's a reasonably enlightened approach to outcomes measurement that doesn't rely solely on high-stakes testing. They track:

* Measure 1: Student achievement gains on assessments

* Measure 2: Classroom observations and teacher reflections

* Measure 3: Teachers’ pedagogical content knowledge

* Measure 4: Student perceptions of the classroom instructional environment

* Measure 5: Teachers’ perceptions of working conditions and instructional support at their schools

The report associated with the MET program is indeed rigorous research based on this framework. You may disagree with it, but at least represent it accurately.

jforman··on A conversation with Bill Gates on the future of education
The Gates Foundation does a huge amount of research into education, making him a much better representative of the state of the art than people who have taken specific approaches to reform.
jforman··on 1 in 2 new college graduates are jobless or underemployed
a) No, in fact, I benefitted from the semester. I learned interesting things about, for example, the role of gift giving in society and what it means to be a social anthropologist. I don't regret the semester, but I do think I would have regretted a degree.

b) I never said CS didn't interest me — that "study what interests you" is bad advice doesn't mean to do the opposite. See my reply above for more explanation and a short description of my thought process.

jforman··on 1 in 2 new college graduates are jobless or underemployed
I suppose I should clarify: people generally interpret "do what interests you" as "study what you think you will enjoy studying" when they should really be asking themselves what they will enjoy doing as a career.

Social anthropology was interesting to study, but at some point I realized that actually embarking on a career as a social anthropologist would have been terrible for me. I like learning about different cultures, not studying a few scientifically. I can do that as an amateur.

When I sat down to decide what to do instead, I thought, a) I like making ASP pages for our newspaper, b) you can go into a lot of fields with a CS degree, and c) there is a clear path for making a tangible impact on society. It turns out, that was pretty sound reasoning (despite ASP pages being entirely different from CS): I've worked at Microsoft, in computational biology, and now at a publishing startup. I've never lacked for engagement (except toward the end of my time at MSFT), and the problems I'm able to solve in our economy are a larger part of that than the practice of the discipline itself.

jforman··on 1 in 2 new college graduates are jobless or underemployed
"Do what interests you" is very common and very bad advice. I studied social anthropology for a semester because it "interested" me — but only in theory, not in practice. The computer science degree I eventually received has yielded a far more interesting career than what my friends in psychology/philosophy/sociology have experienced, on average.
jforman··on Codename: Obtvse
Somewhere, Richard Stallman is weeping.
jforman··on There is no simple solution for local storage
I was skeptical about the same argument. Both indexing and virus scanning are non-blocking processes that shouldn't impact page load time. And I'm not sure what he means when he says "for an end user on the web they could mean a few seconds of waiting during which the web site stalls"? Filesystem caching isn't something specific to developers' boxes...
jforman··on Google Near Launch of Cloud-Storage Service
Yes, it's code for a source who is "on background" or of similar attribution status. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalism_sourcing under "Speaking terms."
jforman··on Khan Academy: It’s Different This Time
This is an incredibly depressing post. The discussion over educational reform has devolved into one side begging for teachers to stop being treated like cattle and the other saying, essentially, "if you cared about the kids, you'd be happy being treated like cattle."

Doctors go through significantly more schooling and receive significantly more professional development — yet they are still perceived with respect as professionals who care about their patients. Why can't we do the same for teachers?

jforman··on Study Finds Engineers Far More Likely than MBAs to Build and Run Companies
The conclusion ended up the same, but in the future you should consider normalizing against the size of the population you're drawing from.

In this case, rather than "business undergrad CEOs vs. eng undergrad CEOs" you should have "business undergrad CEOs per 1000 business undergrads vs. eng undergrad CEOs per 1000 eng undergrads".

Or the more wonky form of P(CEO | biz undergrad) vs. P(CEO | eng undergrad) ("probability of being a CEO given a business/eng undergrad degree...").

jforman··on 25 Startup Ideas for 2012
Zero-gravity, self-assembling, space-debris-katamari-satellite, then? I've got this.
jforman··on 25 Startup Ideas for 2012
If that's the plan, I don't think you've reduced complexity by plotting a zero-gravity rendezvous with a cheeseburger
jforman··on 25 Startup Ideas for 2012
"This satellite would self deploy/build itself at least partially to reduce weight..."

...I'm pretty sure you're not going to save much mass by soaking in a year of sunlight...

jforman··on Introducing Palantir's first open source releases
Palantir is definitely True Neutral
jforman··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
- Add a display that shows the current positions of both control sticks. Add an alarm when the two sticks are not within a certain margin of the each other, if both are engaged. Such as if one is full forward & the other is full back.

This was my first thought as well. Confusion in one pilot was allowed to cause confusion in the second pilot, because he didn't realize that his partner was doing something unexpected and incorrect. If you make sure a pilot can always detect inconsistent reaction in a co-pilot, you can keep them in sync and prevent spreading confusion. An alarm when the two pilots are out of sync seems like a pretty straightforward benefit.

jforman··on At Google X, a Top-Secret Lab Dreaming Up the Future
Ironically enough, the refrigerator-ordering-ingredients thing was one of the talking points of Microsoft Home [1] when I worked there eight years ago...

[1] http://www.engadget.com/2011/05/03/microsofts-home-of-the-fu...

jforman··on Ask HN: Startup promised me a job, then backed out after the internship
In many states, explicitly agreeing on consideration in the case of rescindment isn't required for a claim.

In contract law, there's a doctrine called "promissory estoppel" (see http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/promissory_estoppel) that basically says, "if somebody promises you X, and as a reasonable result of that promise, you do Y, and Y is very bad for you if promise X is revoked, you can sue for damages." The OP's case is a classic example where promissory estoppel can be applied.

Alas, New York does not recognize promissory estoppel (see Marino v. Oakwood Care Center http://caselaw.findlaw.com/ny-supreme-court/1371955.html), but many states do.

jforman··on Your DNA may carry a ‘memory’ of your living conditions in childhood
The mechanisms of traditional genetics, which include (at a simplified level) random variation at the base-pair level, are extremely well understood.

The impact of this potential new mechanism of inheritance is unknown, but it will only add to our current understanding of how things work. It will not tear down our understanding.

jforman··on Your DNA may carry a ‘memory’ of your living conditions in childhood
I can't tell if you're joking or not, but just to be clear: traditional genetics' utility for explaining natural variation among individuals represents an enormous increase in scientific understanding, and is supported by tens of thousands of scientific papers and countless benefits to society.

It's somewhat absurd to compare the credibility of genetics as a field to what is still almost entirely conjecture.

jforman··on Your DNA may carry a ‘memory’ of your living conditions in childhood
Recent studies show there may actually be some limited transmission of epigenetic information:

http://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/epigenetics/inheritan...

Our understanding is still very limited, though. And yes, it is kind of ironic that Lamarck is getting a jab in after all this time :)

jforman··on Occupy George
One of the common outcomes I've heard called for is a "separation of corporation and state," in response to what people feel is an outsized voice in the democratic process for corporations at the expense of individual citizens. The backlash against TARP is a good example of fairly broad sentiment that federal policy favors financial institutions and high-value investors over "Main Street."

Lawrence Lessig has spoken rather extensively about campaign finance reform in this vein. His latest campaign is for the Fair Elections Now Act, which would encourage small donation-powered campaigns. He's also often argued for a constitutional convention that would address these concerns without needing to stay within the current legal boundaries...that seems to have fizzled a bit, though, I assume because it's so hard to pull off.

jforman··on Why Can't We Drink Sea Water?
"The article simply focused on osmosis to explain the process of dehydration at a cellular level (blood). In that, I'd say it was rather accurate."

Cellular osmosis and dehydration have almost nothing to do with one another. The article is, indeed, wrong, in trying to associate these things with one another.

jforman··on Why Can't We Drink Sea Water?
Yes, I read the article.

"Do you suggest sea water is a remedy for dehydration. Or are you suggesting osmosis doesn't occur across cell membranes. Or maybe you're disputing the process of osmosis altogether and the transfer between varying salinities. Which one is it exactly?"

I just mean this: whether seawater causes dehydration in small quantities is a complex question, one which reading this article will provide absolutely no insight into.

"You can't extrapolate the sodium in Gatorade to drinking straight sea water. That's not only haphazard, but completely irresponsible considering we're discussing health and survival."

I never said that seawater is hydrating? Seawater lacks glucose and may have too high a salt concentration to promote hydration even if it did contain glucose. My apologies to anybody who misinterpreted my post after finding themselves stranded on a desert island.

"Also, the images depict cells all over the body; not just in the small intestine and certainly not villi."

The images are clearly presented in such a way as to suggest that simple osmosis between cells and seawater-containing blood is the operative factor in determining hydration. This is totally untrue.

"Sure, this isn't the most robust explanation of a bodily function. This is an expedition travel website. It's not the Journal of Medical Science."

That doesn't give them license to just make stuff up.

jforman··on Why Can't We Drink Sea Water?
"The stated problem is... what happens after you absorb the salt water" — other comments about this paragraph notwithstanding, it's just not true that simple osmosis from blood to cells is the operative factor in hydration, so the article is totally off-base. You can't talk about hydration without talking about intestinal absorption and concentration of urine in the kidneys.
jforman··on Why Can't We Drink Sea Water?
Alas, this article is not remotely accurate. In truth, the best thing that you can drink when extremely dehydrated is lightly salted, sugared water (on an empty stomach, at least — food can provide the salt/sugar otherwise). This is why Pedialyte, which contains both salt and glucose, is often given to dehydrated children and adults. This is also why Gatorade is better than pure water.

The reason for this is that water absorption in your small intestines is significantly more complicated than depicted in the image in this article. Water is not absorbed across a simple membrane passively — rather, the small intestine is a two-layer barrier with specific transport proteins positioned in each layer of the barrier in order to pull nutrients into the body at a very high efficiency.

A dominant theory right now is that sodium-glucose co-transporters are responsible for drawing water into the body (see http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16322051 and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sodium-glucose_transport_protei...). Specifically, an osmotic gradient is created by (I think) the Na/K active pump ("active" meaning the body uses up ATP to overcome the normal steady state). The Na/glucose co-transporter then uses this gradient to pull those molecules into the body, bringing water with it — the water of hydration.

If we were hydrated using a simple system such as the one depicted in the link, we would be orders of magnitude more responsive to the food we eat. Our bodies are very good at maintaining homeostasis, but it takes a lot of complexity to do it.

Edit: it's worth noting that seawater may indeed be too highly concentrated to drink safely, even in moderate quantities, if it's true that the kidney cannot excrete at a greater concentration of salt as is present in seawater. This link from Wikipedia suggests this is the case: http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/bio99/bio99416.htm . But the posted article's explanation is entirely off-base in its explanation regardless. And I'm not even sure what of seawater would be absorbed on an empty stomach...it's possible more salt than water would be absorbed, leading to diarrhea as water is left unabsorbed in the intestine, leading to dehydration from poor water absorption and poor salt excretion.

jforman··on Quake's Fast Inverse Square Root
This isn't a universally effective optimization. It's an exquisite optimization for when a little imprecision is tolerable. Micro-optimizations like this are rarely worth the increase in cognitive complexity of the code, but Quake had to do a lot of math in very little time on 1996 hardware, so I'll trust Carmack (whose programming skills are legendary if you aren't familiar with him).
jforman··on The last time I saw Steve Jobs
Reminds me of The Hero's Journey: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hero%27s_Journey (the pattern of separation, initiation, and return common to many hero myths).
jforman··on An 'Unknown' Co-Founder Leaves After 20 Years of Glory and Turmoil (1997)
"You have all these waiting periods, and it was just too awkward and too slow. So Mike [Markkula] said we needed two things: a floating point Basic (that's a Basic with decimal points, which I didn't have) and a floppy disk."

Sounds like a meaningful contribution to me.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →