HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgg

937 karma · joined October 1, 2009

submissionscomments
jgg··on HN Members' Workspaces
I've been meaning to try the Kinesis Advantage, how is it?
jgg··on Roll your own computer science masters
I agree. The special skill you need to really do mathematics - creative problem solving - is a very hard skill to develop in anyone. It seems like schools are taking the easy way out by not requiring you to use it that much.
jgg··on Penny-Arcade TV on chronic anxiety and antidepressants
>To me it seems absurd that much of the medical establishment would regard the unhappiness a recently bereaved person as a chemical imbalance or a symptom of illness

It doesn't seem so absurd when you realize that they make a lot of money that way.

I agree with your post though. The marketing agencies for drug companies want you to feel as though being uncomfortable for any amount of time means something is wrong with you. It doesn't help that (in the United States at least) there is a very large consumer culture which is based around an intellectually-unhealthy ideal, which, I think, makes people deeply unhappy. Thus, when people realize what is wrong with the world around them, they feel extremely uncomfortable and are quickly herded into the category of "mentally ill" rather than being allowed to face what is troubling them. Depression is very much a fad disorder, like ADHD and Asperger's syndrome (much to the dismay of people who suffer from them legitimately, no doubt).

jgg··on Postcard from Halden
Yes, my example of a serial killer was a really bad one in retrospect, exactly because most if not all are sociopaths and there probably isn't a way to help them.
jgg··on Postcard from Halden
What about the part where we hypothetically solved their problems? Once we kill a few people, have we crossed a line that keeps us from being ethical, higher-level beings?

I find it interesting and instructive in situations like this to think about what it would take to make you or me go over the edge and just start killing people (I'm NOT justifying murder in ANY way, I'm just throwing this out there). As I said above, these people did it for some reason, despite most or all of them knowing that there was a punishment involved...what is the reason? If we uncover it, can we help them and maybe release them into society? Why is my response starting to sound like a bad paper for an undergrad philosophy course? (-:

jgg··on Postcard from Halden
Agreed. What's more valuable - letting a serial killer sit on death row for a few years, sucking up tax payer money for no good reason, and then killing him OR trying to understand why he did the things he did, and seeing if there is any way to help him enter society and be happy and productive? Does he deserve punishment? Well, that's another problem entirely. In many ways, my issue with this issue is the same one I have with religion - forcing people to not do bad things out of fear alone never works. If they're still doing them even when aware of what the de facto punishment is, there's a reason they're doing it and that reason needs to be understood.

Now I fear replies of the "But all perpetrators of Crime X can never be cured!" sort (with no supporting evidence, of course). The desire of modern society to punish everyone who doesn't live up to what is basically an arbitrary moral ideal without any attempt to help or understand the criminal is, to me, just as disturbing as the crimes they are seeking punishment for.

jgg··on Roll your own computer science masters
(Aside: the possible exception to this is Calculus and other advanced math classes, unless you are one of those people who absorb that with a minimum of effort; you either understand Calculus (et. al.), or you don’t, you can’t really just push your way through those one. YMMV.)

First day of my Calculus class: "This is a proof-based Calculus class! This means you must memorize these proofs for the test...".

Actually understanding Calculus is hard work. If you don't believe me, pick up Michael Spivak's Calculus book sometime. Regurgitating the exact formula for integration by parts or the difference quotient will get you nowhere in solving real mathematics problems, which assume that knowledge as a base-step and require you to apply critical thinking and creativity to actually get somewhere. But universities are run like a business: the more money, the better. Students who become frustrated and quit because they're too lazy and/or stupid to actually think do not give them money, so it's easier just to make the tests easy for idiots who spend all their time memorizing things without analyzing their meaning or worth.

Feh.

jgg··on Roll your own computer science masters
If you really look at it, this is true for just about any field. For example, most of my mathematics education has come from the Internet or sources that were pointed out/purchased using the Internet. Other than giving you access to smart people face-to-face and a stupid piece of paper, the Internet can give you everything valuable about a college education and more.

(I know you can earn degrees online, but they are usually extremely poor quality and often inconsistent.)

jgg··on BBC Horizon - Psychedelic Science - DMT, LSD, Ibogaine
On a related note, here's a mathematician comparing his experiences with DMT and LSD: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYDgmpiE-U0
jgg··on Steel Bank Common Lisp Version 1.0.38 released
>No functional language exp.

Common Lisp, at least, isn't really a purely functional language. It supports multiple paradigms. Scheme and Clojure are a little more "functional" than CL, but they too are not pure. I wouldn't worry about this yet.

>Are there not several versions of Scheme, too. Any suggestions for what to start with.

I replied above. (-:

>Is scheme/lisp/clojure the correct language to use for terminal/command-line apps or ncurses stuff ?

I don't see why not.

>Does anyone offhand know if there is ncurses support for these languages ?

It looks like there is a package for Common Lisp for doing ncurses stuff. There's a thread on the PLT mailing list that indicates there's no support for ncurses in PLT Scheme, but other implementations might have it. A search in Clojure's libraries didn't reveal anything, but I may be looking in the wrong place (it seems like they would have one).

jgg··on Steel Bank Common Lisp Version 1.0.38 released
I'd use PLT Scheme: http://www.plt-scheme.org/
jgg··on Steel Bank Common Lisp Version 1.0.38 released
That's a good question, actually. The answer is: Yes and no. Scheme, Emacs Lisp, Common Lisp and Clojure are all different, certainly. For example, when you look at programming texts, you realize that there really is a "Scheme" way of doing things and a "Common Lisp" way of doing things, which aren't always the same. That being said, if you learn one dialect, that will probably make learning another much easier. If you're new to the Lisp thing, I'd learn Scheme.
jgg··on The United States is completely unprepared to fight a cyberwar
Amusingly enough, I found a page on RAND's site ( http://www.rand.org/publications/randreview/issues/RRR.fall9... ), where the definition of Cyberwar isn't anything unique enough to warrant a new label. I think it's just another (surprise!) stupid buzzword.

Point in case:

"Cyberwar refers to conducting military operations according to information-related principles. It means disrupting or destroying information and communications systems. It means trying to know everything about an adversary while keeping the adversary from knowing much about oneself. It means turning the "balance of information and knowledge" in one's favor, especially if the balance of forces is not. It means using knowledge so that less capital and labor may have to be expended."

jgg··on A Formal System for Euclid's Elements
The Cambridge link appears to be down. Try arXiv instead: http://arxiv.org/pdf/0810.4315v3
jgg··on Cinder - open source library for professional-quality creative coding in C++
This whole thing implicitly assumes there's some acceptable "balance" you're making when you compare abstraction power and performance. Ignoring the fact that "choosing speed" or "choosing abstraction" is a bit of a false dichotomy, that's okay. But according to this page, C++ is the perfect harmony between these two areas. I'm calling bullshit on how arbitrary that is.
jgg··on Ask HN: Please stress-test the arc server for my latest prototype
>But this prototype isn't there yet.

Ah, of course. I just wanted to see what you'd say in response. (-:

jgg··on Cinder - open source library for professional-quality creative coding in C++
From the FAQ:

>First, when it comes to power and performance, C++ is still the language to beat.

Oh really?

jgg··on Ask HN: Please stress-test the arc server for my latest prototype
How will this be different from StumbleUpon?
jgg··on You are Probably Mis-Diagnosing People as Stupid
That doesn't make the metric any more accurate though. It just means it gave you a result that inspired you. That's good for you, but why the hell aren't schools inspiring kids like this, instead of grinding them into the mindset required to "be successful", which usually boils down to rote memorization and lots of busy work?
jgg··on Geocities-izer - Make Any Webpage Look Like It Was Made By A 13 Year-Old In 1996
I clicked one of the flashy things, and I think I voted something up. I'm not sure though.
jgg··on Jason Calacanis on how to resign.
Ah, okay.
jgg··on Jason Calacanis on how to resign.
I haven't really been following this entire storyline, because quite frankly, it seems trivial and unimportant to me. So please forgive my ignorance when I ask, how did the employee's original e-mail come off as provocative?
jgg··on You are Probably Mis-Diagnosing People as Stupid
>People like linear status orderings. They exist in every culture and get reinvented when there's no culture present at all.

You're right, I think I was just letting my cynicism towards the United states bleed through with that comment.

>That's why we're prepared to believe things about IQ that we'd never believe about processor or compiler benchmarks.

That's a brilliant parallel, but also a stunningly-accurate one.

jgg··on You are Probably Mis-Diagnosing People as Stupid
Part of the problem, particularly with Western culture, is the desire to assign everything a rank, without much clue as to whether or not the metric used is credible at all. Your GPA, SAT/ACT/GRE scores, IQ, credit rating, college major, average income and choice of university all form an impression on people who want a nice box to put you in, whether you like it or not. Sure, some intelligence is probably required to achieve high rankings in some of those areas, but it isn't indicative by itself of who you are or what you're capable of. To the perceptive crowd on Hacker News, this probably seems obvious, but to most of society, these facts and figures define who you are and what you should do with your life.

The best hope for humanity, in this regard, is to judge people on what they contribute or accomplish. This will probably never become a viable paradigm for most people, because it isn't inherently concrete; it's much harder to look at someone's entire life and judge their merit relative to someone else, rather than noting that a 3.5 GPA is higher than a 3.2 GPA. In fact, once you look at the big picture, it starts to become rather noticeable that judging people at all is, most of the time, a fruitless task.

jgg··on Books Programmers Don't Really Read
This makes two JWZ references I've handed out today, but this is pretty relevant: http://www.jwz.org/doc/gc.html

Memorable quote:

"It's a common belief that garbage collection means inferior performance, because everyone who has gotten into programming in the last decade regards manual storage management as a fact of life, and totally discounts the effort and performance impact of doing everything by hand.

In a large application, a good garbage collector is more efficient than malloc/free. "

jgg··on Books Programmers Don't Really Read
I don't understand this at all. To me, this reads as "Here are books that have been recommended to me that I haven't read. Nobody reads these." He implicitly says this himself, when he states "I've read all of these books myself, so I have no difficulty believing that many moderately competent programmers have read them as well."
jgg··on Why Desktop Linux (Still) Sucks. And What We Can Do To Fix It.
I listened to the first half, but didn't listen to the second half, since by that time him constantly cutting out on the mic had driven me insane.
jgg··on Why Desktop Linux (Still) Sucks. And What We Can Do To Fix It.
Worth mentioning: http://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html
jgg··on Books Programmers Don't Really Read
I agree. At first glance, their length makes it appear to be a reference work, but when you look at his writing style and the exercises at the end of each section, it seems quite clear that he intended otherwise.

That being said, I haven't finished the series.

jgg··on Free OpenBSD Shell Provider
I just signed up for an account. It seems fairly nice, but the big issue with shell accounts is whether or not they stick around. Their manifesto page (http://devio.us/manifesto) seems to indicate that they're taking this seriously, so let's hope they stay. (:
← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →