HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgoodleaf

2 karma · joined October 9, 2009

submissionscomments
jgoodleaf··on Ask HN: Is eBay-style Feedback for the World a Startup Idea?
Accelerando is freely downloadable. Google it. (It's a legit copy, not pirated.)

It's not high art. Like most Stross books, the writing is uneven and the character development is close to nil. But the ideas are breathtaking, and make the book worth a look.

I meant, by the way, that diaspora might provide a good platform on which to build reputation, and OpenID might provide the means to uniquely identify a single human so that a reputation can follow him or her around. But I don't know much about either project, so I could be wrong.

jgoodleaf··on Ask HN: Is eBay-style Feedback for the World a Startup Idea?
This idea has been around in science fiction for a while. Note especially Charlie Stross' "Accelerando" and its worldwide reputation markets. You're talking about a reputation server of sorts.

It's an excellent idea and actually marketable I think. But reputation servers would need to be highly interconnectable and data needs to be easy to migrate. I wonder if diaspora + openid would get us more than halfway there...

jgoodleaf··on Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See
I agree. If you look at the history of contact in northeast N.A., you'll find that the Europeans were relatively few at first. The natives in the area were notably not fond of each other and regularly used Europeans to acquire the means to slaughter their enemies.

Before the arrival of the Europeans, relations between the Huron and the Iroquois consisted of constant, low-level warfare (which could be brutal, and involved post facto ritual torture).

So in the early-mid 17th century, the French traders were generally allied to the Huron, while the Iroquois were allies of the Dutch, then English. Both sides sought trade monopolies with the Europeans, but the Iroquois, the Mohawk in particular, acquired heavy armaments first. They then used those armaments to slaughter, and in fact, pretty much eliminate the Huron. (I'm glossing over a lot of detail. See Francis Jennings' many books on this period.)

Now the Iroquois weren't tricked into doing it. They did it because they didn't like the Huron and wanted what they had. The Dutch and English supplied guns and "monetary" incentives, but the Iroquois were morally responsible.

I think that pattern is most obvious in the example I'm trying to describe, but it was hardly unique. There's a tendency to romanticize the Natives (coughAvatarcough) but they could be as filled with hatred and lust as any of the Europeans. Not all of them, of course, but neither were the Europeans all alike.